Not the Normal Governor Means Not the Normal Ethics

Matt Moran, Deputy Chief of Staff, aka Special Advisor
Photo credit: Creative Direct

by Dick Hall-Sizemore

Glenn Youngkin recently declared, “I guess I’m maybe not the normal governor. I think one of the differences is that I am an outsider and I come in with ideas on how we communicate.”

We are beginning to find out how true that is. The Richmond Times-Dispatch reports that one of the Governor’s top policy aides is not a state employee, but a lobbyist on the payroll of a lobbying company. Matt Moran is on a paid leave of absence from Creative Direct, a political consulting firm, and LINK Public Affairs, an offshoot from Creative Direct. When Youngkin first announced his appointment, he listed Moran’s title as “deputy chief of staff and director of policy and legislative affairs.” A sign on his door in the Patrick Henry Building bore the title, “deputy chief of staff.” The statement of economic interest he filed upon taking office listed his position as “deputy chief of staff.”   In appearances before legislative committees, he identified himself as “deputy chief of staff.” He is now labeled “special advisor” and the January 21 news release announcing his appointment has been “corrected.”

Richard Cullen, counselor to Youngkin, says he reviewed Moran’s “arrangement” and found it legal and ethical.

Moran defended his “arrangement” by declaring, “As senior adviser in the Governor’s office, I serve in a volunteer capacity and do so without compensation. I am on leave from all companies and as a result do not have clients with business before the Governor or state government.” This statement is disingenuous. He may be serving “without” compensation from the state, but he is certainly being compensated by his lobbying firm  He may not personally have clients with “business before the Governor or state government,” but the folks who pay his salary have clients like that. As LINK advertises on its website, “LINK provides our clients with a campaign-styled approach to navigating the current Republican-controlled executive branch in Virginia.”[emphasis added]

Bob Holsworth, a longtime observer and commentator on Virginia politics and government, described the lack of transparency in this situation as “unsettling.” “I know of no situation where a deputy chief of staff role has been outsourced, and without any public acknowledgment,” he continued.

In addition to Moran, Aubrey Layne, former Secretary of Finance and currently senior vice president and chief of staff at Sentara Healthcare, is staying on as an unpaid special adviser to new Finance Secretary Steve Cummings.

In summary, there are now two paid lobbyists with state-provided offices and support on the same floor as the Governor’s office, privy to all the discussions and decisions that could directly affect either the clients of their employer, as is the case with Moran, or the employer directly, as is the case with Layne, not to mention threatening and bullying legislators in the name of the Governor. Yes, indeed, this is not your “normal governor.”


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

14 responses to “Not the Normal Governor Means Not the Normal Ethics”

  1. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Aubrey Layne has never been a paid lobbyist for anybody ever (easy to confirm on VPAP, which you didn’t!). Aubrey Layne neither sought not took a title or office space within the Youngkin Administration. In fact, most of his predecessors at Sec Finance have offered exactly the same free advice to the new incoming team. You have done him wrong with that comparison Dick, you really have. You are in Louise Lucas’ league with that one.

    When his current hospital employer had health care issues to discuss, the company’s lobbying staff handled it. Everybody in the building knew who Layne actually worked for. Moran? Stand by for more on that. Stand by for the Rest of the Story.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      Comparing me with Louise Lucas? You really know how to hurt a guy!

      First of all, Sentara’s website’s description of Layne’s duties starts off like this: “Layne oversees a number of Sentara teams including legislative affairs….” So, he may not be a registered lobbyist, but he certainly is significantly involved in the company’s legislative activities.

      Second, none of Cummings’ predecessors have needed free advice from someone from the private sector whose employer had a significant stake in government policy. Go back through the list: Layne himself, Ric Brown, Jody Wagner, John Bennett, Ron Tillett, Paul Timmereck, Stuart Connock. (I skipped over John Forbes for obvious reasons.) All of them, with the exception of Jody Wagner, had extensive experience in Virginia government. As for her, she had Ric to guide her, as well as a stint as the head of the Dept. of the Treasury.

      I can understand Layne helping with the transition for the new guy who had no experience in state finance or in Virginia government. But the administration says he is going to “continue” in that role. Why? Cummings has a team of experienced agency heads that Youngkin has reappointed. (The only exception was DPB, where Dan Timberlake suddenly announced his retirement a few days before Youngkin took office, but the acting director, Jon Howe, has years of experience of participating in budget development at the highest level.)

      I have no doubt that Layne is acting with the utmost integrity. But, having someone in his current employment involved in advising folks who make decisions that affect his employer creates at least the perception of a conflict of interest. And, as someone on this blog recently said, “In politics, perception is reality.”

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Timmerick and Connock went on to state universities! They didn’t have a stake in the future budgets? Did you stop seeing them in the halls? No. You’ve been unfair to Layne. And he hasn’t had an office on the Third Floor (did you ask?)

        But your target is Youngkin.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          I think what Dick is saying is that if you have a role like Layne has – do you have transparency into his activities to ascertain/verify he’s not using that role for his employer’s interests.

          Occupying that role presents risks of corruption without enough transparency to discourage it.

          it’s not Layne per se, it’s the way that role works – it provides a path to corruption.

          IMHO.

        2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
          Dick Hall-Sizemore

          So did Bennett. But they were not on the payroll of an outside entity.

  2. Lefty665 Avatar

    I had hopes for Youngkin, so this is disappointing.

    Layne sticking around to help the new guy figure out state finances is a good thing. We can all benefit from that, and I believe that was disclosed.

    The “deputy chief of staff” is too cute by half. Did his disclosure list his employer and income? Falsifying that form is itself grounds for dismissal.

    The smell alone might encourage the Gov to find a less conflicted “deputy”.

  3. Does the state need to save money and bring on volunteers for these jobs? Did Youngkin have volunteers as officers of Carlyle? No and no.

    I find the “volunteer” arrangement to be a rather “swampy”, even if legal, tactic. Maybe there is more to the story, but this is disappointing. I hope he will fix it.

  4. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    Okay, give Layne a bye and ding Dick but what about the other?

    Do we have any comments from the usual BR commentators on this – like JAB who had to know the story and bills BR this way :
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a09810d88640ea25651233a97823cb67c8bbdb7312991fb42e9364381d2b3f4c.jpg

    This is okay?

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Did my post later imply I think it okay? Was waiting to see if the media would drop the other shoe.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        Nope. But I suspect if this was Stoney, JAB would be all over it. beat you and Dick to post and then bring up all the other bad stuff to boot… bad schools.. bad business environment, etc…

        Takes Chutzpa to call it “legal and ethical” but as already said, not the first Gov to do these shenanigans but pretty early in the process.

        I give Youngkin credit. For someone self-described as an “outsider”, he is no shrinking violet!

  5. Lefty665 Avatar

    Looks like Youngkin has sketchy private/public/private which hat am I wearing today practices in line with the Biden administration.

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/03/28/anita-dunn-biden-skdk/

  6. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    None are so blind as those who won’t don a mask…
    “However, our current retina-organoid study shows that infection with SARS-CoV-2 can have direct pathological consequences for retinal ganglion cells, even though visual impairment is not common in patients with COVID-19,” Rauen said.
    “But our data give us reason to believe that so-called long-COVID symptoms may include degenerative retinal disease.”

  7. DJRippert Avatar
    DJRippert

    In a state where the regulated utility can (and does) make huge donations to the politicians who are charged with regulating it, and … where those same politicians can eventually use the donated money for just about anything … I’d say this is a nit. The Deputy Chief of Staff doesn’t vote on or veto anything.

    My guess is that Matt Moran couldn’t be convinced to take the job for whatever it pays so the “paid leave” plan was implemented.

    Is this unseemly? Yes. Is it even a Top 10 problem with ethics in Virginia politics? No.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      The whole thing about “money” is that it supposedly buys one direct access. This is why recently-departed officials become such favored new “hires” for lobby firms. No?

      Here you have one that is STILL involved actively , the best possible scenario – just shy of a direct audience!

      Think of Bob McDonald and Jonnie Williams. Of course as bad as that looked, SCOTUS said it was not bribery.

      Are folks tone deaf on this or is it me?

Leave a Reply