by Kerry Dougherty

Labor Day. America’s most ambiguous national holiday.

Think about it. On other special days – Memorial, Independence, Veterans, Thanksgiving, Presidents, Martin Luther King and Christmas – we pause, however briefly, to honor a beloved person or a historical event.

We have parades, visit cemeteries, blast fireworks, give thanks, recite a famous speech or watch It’s a Wonderful Life.

Not on Labor Day.

Take a peek at the festivities scheduled this weekend. Wait. What festivities? The Rock ‘n’ Roll Half Marathon has moved on, so there’s nothing to do today other than hit the beach and cook out.

Swimming and eating burgers has nothing to do with Labor Day’s grittier, trade union roots.

And that’s a good thing.

I’m not sure anyone wants to mark Labor Day by dragging a picket sign to the beach or by joining a national scavenger hunt to look for Jimmy Hoffa’s body.

Does anyone plan to watch Norma Rae today? Or gather the family together for a few choruses of “The Ballad of Joe Hill”?

Anyone inviting the repulsive Randi Weingarten to their cookout?

I didn’t think so.

On Labor Day, it’s not what we do, it’s what we don’t do – labor.

On its website, the U.S. Department of Labor clings to the fiction that those taking the day off are paying tribute to the trade union movement. It features black-and-white photos of famous and obscure labor leaders and this:

Labor Day, the first Monday in September, is a creation of the labor movement and is dedicated to the social and economic achievements of American workers. It constitutes a yearly national tribute to the contributions workers have made to the strength, prosperity and well-being of our country.

Please.

Maybe Samuel Gompers and Walter Reuther are revered in some Rust Belt regions. But everywhere else, Labor Day is simply the bittersweet end of summer.

It’s also the last time we can wear white until Memorial Day.

Here in Virginia, where — until 2019 — the commonwealth’s children enjoyed the protection of what’s been dubbed “The King’s Dominion Relief Act,” this was also the day before public schools are allowed to open.

That was a good law, by the way. It’s unnatural to send kids back to the classroom in August. Besides, 180 days of school are 180 days. What difference does it make when they commence?

For the kid in each of us, the start of school makes Labor Day feel a little like New Year’s. As someone who was educated in public schools that started the Tuesday after the first Monday of September, Labor Day always was about the proverbial clean slate.

The start of a school year meant crisp notebooks, sharp pencils and three-ring binders full of pristine paper with bright plastic dividers. It meant new clothes in fall colors and stiff shoes guaranteed to produce blisters the size of Ritz crackers.

It was the giddy optimism that came with meeting a new teacher – one who might finally recognize your hidden genius – and new classmates and maybe even a new best friend. It was the absolute certainty that this year would be better than last.

Sometimes it was. Often it wasn’t.

But on Labor Day, all things seemed possible. That alone is worth celebrating.

Republished with permission from Kerry: Unemployed and Unedited.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

12 responses to “Labor Day: A New Start”

  1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    On this occasion, I agree with Kerry. It’s nice having traditions and markers along the way. Labor Day used to mark a new year. It marked the end of summer and the beginning of school. In rural Halifax County, the start of school was delayed until after Labor Day, even before the Kings Dominion bill was passed, to give the farmers one last shot at “pulling leaves [of tobacco]” and getting a load of tobacco into the barn before the kids who helped them in the fields and at the barn were off to school. For them, it truly was a Labor Day.

    1. VaPragamtist Avatar
      VaPragamtist

      I’m curious about the history of the Kings Dominion bill. Prior to its passage, what was the status quo–most/all public schools started in September, or was there a mixture?

      At nearly 40 and growing up in a rural community, my experience is that schools started after Labor Day until recently (the last 10 – 15 years or so).

      The school systems prefer starting before Labor Day because of SOL testing. The earlier start provides a cleaner timeframe in which to teach and test, all before the holiday break, much like a college semester. Then everyone comes back and starts fresh (instead of coming back and spending time relearning what was forgotten over Christmas).

      I also suspect, prior to the KD bill’s repeal, school divisions found ways to manipulate KD bill waivers to their advantage. There were a couple of years in the early 2010’s where school divisions closed for extended periods for severe inclement weather (snow storms, Hurricane Irene, and so on). As a result, those divisions were eligible for waivers to open before Labor Day. Subsequent years saw trends of school divisions closing for questionable weather decisions (“too cold”, “too windy”, “too much rain”). . .whatever excuse was needed to meet the waiver requirements.

      Of course this is all anecdotal, but I’m sure a look at the data (reasons for closure, weather reports, and waiver applications over time), would tell a fuller story.

      1. It was a mix with the majority starting after Labor Day. However, there was pressure for more to start before Labor Day. The law stopped that trend. At least that’s how I recollect it.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        That’s why all these amusement parks bring in foreign kids on some kinda J-1 visa, or such. They put ‘em up 4 to a room in some condemned motel the park owns/leases, pays them squat, charge for food and room. They do cover flights, but if the kid leaves early, they own the whole flight costs.

        https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/j1-visa-summer-work-travel-abuse/

    2. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      For decades I would receive a W&M poster calendar. It was the usual 3×4 block of months except the top row was Sept, Oct, Nov, 19xx and the second row was Dec then Jan and Feb 19xx+1, etc., to the bottom right block was Aug 19xx+1.

      I loved it. It screwed up people in the office so badly when they were talking schedules. Funny watching them try to find the correct months.

  2. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    “It’s unnatural to send kids back to the classroom in August.”

    Really? Something in our evolutionary DNA screams to tell us to wait until after Labor Day to start school…??

    1. VaPragamtist Avatar
      VaPragamtist

      Its funny. . .because Kerry also says “Besides, 180 days of school are 180 days. What difference does it make when they commence?”

      So what difference does it make if they commence before Labor Day?

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Even funnier is the party of the Chamber of Commerce co-opting Labor Day as some sort of mixed 4th & Memorial uber patriotic holiday.

        So look for the union label…

  3. LarrytheG Avatar

    Labor day really has little to do with what schools need to do for getting kids educated IMO.

    It’s a familiar cultural “marker” but in a world where folks like Kerry also talk about the performance of our schools, and a need to get better, why not start in August if doing so actually is a benefit to some kids?

    The number one biggest issue with schools is how much the kids lose over the summer vacation. It takes weeks for the schools to get the kids back to where they were when school ended the prior year and especially so the low-income/at-risk kids.

    If we are every going to get better at this, blindly defending things like Labor Day really do call into question how serious we are about actually trying to get better… IMO.

  4. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Labor Day has turned into a 4 day school holiday in most schools up here in the northern part of the state. In Loudoun there are 20 student holidays between the first day and new years day. Thinking back 40 years ago there would have been no more than 10 student holidays between the first day and new years day. Knock off the holidays and get busy teaching and learning. A sure fire way to raise NAEP and the other host of test scores.

  5. It’s unnatural to send kids back to the classroom in August. Besides, 180 days of school are 180 days. What difference does it make when they commence?

    It seems to make a big difference to you, Ms. Dougherty. This is the second piece you’ve written about it.

    Starting school before Labor Day is no more “unnatural” than Labor Day itself.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      The kids have lost a year of school. It doesn’t seem unreasonable that they’d need some additional time to try to get some of it back.

      Wasn’t that long ago that kids who were behind needed to attend additional school in the summer.

Leave a Reply