Virginia School Superintendent Supports Accelerated Math Pathway

Virginia Superintendent of Public Instruction James F. Lane

Dr. James F. Lane, Supervisor of Public Instruction, has been gracious enough to address with me his thoughts on the the Virginia Department of Education Virginia Mathematics Pathways Initiative (VMPI).

The headline for readers of this column is that he will not support any program that eliminates acceleration in mathematics.

I sent him my column this morning that addressed VMPI and recommended a program of statistical analysis of 40 elementary schools in Fairfax County followed, if justified by that analysis, by a pilot of VMPI in those same schools in Fairfax County

His response:

“I’ve asked my team to provide a longer response with more detail, but please know that I do not support any movement to eliminate acceleration in mathematics and will work over the coming days to clarify my position on this should that not be clear.  Regardless of any discussions the team may or may not been having in the community, no recommendation of this kind will come from me.”

My note back to him:

“Thank you very much.  I look forward to hearing from your team, and I will publish the core of your response so my readers know where you stand.

I really believe in the recommendations I have made for statistical analysis and a K-3 pilot (of VMPI) in the (40) Fairfax County schools.

Fairfax County, because of the massive size of its school system, offers a rare opportunity to eliminate the variables of place and school division management while still gathering statistically significant data.  You would do Virginia and the nation a favor with such a program.  I am all but certain the federal government would pay the costs to benefit from the results.”

I appreciate both his personal involvement and his response.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

15 responses to “Virginia School Superintendent Supports Accelerated Math Pathway”

  1. Jim, if you get a chance, pin him down on what he’s counting as “acceleration in mathematics.” Notice that he does not say “accelerated math classes.”

    Does he embrace VDOE spokesman Chuck Pyle’s verbal formulation of “differentiated instruction.” If so, what does that mean. Presumably, it means teachers providing instruction suitable to the level of the student — a ludicrous, unworkable idea if there is a wide gap in attainment among students in the class.

    We cannot let him get away with verbal subterfuge.

    1. Maria Paluzsay Avatar
      Maria Paluzsay

      Please explain your definition of “differentiated instruction” and why it should not be implemented, as this was a core tenet of my elementary teacher training in the 90s – a principle I have not seen applied in my children’s current middle and high schools. Ah, equity. Let’s be sure not to teach our students at levels and in methods most suitable for each of them.

  2. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Great work Captain! Your spotlight is making a difference. I salute this important reporting. Lane was on Channel 5 news in Washington DC today. NOVA parents are hearing about this.

  3. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    https://www.audacy.com/newsradiowrva/news/local/state-superintendent-refutes-diploma-math-claims

    Uh, Lane also spoke to WRVA Radio and refuted the claims about abandoning accelerated math classes or the advanced diploma. He probably reacted because the GOP candidates were starting to jump up and down about this.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      They are also jumping up and down about red meat bans, that the election was stolen, COVID didn’t kill anyone and there was no insurrection. Yet another.

      1. Wait!

        There’s going to be red meat bans?

        1. Nancy Naive Avatar
          Nancy Naive

          Oops. BANDS. Wrist bands.

  4. William Cover Avatar
    William Cover

    Good reporting on this subject. I think the tendency or philosophy of some educators is to give all teams a trophy even if they come in last place. If there are not enough trophies for the low scoring math students, then the high scoring math students can not have one either. Has King George returned?

  5. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    “In no other country are the professional students of education so influential. In no other country is school practice so quickly responsive to the suggestions emanating from this group. We may stigmatize our schools as “static, ” “reactionary,” “slow to change,”– reluctant to adopt what we, in our wisdom, prescribe. But compared to other countries, ours is the educational expert’s paradise.” — William Bagley, 1926

    http://www.csun.edu/~vcmth00m/AHistory.html

    We need SMEs. “We, the unwilling, led by the unknowing, are doing the impossible for the ungrateful. We have done so much, for so long, with so little, we are now qualified to do anything with nothing.” ― Konstantin Josef Jireček

  6. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    I’m amused by the fact y’all are worried that students 8-12 might lose access to advanced mathematical concepts when y’all waste the first 1-7 counting, adding, and memorizing. Seriously, y’all memorized multiplication tables? Why?

  7. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Okay, based on the overnight coverage of Lane’s very energetic denials, and the quite telling changes on the state’s own website on this topic, it is clear: 1) they were indeed considering exactly what they were accused of, at least some of the people involved and 2) post election they could easily get back to it. Oh, and 3) Bacon’s Rebellion punches above its weight.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      1) they denied it therfeore it happened?
      2) they didn’t do it therefore they’ll do it again?
      3) okay, but relative to what?

  8. From an article I just read; ” traditional math coursework is failing students from many backgrounds.”

    So one of the three main courses of instruction is to blame…….

    We are doomed!

  9. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    My next inquiry with Jim Lane on this issue is whether and how they will measure the impact on teachers of whatever changes they wind up making.

  10. […] “equity.” It sort of already is. As soon as the idea made contact with parents and media the state superintendent submarined it and the Department of Education overhauled its […]

Leave a Reply