Northam’s Hidden 40% Gasoline Tax Hike

Fill ‘er up

Did you know that last year Virginia’s tax on gasoline increased 5 cents per gallon, on July 1, 2020, from 24.4 cents to 29.4 cents?

Did you know that this year Virginia’s tax on gasoline is increasing again, by another 5 cents per gallon on July 1, 2021, to 34.4 cents? That is a 40% increase in one year.

Also, starting next year the Virginia gasoline tax will automatically increase with inflation every July 1st.

Did you know that in addition to the Virginia gasoline tax, there is a federal gasoline tax of 18.4 cents?

Therefore, the total gasoline tax at Virginia pumps will have increased from 42.8 cents in 2019 to 52.8 cents this year.

You won’t find these numbers in press reports because the Virginia government obfuscates gasoline taxes.

For example, a March 8, 2020, Washington Post article, “Virginia General Assembly approves higher gas tax …” quoted Virginia officials as saying that the gas tax before last year’s increase was 16.2 cents. It wasn’t; it was 24.4 cents. The 16.2 cents is what the retailer pays the state. In addition, the wholesaler pays another 7.6 cents per gallon to the state. On top of that there is a 0.6 cent tax per gallon for tank storage.

The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) collects gasoline taxes and is responsible for reporting them. A June 5, 2020, DMV press release, “New Law Reduces Vehicle Registration Fees for Virginians …” does mention “increasing the statewide gas tax by five cents this year and next.”

The press release however emphasizes a $10 reduction in vehicle registration fees, while admitting to a new “highway use fee” of $19 for fuel-efficient cars.

Elsewhere the DMV website does mention the 2019 retailer 16.2 cent gas tax, that it increased to 21.2 cents last year, and that it increases to 26.2 this year, but try to find it. The 0.6 cent storage tank fee is also shown, but with a typo: It’s shown as “0.006 cents.” It should be 0.6 cents or $0.006.

The wholesaler’s 7.6 cent per gallon tax is on a separate DMV page. Nowhere does the DMV state that the total Virginia gasoline tax was increasing from 24.4 cents to 34.4 cents.

Nowhere does the DMV website mention that with the federal gas tax, the total gasoline tax at Virginia pumps will be 52.8 cents.

The gasoline tax hikes along with increases in hotel taxes and real estate transfer taxes plus the new “highway use fee” were enacted by House Bill 1414 (HB1414), passed in the 2020 General Assembly.

Patrons of HB1414 include Fairfax County Delegates Eileen Filler-Corn, “Rip” Sullivan, Jr., Vivian Watts, and Kathleen Murphy.

Patrons of the identical senate version, Senate Bill 890, include Fairfax County Senators Richard Saslaw, Jennifer Boysko, and Barbara Favola.

In the Washington Post article, a Northam spokeswoman said that HB 1414 is a “once-in-a-generation” package. Not so. In 2019, HB2718 imposed the 7.6 cent wholesale gas tax on the I-81 corridor. Add to that the new tolls on I-66. In 2013, HB 2313, another transportation bill, raised the Fairfax County sales tax from 5 to 6 cents, a 20% increase, and increased the auto sales tax from 3% to 4.15%.

In 2007, House Bill 3202, a transportation bill, resulted in a 12.5 cent increase in the Fairfax County real estate tax for businesses.

Perhaps Virginia’s fastest growing revenue is “General Fund” revenue, which is primarily income taxes and the portion of state sales taxes not earmarked for transportation. Earmarked taxes go into a “Non-General Fund.”

Since 1961, General Fund revenues, which are mainly spent on education and welfare and are off-limits to transportation, have grown seven times faster than Virginia population and inflation.

If transportation had been allowed to compete against bloated education and welfare budgets for soaring General Fund revenues, the repeated transportation tax hikes would not have been necessary.

This column is republished with permission from the Fairfax County Taxpayers Alliance “The Bulletin” newsletter.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

58 responses to “Northam’s Hidden 40% Gasoline Tax Hike”

  1. Penrosian Avatar
    Penrosian

    Did you know that this year Virginia’s tax on gasoline is increasing again, by another 5 cents per gallon on July 1, 2021, to 34.4 cents? That is a 40% increase in one year.

    29.4 >> 34.4 is a 17% increase

    24.4 >> 34.4 is a 40% increase but that’s over 2 years.

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Yes we need more valid numbers.

      Recent past (before the Northam/Dem increases) I believe we had 17.4 cents base (floor) tax, but NoVA/Hampton had 2% per gal more regional tax.

      But also don’t forget, in addition to tax at the pump, many of us are seeing the new increase in registration fees for fuel efficient gasoline cars, that the state is adding into the fuel taxes.

      Sounds like xxx (undefined) numbers of vehicles are paying and average of $19 more per year in pump tax fees during registration, and that $19 is going up on July 1.

  2. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    So, on an inflation-adjusted basis, are we paying MORE for transportation than before?

    Is there a trend chart?

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      You wouldn’t ask if you didn’t already have the graph, Larry.

  3. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    I wonder how much of this started under McDonnell :

    ” McDonnell Signs Largest Tax Hike in Virginia History into Law
    Posted by Paul Blair on Monday, May 13th, 2013,

    Governor Bob McDonnell, in one of his final acts as governor of the Commonwealth of Virginia, signed into law a $5.9 billion tax increase on Virginia families to fund light rail and transportation projects throughout the Commonwealth. The tax increase is the largest in the history of Virginia, edging out Democrat Governor Mark Warner’s 2004 tax increase.

    Virginians will see increases in their diesel fuel taxes and the gas tax will rise with higher gas prices and inflation. Residents of Northern Virginia and Hampton Roads will see increases in the local sales tax from 5 to 6 percent, increases in taxes on home sales, and increased hotel taxes. The rest of the state will experience a sales tax hike from 5 to 5.3 percent.

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      That bill in reality (and unexpectedly) decreased pump taxes, because shortly after the Bill was enacted, gasoline prices dropped substantially. The Va. pump tax, for the first time indexed to gaso price in 2012, hit the lowest floor amount (about 17.4 cent/gal floor) and remained there until Northam’s increases. Of course NoVA cost of living was increased to compensate, as you state above.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Ah, but what goes down, must come up. Something like that. Money — no gravity.

    2. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Anyways Larry you have made progress this week. Last week you said we had almost lowest gaso taxes in the whole USA (using 2019 numbers). Now you know we have a whole new ballgame, and that’s before I add in the added new HUF fees.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        Perhaps, but even now we’re no where near the top states. I’m not even sure I said “lowest” even!

        It costs money to maintain roads and congestion costs money but not too many want to pay even their fair share.

        So the DOTs and the legislators try to find ways to generate the money in ways not easy for folks to figure out even though when you buy a vehicle it’s there right on your invoice!

        I bet not one in 100 would know how much something like police cost them either.

  4. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Makes ya almost wanna buy an EV, now don’t it?

    As long as it comes with a synthesized engine sound with a 1000W amplifier. Select your sound, NASCAR, F1, Mustang, Harley…

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      https://www.baconsrebellion.com/is-dmv-hiding-26-of-virginias-fuel-tax/

      I’m going to start charging a fee for these re-writes of my old posts….

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        I almost said something, but it is a Conservative blog and a “whump” does not a drumbeat make. Besides, this particular horse still has some life.

        Well, at least it’s about a tangible.

    2. Packer Fan Avatar
      Packer Fan

      Yes! Let’s all switch to EV’s and then watch with great anticipation to see where the Generally Assembly pivots to make up for all the lost gasoline tax money.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Mileage tax… every year when you register, you’ll provide the odometer reading and be billed.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          yep. or tolls. But again – some time ago, Virginia diversified transportation taxes and now fuel taxes are only about 1/3 the tax stream.

          Virginia taxes car sales at 4.5%. Calculate that for a 20-30K car.

          And I think about 1/2% of the general sales tax now goes to VDOT – actually MORE than the tax on fuel.

          Virginia also taxes car insurance premiums

          and they charge cell phone carriers to put towers on VDOT right of way. They get a slice of recordation fees also.

          VDOT is way ahead on this issue and do you know who was at VDOT prior to the Northam administration? Yep, none other than Aubrey Lane!

          I’m just amused at the borderline conspiracy theories that are engaged in when it comes to transportation taxes and funding.

          Clearly, most folks know very little about how transportation is really funded in Va and VDOT is not about to make it more transparent!

  5. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    Here’s the DMV website with the revenues.

    Not counting the Fed tax, nor the Regional ones for NoVa/Tidewater – the lions share of taxes for transportation in Va break out this way

    https://www.dmv.virginia.gov/general/#revenues.asp

    fuel taxes = 1/3
    sales tax on new vehicles = 1/3
    general sales tax = 1/3

    So the taxes have gone up but have they really? Are they clawing back taxes lost from more efficient cars?

    Everytime you turn around, someone is complaining that Virginia is not prioritizing transportation infrastructure.

    https://tripnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/TRIP_Virginia_BTN_Report_February_2020.pdf

    So which is it?

    Is it the age old quandary of people wanting more but not wanting to pay for it or tax that guy behind the tree.

    Now we have folks who think there should be no fuel tax and no tolls, that general taxes should pay for transportation.

  6. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    The other hidden new tax is Virginia’s new HUF Fee: the tax on Fuel efficient vehicles. Quoted $19 is misleading statement, by a country mile….

    Something like a Prius is paying about $50 a year annual penalty now. And sounds like that is creeping up to near $100/year soon. That’s just a ridiculous 10-yr ownership penalty on someone already paying extra for fuel efficient vehicle.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      But when they do that, they are no longer paying their share of funding the maintenance and operation of the roads.

      no?

      1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
        energyNOW_Fan

        Name another Blue state taxing fuel efficient vehicles?

        How does it make sense to penalize fuel efficient vehicles, and at the same time, say Climate Change is the biggest threat to America? Nonsense.

        In my personal case, most of my fuel is purchased in MD, so I am not cheating Virginia $50 taxes. The $50 bucks/yr I have to hand over to Virginia is pure profit to Virginia and pure penalty to me for buying a fuel efficient car.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          but the point of transportation taxes has nothing to do with climate or pollution, but rather how to pay for the transportation network.

          If one person does not pay their fair share, then others have to pay more.

          no?

          1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            But then electric cars get enormous tax discounts, including pump tax fees. Why does that make sense.

          2. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            because it’s not about paying for the road system, it’s a separate thing the govt is doing to encourage a separate thing – conservation. Not only electric cars, but HVACs, and insulated windows, and simliar…

            but the roads still have to be paid for – no matter what is done about conservation.

            For each person, who does not pay their share, someone else will have to pay more.

          3. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            Exactly so I have to pay a lot of extra taxes give to electric vehicle advocates.

          4. Stephen Haner Avatar
            Stephen Haner

            So, Lar, you will join me in the effort to crush the Transportation and Climate Initiative, since it is fuel tax that 1) is not going to the network and 2) will reduce the traditional funding from fuel taxes??

          5. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            I think the whole thing is a partisan argument, and it’s hard to really get hard, believable numbers on impacts to this point.

            It’s a standard boogeyman thing.

            They could do something similar with tolls.

            In fact, dynamic tolls actually have more to do with managing congestion levels than transportation funding per se.

        2. Stephen Haner Avatar
          Stephen Haner

          Here’s a list. VA not unique.

          https://www.myev.com/research/interesting-finds/states-that-charge-extra-fees-to-own-an-electric-vehicle

          The fact that they are hitting them with fees is proof they know the climate catastrophe narrative is total BS…. 🙂

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            well , this stuff was going on BEFORE the “climate” issue – way back when cars started to get more efficient and the gas tax itself and transportation funding overall was predicated on less efficient levels of fuel use.

            This stuff went sideways when they started rewarding HOV status to more efficient vehicles on the premise that it would improve air quality in urban areas.

            That came at a cost – a reduction in funding for those roads – which meant either increase fuel taxes on others or less congestion-reducing infrastucture.

          2. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            True.
            The real argument is those who use electricity are good human beings, Those who use fossil fuels and bad human beings.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            A LOT of states are doing this – for the SAME reason. They have a budget for transportation and more efficient cars are eating away at it.

            If not this, then what? Mileage -based fees for everyone?

          4. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            But that list is for Electric Vehicles. we are penalizing fuel efficient gasoline vehicles. EV’s only pay $64 in Virginia. That ‘s a bargain. An average car would pay about $140 for 12k miles per year.

            If you instead own a Prius Hybrid, you would pay all of your normal gaso pump taxes, plus about $65 penalty fee for owning a hybrid in Virginia, and climbing.

            Agreed in recent years some Red states have started penalizing “hybrids”. But that is wrong headed too.

  7. Paul Sweet Avatar
    Paul Sweet

    I’m a Conservative, but I’ve always considered the fuel tax as a user fee rather than a tax. Indexing it to inflation shouldn’t be considered a tax hike. The two nickel hikes probably made up for past inflation since the the last increase during the Baliles administration. McDonnell’s tax bill would have increased gas taxes if gas prices kept climbing like everyone expected, but they went down and stayed down for a while.

    A lump sum extra for fuel-efficient vehicles is unfair because it makes somebody who drives only 5000 miles a year pay as much as somebody who drives 20,000 or more miles a year. It might be possible for inspection stations to enter the odometer reading into a database which would calculate the next year’s fee. Of course that would require several agencies computer systems to talk to each other.

    I hope somebody can come up with a way to collect a road user fee for electric cars and fuel-efficient cars that’s as unobtrusive as the fuel tax. A few bucks every fillup is much easier to live with than an extra hundred bucks to renew a registration. A lot of poorer people wouldn’t have that kind of money to spare at registration time.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      You have a point about mileage – I thought they were keying it to mileage… if not, I agree, not allocated fairly.

      VDOT is no longer relying just on the gas tax. They’ve diversified and now sales taxes on cars and general plus an insurance tax and something else – make up about 2/3 of the Virginia taxes. They don’t book toll revenue collected by private company tolls, I don’t think.

      I don’t think a mileage tax will work unless it’s nationwide – state lines are messy …and people will evade if they can.

    2. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Also I know my fuel purchases tend to be in Md and then I owe Va. a penalty for what? Underpayment in Maryland?

  8. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    not sure if this includes the latest increases in Virginia:

    https://files.taxfoundation.org/20200729125555/Gas-Tax-July-2020-FV-01.png

    I know Steve does not think like this – but higher taxes and higher gas prices actually increases productivity – to do the same work with more efficiency – that’s the very definition or productivity ,no?

    ” Considerable debate exists about the size of the rebound in energy efficiency and the relevance of the Jevons paradox to energy conservation. Some dismiss the paradox, while others worry that it may be self-defeating to pursue sustainability by increasing energy efficiency.[3] Some environmental economists have proposed that efficiency gains be coupled with conservation policies that keep the cost of use the same (or higher) to avoid the Jevons paradox.[6] Conservation policies that increase cost of use (such as cap and trade or green taxes) can be used to control the rebound effect.”

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Yes correct this time Larry (last week you gave me 2019 numbers). Above includes the July 2020 increases (not including the HUF fees new added for 2020).

      We are still at 29.4 cents today (but July 1 we go up again):
      https://www.api.org/oil-and-natural-gas/consumer-information/motor-fuel-taxes/gasoline-tax

      The API numbers are state total average tax receipts, including all eco-fees and regional taxes, so if you live in NoVA/Hampton you are really paying more than 29.4 cents (maybe 2-3 cents more), and in RoVA you are paying a little less (maybe 2-3 cents less). It’s about a 50/50 split. So roughly that would be 32.4 cents NOVA/Hampton, 26.4 cents RoVA.

  9. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    By the way, decades ago Congress deemed it a criminal act for gasoline stations to show taxes on the receipt. So we cannot see that on the receipt. So that is partly why we need articles like this to understand it.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      I’m not sure that is true though. Virginia changed the way it taxes fuel but I think other states still tax at the pump.

      Are you sure about that?

      1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
        energyNOW_Fan

        I believe federal commerce law prohibits showing gaso taxes on your recepit. That goes back maybe 70+ years: elected officials were very irked when gaso stations advertised Price= 25 cents + 6 cents tax.

        It was deemed false advertising and banned accordingly.

  10. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    Here is the recent history, as best I can piece it together, since McDonnell’s 2012 Transport Bill.

    (1) Thru 2019: Approx 22 Cents Total Average Virginia Gaso Tax
    >> NoVa seeing approx. 24 cpg/ RoVA seeing about 20 cpg

    what happened next:
    (a) NoVA was hurting; regional element was upped (was 2% )
    (b) Statewide gasoline tax increase #1 by Northam
    (c) Penalty initiated on fuel efficient gaso vehicles over 25 MPG

    (2) Thru June 2021: 29.4 cents Average Virginia Tax
    >> NoVa seeing approx. 33 cpg/ RoVA seeing about 26 cpg

    what happened next:
    (d) Statewide gasoline tax increase #2 by Northam

    (3) July 2021 : Estimated Add 5 cpg, plus inflation if any
    >> NoVa seeing approx. 38 cpg/ RoVA seeing about 31 cpg

    Thus since 2019 in NoVA, our per gallon tax will go up from about 24 to about 38 cents, not including about $45/year added penalty to me for owning a fuel efficient RAV4, all of which are minimums (subjected to possible large increases due to inflation – depending on the price index given to us by the Va.Dems).

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Re: New Penalty on Fuel efficient Cars over 25 MPG
      We are told the average penalty is $19 but that is going up too now, so lets say $23. we have 8 million registered vehicles so maybe what? 35% over 25 MPG? If so, that would be $64 million added gaso taxes by the new penalty.

      1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
        energyNOW_Fan

        PS- I sure hope NoVA gets to keep the tax penalty on NoVA cars over 25 MPG!!!! Or else we have yet another giant sucking sound in NoVA.

      2. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
        energyNOW_Fan

        PS- I sure hope NoVA gets to keep the tax penalty on NoVA cars over 25 MPG!!!! Or else we have yet another giant sucking sound in NoVA.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          You can see just how small the revenue is right now from the Highway Use Fee:

          https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/52c52492eefecc1ce0aaf4692f4a585d5a30406ff61e181fe3826a5f94edfed1.jpg

          1. Brian Leeper Avatar
            Brian Leeper

            What’s the multiplier on that?

            I find it really difficult to believe that the total Commonwealth Transportation Fund is only $3.734682 million….

          2. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            It’s billion.

            And the total is actually close to 7 billion because of other revenues – like from the Fed Gas tax and a category that generates 1.5 billion called
            Receipts from Cities/Counties that I
            do yet understand from what:

            but is the page where this data is:

            https://www.dmv.virginia.gov/webdoc/pdf/tracking_may21.pdf

            Here is more breakdown but keep in mind that “transportation” funding is MORE than just highways.

            https://www.virginiadot.org/about/resources/budget/Final_CTF_Budget,_6-18-2019.pdf

          3. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            So I was not too far off with my estimate of $64 million. I was projecting forward to next year, so $46 million would be my final estimate, based on your data above (thank you).

  11. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    Bottom line, Virginia is quickly moving from lowest to among the highest gasolines taxes. Those in NoVA with fuel efficient vehicle penalty are now seeing among the highest gaso taxes of any state.

    In other words, NoVA is now seeing about 38 cpg tax vs. say NJ at 41 cpg. Added to that my RAV4 penalty equates to about $45 per year, which equates to about +15 cents/gallon. So the effective fuel tax I am seeing NoVA is 38+15 = 53 cents per gallon.

    This does not count the NoVA sales tax increase from 5 to 6% from 2012, which probably equates to another +10-15 cents/gal.

  12. William O'Keefe Avatar
    William O’Keefe

    No one likes to pay more taxes but the gasoline tax is intended to be a user fee. If the revenue from the tax goes toward road and bridge maintenance we should not be complaining.

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      As a NoVA resident, it would not be so bad if the cost were spread out more evenly, as most states do. Considering the regional gaso tax bite + fuel efficient vehicle tax bite + general sales tax bite, the lion’s share of funding is probably coming from NoVA with our lopsided, bifurcated “tax the heck out of NoVA” system.

      I was somewhat in favor of higher gaso tax in NoVA, on the theory we might not see the increase at the pump. Not sure how that theory is working out yet. But I do not like the fuel efficient vehicle penalty.

      PS- In addition the much higher fuel taxes and sales taxes imposed on NoVa (and Hampton Roads) by the state, NoVA also has to use Reformulated Gasoline, which is probably an added 20-30 cents per gallon before we even start talking about taxes.

      1. William O'Keefe Avatar
        William O’Keefe

        I think that RFG is required through large portions of the state. although I doubt that the difference is as high as 20-30 cents per gallon but you do get reduced MPG.

        1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
          energyNOW_Fan

          RFG not so wide spread …I am thinking NoVA, but cuts off out by Manassas, and some Hampton maybe Richmond. Maps here.

          https://www.api.org/~/media/Files/Policy/Fuels-and-Renewables/2016-Oct-RFS/US-Fuel-Requirements/US-Gasoline-Requirements-Map.pdf

        2. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
          energyNOW_Fan

          Interesting right now COSTCO NoVA is $2.86 and COSTCO UVa is $2.76. The small price difference there strikes me as very unusual…but takes money to get the past data. Maybe my theory is working: NoVa not seeing the higher taxes in the pump prices?

          1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
            energyNOW_Fan

            The theory that NoVA might not see gaso tax increase at the pump, is an educated guess by some observers, that it is unfavorable economics for oil companies to truck fuels all the way to NoVA. So NoVA pump prices need to be held at status quo compared to Maryland/DC. In other words, we cannot have cheap gasoline in NoVA, so we have a choice, let the oil companies increase price here, or we can increase price ourselves, and then the oil companies do not have to charge extra in their proprietary models of fuel distribution costs.

        3. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
          energyNOW_Fan

          Looks like RBOB CBOB spread only around +7 cents now which is historical low, in part due to new 2021 RBOB blending rule simplifications. Historical high was 28 cents. I cannot find good historical trend data for CBOB vs. RBOB. NoVA/Hampton get the RBOB (RFG).

          https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/042021-feature-us-gulf-coast-rbob-premium-over-cbob-starts-summer-grade-season-at-record-low

      2. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        A substantial portion of VDOT expenditures – is for Highway Maintenance and Operations, i.e. all those roads that were built (and theoretically paid for once), well they have annual operating and maintenance costs that far exceed their original cost. Someone has to pay for that but no on wants to or they want to claim that somehow they are being screwed over unfairly by the taxes.

        Regional “envy” is also endemic. Every highway district from NoVa to Hampton Roads to Fredericksburg and the others all thing the other districts are getting more than their share and their district is being de-funded and their money given to other districts.

        The transportation funding conundrum is an interesting insight into how people REALLY feel about taxes, government role and services/facilities.

        When we have a ton of people suspects that VDOT is screwing them over, not a big jump at all to other government taxation and spending!

  13. Moderate Avatar
    Moderate

    A tax that went up July 1, 2020 and again July 1, 2021 didn’t go up but once in the year 2020. The increases were exactly a year apart, not in the same year. The story is bad enough going up 10 cents over two years, worse if it was just over one.

  14. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    What we don’t do on transportation and taxes is ask ” How much SHOULD it cost” . That’s not as crazy as it sounds IMHO because it would help get us beyond the wild out of the blue mantra that ” We pay too much in taxes” or ” the taxes have gone up too much to quickly” which are little more than wild ass guesses that sometimes vary according to one’s political philosophy more than any legitimate metric.

    You could START with how much citizens pay per capita for each state, no?

    here’s another:

    “How much do state and local governments spend on highways and roads?
    In 2017, state and local governments spent $181 billion, or 6 percent of direct general spending, on highways and roads.2 Highways and roads were the sixth-largest source of direct general spending at the state and local level in 2017, and spending was roughly on par with that on police and corrections.”

    https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiatives/state-and-local-finance-initiative/state-and-local-backgrounders/highway-and-road-expenditures

    that’s about $550 per capita nationwide.

    Virginia is more like $750 I think.

Leave a Reply