I Guess I Called that One Wrong

by James A. Bacon

Steve Haner likes to yank my chain every so often, and he did so this morning — digging up my 2019 prognostication that Dominion Energy had lost the Democratic Party in Virginia. At the time Dominion was still committed to natural gas and the Atlantic Coast Pipeline, and opposition to the proposed gas pipeline had become a Democratic Party rallying cry. The Clean Virginia advocacy group was extracting promises left and right from progressive Democrats to reject Dominion campaign donations. 

Well, the ACP is history, Dominion pivoted hard and embraced renewable energy, and now the power company is favoring Democrats with its donations to electoral campaigns and Political Action Committees. As Steve recently highlighted here, Democrats are happily taking the money.

So, is it time now to write the headline, “Dominion Has Lost the GOP. What’s Next?”

Not so fast, says Steve. He thinks Dominion can cobble together a bipartisan coalition of Dems and Repubs willing to carry its water. Environmentalist purists may continue to scorn the utility’s money, as might conservative foes of the Virginia Clean Energy Act, but there are plenty of politicians in the House and Senate who are happy to play along. Counting noses is Steve’s expertise, not mine, so I’ll accept his judgment.

But I did get one big thing right in that story: “In a Democratic-controlled General Assembly, you can be sure that environmentalists will ratchet up their demands — such as accelerating the goal, announced recently by Northam, of achieving a carbon-free electric grid by 2050.”

Oh, please, Br’er Fox, don’t throw me into that briar patch! From Dominion’s perspective, who needs gas pipelines when you can build wind farms, solar farms, transmission lines, and redundant backup systems instead — and charge it all to the ratepayers?

Now Terry McAuliffe has promised to accelerate the 2050 deadline for a net-zero grid. If Dominion is backing McAuliffe for governor, you can be sure that its strategists have calculated they can make money by accelerating the adoption of wind and solar. Ratepayers might not be happy when the bills come due, but the consumer movement that once railed against spiking electric bills in the bad ol’ VEPCO days no longer exists.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

11 responses to “I Guess I Called that One Wrong”

  1. LarrytheG Avatar

    I was curious about opinions in terms of DOM/ACP ‘pivots” .

    Were those “pivots” politically motivated and could change if Virginia
    swings to a GOP governor?

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      If you are asking whether Dominion is actually agnostic, sure, of course. If you can’t be with the one you love….

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        but they would “pivot” again if the political tides went against the green energy things?

        so Dom’s stance is more or less purely aligned to the political tides?

        1. Stephen Haner Avatar
          Stephen Haner

          No….the financial tides are far stronger! The company makes money by building things, with its cap ex. Wind turbine, gas turbine, battery or transmission line, nuke upgrade, it just wants to keep building stuff. Shipyard wants to build ships and the energy utilities want to build plants and grids.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar

            so the GOP likes that also? must be…

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            sometimes it’s hard to understand what the GOP – REALLY WANTS as opposed to what they say they want! I think what the GOP wants – is to be in charge – but they’ll screw it up if they do what they base expects, guarantee it.

          3. Stephen Haner Avatar
            Stephen Haner

            And this differentiates them from the other team how? If Youngkin wins, it will because the D’s did far too much of what their most lefty base voters demanded. ‘Tis a great wheel….

          4. LarrytheG Avatar

            Always pretty clear with the Dems. The GOP actually uses that against them. You are citing it! The GOP does the opposite and runs on cloaked positions. “You gotta elect us to see what we REALLY will do”!

  2. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Since you referenced my email I might as well expand on it. As I’ve written often, the abominable anti-consumer bills of 2015 and 2018 depended heavily on Republican votes to pass, and just this past session many Republicans (too many) stood fast with Dominion against efforts to restore some SCC authority as the rate case approached. Perhaps the revelation that Dominion was giving money to a sleazy pop-up PAC to beat Youngkin (using gun issues) will change some hearts, but as the old saying goes, “when you’ve got them by the ….., their hearts and minds will follow.”

    Peruse the Dominion donor list and you can see its pockets bulging with shorn testicles….And those who claim to oppose Dominion give all their money to Democrats only, the freaking morons. (Clean VA this year: $4 million to Ds, $15,000 to Rs. The House flips and that huge mistake will have me laughing.)

    Should the 2022 session return us to divided government, I suspect Dominion will be able to maneuver to an outcome 75-80% satisfactory to its goals. Repealing or substantially changing VCEA will prove very difficult. The vested interests behind the offshore wind boondoggle are massive. The SCC is now very different with the departure of Mark Christie and probably quite willing to enforce that law as written. If the Democrats remain in full control when the smoke clears, double your business or household energy budgets….

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      I had forgotten that Mark Christie had departed Virginia for the FERC.

      I am constantly amused by how all those folks who came in with George Allen declaring that government was bad and the private sector was always better have, for the most part, remained in and around government, making their living off it.

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Christie was involved in the process long before GA ran for Governor…and people get involved in campaigns because they want to get into the game. I certainly did. I’ll take the Allen alumni over the likes of Bob Blue and Bill Murray, who went for the seven-figure jobs at the utility and used what they learned to enrich its stockholders.

Leave a Reply