Virginia Republicans, in Need of a Public Education Strategy for the Fall Elections, Should look to Florida

by James C. Sherlock

Virginia still supports in law the pillars of the progressive takeover of public K-12 and higher education.

Our elected Democrats, having made those laws even crazier in 2020 and 2021, resist any efforts to change them even at the margins.

Mystifyingly, Virginia Republicans seem not to have a public education strategy for the fall elections.

They need to look south.

The Washington Post reports that the legislature of the state of Florida, having already proscribed in law some of the more radical progressive educational dogma, is now taking down the pillars of that control in both K-12 and higher education.

It will consider various bills:

  • requiring teachers to use pronouns matching children’s sex as opposed to a gender construct;
  • changing the current Florida law that offers school choice funding subject to income limitations to make it a universally available program;
  • eliminating college majors in gender studies;
  • banning spending on DEI administrative positions and programs not required by federal law;
  • requiring post-tenure reviews at prescribed intervals to evaluate an individual’s continuing contributions to scholarship;
  • strengthening parents’ ability to veto K-12 class materials;
  • extending a ban on teaching about gender and sexuality — from third grade up to eighth grade.

I would have to see the final language of any of the bills to determine my personal support, and am unlikely to back all of them either personally or for Virginia.

But the strategy is right.

They attack the foundations of the progressive strangleholds on public K-12 and higher education.

Not shockingly, The Post reports that:

The legislation has already drawn protest from Democratic politicians, education associations, free speech groups and LGBTQ advocates.

One Kenneth Young, who resigned as a law professor at the University of Florida in part because he opposed the Republican education agenda, said of the higher education bills:

It’s a complete takeover of higher education.

No, professor, it’s actually an attempt to return the current system so destructive of the public interest back to serve the people and values of this nation.

Progressives should recognize the takeover strategy, having successfully executed it at every level of public education in Virginia.

Republicans here need to work to end progressive control of education in a much more focused way than they currently exhibit. Or, frankly, have ever exhibited as a group on this issue.

Virginia’s Republican office seekers need to stop nibbling at the edges of progressive control of education, develop a common legislative strategy and run on it statewide.

The Republican right in particular needs to take a breath and join in common cause with centrist Republicans in a strategy that can win on this issue statewide. Common campaign ads on the subject. That sort of thing.

Like a real political party.

Ask Governor Youngkin.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

29 responses to “Virginia Republicans, in Need of a Public Education Strategy for the Fall Elections, Should look to Florida”

  1. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    Sherlock likes the Florida approach to “education”. Shocking! 😉

    As news of what Florida has done/is doing comes out, it makes me think just how close it follows many of Mr Sherlocks tomes here on BR.

    And here’s the question. If the Virginia GOP came out strongly in support of Florida’s approach BEFORE the elections, made it their plank and promise, would they win both houses of the GA and then be able to replicate the Florida approach?

    OR, is it better for the Va GOP to NOT come out strongly and publicly for the Florida approach before the elections but do it if they win both houses?

    Isn’t THAT , THE “question”?

    Does the GOP in Virginia think there is enough support of the Florida approach, that they’d win the GA?

  2. LesGabriel Avatar
    LesGabriel

    There are common sense laws that were not on the Florida list that have widespread support among citizens but divide the Parties, such as maintaining same-sex restrooms, shower rooms and sports teams.

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      They will forever divide progressives from the rest of us. That is why they must be defeated.

  3. I agree with the general idea of “taking back” K-12 education from the Wokies. Some of the ideas Sherlock lists are good ones, but not all of them (as he himself believes). Florida Republicans threaten to become the authoritarian mirror image of the left.

    For example, take the first recommendation — require teachers to use pronouns matching children’s sex as opposed to a gender construct. I totally oppose the idea of Wokies compelling people which pronouns to use. But this proposal does essentially the same thing. If people voluntary go along with the idea of using thirty different zany pronouns to describe the multitude of emerging genders, well, as long as they aren’t coerced, that’s their choice. If Wokies win in the marketplace of ideas, then…. (gulp) OK. As a libertarian-leaning conservative, I object to coerced government language regardless of who is doing the coercing.

    As much as I criticize gender studies and other woke studies in universities, I cannot support the idea of defunding them…. at least not if people continue to willingly enroll in them. I totally and utterly oppose the idea of coercing students into taking these courses. That amounts to indoctrination. But if people like learning that garbage, I’m not willing to interfere with their freedom of choice. If I want to stop people from taking Woke studies, I need to persuade them using reason.

    If conservatives have to win the battle of ideas by using government coercion, what sets them apart from the left?

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Good LORD! Bacon is dead on correct. But I don’t see the “left” instituting laws that FORCE in the same ways the Right is now advocating.

      Many GOP these days are all in on autocracy. Not only Trump, but MAGA and DeSaintis.

      You’ll have to convince me that this is the “left” approach. I don’t see it.

    2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      My main issue is chronically failing schools. More of the same has no chance of giving those kids the opportunity they deserve.

      A policy I would recommend leading with is for a constitutional amendment permitting the state to take over failing schools and school divisions and run them either directly or with charter management organizations.

      In Tennessee, the mere threat of state takeover causes some failing school districts to make decades overdue changes in their own policies and funding to lure the best principals and teachers to implement them.

      “In Louisiana, the state stepped in after Hurricane Katrina to take over most of the public schools in New Orleans, converting them to independent charter schools overseen by the state-run Recovery School District. The state also eliminated attendance zones so students could enroll in any public school in the city.”

      Michigan’s system sent children back to their neighborhood schools but under new management.

      Tennessee embraced a hybrid approach, taking over schools with its Achievement School District (ASD) and handing them to charter operators.

      In 2015, Georgia amended its constitution to create opportunity school districts. See Georgia’s ideas at https://gacharters.org/press-releases/opportunity-school-district-overview/#:~:text=Opportunity%20School%20District%20Overview%201%20Atlanta%20Public%20Schools,has%20been%20determined%20to%20be%20chronically%20failing.%20 For the map of Georgia’s Charters, see https://gacharters.org/school-locator/

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        This coming from a Conservative who used to say that government that is the closest to the people is best.

        Now we want top-down autocratic rule fro the State. Threats to boot!

        Sherlock advocates for Constitutional Amendments.

        Does he realize that it takes two General Assembly sessions and a citizen referenda to accomplish that?

        It goes back to my original question.

        Do the voters of Virginia want an autocratic down-down rule from the Gov?

        Especially right after they blamed Northam for such behaviors!

        1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
          James C. Sherlock

          Of course he “realizes” that.

          Running on passing a constitutional amendment to fix chronically failing schools with chronically failing school boards is the only path forward that gives those children any hope of a better future. If Republican majorities come out of such an election they will have a mandate to do it.

          How much more time are you willing to give the Richmond, Portsmouth and Petersburg school boards? Or do those kids not count?

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            I don’t agree that all schools in Virginia are “chronically failing”. That’s really not the truth.

            But aside from that – I ask this – Should GOP candidates come out and SAY what you are claiming that Va schools ARE failing AND promise a state level top-down “reform”?

            It’s a question, not an assertion. If the GOP is honest about what they want to do, will they be elected?

      2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        I could probably agree with you on most of this. However, going back to your example of Florida, none of those proposals have anything to do with failing schools.

    3. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      What if the “marketplace of ideas” condemns poor minority children to lives of desperation?

  4. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    Sherlock likes the Florida approach to “education”. Shocking! 😉

    As news of what Florida has done/is doing comes out, it makes me think just how close it follows many of Mr Sherlocks tomes here on BR.

    And here’s the question. If the Virginia GOP came out strongly in support of Florida’s approach BEFORE the elections, made it their plank and promise, would they win both houses of the GA and then be able to replicate the Florida approach?

    OR, is it better for the Va GOP to NOT come out strongly and publicly for the Florida approach before the elections but do it if they win both houses?

    Isn’t THAT , THE “question”?

    Does the GOP in Virginia think there is enough support of the Florida approach, that they’d win the GA?

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Larry, as per my usual, no, eternal, recommendation to you: read it again.

      You wrote is it better to “come out strongly and publicly for the Florida approach before the elections “ or after the elections.

      You are fantasizing. How about neither, which is what I recommended.

      I praise the strategy of the Republicans of Florida.

      I also wrote that I do not endorse every tactic of the Republicans in Florida.

      My message is for the Republican Party of Virginia to try to corral its general election candidates behind a single education strategy that makes real headway but not does not expose candidates to far right positions.

      You are encased in an intellectual prison of your own construction.

      1. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        Nah!! You hedged by stating you’d need to read the final legislation before offering your imprimatur but offered that FL was on the right track substantively, not merely strategically. Larry correctly characterized your repetitive prior perorations on the education topic.

        1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
          James C. Sherlock

          Yet Gov. Youngkin led with it.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            Not at all the way DeSantis is and that remains my legitimate question. Are Virginia voters LIKE Florida voters and would KNOWINGLY (with the GOP openly advocating) vote for it?

            My bet is that if Virginia voters knew they were voting for a DeSantis autocratic approach to governance, they’d reject it.

            So wil the GOP, HONESTLY admit what their real agenda is before the election or will they hid (like Youngkin did) and get elected THEN try to institute it?

            Do Virginia voters want a DeSantis style government?

          2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            What you have written tries to change history. It is utterly untrue.

            Glenn Youngkin featured education reform in his campaign and it won him the election.

            In his first day in office started attempting to implement the education reforms he ran on.

            Try another story.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            What Youngkin did not do was say up-front he wanted to institute State level top-down control.
            He selectively exploited some voter sentiment on schools.

            You say “reform”. I ask if what Florida is doing is “reform”? AND if you say it is, then I ask if
            you put to voters to do in Virginia what Florida is doing, would they approve it?

            In other words, do voters in Virginia want “reform” of the scope and scale that is going on in Florida?

            If GOP candidates PROMISE to do that, if elected, will they be elected?

            is that the “coordinated” strategy you speak of?

          4. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            He did not “say” he wanted to institute top down control and he has not done it.

            Next story.

            As for will Republicans be elected on a broad education reform agenda, I say yes.

            The most significant part of that is that they will have a mandate to accomplish what they promise, rather than just scratching local issues in the election and showing up in Richmond without a common agenda.

          5. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            Of course he did not say it. The question is, is that what is being advocated but in a stealth way?

            Does Virginia want to adopt the Florida approach to education reform?

            If the GOP promises it up front, will they get elected?

  5. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Yes Captain! A coherent all hands on deck strategy is needed. Somebody needs to articulate an education vision and slogan to rally voters. It needs to be more forward thinking than just the catch phrase. Youngkin would be wise to enlist members of the General Assembly to rewrite the Standards of Quality. That is the big pretzel. Someone like Lee Ware, who has an education background would be the ideal candidate. A genuine policy wonk, like Jenny McClellan is a must. The SOQ’s as they stand should be dismantled and reconfigured to produce positive outcomes that reach all parts of the Commonwealth. Of course, you need to win both houses first!

  6. Kathleen Smith Avatar
    Kathleen Smith

    What are local school boards for? What purpose do they serve?

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      They should do the right thing as well, Kathleen, but state laws need to be changed. And the targets of the laws, and thus the changes, are state institutions of higher learning as well as K-12.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      The “new” GOP approach is top-down autocracy. Do away with the authority of local elected governance, like school boards and prosecutors, etc.

      It’s what Trump was selling, and the MAGA folks are all in on it and quite a few voters these days apparently,

      The ” right” thing is for some guy like DeSantis to dictate state policy. That’s what they want.

  7. Matt Hurt Avatar
    Matt Hurt

    These culture wars are insidiously destroying public education’s ability to ensure the success of our students. Most casualties are borne by educators and students, as evidenced by teacher vacancies and declining scores.

    I have witnessed atrocities by both factions of this war, and neither side can be held blameless. It seems like the mindless political battles for hegemony over the hearts and souls of the citizenry have become paramount.

    To add insult to injury, when both sides do get together on educational policy, such as with the through year growth scheme (HB2027 and SB1357 of 2020) they do so without meaningful input from educators. These bills were passed unanimously and produced the negative unintended consequences of trading two weeks of very valuable instruction for unreliable assessment data and lowering expectations across the state.
    https://www.baconsrebellion.com/virginias-student-growth-model-stunts-achievement/

    It seems a more prudent path forward would be to develop a bipartisan mission for the public PreK-12 educational program (with significant input from folks who understand the incentives and negative unintended consequences- i.e. educators) in which outcomes are clearly and objectively defined. Given the fact that Virginia is likely to teeter precariously back and forth from Blue to Red, partisan opportunities for initiatives unsupported by the other side will only have the effect of jerking the system violently back and forth. Both sides need to realize that they cannot remain in power indefinitely.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      I agree with you. But I do think there are some who are involved who oppose the concept of public education and want to tear it down – as opposed to others who disagree on what public schools should do or not.

      The current culture war IMO has some of it’s roots in the prior arguments about prayer in school, and grew from that core disagreement to expand to other issues involving other “values”.

      Saw this article, not good:

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a37056f1f4adfcf8235116b1879159d6e2d1de2a123beb2d7ffa5c166ac55e52.jpg

      https://apnews.com/article/school-report-card-parent-teacher-conference-53b69e145f2dca3a00b50c80004c4a1a

      1. Matt Hurt Avatar
        Matt Hurt

        I don’t care about the roots of the culture war in school, we just need to nip it in the bud, as Barney would say.

        The article you posted relates a very pervasive problem, one which Covid made significantly worse. Last year we had tons of kids earning A’s, B’s, and C’s on their report cards who also failed to meet the very basic minimum score on their SOL test.

        https://www.baconsrebellion.com/educational-expectations/

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          Part of the culture war is, IMO, not unlike the issue with religion, different values about what
          schools should teach or not and there is no “sweet spot” , just hardened and strident views. I sent the article because I thought it was about the “expectations” thing that you have spoken of.

          thanks.

Leave a Reply