Part Two on SuperCapitalism

In the first installment of Supercapitalism Redux I listed what I thought were Robert Reich’s key correct findings. Here are my suggestions on what we should do in Virginia about those findings for the common good in the Commonwealth.

Everyone has more money and stuff than 30 years ago. Our American poor are richer, materially, than they were three decades ago. They are considerably poorer, spiritually and in quality of life, than the poor from the 70 years ago – because of the destruction of the family.

Yet, the middle class has thinned out considerably. The squeeze increased the number of upper middle class and wealthy (is rich a better term?) folks. Likewise, the number of lower middle class people increased. If these folks don’t get new competitive skills or go into business, successfully, for themselves, they will not progress to the middle class. Ever.

What to do for the people at the bottom economically?

First, don’t destroy capital. Reich agreed (p. 4) that “Capitalism’s role is to enlarge the economic pie.” Build capital. Build capital as fast as it can – grow the economy just shy of cross-over point of inflation. Tax capital once – period.

The 3% growth in total tax burden in Virginia since the 70s means about $157 a month for the median family (earning $51k in ROVa and more in NoVa). Lower personal taxes.

Expand the supply of energy, as much as Virginia can, to lower the price. The cost of rising oil prices destroys the discretionary income – and even pushes into mortgage failure – too many working families. Build the double refinery capacity at Yorktown, build new nukes, build sea-based tide and windmills, etc.

Provide individual supported by community, not government, opportunities for the big expenses – health, retirement, job insecurity, and education – that will break marginal income families. I wrote in Bacon’s Rebellion about Commonwealth Trust Accounts for lifelong individual savings. Return the bogus $1.5 B sales tax increase (2004) into individual accounts ($200 @)) for all 7 million Virginians. Give generous tax cuts for folks who contribute to other folks’ accounts.

Elect Representatives and Senators to the Federal government who will morph Social Security into individual, personal accounts. Elect politicians who will morph Medicare, Medicaid and the drug benefits into sustainable health insurance accounts. But, don’t wait for the Federal government to reform to take action in Virginia.

The social pathologies that plague families of every income can’t be solved by government. Government shouldn’t promote the pathologies, like welfare did.

Coming up next…what to do about corporate excesses.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

  1. Larry Gross Avatar
    Larry Gross

    I’m not advocating an isolationist trade policy but in the end, we have to ask ourselves that if folks in India and Thailand are willing to work at such low salaries that they cannot afford health care or have to work until they die…

    … we have to decide is that is the Supercapitalism benchmark… for the world – to include us.

    Because.. if we shift Social Security and Medicare to be the individual responsibility of each person .. and then multi-national companies will “buy” the cheapest labor… what next?

    There ARE industrialized countries in the world that manage to provide health care – universally to their citizens – to the point where their life expectancy and other metrics are superior to ours – and they still compete worldwide.

    I would argue that those countries that invest in the health of their people are really doing no less than investing in their citizens education.

    BOTH of required for a healthy and educated workforce that can compete in a Supercapitalism world.

    Policies that favor those who have “capital” at the expense of the health and welfare of the workers and the middle class – do not ultimately benefit the country..

    I think to a certain extent that Supercapitalism is the modern-day equivalent of Colonialism .. except independent of nation-states.

    It’s a quest to gather capital (wealth) by “extracting” resources – both human and non-human and it’s the same old game…

    The ‘wealthy’ (the owners of companies) say to Governments: you give us this deal or we go elsewhere…

    totally predatory…

    It’s like in the pre-EPA days when Dow Chemical would say to Virginia: “you let us dump in this Virginia River .. or we’ll go do it in West Va.” .. except now… it’s countries…

  2. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    J.A. Bowden,
    I agree with many of these ideas but have trouble with others.
    Giving the middle and lower income brackets a tax break is a good idea (The Bush cuts favored Americans grossing more than $200K annually). Improving and diversifying energy supplies isa good idea, but I am not sure that doubling the refining capacity of a Chesapeake estuary refinery is a good idea. It raises plenty of environmental questions is will end up refining foreign, imported crude anyway. As for more nukes — OK, but let’s make sure the safety upgrades are in place upgrading designs of the 1960s and 1970s.

    As far as medical care, there is a true crisis in the sector but you don’t really say much about what to do. Are you advocating universal coverage? Should all citizens be required to have health insurance (latest riff on Hillarycare)? Many lower income Americans are stuck in a cycle of debt because they have plenty of health problems, have no insurance and are in debt to the health industry. See Joe Bageants “Deer Hunting with Jesus” for good, ground-level anecdotes.
    Lastly, as Larry Gross points out, you don’t really address how our citizens should respond to the globalization of Supercapitalism. I think that one of Reich’s points is that traditional, local, state and federal governments are becoming increasingly irrelevant as policy decisions affecting all Americans are taken by a stateless cabal of companies and banks that act in their self-interest and that doesn’t include any particular country where the headquarters happens to be based. I was an editor at BusinessWeek back in 1991 when we had a cover noting the rise of the “Stateless” corporation (to be honest I didn’t really have much to do personally with the cover, but I thought it was good). Despite what the marketers and economic development authorities would have you believe, companies don’t really care about where they are. Wachovia Securities, for instance, isn’t really prostate with grief over leaving Richmond in favor of St. Louis.
    You advocate electing smarter politicians. Great idea, but how should they deal with health care and with powers over which they have little control, such as stateless companies?

    Thanks.

    Peter Galuszka

  3. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Is the 3% growth in tax burden infaltion adjusted since the ’70’s?

    RH

  4. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Correction: In my above post I mean to say “prostrate with grief,” quoting Mammie in “Gone With the Wind.”

    I may at some time, however, be “prostate with grief.”

    Peter Galuszka

  5. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    LG & PG & Anon: I’m limited on space in a blog post. I’ll answer your questions when I get home.

    Yes, the 3% increase is after adjustments for inflation.

    Virginia’s median total taxation – all sources – went from 29.2% to 32.2% Median = 50th per centile family of 4.

  6. E M Risse Avatar
    E M Risse

    A few marginal notes on proposals:

    “They are considerably poorer, spiritually and in quality of life, than the poor from the 70 years ago – because of the destruction of the family.”

    Perhaps destruction of “social fabric” would be more accurate.

    “Families” were not destroyed. They still exist but are disagregated.

    The basic social unit of nonurban society is the Family.

    The basic social unit in an urban society is the “Household,” not the “fiamiy.”

    As I recall all those who you have referred to as “family” in past posts do not live in your Household or even in your Dooryard, Cluster, Neighborhood, Village or…

    “Yet, the middle class has thinned out considerably. The squeeze increased the number of upper middle class and wealthy (is rich a better term?) folks.”

    By some but not much as a percent of the total because of importing those as the bottom.

    “Likewise, the number of lower middle class people increased.”

    By most measures “Middle Class” does not exist so both of these statements need “percentage of the total economic food chain” quantifiers.

    “If these folks don’t get new competitive skills or go into business, successfully, for themselves, they will not…”

    be able to support themselves in a competetive society.

    “progress to the middle class. Ever.”

    See above re “Middle Class.”

    “What to do for the people at the bottom economically?

    “First, don’t destroy capital. Reich agreed (p. 4) that “Capitalism’s role is to enlarge the economic pie.”

    “Build capital.”

    Ah, this is the problem.

    How to “build” financial capital and social capital without destroying natural capital — air, water, soil, marine, petroleum, minerals,…

    “Build capital as fast as it can – grow the economy just shy of cross-over point of inflation.”

    Nice theory but how?

    “Tax capital once – period.”

    Financial capital or social capital or both?

    “The 3% growth in total tax burden in Virginia since the 70s means about $157 a month for the median family (earning $51k in ROVa and more in NoVa).

    “Lower personal taxes.”

    The problem is that urban existance costs far more that has been paid for it. Citizens have been living off of natural capital.

    Who pays for urban life if personal taxes on citizens do not raise money? Fees or taxes, take your pick.

    That is especially ture for those on the top of the food chain.

    “Expand the supply of energy, as much as Virginia can, to lower the price.”

    Here we part company.

    Cheap energy is the problem, not the solution.

    “The cost of rising oil prices destroys the discretionary income – and even pushes into mortgage failure – too many working families.”

    Is it the cost of energy or the waste of energy?

    Lets cut the old growth forest for fuel first because we would raise more fiber to turn into energy if we get rid of the deadwood …

    “Build the double refinery capacity at Yorktown, build new nukes, build sea-based tide and windmills, etc.”

    No, lets find way to cut consumption and cut energy waste.

    “Provide individual supported by community, not government,”

    Is this “community” an Agency, an Enterprise, an Institution or some location oriented “public accociation in ciil life” to use de Tocqueville’s term?

    “opportunities for the big expenses – health, retirement, job insecurity, and education – that will break marginal income families.”

    Not sure what this means?

    “I wrote in Bacon’s Rebellion about Commonwealth Trust Accounts for lifelong individual savings.”

    Reference? We do not recall that, sound like it might be a good idea.

    “Return the bogus $1.5 B sales tax increase (2004) into individual accounts ($200 @)) for all 7 million Virginians.”

    But back to who pays. Urban life and the support of urban life cost a lot. Far more than has been paid. We are in debt, finacial, social, natural capital and getting deeper every day.

    If Agencies do not pay for urban existance with taxes who does and with what resources?

    “Give generous tax cuts for folks who contribute to other folks’ accounts.”

    For example?

    “Elect Representatives and Senators to the Federal government who will morph Social Security into individual, personal accounts.”

    What chance is there that these folks would be elected on such a platform and if elected what chance they would be re-elected and that those who replace them would not recreate the dole?

    So long as the existing governace sturcture exists you will get the same policies you have gotten in the past.

    “Elect politicians who will morph Medicare, Medicaid and the drug benefits into sustainable health insurance accounts.”

    See above.

    “But, don’t wait for the Federal government to reform to take action in Virginia.”

    What action?

    “The social pathologies that plague families of every income can’t be solved by government.”

    Is buying a new flat screen TV watching 8 hours a day of television a “social pathology?”

    How about 12 hours for those under 5?

    How about 14 hours of Television, IMing and video games and unlimited anytime cell munutes?

    “Government shouldn’t promote the pathologies, like welfare did.”

    No argument there.

    You say you agree with Reich on the recent course of action that has resulted in Supercapitalism.

    I am not sure these ideas will reverse any of the damage to “democracy.”

    EMR

  7. Larry Gross Avatar
    Larry Gross

    re: “build capital”

    why?

    be specific… in the answer…

    why is “build capital” not the same as “the rich get richer and the middle class disappear”?

  8. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    Responses in order of comments.
    LG:SS and Medicare,etc become individually managed and owned programs – more like FDR promised. The same taxes can support them.

    PG: You can double the capacity at Yorktown and no crabs will die. I know people there. I live nearby. Agree on safety as part of business.

    I am NOT advocating single payer, universal coverage. I advocate universal accounts which will not provide full coverage from the start, but will grow and grow to provide much coverage and important coverage. No single payer, but in Virginia 7 million plus payers. Everyone would have an account – that is a savings account, not the same thing as current health insurances.

    I’ll make a separate entry on individual citizen response to super capitalism.

    I advocate hiring politicians who have a clear understanding of some things they must do in the General Assembly. There are a number of things to do in healthcare (my short entry didn’t cover them all) like create these Commonwealth Trust Accounts, remove administrative burdens where possible and create competition when possible, etc. (Separate subject worth a detailed discussion).

    EMR: The basic unit of American society remains the family.

    The creation of capital in products and services involves the use of some resources that are finite and some that are renewable and sometimes it is the unrenewable resource of time in a human life. The creation of capital is what it is – to use a hackneyed phrase.

    Financial capital should be taxed once only.

    The cost of energy is hurting families. The waste of energy influences the available supply.

    We can reduce demand in Virginia, but in a global economy with demand growing in China and India petroleum and its products will go up in price – supply and demand. So, we need to increase supply of energy – all alternatives – to lower the price.

    My oped on accounts http://americancivilization.net/
    articles/Virginia06/Putting_Taxes_
    To_Work_Commonwealth_Trust_Accounts.
    pdf

    Watching TV isn’t a social pathology, if indeed it is one,
    on the order of illegitimacy, divorce, school dropout/ignorance, drug use, alcohol abuse, crime, etc.

    LG: Growing capital enriches all persons unequally. But it matters to everyone. Read Milton Friedman. The 90fold growth of capital from 1870 to 1960 meant new technologies, scientific breakthoughs, food, etc – almost everything material to the society.

  9. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    J.A. Bowden,

    Sir, with respect, sir, a few comments:

    (1) On the refinery, the Bay seems pretty stressed out as it is with “dead zones” and the like. I realize these are caused by non-point sources such as farms and road and parking lot runoff, but just saying you have friends and live next door does not for a successful EIS make.
    Moreover, where’s the curde going to come from? Chavez’s Venezuela? I remember back in the 70s when the Portsmouth refinery was being pushed by the late Dick Davis and his crowd. They said it would be “Energy Independence” an all. Turned out the oil would have come from overseas anyway.

    (2) On health care accounts, would thse be government or private?

    (3) You never addressed what difference elected smart politicians can make if so many major decisions affecting this state and others are being made in Dubai, London, Shanghai or Mombai. How would you deal with globalization and its economic fallout.

    Thank you.

    Peter Galuszka

  10. James Atticus Bowden Avatar
    James Atticus Bowden

    PG:
    1. The killer phosphates in The Bay need to be stopped at point of pollution or entry to water or when in the tributaries or in The Bay. Got it.

    I haven’t seen the cause and effect for the Yorktown refinery increasing any phosphates in The Bay.

    The crude oil could come from off our shore if we got busy. If not, it still makes a difference to have more of the refined product available on the old supply and demand curve. Much of the year there is a 10 cent a gallon difference between the gas in Gloucester and York based on the requirements in one place for ethanol and not in the other.

    2. I see the Government moving the money from taxes to individual, private accounts. That is the not the sum of the accounts. The government would likely provide some insurance for the companies that manage the accounts, in case they go under, like bank insurance. Please check out my op ed I cited above from some time ago.

    3.There are many aspects of globalization that local, Virginia, politicians can do little to control or, nothing to control. If you were working at Business Week right after my group finished our long range study for 2005-2015, they you know that in a global economy entire industries will be wiped out or wiped out in a region. Furniture making in SW VA is a good example.

    Politicians serve their constituents if they make Virginia a place where businesses can make money. Put their headquarters here. They create services locally when they allow capital creation through lower taxes locally.

    When I got home from NoVa I was running an errand and noticed a large building. In the past 20 years it has been a HQ hardware and now a Best Buy. The Compuserve next door went out of business. People lost their jobs. People got new jobs.

    Commonwealth Trust Accounts could cover more than medical – and help for time in between jobs.

    I’m missing something specific you have in mind about globalization that you think government can or can’t deal with.

Leave a Reply