Virginia’s Test Scores at The Bottom of the Nation’s Steaming Heap

by Kerry Dougherty

Geez. Who could have predicted this:

Only one thing wrong with The New York Times reporting on yesterday’s horrifying report that showed the sharpest drop in national test scores in three decades.

It’s this: the devastating failure of American education isn’t due to the pandemic.

It’s due in large part to school closures, hysteria, and the isolation that kids were subjected to during the pandemic. But it began before COVID provided an excuse to stop teaching kids. It began when schools did things like abolishing zeroes and scrapping honors and awards in the name of equity. It began when teachers unions obsessed about pronouns instead of achievement.

In other words, it’s the direct result of the feckless actions of government officials who closed schools but kept liquor stores open and the teachers unions who put ideology and idiotic politics ahead of teaching,

No state performed worse in math than Virginia. Gov. Glenn Youngkin held a press conference yesterday where he rightly dumped this reeking heap of embarrassment at the feet of Democrat Gov. Ralph Northam and his predecessor, the awful Terry McAuliffe.

“In the business world, if this was your report card, there would be an immediate change in management,” said Youngkin, according to the Richmond Times-Dispatch. “You would get fired — and I think that is exactly what voters did last November.”

The National Assessment of Educational Progress, dubbed the nation’s report card, tested hundreds of thousands of fourth and eighth graders this year for the first time since 2019. Significant losses were reported nationwide; national reading scores dropped to 1992 levels while math scores saw their largest decrease ever.

Superintendent of Public Instruction Jillian Balow, who also spoke at the press conference, said Virginia’s fourth graders had the largest decline in reading in the nation. Only 32% of Virginia’s fourth graders performed proficient or above in reading, compared to 43% in 2017.

For fourth-grade math, only 38% scored proficient or above, compared with 50% in 2017.

Our last governor was too busy tearing down monuments as penance for his blackface days to care about education. Before that he was too busy flirting with Randi Weingarten to care about schools.

Worse, Northam was one of the first governors in the country to happily announce that the two-week shutdown of schools to “slow the spread” in March 2020 would continue through the end of the school year.

Those of us who howled in protest were called “grandma killers” and “covidiots.”

Where’s our apology? Will anyone ever own up to the tragic mistakes made by government officials and teachers unions that merrily sacrificed children to the gods of COVID-19?

There needs to be a reckoning for what was done in 2020.

In his feckless, foolish overreaction to a virus that from its earliest days was clearly not a danger to children, Northam doomed Virginia’s students to failure. He finished what McAuliffe started.

When Northam announced in the summer of 2020 that schools could reopen in the fall only if they followed stringent, impractical, impossible mitigation rules — something like 13 children riding, masked, on a school bus that could hold 77, for instance — school boards around the commonwealth complied with the boneheaded governor and meekly stayed closed for most of the next year.

Truth is, the decline in educational standards — in Virginia, anyway — did begin during the McAuliffe administration and was simply magnified by the COVID restrictions. Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears issued a statement Monday pointing out that it was minority children who suffered most under these two “progressive” governors and their teachers union friends.

“This decline started in 2017, well before the Governor Northam-ordered pandemic school closures. The two previous Virginia administrations reduced accountability, transparency by our schools, and standards both for students and schools, resulting in these shameful consequences, all in the name of equity. Sadly, students of color were hit the hardest by these failed policies. Prolonged closures of in-person learning exacerbated the decline. Our children are not learning the basics of math and reading! We have known this for some time and the NAEP scores prove it; change is in order,” stated Lieutenant Governor Earle-Sears.

Youngkin is demanding that school districts use the $2 billion in unspent COVID emergency relief funds on tutoring programs to remediate the learning losses that occurred during the Northam and McAuliffe administrations.

You would think that the Virginia Education Association, which was complicit in every catastrophic policy, would have the decency to stand down now that they’ve seen the scores. But no sooner had Youngkin announced plans to try to repair the damage done by his predecessors than the largest teachers union in Virginia denounced him for not spending “new” money on it.

It’s always money with these militant greed balls.

TWO BILLION DOLLARS, you dopes. Now sit down and shut up. You’ve done enough damage.

This column has been republished with permission from Kerry: Unemployed & Unedited.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

39 responses to “Virginia’s Test Scores at The Bottom of the Nation’s Steaming Heap”

  1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
    Kathleen Smith

    Kerry, your last statement is the best. Two billion, you dopes!

  2. killerhertz Avatar
    killerhertz

    There has been zero accountability to boot. Every single school administrator that advocated for school closings should be defrocked. Parents don’t have the resources and bandwidth to kickstart petitions and special elections to remove the school board enablers. Democracy is a sham. None of these beta humans represent me or anyone else. At a minimum we need to defund government schools. When are conservatives going to start realizing that state schools are raising your children to be your enemies?!

  3. Ken Reid Avatar

    There was never any reason to lock down teh schools for so long . We knew from the get go of hte pandemic that children throiugh young adult age were not at serious risk of dying from COVID and the rate of transmission from child to adult was low. Florida never closed their schools. Whats the rate of infection among FLorida teachers and schools staff and Virginia or NY where they locked down? Yet, the NEA lobbied CDC and the governors and used their PACs and voting clout to pressure school systems not to reopen in 2020-21 when they could have (especially with the vaccine ready by that December 2020). For Virginia, it was especially shameful to keep schools closed as we are a right to work state and unions have no collective bargaining ability. However, the VEA and its local asssociations are extremely influential in local races. In Loudoun, the schools are the Largest employer! Will public schools they require summer schooling to enable these kids to catch up?” Oh, obviously not as the teachers want their summers free to work a 2nd job. In my view, this study should give marching orders for conservatives to truly get involved more in K-12 education and not just the funding side — but curricula. Every GOP candidate for General Assembly and county supervisor and school board should be running on this issue in 2023.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Nope. Teachers were susceptible to Covid no different than the folks in nursing homes or airlines or Walmarts. Teachers and THEIR families. Conservatives did not care. Even if hardly any other workplace remained “in person”, Conservatives wanted teachers to be.

      Red states DID do in person and DID see teacher deaths BUT they had similar decline in academic performance.

      What we need is the truth here and it’s in short supply when it comes to Conservatives and COVID. Full of deniers and full of those who did not care if teachers had to risk their lives even when the State itself went to remote in government and even the GA, DMV and other.

      1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
        Kathleen Smith

        The stats on in person learning during the pandemic were not that high even in red states? Where are you seeing that data? What was given yesterday at the NAEP release conference showed almost no in person in 19-20, more in 20-21.?

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          Wasn’t there in-person in some Red states like Florida and Texas as well as private schools?

  4. Ronnie Chappell Avatar
    Ronnie Chappell

    My hope is that Democrats will end the hypocrisy of social promotions, higher graduation rates despite lower test scores, abysmal SOL and NAEP test results by enacting legislation mandating that every Virginia child receive a high school diploma on their 18th birthday. Simply show up at school after blowing out the candles on your cake, drive to the takeout window, roll down your car window and receive your sheepskin from the NEA shop steward.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Private schools and GOP RED states (with right to work laws) that did in-person ALSO had historic declines.

  5. Stop social promotion… if a student fails to master the skills required to move to the next grade, hold them back for a second year. PERIOD!!!!!

    The school helps no one when a student is moved forward without proof of knowing the subjects…. not the student, not the new teacher, not the college or trade school or business, not the college, not society.

    Hold all accountable with results and consequences. If the teacher can’t teach — move them to gym or Starbucks.

    1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
      Kathleen Smith

      Then again, one year in Petersburg, I had more 13 yr olds in 5th grade than 10 year olds. I had a parent ask me once to help her as her 14 yr old did not want to return to 4th grade, he wanted to work.

  6. An important point of clarification. When Kerry writes, “No state performed worse in math than Virginia,” it is important to note that Virginia showed the biggest decline in NAEP test scores, not that it experienced the lowest test scores. Virginia started from a position as one of the top-performing states and has declined into the middle of the pack.

    The big question is whether Team Youngkin can turn it around. As I noted in a post yesterday, his recommendations make sense… as far as they go. What they don’t do is root out the “equity” obsession at the bottom of so much dysfunction.

    Otherwise, Kerry’s column is spot on. Ralph Northam will go down as the worst education governor in Virginia history. He has no peer in sheer institutional destruction.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Thanks for the clarification. Can you also clarify why Northam was responsible for the decline in Virginia private school scores also?

      1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
        Kathleen Smith

        Private schools, with the pandemic to blame, did go down, but not as much. Public schools did much worse. Kids in K-2 received terrible instruction and coupled with poor accountability, i.e., the growth measure, choked up the biggest loss.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          Private schools tend to have smaller class sizes and far less economically disadvantaged kids, right?

          1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
            Kathleen Smith

            Yep

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            If private schools had bigger class sizes AND were required to educate low-income kids with vouchers, would they do any better than public schools? Would we even know if there was no requirement for SOL testing?

            Those who advocate vouchers for private schools should answer these questions along with what would be done if such schools also “failed” to educate these kids.

            This takes me back to Kathleen’s remark that we need to focus of change and fixing not blame and I would add “beliefs” about private schools as “solutions”.

    2. Kathleen Smith Avatar
      Kathleen Smith

      I agree, she is spot on. Sears comment says it all.

      “ This decline started in 2017, well before the Governor Northam-ordered pandemic school closures. The two previous Virginia administrations reduced accountability, transparency by our schools, and standards both for students and schools, resulting in these shameful consequences, all in the name of equity…”

      Let’s not blame, let’s make changes. The problem with blame is that it beats up the folks who have to do the work. Not the politicians that created the mess.

      I was sickened yesterday at the comments.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        re: ” Let’s not blame, let’s make changes. The problem with blame is that it beats up the folks who have to do the work. Not the politicians that created the mess.”

        the declines that happened (worse in Va) also happened in other states , Red States that maintained in-person instruction.

        In fact, there apparently is little discernable difference between states that were in-person and virtual.

        So the comment about blame is SPOT ON and apparently not something the critics are capable of.

        Perhaps Youngkin is. Lotta talk, let’s see the changes.

    3. Teddy007 Avatar

      When anyone gets involved in education such as running and winning a school board seats, one of the first issues presented is the huge gap between White/Asian test scores versus black test scores. No one on the right has present anything that will really close that gap nor is anyone on the right willing to publicly state that it should not be a concern of public education.

    4. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      Kerry is never one to be bothered by facts and details. I am surprised that she made it as a reporter when there was much more editing control.

      1. Matt Adams Avatar
        Matt Adams

        “Dick Hall-Sizemore James A. Bacon • 13 hours ago • edited
        Kerry is never one to be bothered by facts and details. I am surprised that she made it as a reporter when there was much more editing control.”

        Ad hom attack by someone who themselves has trouble with facts.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Kerry was never a reporter. She was always only an opinion writer.

  7. LarrytheG Avatar

    The dominant and overall commentary from Conservatives is blame – as if the “historic losses” were due to Democrats closing schools. The same Conservatives were blaming Dems for the deaths in nursing homes as I recall.

    And the same Conservatives who questioned the mask protocols and even the COVID shots that were “mandated”.

    Not how to take measures to deal with the pandemic but blame that we did not stay open and instead “lock down”.

    And now, not how to go forward to try to get kids back to learning and catch up, Nope. It’s more culture war and partisan politics by Youngkin and company.

    1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      The truth about the NAEP scores. The slope of progress is nearly imperceptible prior to 2020. 2000 to 2020 only marginal and modest gains can be seen.
      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/07baa01b18690cdab24281c6e89c3b32a02fc6e95da41914ca71e30da219d584.jpg

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        yep. for years. And if we listen to Conservatives, an opportunity to fix it.

        will be refreshing to hear the narrative shift from blame to what to do….

  8. Teddy007 Avatar

    Once again, a know nothing claiming that every child can learn calculus just as long as there is more discipline, more requirements, more high standards, and more yelling at teachers.

  9. Only 32% of Virginia’s fourth graders performed proficient or above in reading, compared to 43% in 2017.

    I’ll probably take a [verbal] beating from the educators who comment here, but I don’t think 43% is good. That means that in 2017 (which apparently was a peak year for test scores) more than half of Virginia’s 4th graders could not read proficiently.

    Am I the only onw who thinks that should not be considered acceptable?

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      We have been over this before. For NAEP, “proficient” d0es not have the same meaning that is commonly associated with the term. The NAEP folks define it this way: “Proficient on NAEP means competency over challenging subject matter. This is not the same thing as being “on grade level,” which refers to performance on local curriculum and standards. NAEP is a general
      assessment of knowledge and skills in a particular subject.” https://reachinghighernh.org/2018/04/18/naep-proficient-grade-level/#:~:text=Fact%3A%20Proficient%20on%20NAEP%20means%20competency%20over%20challenging,of%20knowledge%20and%20skills%20in%20a%20particular%20subject.

    2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      We have been over this before. For NAEP, “proficient” d0es not have the same meaning that is commonly associated with the term. The NAEP folks define it this way: “Proficient on NAEP means competency over challenging subject matter. This is not the same thing as being “on grade level,” which refers to performance on local curriculum and standards. NAEP is a general
      assessment of knowledge and skills in a particular subject.” https://reachinghighernh.org/2018/04/18/naep-proficient-grade-level/#:~:text=Fact%3A%20Proficient%20on%20NAEP%20means%20competency%20over%20challenging,of%20knowledge%20and%20skills%20in%20a%20particular%20subject.

      1. Thank you. I must have missed the previous discussion, but I should have looked up the NAEP definition before I posted my comment.

      2. Matt Adams Avatar
        Matt Adams

        “We have been over this before. ”

        You’re the last poster to be making this statement. You’ve been corrected numerous times, by numerous people on other articles and haven’t shown any contrition.

        Be less of a “Dick” and more of a “Richard”.

  10. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I am really tired of all the Monday-morning quarterbacking. It is always easy to criticize in hind sight. School officials were facing a pandemic about which it little was known. I find it strange and humorous that people these days don’t raise an eyebrow when schools close at the mere mention of a possibility of snow. After all, we don’t want to put the kids in danger. However, there is now howling because schools were closed because there was a deadly pandemic around killing lots of people.

    And Kerry and lots of others are quick to blame the teachers and the teachers’ unions for the closures. But, parents were also in favor of closing schools and many were reluctant to send their kids back to in-person learning when it was available. In early 2021, when Henrico County opened schools and gave parents the choice of sending their kids to school or continuing virtual education at home, less than half the students showed up at the schools. https://www.wtvr.com/news/local-news/teachers-parents-react-to-henrico-schools-reopening-plan

    1. Schools are closed in inclement weather because of concern for student safety. Randi Weingarten and the other union bosses who kept schools closed during the ‘pandemic’ were not concerned about children who fortunately were almost immune to C-19, their only concern was teachers or more precisely, union members!

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        Kids were not “immune” as now they are recommended to get shots.

        And teachers – what are you thinking about THEIR safety and susceptibility to COVID – really no different than many other workplaces that were closed?

        You guys have the astounding ability to close your minds and ignore reality to keep your own ignorance secure.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        What an amazingly willfully ignorant statement. Inclement weather affects the safety of faculty as well

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          but standard for most Conservatives including in this blog.

          the primary narrative for Conservatives is _uck the teachers both pre, during and post COVID.

  11. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Scores fell in Florida as well and schools there remained opened.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Scores fell for almost all states and California with virtual fared better than Texas or Florida.

      Not only did Conservatives insist on in-person, they were violently opposed to social distancing and masking.

  12. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Scores fell in Florida as well and schools there remained opened.

Leave a Reply