No Better Time to Instill Financial Literacy in Black and Brown Virginian Youth

by Sherifah Munis

Racial systemic inequalities have recently been brought to the forefront of our national conscience, shedding light on the centuries of policies that have disadvantaged Black and Brown Americans’ ability to build, maintain, and pass on wealth. A striking 2019 statistic shows that the median family wealth (the difference between gross assets and liabilities) for White Americans was $188,200 compared to $24,100 for Black Americans and $36,100 for Hispanic families.

One area of resounding disparity is the inequality between Black and Brown Americans and their White counterparts regarding access to and knowledge of financial literacy – the ability to understand and apply financial skills related to personal financial management, budgeting, and investing. This gap is evident in the research on Black Americans with regard to low home ownership, low participation in the financial marketplace, high credit card and student loan debt, and expensive credit card behavior (such as paying minimum fees, incurring late fees, and taking cash advances).

The financial literacy education in U.S. public schools is inconsistent across states, often integrated into history or other social studies curricula, or only offered as an optional topic. The good news is the Virginia Board of Education approved one standard unit of credit in economics and personal finance as a requirement for high school graduation beginning with students who entered ninth grade in fall 2011. However, as a mom of teenagers, I noticed first-hand that the personal finance classes my kids participated in were varied in that an economics class fulfilling the personal finance requirement didn’t necessarily teach how to create a budget, or what it takes to build and maintain credit, etc. One potential solution to this problem is a standardized, culturally-relevant, and youth-oriented financial literacy program.

Drawing from our seven years of experience as a trusted nonprofit organization, Newwave Foundation’s (NWF) mission is focused on inspiring the next generation of dreamers by creating opportunities for educational equality. To that end, NWF is launching a new project named Money Talk$ Financial Literacy Program. Inspired by the success of our virtual seminar and workshop series, Money Talk$, this initiative has the potential to increase the economic and political capital of our Black and Brown communities. By creating a new cycle of generational wealth, increasing responsible participation in a more equitable marketplace, and empowering our youth to utilize their financial know-how, our underrepresented communities will leverage influence in the policies and politics that have historically marginalized and disenfranchised their communities.

To take on this challenge, Newwave Foundation will provide practical financial literacy skills in a workshop format to high school students through our existing community partnerships in Northern Virginia, Washington D.C., and Maryland. Our program differs from school-based programs in that our culturally relevant and age-appropriate curriculum will be designed to engage our Black and Brown teens and acknowledge their different post-high school life tracks. In addition, our goal is to connect financial knowledge to real-world application; for example, students will be offered mentored opportunities to open bank accounts and manage a budget while in high school.

Our goal is to “instill the dream” where we can bridge the wealth gap by having more Black and Brown people investing in assets, owning homes, becoming entrepreneurs, passing on wealth and knowledge, and building legacies. An early start to acquiring financial literacy skills is key to success; a strong foundation in personal financial knowledge can support life goals including entrepreneurship, saving for education and retirement, stimulating a new cycle of generational wealth, and using debt responsibly. The Money Talk$ Financial Literacy Program, rooted in the belief that our youth will be our tomorrow, is focused on cultivating and facilitating a lasting impact for the youth of our Black and Brown communities. Although our program will be targeting Black and Brown students, it will be open to any and all students who are being served by our partner organizations who wish to participate.


Sherifah Munis is the Founder and Executive Director of the Newwave Foundation (NWF), an organization focused on inspiring the next generation to action. The Foundation’s vision is to “Instill the Dream” in deserving students through scholarship opportunities, educational workshops, and partnering with like-minded organizations who want to make a positive difference. Guided by her passion for empowering students, building relationships, and her heart for service, Sherifah supports the mission of the Foundation by leading NWF in its development and implementation of strategic initiatives for educational equality. A resident of Arlington County, she is actively involved in her local community as a member of the Business Women’s Giving Circle (BWGC) of Northern Virginia. Sherifah holds a Bachelor of Science and a Master’s of Art in Economics from Morgan State University and a Global Executive MBA from Georgetown University.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

27 responses to “No Better Time to Instill Financial Literacy in Black and Brown Virginian Youth”

  1. LarrytheG Avatar

    financial literacy is one of those things that can and does come from family. Not that schools should not teach it , they should ( as well an entrepreneurship also).

    But even if you or your kids are financially literate, how much family wealth you have to start with is also a factor.

    Mom/Dad paying for your first car or for some or all of your College means less debt for you compared to kids whose parents have no money to give/loan to their kids.

    1. It is much more complicated than that. Can the family support a child’s move to NYC, for the semester abroad, for the low paid entry level job. For waiting months before the clearance is approved?
      No personal finance class is going to tell a child from a blue collar family about the massive financial risk in trying to become a psychologist that requires graduate school, a fellowship, and years of study.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        yep. no disagreement. But my point also is that in a family of higher level education
        that they have a better opportunity to understand the issues and make more informed decisions that say a family where there is a lot less understanding and/or the mom/dad themselves have financial issues with debt and loans.

  2. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Yes, yes. Financial literacy! Everyone should be depressed equally.

    In “Kodachrome” Paul Simon laments on all he was taught in high school. It’s actually what they don’t teach, and handling money is one of those things lacking from the curriculum. BUT IT ALWAYS HAS BEEN.

    Money and sex are the two subjects left for the parents to teach. That worked well. “Don’t teach my kids about sex, and don’t tell they how poor they really are.” Amazing the number of celebrities I have seen interviewed in my life who have said, “I grew up poor but I never knew how poor we were.”

    In the 90s, I used to take the last class in the semester and tell my students about 401(k)s and IRAs.

    1. I’m all for this, and might even volunteer to help if there’s something happening locally.

      But literacy doesn’t necessarily bring about change. For example, does anyone not know that smoking is harmful? But in spite of that, some segments of society smoke more than others. It’s not “access” to information. It’s to a large degree how you were brought up, and what those around you are doing.

      I grew up in a low income family where both parents smoked, and neither went to college. None of my ancestors had been to college, nor my aunts and uncles. My parents earned enough to get by, but never invested anything. Breaking the cycle is very difficult, no matter what the color of your skin is.

      What really helps is to have dreams, set goals, and socialize with others who are equally determined to get ahead in life. A child’s friends can either help them up, or pull them down.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        If your parents are not telling you that you’re going to college and they’re going to make sure it happens financially, it’s a whole different kettle of fish – from the kids point of view.

        And if your parents never went to college and never had a good job that paid health care and built a pension – they may not have good advice as to how to proceed.

        It’s easy for some folks to blame the parents (or one parent) but the reality is if the parents got crappy K-12 education and never went to college, their involvement and motivation for the kid to essentially do what they never did , is not an easy thing.

        Some kids make it despite all odds but the majority of them do not and they grow up and have kids and repeat the cycle.

        The way to break the cycle is to have some adult involve beyond just the parents.

        For me, it was some of my teachers as neither parent had a college education, were in trouble economically once they left the service, and then added smoking and drinking to the mix.

        tough row to how for the kids.

        1. My boys have had it much easier, but having not learned the hard lessons I did, it remains to be seen if they will live frugally and save. I hope they do, but many of their friends from college are living high off their parents money.

          Let’s just say that “sacrifice, save and invest” aren’t at the forefront of their minds right now.

          I can set an example, but spending comes easier than saving, and it doesn’t seem to matter how much to one makes.

          The country itself, and most of the people in it, are living beyond their means. Living beneath one’s means is like swimming upstream.

      2. LarrytheG Avatar

        not just black or brown. ANY kid whose parents are not financially literate themselves, not well educated, and on the economic margins with their employment and own financial status.

  3. “One area of resounding disparity is the inequality between Black and Brown Americans and their White counterparts regarding access to and knowledge of financial literacy – the ability to understand and apply financial skills related to personal financial management, budgeting, and investing.” Unfortunately, until the public schools ensure all children have basic reading and math skills, there can be no real changes.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      No better subject to interest kids in reading and math than money! Kepler’s barrels was inspired by the king’s desire to know which merchants were cheating him.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        Indeed. In 2nd and 3rd grade, they teach kids how to count with coins.

        But that’s not really financial literacy in my mind. It needs to be something like they get X allowance per week and they want a Y doodad… or do they want to save for the Z doodad…and … they got the doodad but they did now have enough to pay for all of it so they got the doodad and a loan, etc…

        And when they get older – DON’T “cash: your IRA when you change jobs!

      2. https://www.maa.org/press/periodicals/convergence/mathematical-treasures-english-gaugers-scale

        As far as volumetric measurements go, I know that 1 Butt = 1.457 Imperial Hogsheads, or 2.00 U.S. Hogsheads*.

        But do you know how many Kepler’s Barrels are in a Hogshead?

        * This means that if you have 126 gallons of Madeira you can honestly say that you have a buttload of wine.

  4. This sounds like it can be valuable to all students, especially the ‘target audience’. Kudos to Sherifah Munis for her efforts.

  5. This sounds like it can be valuable to all students, especially the ‘target audience’. Kudos to Sherifah Munis for her efforts.

  6. Financial education at the k-12 level is generally a waste of time because of how unrealistic it is.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      I agree. A bunch of them graduate and don’t know how to handle loans and debt.

      1. And what would one teach about loans that would be applicable for an 18 year old. net present value? What revolving credit is?

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          something more than currently taught. Even kids of college-educated will go off and get themselves into decades long debt for their college… right?

          1. It used to be worse with the credit card companies giving unsecured credit cards to college students knowing that the parents would bail them out if the students got into trouble.

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            still pretty bad with kids incurring loans that will take a decade or more to pay off. They make that decision based on desire to go to college without really considering the downstream impact on their own financial affairs.

    2. DJRippert Avatar

      I agree. While I never had any financial literacy classes in high school, I can only imagine how fast I would have forgotten the lessons had I been in such a course. I didn’t have a checking account until I went to college. Don’t get me wrong – I think financial literacy is important. I just question how effective it is to teach that in K-12.

      I guess exposure to things like loan amortization in high school would provide a slight benefit to teenagers but, like chemistry, I’d expect that most of what would be taught would be quickly forgotten.

  7. f/k/a_tmtfairfax Avatar
    f/k/a_tmtfairfax

    NOVA community college used to have a personal finance course that satisfied a social studies requirement. However, it discontinued the court. Not a good idea. As I recall, in HS, we had a month-long personal finance course that was mandatory to graduate.

  8. Bob X from Texas Avatar
    Bob X from Texas

    The inequality between Black, Brown ,and White Americans is caused by the adherence (or lack of) to basic long known rules for success.
    1. Get as much education as you can, at the very least finish High School.
    2. Get a job, work 40 hours a week and prepare yourself for a better job.
    3. Have babies in wedlock.
    Those that follow these rules have a much better life.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Folks who don’t achieve higher levels of education, regardless of their color, often have these issues.

      So , how do we improve this?

  9. walter smith Avatar
    walter smith

    Why just black and brown?
    How about our politicians? Modern Monetary Theory? Print yourself rich!
    There are simple rules. Spend less than you make is not difficult to understand. Neither is save early and often. Neither is thrift.
    If you live beneath your means for an extended period of time, you will have more means than you ever thought.

  10. I am all in favor of more responsible behavior and applaud this effort.
    I do have 2 questions.
    1- if the effects of systemic racism can be overcome by acting responsibly, what does that say about the concept of systemic racism and its causal effect on the issue? (How much poverty is caused by bad choices?)

    2- would an outbreak of responsible fiscal behavior among the population signal the end of the welfare state and the dem party?

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      The harm of a lack of financial literacy is not isolated to only black folks.

      It’s endemic to folks of poor educational attainment who, as a result, suffer economically and it is independent of race.

      The difference is in percentages of economically disadvantaged with regard to race.

      Blacks and hispanics have far higher numbers of economically disadvantaged than whites or Asians.

      It’s no big mystery as to why except perhaps for those who want to believe more people of a particular race are actually more inclined to be illiterate, choosing to be so as a culture.

      The facts are below:

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/9b043178083f766797e32f292b6520086a40ef7e6d8ebeae696afb36298d3a70.jpg

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/db7ef0e9f6d8f3d831076d759c16c7df61c9fdf6580d46573032b7b51d1cdec7.jpg

Leave a Reply