The Kids Are Not All Right

by Kerry Dougherty

Remember when they told us students were “resilient”? Remember when they said kids didn’t need to see faces to learn? How about when they claimed remote learning was a fine substitute for in-person classes?

Remember when they said those who wanted schools open were selfish, just wanted babysitters for their kids, or worse, wanted to “kill grandma?” Remember when they said cloth masks protected against Covid?

Well, they were wrong. About all of it. And the kids suffered.

Boy, did they.

The nation’s so-called “report card” was released Thursday morning and even The New York Times — print media’s biggest cheerleader for lockdowns — had to admit that the results of Covid lockdowns were catastrophic for school children.

Their headline is wrong, though. The pandemic didn’t cause learning loss. School closures did. Time to stop conflating hysterical overreactions to COVID with the pandemic itself. The blame for this godawful mess rests squarely on the shoulders of the lockdown lobby.

The Washington Post, also a strong supporter of lockdowns, did better than The Times:

Student Test Scores Plunged During Pandemic.

So did US News.com:

New Federal Achievement Data Shows Grim Trajectory for Country’s 9 Year-Olds.

The Nation’s Report Card was issued by the National Assessment of Educational Progress. It showed that America’s 9-year-olds fell far behind in math and reading after 2020.

“The drastic academic declines hit almost all races and income levels. In math, Black students lost 13 points, compared with five points among White students. Nine-year-old’s reading scores dropped by the largest margin in more than 30 years. reported Fox News.

And the most devastating part of the report:

Already low-performing students were hit hardest.

The fact that militant teachers’ unions led Democratic governors and the CDC around on leashes and either couldn’t see or didn’t care what they were doing to children is a scandal.

Remember who Terry McAuliffe campaigned with on the eve of last November’s Virginia gubernatorial election?

Randi Weingarten.

Yep, the Queen of School Closures. The teachers’ union boss who believed in the fantasy that kids could learn to read via Zoom. Clearly Weingarten knows nothing about children.

Weingarten, whose union worked with the CDC to draw up “reopening” guidelines that were so unworkable that schools were forced to remain closed in states like Virginia for nearly two years. States that ignored the CDC fared far better.

This abysmal showing by students is the fault of Weingarten, the CDC and governors like Ralph Northam, who hastily closed schools, and slavishly followed CDC guidelines, making it difficult for school districts to comply and reopen.

Yesterday Governor Glenn Youngkin announced an initiative to repair the damage brought on by his predecessor’s policies. The program, called “Bridging the Gap,“ is a pilot being launched in 15 school districts to address learning losses.

This needs to go statewide and soon.

Virginia has a lot of catching up to do. We owe it to the kids to get it done.

This column has been republished with permission from Kerry: Unemployed & Unedited.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

43 responses to “The Kids Are Not All Right”

  1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
    Kathleen Smith

    I have looked at Virginia’s data. Honestly, we have far to go, but maybe not as much as the news would like us to believe. Kids are back in school, good news, teachers are teaching, more good news. Lessons learned moving forward are lessons, but it isn’t hard. Teach. Spend more time teaching what matters to each kid. Count each valuable second as an opportunity to teach. Going to bathroom break means quizing kids on multiplication facts. Going to lunch, means recite rhyming patterns. Don’t give up fifteen minutes at then end of the day to get their things together to go home, give up three. Three minutes is enough time if you help kids organize in advance. 12 minutes x 180 days is a lot of time (36 hours). Teachers can do this, kids can do this. Let’s not tell them they can’t.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      As always happens, you left out the most important people, the parents. Unless the parents double down, making the little darlings put down the &^%$ phones and turn off the %$#( screens and read a book, unless they help with the math and spelling drills, etc., the loss is permanent.

      It’s bad, Kathleen, very, very bad. In some divisions like Richmond it is an epic disaster.

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      As always happens, you left out the most important people, the parents. Unless the parents double down, making the little darlings put down the &^%$ phones and turn off the %$#( screens and read a book, unless they help with the math and spelling drills, etc., the loss is permanent.

      It’s bad, Kathleen, very, very bad. In some divisions like Richmond it is an epic disaster.

    3. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      As always happens, you left out the most important people, the parents. Unless the parents double down, making the little darlings put down the &^%$ phones and turn off the %$#! screens and read a book, unless they help with the math and spelling drills, etc., the loss is permanent. (Oh, that’s right, those drills are out of fashion….silly me.)

      It’s bad, Kathleen, very, very bad. In some divisions like Richmond it is an epic disaster.

      I also was disappointed in Northam, but those who complain he was too strict with lockdowns just hate him and want to ignore fact. The problem after the initial wave of school closings, BLESSED BY THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, was once it became clear the kids could go back to school, Northam dithered, caved and showed zero leadership, let the localities scatter to the winds. He better than anyone, a pediatrician, understood the damage but by that point his cojones were in other people’s pockets and he caved.

      To date CDC reports 27 deaths age 17 and under in VA tied to COVID, and you know at least some of those were very sick kids before they got it. OTOH, 15,000 deaths age 65 and up. Assuming the schools were the same environment as the nursing homes was to ignore the obvious.

      1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
        Kathleen Smith

        Teachers have to lead the charge, and yes, parents do too!

  2. LarrytheG Avatar

    Gov Younkin is apparently working on some changes that at first blush sound good. He’s talking about apprenticeship programs for teachers and paras. Would love to hear more about it from someone in BR who can write it is fair and objective terms.

  3. The perfect storm: corrupt unions, corrupt government officials, corrupt health officials, corrupt pharma…. and the kids suffer. Saint Fauci even stated he didn’t think the harm was permanent nor irreparable…. he should know as he’s science.

    Stephen, if parents are the solution/cause, I assume you believe government should let then let them take their tax dollars and children where they want…..

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      St. Fauci don’t know his ^%$# from a hole in the ground about education. I’m fascinated that you think the parents are NOT the most important teacher, public or private setting? They are either way. No, nameless one (unless this is Kathleen), I do think all taxpayers have a stake in effective, free public schools and should continue to pay for them, but some level of government support to provide choice to low income students is an excellent addition.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Shinola. It’s $#!^ from Shinola.

        1. Stephen Haner Avatar
          Stephen Haner

          I edited and went a different route….

          1. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            You always do.

      2. LarrytheG Avatar

        The average taxpayer in Virginia pays about $3K and that covers everything including education.

        The state kicks in about 5K of the 10K cost of k-12 – rough average.

        So if we had a rule that allowed citizens to take the tax money and go find a school for their kid, they’d have to find one that cost 3-5K or so. I’d say let them do it. It would save the rest of us money and give them something else to _itch about.

      3. 1. I never stated parents were not the most important teacher [if you think I did, please point to which words stated such].
        2. I believe in freedom of choice and the govt should help those without the means to achieve such with that option.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          “freedom of choice” is a nice sounding phrase that really means nothing if there is no transportation provided to the child like there is for nearby neighborhood public schools.

          The fundamental problem is what do we do about kids whose parents are poorly educated, and work low income jobs and are unable or unwilling to help their kids.

          Do we abandon these kids?

          That seems to be the premise behind charter schools like Success Academy that demand parental involvement or the kid is booted.

          1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
            Kathleen Smith

            I worked my entire teaching career in Petersburg. Parents that will not help their kids are few and far between those that can but lack skill in many areas.

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            Lord, you answered me!

            I know teachers , some pretty well and as you say, most of the time, the situation is that parents are not capable of helping their kids. There are others that may or may not but have no trouble taking their kids – who are behind – out of school for a week or kids who shift who they live with , etc.

            The question is – what do we do with these kids who do not have parental support and are failing?

            Do we just abandon them?

            serious question. I don’t blame the teachers at all – they have the rest of the class they must attend to.

            The Charter School folks claim that if there was a Charter, they would “help” these kids that the public schools are failing.

            I’m a skeptic. I have no trouble at all with publicly funded charter schools that do perform especially with the low-income/low education (economically disadvantaged” demographic.

            It they can do it , let’s do it.

            But call me a skeptic at this point. I just don’t see a good plan being offered by the proponents.

            Their only “plan” seems to be a claim that Charters will do better and don’t need transparency and accountability like public schools do.

            thanks for responding!

  4. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Glen Y’s “Bridging the Gap” initiative has captured the headlines with an emphasis on teacher recruitment.

    Embedded in the executive order we find the creation of personal individualized data reports for every student.

    Students not on track will have a Personalized Learning Plan constructed by teachers, parents, and students to bring learning loss up to speed.

    15 school districts are in the pilot. Starts Fall of 2023. Not one NOVA district is participating.

    https://www.doe.virginia.gov/instruction/bridging-the-gap/index.shtml

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Saw that also. Interesting. Haner thinks it adds paperwork. Probably does, but what’s actually in such IEPs? What actual things are done to bring the kid back up to snuff? Tell the teacher to teach harder? Tell the parents to do better? Call in additional teachers? Would be an interesting blog post – again if done on a fair and objective basis and not as yet another attack on public education.

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Mrs. H. would have to write it. But I bet Whitehead has dealt with an IEP and can answer.

        1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
          James Wyatt Whitehead

          A well written IEP that has commitment from teachers, parent, and student should result in an eventual exit from the plan. Unfortunately, successful exits don’t happen often enough. I have to assume that Glenn Y’s PLP will put the parents in the driver’s seat for what is written out into the plan. The PLP must be straight forward for parents to understand. If it becomes tangled in law, policy, and education code speak all will be in vain.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar

            More than a few of the parents are the problem in the first place.

          2. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
            James Wyatt Whitehead

            So are more than a few teachers, administrators, and bureaucrats.

            Glenn Y ran on this. Put the parents in charge of their own child’s education. We shall see how this works out.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar

            In K-3, the kids try hard if their parents urge them to do so.

            It’s the kids whose parents don’t care that usually have problems.

            And this is the essence of those who advocate for voucher/success type schools – i.e. parental support to enroll.

            Teachers, administrator and bureaucrats can’t help if the parents are not on board.

            Most parents don’t want their kids to get bad grades – even if the kid deserves them.

            Called the bigotry of low expectations… teachers do it to avoid parental anger.

            All said and done, willing to give Youngkin a chance to have a run at it – and hope he succeeds but to do so, he will have to face some hard realities as to things that are not in the hands of teachers.

            If he wants to “toughen” standards, more kids will fail unless he has to way to boost them all up higher academically.

            If he can do that with “Lab” schools , apprenticeship and IEPs, I’ll give him credit further support his reform unilaterally.

      2. Kathleen Smith Avatar
        Kathleen Smith

        Larry, it is not the plan that will help the child, it is the teacher. Just teach.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          Hey Kathleen – If a teacher has 15-18 kids and all but 3 are doing fine and the 3 are not and do not have good parental support, what does that teacher do then?

          I know at one school – the teacher is evaluated based on how many of her/his kids advance to the next grade and how many are behind grade level. At the SOL grades, it’s basically how many kids pass the SOLs and how many do not.

          Is that how it works in your neck of the woods?

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Goody, lots more paperwork burden…weren’t we just discussing similar IEPs on discipline issues? Is there evidence that the approach has worked with special ed, where it has been the rule for decades now? If there is, that’s one thing. You can’t do this to teachers with 30 elementary kids in a class…or 150 middle schoolers in a subject. You will need more people….good luck with that!

      1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
        James Wyatt Whitehead

        I detect the teacher blood pressure meter rising again.

      2. Yes, there is abundant evidence that IEPs work with kids in Special Ed. They are the central tool that identify the disability, the methods used to remediate it and the measures of success.

        You may have legitimate reservations about the current proposal. That is no excuse to throw dirt on policies and procedures addressing a very different issue that have long proved effective.

        Just for the record, behavioral programming for discipline issues also have proved effective. Their shortcomings were when they were stopped. A chronic behavior/discipline problem is a very different issue than an acute learning deficit precipitated by the abandonment of in school learning. Once that deficit is remedied the plan is no longer needed. Discipline issues need longer term attention.

  5. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Two decades, eh? So, no New Math?

  6. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Wait! Does this mean that we’ll have a generation of Americans who can take back the jobs that the lazy undocumented workers came here to steal?

    I always wondered about that GOP talking point. Which is it? Are the illegals lazy, or are they here to steal our jobs?

  7. f/k/a_tmtfairfax Avatar
    f/k/a_tmtfairfax

    Discovered this school while on a walk through the neighborhood. https://www.esaeagles.com/ I assumed its was a Wake County Public School. Wrong!

    And look at who founded the school. https://www.esaeagles.com/about-esa/history MSM wouldn’t like that.

    Honors. https://www.esaeagles.com/about-esa/honors

    School improvement process. https://www.esaeagles.com/about-esa/school-improvement-plan

    This guy cannot have been an MSM reporter. He’s actually investigated and published facts and data that editorial boards would not like published.
    https://ncpolicywatch.com/2022/05/02/monday-numbers-a-closer-look-charter-schools-in-north-carolina/

  8. LarrytheG Avatar

    We still have this issue with Kerry and Sherlock where they talk about Virginia as if the issues are only specific to Virginia and they’re not.

    Both Kerry and Sherlock implicate the institutions as a whole as if public education leadership and “thinking” is responsible for the pandemic as well as the academic “gaps” in general.

    It’s NOT just a Virginia problem and it’s not a de-facto state level or nation “conspiracy” either.

    So what these narratives really boil down to is attacks on public education itself and the “solution” is somewhat akin to “burn it all down and start over” … “reform”.

    The irony is – that NAEP is a Government activity – that does provide transparency into all the states academic performance including Virginia. The NCLB national law is the one that mandated that each state perform standardized assessments that require the testing and providing the results of that testing to citizens – and parents.

    It is THIS DATA and regulations that Kerry and Sherlock use to impugn the public education system.

    Without those laws and regulations, we’d simply not know, and the critics would have no ammunition – and HEY, there are some folks who want to do away with all of it… and go to voucher schools instead!

  9. Chrissy Taylor Avatar
    Chrissy Taylor

    All of these children’s futures thrown under the bus……. just so they could ruin and defame Donald Trump! That’s what it really all boils down to.😒
    In hindsight…it’s easy to see why all of this “calamity and overreaction” occurred. The bureaucrats were protecting their interests. And now we’re busy having to deal with the easily foreseeable aftermath of purposeful bad actions and malfeasance.🤦‍♀️

  10. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    “…or worse, wanted to “kill grandma?””

    Wonderful to see the Conservative philosophy that if grandparents had to die to keep schools open… so be it… so eloquently expressed yet again… what a way with words you have, Kerry…

    1. DJRippert Avatar

      How many liberal commenters on this blog insisted that reopening the schools would risk the lives of the students, teachers, administrators and … yes … parents and grandparents? Fortunately, some schools and school districts didn’t listen to the libtwittery promulgated by the lefties on BR. They opened early. Guess what? No piles of dead bodies. The libtwits were wrong. But do the liberals admit they were wrong? Oh, hell no! They spew verbal diarrhea about Kerry’s choice of words. Heaven forbid that a libtwit admit he was wrong.

Leave a Reply