Sen Allen and Confederate Symbols (Cont.)

Saturday May 13th’s Daily Press (Judge the Senator by fitness to serve, not teenage behavior) gave lawyer Mark Ailsworth an op ed to exonerate Sen. Allen. The author provides the political, if not legal, defense of “young, dumb, male.”

Ailsworth personalizes his history with the Confederate battle flag and writes, “From the moment it was expropriated by the Ku Klux Klan during Reconstruction, the flag became a symbol of the racism that has plaqued this country since the arrival of the first black slaves in 1619.”

His history is a bit off. The occupying Federal Army didn’t take kindly to Confederate battle flags during Reconstruction. So, when the KKK was the most physically threatening, the KKK used the Christian cross. No one kept the association.

In the 1920s, when the KKK was the most politically threatening (see photo above of parade in the Washington DC), the KKK used the American flag – Old Glory. No one kept the association.

In the 1950/60s, when the KKK was heavily infiltrated by the FBI and a fringe element caught in every act of violence, the KKK used the Confederate battle flag. Liberals, historically challenged Yankees, and politically correct Southerners hold the association as eternal.

Finally, lawyer Ailsworth wrote that white Southerners “would do the nation and ourselves a favor if we folded the Confederate flag and stored it in the attic with our yearbooks and relics of the past.” It depends on how you treat memories of valor. Some families take the shadow boxes of medals of family member’s military service and put them in the attic. Most families put those shadow boxes in the front room.

Clearly, Mr. Ailsworth has lost touch with being a Southerner. Attics are where you keep crazy relatives.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

8 responses to “Sen Allen and Confederate Symbols (Cont.)”

  1. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    There our countless proud symbols of Southern heritage and Confederate valor.

    That you focus obsessively on a single symbol, the one most closely associated with racism out of all of them, tells us far more about you and your own preocupations than it does about the South.

    I’m not trying to imply that you are racist. What I’m saying is that you have a huge chip on your shoulder, and you want to keep banging your head against people who oppose the flag because of the racist overtones that people allowed it to come to have, all the while pretending that racism isn’t an issue at all. That’s just plain silly. Like it or not, the battle flag became a symbol of Jim Crow and segregation and lynching and a lot of other ugly things. And it’s just plain dishonest to pretend that part of it’s appeal to many young men (like Allen, no doubt, in building his phony Southern persona) isn’t in it’s offensiveness on precisely those grounds.

  2. Mark Ailsworth Avatar
    Mark Ailsworth

    Mr. Bowden – If, as you imply, “being a Southerner” requires one to believe that displaying the Confederate battle flag to honor the valor of those who served a lost cause is, in 2006, of greater importance than racial reconcilliation, then I plead guilty. I have indeed lost touch with being your kind of Southerner and I intend to stay lost. Mark Ailsworth

  3. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Mark Ailsworth: No one is ‘required’ to do anything with symbols.

    The DP published a survey a few years ago that the majority of Virginia’s Black citizens did not see the Confederate battle flag as a racist symbol.

    Racial reconcilliation is in the past tense for most Virginians. It you still need to reconcile for something in 2006, then go ahead and atone as you see fit.

    You’re welcome for correcting your little historical blip.

    Anon: No doubt some racists abuse this one symbol. You missed the irony that when they abused other symbols no one cared.

  4. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    james, like it or not, none of the other symbols stuck or gained wide appreciation. No irony there I’m afraid.

    And let’s face it: people pushing the Confederate flag issue are simply not doing it out of some sincere love of the South. It’s, as a said, advertising a big chip on the shoulder, bullying for a pointless fight. That’s especially obvious with you, for whom resentment is a big part of your shtick.

  5. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Anon: Nice focus on the messenger not on the message. Typical for Liberals who can’t face issues with facts. You may not be a Liberal, but the focus on personifying and personalizing instead of discussing reasonably is Liberal-like.

    Any symbol sticks only for those who chose to have it stick. That is my point, in case you missed it.

    Consequently, since attitudes can, and do, change, it is worthwhile for some people to spend some time attempting to change the mistaken and politically convenient (for one side) attitudes towards this symbol. I have no doubt that if the flag went into the memory hole right now, the persons who make so much of it now, would find something else ‘Southern’ to revile for their own purposes immediately.

  6. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    “Nice focus on the messenger not on the message. Typical for Liberals who can’t face issues with facts. You may not be a Liberal, but the focus on personifying and personalizing instead of discussing reasonably is Liberal-like.”

    Wow. Just wow. Are you really familiar with the concept of irony you just mentioned? Because that was a pretty amazing example of it right there.

    I’m focusing on you, because you and your message are one in the same: a phenomenon of resentment and hysteria. I mean, I’m not the one with a giant conspiracy flow-chart of all how all society is going to pot on my website.

  7. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Anon: Let me help you understand. The arrows on a timeline are a slide showing ideas through time. The divergence in the arrows is the Culture War, not a conspiracy. Thanks for checking it out. I need to get off my butt and start doing regular entries on American Civilization. Just haven’t taken the time.

    The history of ideas is a subject I find fascinating. Ideas don’t just appear. They grow. To be an American is an idea. Not an ethnicity.

    Try and stay focused on the ideas – the messages.

  8. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Anon: Dennis Prager agrees with my thoughts about Liberal-speak/not think in this op ed –

    http://www.townhall.com/opinion/columns/dennisprager/2006/05/23/198416.html

Leave a Reply