Virginia’s New Population Growth Leaders

by James A. Bacon

The COVID-19 pandemic changed the dynamics of population growth in Virginia. For decades Northern Virginia, with Fairfax County at its core, led population growth in Virginia. And in the 2010s, Virginia’s central cities experienced a population renaissance. But the combination of COVID-19 and sky-high real estate prices have pushed growth out to counties on the metropolitan fringe, mainly around Richmond, but also around Fredericksburg, Charlottesville and Winchester, according to University of Virginia demographer Hamilton Lombard.

The fastest growing localities in Virginia between 2020 and 2022 were New Kent, Goochland, and Louisa counties, expanding by 7.5%, 5.6% and 5.4% respectively. Virginia’s most populous jurisdiction, Fairfax County, lost 26,000 residents. Virginia Beach lost 7,700.

Percentagewise, counties in Southside and Southwest Virginia were among the biggest losers. Some counties in those economically depressed regions also continued to experience out-migration, but several managed to buck the trend. A bigger factor was the fact that the populations of these localities are so much older that deaths outnumbered births. 

Writing in the UVa demographic research group blog StatChat, Lombard said it was “unclear” whether the COVID-era trends would continue or reverse themselves. Either way, the population movements between 2020 and 2022 were striking, as the following map shows.

The past two years have seen a surge of in-migration in the dark blue blob around Richmond, Fredericksburg, and Charlottesville.

However, the rapid growth in the Richmond-Fredericksburg-Charlottesville triangle must be viewed in the context that Virginia is experiencing the slowest overall population increase in decades.

Here are what Lombard sees as the forces driving the new migration trends:

Many residents who left Northern Virginia moved to the fast-growing metro areas in the South, such as Raleigh or Charlotte, but a large number of movers also stayed in Virginia moving to nearby counties and cities. Migration from Northern Virginia into the Richmond Metro area has risen by nearly 40 percent since the mid-2010s. Richmond has been so attractive to Northern Virginians and residents of other large metro areas that in 2022 Zillow ranked it the second most popular metro area in the country for prospective home buyers, while Bon Air in Chesterfield County was ranked the third most popular zip code by Zillow. As the economy strengthened in the late 2010s, migration into many of Virginia’s small metro areas and rural counties increased, driven in part by people leaving large East Coast urban areas.

… There are also some significant differences between today and the 2000s, notably how much more expensive housing is in many of the country’s large urban areas, particularly Northern Virginia. Since 2010, the median home price in Prince William, where many of Louisa’s new residents have moved from, has risen from $34,000 more than in Louisa to nearly $200,000 more last year, in other Northern Virginia counties the median home price is close to $400,000 more. Another difference is how ubiquitous remote work has become, allowing many workers to live further from their employer and helping spur growth in Virginia’s rural and exurban counties. If current patterns continue, Virginia may soon experience trends similar to a time prior to the Great Recession with exurban counties struggling to keep up with population growth and some cities struggling to cope with a declining population and tax base.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

39 responses to “Virginia’s New Population Growth Leaders”

  1. how_it_works Avatar
    how_it_works

    Gonna take a wild guess that most of the counties gaining population have a lot of vacant land to develop.

  2. LarrytheG Avatar

    One of the most amazing things to me as a long-time resident in Spotsylvania is not the growth of single-family subdivisions – that’s been with us for some time, it’s the growth of apartments and many are near to I-95 and VRE so I presume there is a connection.

    We also have large-lot development which is folks who had a house in NoVa, sold it for a bunch of bucks and bought a nicer, bigger house on acreage – no mortgage.

    And we see it every day in our traffic. And I-95 is truly a crap-shoot these days so working from home and/or 4 or even 3day weeks are becoming common. Trying to get to a “must” appointment, like a meeting or a plane flight is a conundrum.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      While I envy the Aussies on gun control, they are NOT the model for urban planning. I read an article on traffic in some of their cities. Accompanying photo showed a line of 100+ cars at a light. It was the apartment complex exit. 10 to 15 minutes just to get on the road.

      I’ll look for it in my history.

      Found it
      https://au.news.yahoo.com/photos-morning-commute-dire-aussie-housing-problem-063932261.html

  3. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Many NOVA migrants have chosen Jefferson and Berkeley Counties in West Virginia as home. Affordable housing but a bruising commute.

    1. Many NOVA migrants have chosen Jefferson and Berkeley Counties in West Virginia as home.

      I think it’s safe to say most of the residents of Hillsboro are not at all happy with this trend…

      1. I think Rural Retreat is still safe.

        1. That’s a different part of the state. Hillsboro is right on Route 9, which is the primary route between the Charlestown WV area and Northern Virginia. Are you thinking about Hillsville?

          1. Lefty665 Avatar
            Lefty665

            Yeah, my bad, those Hillxxx towns sort of blended in together. OTOH, your comment makes a lot more sense to me now:)

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      that’s how it looks at most Fredericksburg traffic signals these days. We’ve been thoroughly “Fairfaxed”!

      1. how_it_works Avatar
        how_it_works

        That’s exactly what you get when you build thousands of homes without any infrastructure improvements. (Well, except that Fairfax actually has jobs that pay well, something sorely lacking in Fredericksburg)

        I guess that sort of thing is part of the “Virginia Way”?

        I told my mother I’m sick of sitting in traffic to get to her house in Fredericksburg, even on a weekend.

        She says, “Well people who live here do it every day going to work”..

        …I didn’t say it, but my answer to that is that I’m neither stupid nor broke enough to live in Fredericksburg and put up with a 2 hour commute.

        My mom moved to Fredericksburg for the same reason everyone else does–cheap housing.

    2. Jeez, where’s that?

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Some neighborhood in Australia. Good thing they don’t have AR-15s, eh?

        “The traffic leaving Kalkallo, 50km north of Melbourne, is up to 1km long every morning. Source: Twitter/Margaret Paul”

        1. Funny, with so much of the continent flat empty that they would choose to congest like that.

          1. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Ever been to Texas? As God is my witness, during a heavy thunderstorm, I watched rain cascade off the roof of a two-story house and land on the roof of the one-story next door.

          2. Yeah, it’s miles and miles across Texas. First time I drove it I was amazed that it took almost 2 days.

          3. There’s a solution for that – drive faster…

            😉

          4. I tend to, unfortunately there are occasionally some folks with badges who take exception. But I’m still driving a V8 Ford. Just where did that Maybelline get off to?

  4. DJRippert Avatar

    The same people who ruined their locations, moved to NoVa and ruined it are now headed to Richmond. Bravo! Get ready for far worse schools and far higher taxes.

    1. It could be worse. They could be coming from California.

  5. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I certainly see it in Henrico–apartment/townhouse/single-family developments continue to spring up. The growth around Short Pump is pushing westward into Goochland. Now, if I could just convince my daughter and her family to move here from Fairfax, but I’m afraid that isn’t going to happen.

    1. Seriously, you should see if you can get them to at least take a look at Goochland.

      As an engineer who has spent his career working in northern and central Virginia, and on ‘both sides of the fence’ (private practice and government) it is my considered opinion that Goochland County is the best-run local government I have ever worked with/for and/or lived in.

      The Real Estate tax rate is $0.53/$100, although there is an extra $0.32/$100 tacked on if your property is in the Tuckahoe Creek Service District.

  6. I lived in Louisa for 20+ years. The commute to downtown Richmond was about 45 minutes. I could get to customer sites in NOVA and D.C. in about twice that if I could dodge rush hour on 95. It worked well, a good place to raise my kids, profoundly rural but access to civilization was not prohibitive.

    Too bad if ‘wisa is getting over run. The county manager used to have stories about new residents complaining about all the noise the cows made or demanding county sewer maintenance and not understanding that they had a septic system that was their own. With the in migration I’m sure there are many new stories. Who knows, some may object to farmers fertilizing using Blue Plains and NOVA effluent.

    1. Minor correction: It’s Class A sludge, not effluent. Effluent is the treated liquid that flows to the stream/river.

      Whereabouts in Louisa did you live?

      1. Does it become effluent when it washes off the fields into the streams/rivers?

        I used to ride with the County Manager to meetings. As we rode past fields he would identify where the Class A sludge came from by the color. I was impressed.

        1. No, it becomes a pollutant discharge.

          The fact of the matter is, though, animal manure washing into a stream is just as damaging as Class A sludge.

          1. I believe that, especially pig manure. That’s nasty stuff. When used as fertilizer it reeked for weeks.

            What concerned me was the heavy metals and some other stuff that seemed to concentrate in the sludge. I opted not take the money so it didn’t go on my fields.

          2. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Last time Old Church Rd flooded in Prince William County, a couple hours after the rain stopped I went that way and I opened the car door to gauge how deep the water was.

            It wasn’t too deep to drive through, but it stunk like raw sewage. I turned around and went the other way.

            (I’ve had the lid off my septic tank before and it didn’t even stink that bad).

          3. There was once a sewage treatment plant on Slate Run in PW County, but it’s been gone for almost 25 years. PW County also has tight restrictions on land application of sludge, so I’m not sure what might have been causing the smell.

          4. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Lots of farmland around there and if Old Church is flooded so are some of the cow pastures off of Parkgate Drive. I think the water may have had some cow patties in it.

          5. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Where was that sewage treatment plant? I’m guessing it was near Fitzwater Drive (they have public sewer there, but no public water).

          6. I believe that is about where it was. It was replaced with a gravity sewer line in the 1999/2000 time frame.

          7. LarrytheG Avatar

            that’s not a good combination. Usually the other way around. Usually
            the groundwater becomes polluted from drain fields and public water is provided.
            Often in older subdivisions where the lot sizes were small and the drain fields are old.

          8. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Groundwater often gets polluted from well casings that are broken or well caps that are left off. Someone on Facebook posted that their well water gets discolored after a rain storm. Someone else posted that they just need a water filter. I told that person that it’s just masking the symptoms of the true cause of the problem which is that water is leaking into the well casing from the surface and it needs to be fixed. That person wanted to argue with me and I took him up on the offer and he ended up getting offended and blocked me on Facebook.

            One of the less endearing traits that seems to be common in this area is the know-it-all who doesn’t actually know it all and gets offended when you try to clue them in.

            Me personally? If you know better about something than I do, I want you to share your knowledge with me!

          9. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            Virginia Tech has a well water program. You can google it. surface water contamination can get into wells – even
            wells that have intact casings and can get into groundwater also depending on the type of contamination and the
            soil characteristics. Older subdivisions on smaller lots with older septic systems are at high risk for polluting the
            groundwater and wells. Often, that is the reason that water lines are extended and wells abandoned. Many, shallow
            wells with casings , as opposed to deep wells with pipes have Coliforms which are present in a lot of groundwater. They are “ok” for most folks but they are an overall class that also includes fecal coliforms and ecoli, both of which are serious
            health threats. The only way to know is to test the well water. Virginia has almost no regulations for well water other
            than the initial boring for a new house. From then on , it’s pretty much up to the owner. Here’s that Va Tech website: https://www.wellwater.bse.vt.edu/

          10. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Manassas Park had to shut their wells down (these wells provided water to the west side of the city) due to fecal coliform contamination…

            …at about the same time their sewer system was having problems with infiltration. I figure if rainwater can leak in, sewage can leak out.

            Wonder if their sewer pipes were contaminating their wells.

      2. Lefty665 Avatar
        Lefty665

        Bumpass, eastern Louisa.

  7. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    Drove by the VRE parking lot today …in the past, jam packed with overflow parking, shocking sight, now after COVID about empty. That’s the Manassas line out to the west, perhaps the Fredericksburg line is more full?

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Down but gaining back. Not sure they are back to half yet.

Leave a Reply