Bob Gibson with the Charlottesville Daily Progress points to an alarming sideline conflict between the Senate and House budget negotiators in the General Assembly. House Republicans have inserted budget language that would ban funding for “any entity” — including the University of Virginia and Virginia Commonwealth University — “that conducts human stem cell research.”
Two UVa professors of neurological surgery — Roy C. Ogle and Gary K. Owens — are conducting embryonic stem cell research in the areas of bone regeneration and smooth muscle research. Ogle, says Gibson, is an expert in skull reconstructive surgery.
Gibson relies upon Del. Brian J. Moran, D-Alexandria, who denounces the House action as “irresponsible,” as at least one of his sources, so it’s conceivable that we’re not getting the full story. But if the account is substantially accurate — and Gibson seems to be a reliable reporter — I find the House action mystifying. Even President George W. Bush’s “ban” of stem cell research prohibits only the federal funding of stem cell research, and it allows exemptions for pre-existing lines of stem cells. Apparently, the House budget language would go beyond prohibiting the application of state funds for stem cell research and — can this possibly be true? — would eliminate all state support for the universities outright.
If such budget language were enacted, UVa and VCU could not possibly absorb the loss of state funding, so they would have no choice but to kill the research programs. That’s called extortion. The stem cell ban is also… how shall I put this delicately… not an astute move politically.
By positioning the House far to the right of President Bush on the stem cell issue, such punitive budget language would hand the state Senate an issue which to flay the House in the budget negotiations — look how out of control these guys are! — and the Democrats an issue with which to flay the GOP at the polls. The stem-cell measure needs to be deep-sixed as quickly as possible before the story goes mainstream and creates a debacle.