The Monetary Rape of Middle-Class Retirees

by James A. Bacon

This past year saw one of the greatest redistributions of wealth in U.S. history. People are upset by the 8.5% increase in inflation, but they’re not nearly as upset as they should be.

Wage earners, especially lower-income wage earners, have every right to be irate. Their hourly pay has increased, but not nearly as rapidly as the Consumer Price Index, and far less than those components of the CPI such as food, housing and gasoline that comprise a major share of their household budgets. Many were living paycheck to paycheck before the onset of inflation. Now they’re drowning.

Retirees ought to be enraged. Inflation is more devastating by far to their financial security than taxes. A retiree family with a middle-class standard of living might pay, say, $20,000 a year in federal taxes. But if they have a $1 million nest egg in 401(k), IRA and other investments, an 8.5% inflation rate pillages $85,000 from their net worth.

Who are the beneficiaries of inflation? Borrowers — homeowners with a mortgage, consumers with credit card debt, motorists paying off notes on their cars, corporations that have taken advantage of Federal Reserve Bank-engineered low interest rates to leverage their balance sheets, and, of course, the biggest borrower on the face of the planet… the U.S. federal government.

The U.S. government debt now amounts to $30.4 trillion, the equivalent of $91,000 per citizen (or $360,000 per family of four). An 8.5% inflation rate eroded the value of the national debt by nearly $2.6 trillion — a massive gift to the political class.

That compares to $15.6 trillion in total consumer debt at the end of 2021. Inflation reduced the real value of consumers’ obligations by $1.3 trillion, but that only partially offsets what it robbed from their savings.

How much did inflation cost households? Here are the numbers. According to the Federal Reserve Bank, total U.S. financial assets amounted to $118 trillion at the end of 2021. Poof! That’s $10 trillion in value up in smoke.

Corporations owed $10.5 trillion in mid-2021. Inflation erodes the debt burden by about $900 million.

If you’re retired, or approaching retirement, and you’ve played by the rules and done the right thing, building up a retirement savings and paying off the mortgage of your house, you are totally screwed. You’ve been monetarily raped.

Admittedly, seniors are among the biggest beneficiaries of federal spending, so the massive deficit spending and accumulating debt does cut two ways. Medicare Part B (covering physician services) and Part D (covering drugs) are significant drivers of deficit spending, and retirees are the biggest beneficiaries of the nation’s reckless fiscal policies. But rather than make the hard decisions that would put the nation on a sustainable fiscal course, Washington’s political class has become untethered from economic reality. Washington is making no effort to keep promises to elders — promises around which they have built their retirement planning.

Medicare Part A’s hospitalization trust fund runs out in 2026, and Social Security’s trust fund in 2034. Payouts will be limited to what Uncle Sam collects in payroll taxes — projected to be 74% of promised levels for Social Security.

In a column which Bacon’s Rebellion republished yesterday, Chris Saxman argued that a “silver surge” helped propel the Virginia GOP to electoral victory in 2021. If elders were aggravated when inflation was running between 6% and 7% in November, they’d be brandishing torches and pitchforks now if it weren’t for their bad knees and lumbago.

Compounding the resentment of fiscal looting is the increase in violent crime and general erosion of public order. Remember, seniors are less physically robust and more risk-averse than younger Americans, and, therefore, more fearful of crime and mayhem. Then there’s the transgender mania. Young people may be adaptable to the idea of multiple gender identities, but the erosion of the distinction between men and women strikes most elders as literally insane — as in a product of mental illness. Old guys and gals have a sense that the world is falling apart, and they’re none too happy about it.

As Saxman notes, old people vote.

The monetary policy responsible for inflation is beyond the control of state and local government officials. Governor Glenn Younkin has the right idea, though. The state’s fiscal cup floweth over. March 2022 revenues exceeded expectations by 22%, according to a press release issued by the Governor’s Office issued this morning.

Said Youngkin: “There’s plenty of money in the system to provide critical tax cuts and needed relief for Virginians struggling with rising gas prices and record-high inflation on groceries and the products they need every day.”

The tax breaks he has in mind are a pittance compared to the scorched earth left by federal fiscal and monetary policy, but at least it’s something. Voters will remember.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

44 responses to “The Monetary Rape of Middle-Class Retirees”

  1. Virginia Gentleman Avatar
    Virginia Gentleman

    Yep — it is about time for the Big Spending Right to conveniently forget the trillions of dollars in spending passed in 2020 supported by Republicans and signed by then-President Donald Trump which economists say has contributed to inflation being where it is today.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      It’s about time? They forgot it as soon as the fat Shapie signed it. And by “fat Sharpie” I don’t mean the pen.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Yep. The GOP … USED to be able to legitimately call themselves fiscal conservatives… no more – now with their whining about the economy and inflation – they themselves helped so it’s gone from honor to hypocrisy.

      Just like in Virginia. Tax cuts out the wazoo… no matter the downstream consequences – ye old GOP “fiscal conservatives” can’t control themselves when the catnip of tax cuts captures them!

      so it takes BOTH some Dems and some GOP in the Va Senate to do what Youngkin did not do – a proper analysis of the current revenues and future forecasts before we sc&&& the proverbial fiscal pooch.

  2. Lefty665 Avatar

    “Social Security and Medicare significant drivers of deficit spending”

    I take the thrust and generally the content of your post. The fiscal mess we are in is bad, and it is getting worse. As an old f*art that makes me anxious.

    However, both Social Security and Medicare currently have surpluses, neither has added a nickel to the deficit. You acknowledge that with your observation that their funding runs out in the future. Please stop perpetuating the fiction that current SS and Medicare programs add to the deficit. They do not.

    In addition to the Medicare taxes we paid all our working lives my wife and I are now paying monthly Medicare premiums out of our Social Security benefits. The coverage is generally good so I’m not bitching, but it ain’t a deficit government give away and has never been.

    1. You’re right about Social Security — and I’ll amend the text of my post. But Medicare Part B is a significant deficit driver.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Not SSI & SSDI?

        1. Lefty665 Avatar

          SSDI comes from the Social Security Trust Fund. SSI is general funds and is strictly regulated.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Not SSI & SSDI?

  3. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    re: ” Social Security and Medicare are significant drivers of deficit spending”

    Social Security and Medicare Part A are funded from FICA not general revenues.

  4. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    re: ” and retirees are the biggest beneficiaries of the nation’s reckless fiscal policies. But rather than make the hard decisions that would put the nation on a sustainable fiscal course, Washington’s political class has become untethered from economic reality. Washington is making no effort to keep promises to elders — promises around which they have built their retirement planning.”

    Since social security and Medicare Part A are funded from FICA taxes, then Medicare Part B is certainly part of the deficit.

    but so is – money that is not taxed that is spent on employer-provided health care , and other that do very much benefit the middle class:

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/3a8e7fcfe180597e16ef75624e6f99ebcff4a8e90e19d961e16932fffd484af6.jpg

    If we really want to talk fiscal responsibility – we have to admit the whole truth and not be selective.

    Seniors do benefit from Medicare Part B – about 600 billion a year.

    But the middle class also has tax subsidies:

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/d02bd2312d37bb8d1c4d4c322ca7fcd88669f2988463aa13de5a32c37c6d0a4e.jpg

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/4e643dff3084a16b07b587222eb1ebc81c8e6861e5d2739800f9d71c599c1628.jpg

      if we cut out all tax expenditures, we could easily cut the deficit by 2/3.

      Then we could increase the cost of Medicare PartB to reach a balanced budget

      BUT it would take BOTH seniors AND middle class to do it.

  5. David Wojick Avatar
    David Wojick

    Technically this is a price spike not inflation. This is important because the remedies are different. Inflation is when the dollar loses value. These are real price increases led by energy price spikes, which then spread to everything that uses energy, which is everything.

    1. A couple percentage points can be attributed to “price spikes” from volatile components like food and energy. But the “core” rate of inflation has surged as well, to about 6% or so. At some point the price of oil will come back down, as it always does, and inflation will moderate. I’ll feel so much better when the CPI drops from an 8.5% annual increase to a mere 5-6% annual increase. Not.

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Oh, the M1 money supply has grown 1400% since Obama (and yes Trump’s spending was part of that) so this is very much classic inflation. It is never just one thing, but that’s a very big thing.

      1. David Wojick Avatar
        David Wojick

        The jump is now, not “since Obama”. It started in Europe, then spread globally.

    3. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      Exactly… agreed 100%

      1. David Wojick Avatar
        David Wojick

        When coal suddenly jumps 300% then steel 100% then everthing using steel 10% it is hard to blame the money supply.

        1. Nancy Naive Avatar
          Nancy Naive

          Especially when the industries are also at record profits.

          1. David Wojick Avatar
            David Wojick

            If profits are a fixed fraction of sales then they go up with prices unless sales drop. Coal sales are way up.

          2. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Generally speaking yes. Most companies shoot for a percentage of profit. My company looked for between 8 and 10% on a contract. Happy with 6 or 7.

            The Great A&P, remember them? “A penny of profit per day”. But it’s tough paying ULM 50x worker salary and $1M bonuses on a penny a day.

            We have our oligarchs too.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        and if anything DOES change, blame must be assigned…..

  6. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Well, let’s say it’s inflation. You have 3 choices.
    1) increase immigration,
    2) increase taxes,
    3) both.

    I’m down for both, either, neither, but ooowheee will the Republicans squeal.

    1. The only choice in the long run is to bring the growth in the money supply back into alignment with the rate of economic growth.

      As for increasing immigration, it’s not much of a choice for lower-income Americans to increase competition for their labor by goosing the supply of workers from low-wage countries.

      But oooowheeeee Democratic elites won’t have to pay nearly as much for their landscaping and domestic help.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Or… this guy is right, and clearly, you agree, at least when it comes to Dominion.
        https://www.inequalitymedia.org/the-truth-about-inflation

        He’s the closest thing I could find to a “one-handed economist.” I cannot recall him ever saying, “but on the other hand…”

        1. Lefty665 Avatar

          But surely he’s said it somewhere, it is one of the graduation requirements.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      well, getting the blame assigned is paramount.. and how to actually fix it – if it involves taxes or fees is not acceptable. Once blame is assigned, they are done.

  7. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    “Who are the beneficiaries of inflation?”

    Corporations, particularly the oil & gas industry.

  8. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Surely (Shirley) you are not implying the folks in Washington ever intentionally trigger inflation. Intentionally erode the value of the currency so they can repay debt more easily. What a thought.

    I agree the Virginia Greens (er, Democrats) who are standing firm against a budget compromise and insisting on the smallest possible tax reforms/rebates — to feed the spending for their key voting blocs — are going to get creamed at the next election. They think in 18 months we’ll be out of this. No way.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Irrational exuberance.

  9. DJRippert Avatar
    DJRippert

    Slow Joe’s endless excuses, articulated by Jen Psaki (aka, Little Red Lying Hood) are falling on deaf ears. His latest approval numbers, from a Quinnepac poll, were an abysmal 33%. The key swing voting bloc of “Independents” gave him a 25% approval rating.

    I wonder how Virginia’s Democratic US Congresspeople will relate to the Three Stooges of the Apocalypse – Biden, Harris and Pelosi – as it ges closer to election day.

    1. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      As soon as the four GOP electoral deniers publicly reveal their reasons for voting to reject AZ and PA results, Dems can answer the question.

      1. f/k/a_tmtfairfax Avatar
        f/k/a_tmtfairfax

        Biden is so demented that he identified himself as Jon. I thought Trump was the bottom, but Slow Joe is the most incompetent individual to sit in the White House. And the Red-Head has the ethics of Hunter Biden, negotiating for a job with NBC while she is still the White House spokesperson.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          The choice was between Biden and Trump. Does anyone seriously believe we would have been better off with Trump? I’ll take Biden ANY DAY over that idiot who would have wreaked havoc both domestically and worldwide.

          No contest.

          1. DJRippert Avatar
            DJRippert

            Yes, I believe the country would have been better off with Trump.

            Mean Tweets and an accelerated vaccine vs …

            1. A catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan
            2. Skyrocketing inflation, not a “transitory price spike” as Little Red Lying Hood would have you believe.
            3. $5.00 per gallon gas
            4. A sinking stock market
            5. The catastrophic Build Back Better legislation that was killed by the GOP and 2 Democratic senators
            6. A VP who is a laughing stock of a nitwit

            Trump may not have been the best president but Biden is a senile blithering idiot who, as Obama observed, “Don’t underestimate Joe’s ability to (expletive) things up”.

            Yeah – we’re much better off with Captain Senility in the Oval Office.

          2. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            Trump was well on his way to becoming a dictator. He was willing to try to undo an election. Ukraine would have been handed over to Russia without a whimper. All Federal agencies would be run by folks who would do what Trump wanted no matter the law.

            Trump would be personally attacking judges, and all manner of people both inside and outside of govt.

            This country would no longer be the Country it was. The rest of the world and NATO was running away and rightly so with this idiot loving dictators like Putin.

        2. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          Biden’s bad compared to Kushner?

  10. walter smith Avatar
    walter smith

    Transitory…
    2 weeks to slow the spread…
    If you like your plan…
    A man can have a baby…
    The oldsters have been getting screwed since Obama with the 0% interest rates. They thought a $500,000 nest egg would generate $25k plus Social Security and they’d be all set…
    So, no, this is going to be very bad, but ignore what you see and trust Larry and full Troll and Nancy who will tell us not to believe our own eyes and pocketbooks and they’ll pull up the cooked-books government chart…blah blah blah.
    My coffee at Walmart went from 9.88 to 11.24…
    Have you noticed the price of premium ice cream? Eggs? It’s just hitting now. Wait until the fertilizer costs and scarcity from Ukraine kick in…
    But trust the people who haven’t been right this time!

  11. Lefty665 Avatar

    reply to CN

    The accumulated debt from 1786 to 1980 including all the wars was about $1T. When Reagan left office it was about $3T.

    Clinton’s last 2 budgets were in surplus and the debt was forecast to be paid off by 2018. Duhbya never met an occasion that did not call for a tax cut, and he put all his wars on our credit card.

    The % of budget deficit decreased under Obama although the dollar amount of national debt kept increasing. Trump’s tax cuts plus Dem spending (you scratch my back I’ll scratch yours) put us on the path to having national debt larger than gross domestic product for the first time
    since WWII.

    Covid spending and Biden’s deficits have sealed the deal of national debt greater than GDP.

    Now we are working on convincing the world that the dollar is no longer a reliable reserve currency. Countries are starting to use Rubles and Yuan to pay for oil, gas and coal. Our whole post WWII house of debt cards may collapse on our kids and grand kids.

  12. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Well, do yourselves a favor. Redeed your house using a Transfer on Death Deed to transfer your property to your kid(s) and avoid probate and lawyers fees. Don’t forget your cars also have ToD registration, i.e., “or surv”. Make sure your accounts have beneficiary statements and that you NEVER assign your estate as the beneficiary on insurance policies. These are much better than a Will. Let ’em fight over the furniture, and not in probate.

  13. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Really fascinating that JAB can claim that demand-driven inflation is “raping” seniors on the one hand and turn around to argue for stimulative tax cuts on the other hand…. I guess he thinks grandpa needs another round…

Leave a Reply