IG of the Day: Millionaire Mobility

Click on graph for more legible image.

The Congressional Budget Office made quite a splash recently when it published its recent report, “Trends in the Distribution of Household Income between 1979 and 2007.” Progressives swooned in droves at seeming confirmation of their conviction that the rich are getting richer while the poor are getting poorer. (Actually, the report concluded that the richer are getting richer while the poor are treading water, while the middle class has gained ground modestly. Even then, it exaggerates the wealth gap by closing its study period in 2007. The wealth gap has declined significantly since then.)

But I post today’s Information Graphic, the work of Veronique de Rugy at the Mercatus Center, to dispel the notion that social mobility is a thing of the past and that a plutocracy is emerging. The chart above shows that million-dollar incomes are highly variable. You can do spankingly well one year and horribly the next. For many people, incomes spike in a single year while they exercise a decade’s worth of stock options or sell a business they built over a lifetime. Literally half of the million-dollar income earners hit the million-dollar mark for one year before falling back into the ranks of the muddled masses. Only six percent of millionaires scored million-dollar incomes for more than nine years running.

What seems to be a widening income gap actually could reflect the increasingly variable nature of compensation for society’s top money makers. Hundreds of thousands of Americans make a disproportionate share of their boodle in a short period of time, an outcome of corporate America’s effort to tie compensation to performance (bonuses, stock options, and the like) instead of treating executives to fat salaries and perks through good times and bad. Last time I checked, that was  a good thing, not a bad one.

— JAB


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

5 responses to “IG of the Day: Millionaire Mobility”

  1. I’m a little suspicious of this concept. How do people who have a million dollars …lose it?

    most folks when they get a million.. know how to not only keep it but goose it….

  2. Larry, they’re not losing their money. They’re slipping in their earnings. One year they report $1 million in income, the next year they don’t.

  3. Two observations.

    1) The tax code is crap.

    Therefore, anything you try and derive from it is crap….hocus pocus…smoke and mirrors. You get the point.

    2) Are these figures based on income tax returns?

    The whole concept behind getting wealthy is that you buy things and hold on to them. These types of assets wouldn’t necessarily show up in data that focuses solely on income.

    People are born poor and stay poor because they can’t/don’t acquire wealth.

  4. “They’re slipping in their earnings.”

    Precisely.

  5. so the “mobility” is on the threshold of one million… so if you “only” earn 990,000 you fall off the chart?

    that sounds bogus..

    how about using something like MEDIAN INCOME or NET WORTH?

    the implication is “big swings” but I suspect the reality is not….

    isn’t this painting a misleading picture?

Leave a Reply