Is Anyone In Charge Over There?

The new rules for occupying a prestigious room on the University of Virginia’s Lawn allow students to post comments and materials on two message boards affixed to each door. An addendum to the “Terms and Conditions for Lawn and Range Residents, Housing and Residence Life” states:

“Any materials placed on the message boards must fit within the four corners of each message board and cannot extend beyond the outer edges of any such board.”

The addendum also provides this context:

The Academical Village – the Rotunda, Lawn and Range rooms, hotels, gardens, and pavilions – is an area of historic and architectural significance that serves as the centerpiece of the University. The beauty and historical significance of the Academical Village is reflected in its designation as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. The Lawn is also the backdrop for many University events and draws visitors from around the world. It is a place visited by school children who are seeing a college campus for the first time, and a place where grandparents picnic with their grandchildren. It also regularly draws many local families and young children. … Lawn and Range residents should respect the unique nature of this space and use and maintain their rooms and exterior areas with appropriate care and consideration of others.

Last week Hector Terrazas Valencia, resident of Room 46. lost no time upon occupying his room for the fall semester in writing “F— UVA (respectfully)” on his message board — an apparent homage to the same words affixed to the door of Lawn resident Hira Azher last spring. The university refused to remove last year’s signage on the grounds that it would abrogate the resident’s right to free speech. The administration argued that because it had failed to police Lawn signage restrictions previously, singling out Azher would constitute a free-speech violation. After an alumni outcry, the administration re-wrote the rules and promised to enforce them this fall.

The administration had not acted to address the new F— UVa message. Now signage on Lawn doors in violation of the space restrictions, which clearly violates the requirement to “maintain their rooms and exterior areas with appropriate care and consideration of others.”

The Jefferson Council President President Bert Ellis took these photos yesterday:

 

 

As members of The Jefferson Council, we’ve got to ask — is anyone in charge over there? Is the administration willing to protect the dignity of the Academical Village, or will it let enforcement lapse like it did last year?

 This column was posted originally on The Jefferson Council website.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

9 responses to “Is Anyone In Charge Over There?”

  1. DJRippert Avatar

    Is anyone in charge? Sure, the guy who just got a $200,000 bonus from the political gadflies called the Board of Visitors.

    The answer is straightforward – encourage all alumni to stop donating.

  2. LarrytheG Avatar

    geeze, looks like doors at a College… lordy. And SHOCK, when have we seen students push the envelope on rules? It’s like shocking!

  3. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Good thing you and your pecksniff friends never walked down our hall on Yates all those years ago…of course, hardly a World Heritage Site, but we loved it….”Stay Hydrated!” I am so offended….

    Have ya seen the ads about becoming your parents? 🙂

    1. “Stay Hydrated!” I am so offended….

      Yes. That statement is incredibly insensitive to anyone who identifies as hydrophobic…

  4. Peter Galuszka Avatar
    Peter Galuszka

    Speaking as a Woo parent, I could care less what the kids put on their doors. Don’t you people have better things to do? The idea of an aging alumn wandering around snapping pictures is downright creepy.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      It’s the Conservative thing to do these days. UVA is the enemy and death from a thousand cuts is the strategy!

  5. LarrytheG Avatar

    Terms of service and selective enforcement – modern day institutional cockroaches…

  6. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    You are sounding like one of those overzealous HOA members now…!

  7. Lawn and Range residents should respect the unique nature of this space and use and maintain their rooms and exterior areas with appropriate care and consideration of others.

    Let’s get technical. “Should” is not the same thing as “shall” or “must”.

    UVA certainly has the power to strictly enforce the “..must fit within the four corners of each message board and cannot extend beyond the outer edges of any such board” requirement if it chooses to. However, I still maintain that the “F— UVA (respectfully)” message, which prompted the resurgence of this issue this year, does not violate UVA’s new message requirements.

    This is not a value judgement on the appropriateness or tastefulness of the message, just my opinion as to whether it meets the so-called “letter of the law”.

Leave a Reply