Hispanic Activists Take Aim, Shoot Foot

The crackdown on illegal immigration continues to spread. First Prince William County… then Loudoun County… now Culpeper County.

Meanwhile, Hispanics aren’t taking the Prince William resolution — which “instill[s] in the Latino community an atmosphere of terror, desperation and a feeling of discrimination” — sitting down. A coalition of Hispanic organizations are preparing business boycotts on non-Hispanic businesses, work stoppages and a massive rally in protest. Writes Dan Genz in Examiner.com:

Hispanic immigrant groups are hoping a strong show of financial muscle can help shape public opinion. “This will show what it would be like without us,” said Francisco Vargas, the owner of Blanca’s Gift Shop in Manassas.

Let’s see if I get this straight. As a way to protest the crackdown on illegal immigrants, militant Hispanics are planning to target the very people who give them work and cater to their needs — in other words, their friends and supporters in the Anglo community. Here’s some unsolicited advice: You’re targeting the wrong people! For the most part, the middle-class citizens who have spearheaded the resolutions don’t have enough money to hire maids, landscapers and day laborers. They may own businesses, but I can assure you, they aren’t selling lottery tickets and Western Union wire transfer services.

Here’s some more unsolicited insight. Middle-class Virginians are sick and tired and they aren’t going to take it anymore. The state has hiked their taxes, local governments have hiked their taxes and, thanks to inflation, bracket creep and the Alternative Minimum Tax, the federal government has hiked their taxes. Meanwhile, they’re paying more and more and getting less and less for medical care. They have a problem with illegals who slip into the country, work for cash, don’t pay income taxes and proceed to avail themselves of free public schools and emergency room care.

If Hispanics want to call that sentiment racist, they’re totally missing the point. Indeed, crying “racism, racism” is self defeating. People know it’s a bogus charge, and it makes them angry. Just like it makes them angry that the Hispanic activists never acknowledge that maybe, just maybe, there’s a teeny-weeny bit of truth to the concern that illegals increase the tax burden on others? Just like, while they’re loudly demanding that others show understanding for their point of view, they show zero understanding for the concerns of others.

I know a lot of immigrants, some legal and some illegal. I like them as individuals, and I help them when I can. I’m sympathetic to their desire to better their lives and become American citizens. But there is nothing, I mean nothing, that infuriates me more than when a group of people come into this country — a country that welcomes those who come here legally — prosper here, and then turn around and embrace the cult of victimhood, hurling accusations of racism and bigotry at those with whom they disagree. It makes my blood boil.

Fortunately, I am quite certain that the activist Hispanic groups don’t represent the sentiments of all Hispanics. Many of the Hispanics that I know believe that everyone, including other Hispanics, need to play by the rules. I recall with some amusement talking to a Mexican bus driver in Jackson Hole this summer who confided that the country has “too many Mexicans.” I wonder if the activist groups would call him racist, too.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

6 responses to “Hispanic Activists Take Aim, Shoot Foot”

  1. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Well, if that’s the case, we could just make it legal for them to pay taxes. Or, we could tax overseas wire transfers.

  2. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    A country that welcomes them? Where have you been? I submitted an visa application once, for a temporary worker. It was three years before I got a letter from immigration nforming me that they need two original copies. (Not stated in the original instructions.)

    You call that welcoming?

    They should fire every person in immigration and replace them with immigrants willing to work.

    RH

  3. Jim Bacon Avatar
    Jim Bacon

    RH (are you Ray Hyde?), I’m not defending the sclerotic immigration bureaucracy; there is no justification for its incompetence. I’m just saying that Americans as a whole welcome legal immigrants of all ethnic persuasions warmly.

  4. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Yep, its me.

    Agreed. Like anything else we have the low grade mumblings about wetbacks swimming back to Mexico, and a few people who just cant tolerate anything different, but as a rule, I think you are right.

    As for immigration, they are doing their job as defined. Unfortunately, that consists more of finding ways to make them illegal, than to let them be legal.

    If I order you to jump over the moon, and you don’t do it, then whose fault is that?

    RH

  5. NoVA Scout Avatar
    NoVA Scout

    Is Ray Hyde the most consistently intelligent and insightful guy in the Virginia blogosphere, or is it just my imagination?

  6. Groveton Avatar

    I would like to see one piece of well reasoned analysis that proves (or even “sort of demonstrates”) that illegal aliens in Northern Virginia take more from the local economy than they contribute.

    On the positive side you have to add up the profits that companies who hire illegal aliens make and pay taxes on, you have to add the sales tax on everything that illegal aliens buy in Virginia, if you’re very clever you have to associate a certain level of economic growth that would not be possible without illegals in an area with extremely low unemployment etc, etc.

    On the negative side you have to subtract the education costs of the children, the medical costs of uninsured workers, etc, etc.

    Has any of our hard working elected officials actually tried to compute this yet?

    I believe we need immigration laws that make sense and can be enforced. Fine – Congress gets the bash from me on that count. We should be rethinking all incumbents there.

    However, the localities get the bash from me for allowing what sounds to me like racially based commentary to emotionalize the issue of illegal aliens who are already in Northern Virginia because the government never really enforced the immigration laws we already have.

    I heaqr people say that the illegal aliens cause a stupendous amount of crime but the statistics never seem to be verified.

    I hear people say that we’re all paying much higher taxes because of illegals but the statistics never seem to be verified.

    We have two problems:

    1. What to do with our obviously flawed immigration laws and policies and …

    2. What to do with all the illegal aliens in our communities now.

    Much of the rhetoric artound the second question has a distinctly racial (note – I did not say racist) tone.

    I am open minded as to approaches.

    However, I’d like to see some facts before we let this emotionalized debate go ballastic.

Leave a Reply