UVA As a “Maze of Predatory Systems”

by James A. Bacon

If you visit the latest exhibit at the University of Virginia’s Ruffin Gallery, “EscapeRoom,” it takes no more than five or ten seconds for the artists’ message to sink in — the amount of time it takes to read the signage at the entrance:

The University of Virginia (UVA) is a site of reckoning. The legacies of slavery and white supremacy reverberate throughout its built environment. EscapeRoom confronts the frameworks of injustice that contemporary audiences inhabit and inherit in relation to this UNESCO World Heritage Site. … EscapeRoom charts critical routes through a maze of predatory systems.

Inside, the exhibits contributed by multiple artists elaborate upon the white-supremacy theme. Five 3D-printed pieces of porcelain, for instance, are described as giving “materiality, scale and dimension to the many ‘tools’ that mediate state violence visited upon Black victims: horses, batons, guns, tear gas, and more.”

A mobile made of steel sheet metal “examines violence visited upon Black people at the hands of the American state. It attends to the paradoxes of Black life and death in this anti-Black world.”

To set foot in the EscapeRoom is to enter a world of victimhood that would have been entirely justified a century or two ago but seems tragically out of date 60 years after the passage of Civil Rights legislation, the enactment of the Great Society’s war on poverty, and the dramatic transformation of attitudes toward race in America — not to mention the implementation of Racial Equity Task Force recommendations at UVA itself that made the exhibit possible in the first place.

Back in 2020 I was saddened and appalled when a student living on the Lawn scrawled “F— UVA” in massive letters on her door. In a subsequent TV interview she referred to the Lawn as a “space for whiteness” and Thomas Jefferson as a “white supremacist rapist and enslaver.” Where did this animosity originate, many of us wondered. How had such thinking gained legitimacy at Mr. Jefferson’s university?

The EscapeRoom exhibit provides part of the answer. The curators and artists speak not only for themselves. They speak with the approval and support of a University administration that has made a point of not just hiring more minority faculty and staff to the University but recruiting minorities marinated in the ideology of intersectional oppression.

Multimedia images from EscapeRoom

It is entirely legitimate to research and reflect upon the impact of slavery and racism in America, Virginia, and UVA. That is part of our history, and it must be incorporated into our collective memory. But what we see from University leadership under the guise of being “great and good” is an unremitting fixation on injustice, grievance, and victimhood that (1) drives home the message that racism and injustice are endemic are still prevalent today; (2) offers no vision of a way forward other than criticizing “whiteness”; and (3) solicits no alternative perspectives.

Not every scholar at UVA subscribes to those propositions. Many faculty members whose hiring preceded the current administration entertain more diverse perspectives. But faculty recruitment under President Jim Ryan has heavily favored faculty who do share the intersectional-oppression paradigm. In recent years, UVA has pulled every financial leverage available to advance the woke narrative. The $20 million spent to maintain UVA’s Diversity, Equity & Inclusion bureaucracy identified by Open the Books only scratches the surface. Intersectional-oppression rhetoric pervades every part of the university.

The EscapeRoom exhibit is illustrative. The Ruffin Gallery, located just off Rugby Road, showcases four to six contemporary art exhibits yearly. Those exhibits receive financial support from a variety of sources. EscapeRoom, for instance, is sponsored by three entities: the UVA Arts Council, the Vice Provost for the Arts, and the Department of Art.

Marisa Williamson as the ghost of Thomas Jefferson

The lead curator of the art exhibition is Marisa Williamson, an assistant professor of studio art. For a deep dive into her worldview, see the profile we are publishing in conjunction with this article, but in brief, she describes herself as a project-based artist who works in video, image-making, installation and performance “around themes of history, race, feminism, and technology.” At various times, she has engaged in performance art as Sally Hemings, alleged rape victim of Thomas Jefferson, and has portrayed Jefferson’s ghost in whiteface.

Despite her status as a victim of intersectional oppression (doubly held down as Black and as a woman), Williamson nonetheless managed to get admitted into and graduate from Harvard and go on to win grants from the Graham Foundation, Rema Hort Mann Foundation and the Arthur and Elizabeth Schlesinger Library on the History of Women in America. In 2018, she was appointed the Ruffin Distinguished Artist in Residence at UVA. Her works have been featured in exhibitions around the country and abroad.

According to her UVA website, Williamson was part of the first cohort of faculty hired through a $5 million initiative devoted to “Race, Justice and Equity.” That builds upon a $3.5 million Andrew W. Mellon Foundation-funded grant to hire 10 tenure/tenure track faculty working on the Global South (Africa, Latin America, South Asia, East Asia, and other regions); another Mellon Foundation grant to appoint “30 Race, Place and Equity” postdoctoral fellows across the University; and a University endowment commitment to recruit “underrepresented graduate students.”

“Our national reckoning on race, justice and equity will test and sharpen our commitment to democracy and reshape the nation: comprehensively, and one community at a time,” stated the November 2020 proposal to Mellon submitted by Provost Ian Baucom, DEI head Kevin McDonald, and the deans of the Batten school of leadership, the McIntire school of commerce, and the College of Arts & Sciences.

One of the best means by which we tell that history is through place-based education and by bringing a next generation of scholars to this place, a University that lives at that point of urgent intersection, to help us imagine and shape its future. [My bold.]

The proposal suggested that “a robust racial equity post-doctoral fellows and faculty-hiring program … will build a community of scholars of race, justice, and equity who can help lead our university, our community, and the nation.”

The exhibit itself was sponsored by the UVA Department of Art and the UVA Arts Council. In the 2022-23 year, the Arts Council disseminated $127,000 in grants to Charlottesville-area programs, including $10,000 to Ruffin Gallery “exhibitions and artists in residence.”

The abstract multimedia presentations might bewilder some visitors to EscapeRoom. In an interview with WTJU radio, Williamson provides an explanation that might prove helpful to those who find the artwork an unintelligible jumble of words, images and themes. “One big theme is race, vision and surveillance,” she said. “That might give us some clues into how Black and brown, and women, and fem people who are vulnerable in society might combat or avoid these dominant surveillance strategies.”

“I wanted to lay a groundwork for being able to interrogate the university from within and perform some institutional critique in a subtle way to get those conversations started about what can be done, mapping the history of this university so we can start repairing where we can in very specific ways,” she continued.

“This show,” she said, “is just the beginning of a larger effort to make visible a hidden past here at UVA.”

James A. Bacon is executive director of the Jefferson Council. This article was published originally on the Jefferson Council blog.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

26 responses to “UVA As a “Maze of Predatory Systems””

  1. Virginia Gentleman Avatar
    Virginia Gentleman

    Does the Jefferson Council exist entirely to eliminate anything that looks like DEI at UVA? This has to be the 50th blog post on this subject.

    1. walter smith Avatar
      walter smith

      Conversely, does UVA exist to do any actual education, as opposed to non-stop DEI indoctrination?
      (Besides lying about Jefferson…)

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        I bet large numbers of students sail through the school with no notice of all this background drama and noise. Which is why the push is on to create mandatory courses in the evilness of white people which the E-school and B-school and Pre-meds cannot just ignore. But they will take little notice of those, as well, as they head on to their respective careers.

        1. walter smith Avatar
          walter smith

          They much prefer to. It’s how it should be! But they have to be on eggshells to avoid triggering the recruited and subsidized pet activists who populate the Cav Daily, Student Council and all the CIOs (College Independent Organizations? Subsidized by Student Activities Fees and home to the likes of SJP and all the other grievance clubs.)

          1. Virginia Gentleman Avatar
            Virginia Gentleman

            Also known as students …

          2. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            The clubs of recruited and subsidized activists? Yes, they are students. And many admitted for their politics or “color” or whatever “marginalization” was part of their “struggle” that as such wise and worldly 17 year olds, they provide “diversity” to UVA, but not one whit of a diversity of thought. Then, maybe they actually get a job at UVA after graduation to make their path available to even more future activists, or go to a NGO, which is subsidized with government funds to do the illegal things the government can’t do directly, to further destroy the country.
            Academia is a giant money laundering scheme to promote democrat politics…that’s what “Save our Democracy” really means.

    2. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Yes. Raison d’etre for BR is DE&I at UV&A. Gives him something at which to rage. Others here have their windmills with some windmills being really windmills.

      Keep waiting for the “didn’t earn it” slight, but I probably just missed it.

    3. Thomas Carter Avatar
      Thomas Carter

      Sometimes, the path to success is arduous.

  2. Perhaps large numbers of students take no notice, but it’s pretty clear the “Maze of Predatory Systems” at the University extends well beyond the Escape Room in faculty and administration circles. If the Jefferson Council can identify a path past the predation and out of the Maze, the University’s alumni should be grateful.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      The same nonsense may or may not infect W&M. As an alum, I don’t care. I got the benefit of my time there, in a different age. And the faculty even in those days was far, far more liberal than I, but as you’ve all noticed marching to my own drum is nothing new for me. Faculty do not live in the real world but the students will have to. 😉 Ms. Williamson wouldn’t stand a chance, and I don’t expect anyone will see her work in the Louvre a century from now.

      1. Most of us were exposed to these academic institutions in a different age. Within academe, it seems to me the “big business” priorities governing these institutions today are the root cause of that different age. Throughout corporate America big business brings its own Maze Of Predatory Systems to protect its public image and ensure conformity to its “brand.”

      2. Matt Adams Avatar
        Matt Adams

        The largest difference being “liberal” and “progressive”. The former encouraged sometimes begrudgingly free thought and respected difference of opinion. The later requires subjugations and an echo chamber.

      3. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Not everyone can write “Hamilton” especially without taking license.

    2. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Labyrinth popped into my head, but Augean Stables works too. Quick question; how do you manage to speak so clearly with your tongue thrust so firmly into your cheek? TJC find a path out. Good one. Out? The money and adrenaline is in the middle.

      Your response to Steve is dead on. I entered academia in 1970 and exited in 2005. It’s big business now. Everything has changed. Power has consolidated in the executive office and dwindled in the faculty senate. The faculty has been cowed. Occasionally, one or two rise up and make the news and JB’s ire, but for the most part they just get&go along.

      1. I think the comparison between the “Escape Room” and the Augean Stables is an apt one.

        A whole lot of bulls### that’s almost impossible to get rid of…

        And I doubt the Rivanna River is up to the task…

      2. I think the comparison between the “Escape Room” and the Augean Stables is an apt one.

        A whole lot of bulls### that’s almost impossible to get rid of…

        And I doubt the Rivanna River is up to the task…

  3. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    “ Back in 2000 I was saddened and appalled when a student living on the Lawn scrawled “F— UVA” in massive letters on her door.”

    Wow, tempus fugit. Seems like it was just a few years ago.

    1. DJRippert Avatar
      DJRippert

      I noticed that too. No way it was 2000.

  4. Back in 2000 I was saddened and appalled when a student living on the Lawn scrawled “F— UVA” in massive letters on her door.

    Are you sure that wasn’t in 2020?

    1. Ack! You’re absolutely right. Correction made.

  5. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    “…will build a community of scholars of race, justice, and equity who can help lead our university, our community, and the nation.”

    If that bothers you, you must really hate the Patrick Henry College mission statement:

    https://www.phc.edu/history-and-mission

    1. Wouldn’t “…will build a community of scholars who can help lead our university, our community, and the nation.” be more diverse and inclusive?

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        That was pretty much the slogan of old UVa back when it was proudly populated exclusively by white male elitists… so no…

        1. Thomas Carter Avatar
          Thomas Carter

          Seriously?

          1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
            Eric the half a troll

            Are you saying that wasn’t the slogan back then?

  6. Chip Gibson Avatar
    Chip Gibson

    To the honorable James A. Bacon, thanks for ruining the morning with your well researched, organized, and justified presentation of the state of our institutional insanity. Remaining in your debt for standing upon the wall of right, freedom, justice, and what was once noble cause and civil endeavor.

    Residing on the Lawn, in those spartan enclosures, was once a great privilege and accomplishment; now, seeming to be a petting zoo for deviants.

    “The legacies of slavery and white supremacy reverberate throughout its built environment” and a black woman white face caricature of President Thomas Jefferson…. again, woke is now a disease which must be treated aggressively and often.

Leave a Reply