Hidden, Spaced Out, Higher Taxes Coming

The green areas are regional transportation districts where additional fuel taxes are already being collected, 7.6 cents per gallon on gasoline and 7.7 cents per gallon on diesel. Effective July 1 those regional fuel taxes will be imposed in all the other Virginia localities. In combination with the 5 cent per gallon increase in the statewide gasoline tax, the total tax on fuel goes to 28.8 cents on gasoline and 27.9 cents on diesel.

By Steve Haner

First published this morning by the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy.

The 2020 General Assembly, with its new progressive Democratic majority, passed a host of changes in Virginia tax laws that will begin to hit individuals and businesses in a few weeks on July 1.  Because of the COVID-19 economic shutdown, a few amendments were made to the implementation schedule during the reconvened session on April 22, but no tax increase was repealed.

This is a follow up on an earlier report on the sixteen tax bills that passed the regular session. Most are taxes will be buried almost invisibly in various transactions, and their phased imposition will also keep many taxpayers from noticing them.

July 1, 2020

The statewide tax on gasoline increases from 16.2 cents per gallon to 21.2 cents per gallon (a 31% increase) and is no longer tied going forward to the rise or fall of wholesale cost. 

The 7.6 cents per gallon added regional tax on gasoline, now imposed in Northern Virginia, Hampton Roads and along the I-81 corridor (see map), becomes a statewide tax. The total gasoline tax, statewide and regional, goes to 28.8 cents per gallon everywhere.  That is a 21% increase where the regional tax already existed, and a 78% increase where it did not.

The existing 7.7 cents per gallon added diesel fuel tax in those same regions is also expanded statewide. The base statewide diesel fuel tax is already 20.2 cents per gallon and does not change on July 1.  So outside of the existing transportation regions, the total 27.9 cents per gallon combined tax represents a 38% increase.

The state tax on cigarettes rises from $3 to $6 per carton, a 100% increase.

The state tax on other tobacco products (snuff, pipe tobacco) rises from 10% to 20%, a 100% increase.

A new tax of 6.6 cents per milliliter is imposed on liquid nicotine products used for vaping.

Counties without a tax on prepared meals may impose one, unless rejected in a recent referendum. (The county must wait until six years after a failed referendum.)  The maximum allowed tax rises from 4 to 6% (a 50% increase), so some existing meals tax rates may rise.

Counties may impose a local tax on admissions to movies, concerts and other amusements.

Additional grantor’s tax on real estate transactions is imposed in the Hampton Roads Transportation District for transportation uses.

Higher taxes on public utilities may be imposed to fund operations of the State Corporation Commission (taxes which eventually are passed on to consumers.)

A tax of $1,200 is imposed on those ubiquitous “games of skill” machines. The Assembly had originally voted to ban them, but the machines were reprieved at the reconvened session and taxed to create a fund for COVID-19 expenses.

Eight localities are authorized to call referendums on increasing their sales and use taxes an additional 1% to pay for school projects. They are Henry, Charlotte, Halifax, Mecklenburg, Pittsylvania, Gloucester and Northampton counties, and the City of Danville.

October 1, 2020

The Central Virginia Transportation Authority is created. The regional fuel taxes imposed on July 1 are diverted to its control, and an additional 0.7% general sales tax (to 6%) is imposed on that date in:  Counties of New Kent, Charles City, Hanover, Henrico, Chesterfield, Powhatan and Goochland, the City of Richmond and Town of Ashland.

A peer-to-peer vehicle sharing tax, similar to the current vehicle rental tax, is imposed. Peer-to-peer sharing is like Airbnb for cars.

January 1, 2021

All localities are authorized to impose a 5-cent tax on plastic bags, by local ordinance.

Electricity generators begin to pay a carbon tax on emissions from fossil fuel plants, costs which will eventually be passed directly on to consumers. The amount of tax will be set by an auction.

All customers of the major electricity providers (Dominion Virginia Power and Appalachian Power) begin to pay a usage tax on their electric bills to fund the new Percentage of Income Payment Plan, providing subsidized electricity to certain low-income customers. The amount will be set in a State Corporation Commission proceeding.

May 1, 2021

Any county not yet collecting a transient occupancy tax may do so.

Existing transient occupancy taxes are raised in the Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia transportation regions for transportation uses, and the existing grantor’s tax for transportation is raised in Northern Virginia.

July 1, 2021

The tax on gasoline rises another five cents to 33.8 cents per gallon, another 17% increase.

The tax on diesel fuel rises another 6.8 cents to 34.7 cents per gallon, another 24% increase.

Any county without one may impose a local cigarette tax.  Existing local tax rates are grandfathered, and new taxes limited to $2 per carton.

July 1, 2022

The statewide taxes on gasoline and diesel fuel begin to rise annually based on the consumer price index.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

36 responses to “Hidden, Spaced Out, Higher Taxes Coming”

  1. matthurt92 Avatar
    matthurt92

    If folks ever tallied up that taxes that they pay across all of the local, state, and federal taxing schemes, they would be appalled and elected officials would be run out of office on a rail. We get taxed when we make money, taxed when we save money, and taxed when we spend money. This is not a transparent means by which government “of the people, by the people” should raise money. This is one means by which government skirts accountability. I don’t doubt the need for taxation, but it should be completely transparent to all without having to read all of the fine print and track down all of the minutia.

  2. Thanks for the re-cap, Steve. Life is going to get a little bit harder for Virginians over the next couple of years but the causes won’t be visible. That’s just how the General Assembly likes it. The social “needs” identified by Virginia’s political class are infinite. Unfortunately, Virginians’ pocketbooks are not.

    1. Steve Haner Avatar
      Steve Haner

      The pressure for more — another sales tax hike, increases in income taxes — will be enormous once the depth of the state’s financial hole is known.

  3. James Wyatt Whitehead V Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead V

    The return of limited government is here. Virginia’s treasury is never going to fill up again until the economy can recover. Perhaps a return to “pay as you go”?

  4. TooManyTaxes Avatar
    TooManyTaxes

    But let’s be happy since, unlike in 2012 when Delegates Joe May (R) and Mark Keam (D) shepherded legislation that raises permit fees for overweight truck permits, the 2020 GA did not raise permit fees. But that cannot be! Democrats look out for the small guys.

    1. Steve Haner Avatar
      Steve Haner

      Hey, I don’t claim I found everything.

  5. djrippert Avatar
    djrippert

    “A tax of $1,200 is imposed on those ubiquitous “games of skill” machines. The Assembly had originally voted to ban them, but the machines were reprieved at the reconvened session and taxed to create a fund for COVID-19 expenses.”

    Even a broken clock is right twice a day. As far as ubiquitous … I’ve never seen one of these “games of skill” machines and I am more than a little familiar with any number of drinking establishments around The Old Dominion. Is there some way to figure out where these machines are located? I think BaconsRebellion needs some first hand reporting on this matter … after King Ralph allows us “little people” back into bars and restaurants to pursue our lower class vices.

    And speaking of lower class vices (and never wasting a crisis) …

    Libertarians and true liberty-loving, individual-rights-preserving, fiscally- responsible conservatives should be looking for alternative “revenue sources” (i.e. taxes) for Virginia. Turns out, I have a few ideas:

    Legalize medical and recreational marijuana now. Money for the state and jobs in Virginia. And guess what? On July 1 possession will be punishable by a $25 fine (as I recall). People are smoking pot all across Virginia … right now. Our laws haven’t stopped marijuana use and our new laws will make it a “crime” equivalent to jaywalking. Why let the money go to lawbreakers and drug cartels? Conservatives can pay ever higher income taxes or tax an activity that is happening right under their noses.

    Build the casinos – anywhere a private company wants to build a casino. Northam originally said he didn’t want to reopen by region because it woulkd pick winners and loser. But he signed legislation specifying the locations in Virginia where casinos can be built. There’s a reason that the MGM Grand in Maryland was built so close to NoVa that you can see it from Old Town Alexandria. Virginians gamble there and the taxes go to Maryland. Regularly scheduled buses leave Richmond all the time headed to that casino. Our laws aren’t preventing Virginians from gambling, only preventing Virginia from taking a fair share of taxes from that gambling.

    Legalize sports betting. Once again, Virginians place bets on sporting events all day every day (give or take pandemics). The law isn’t stopping sports betting in Virginia. Not at all. So, what’s the point? Legalize it and tax it.

    C’mon King Ralph. This could be a virtue signaling extravaganza. Declare that minorities have been the most penalized by marijuana laws and give a disproportionate percentage of dispensary licenses to minorities. Declare that rural Virginia has been neglected by the state and legislate that the growing be done in impoverished rural counties. Demand minority people get an ownership stake an any casino that gets a license.

    Take a little money away from the criminals who supply marijuana and gambling to Virginians today and a little less from the hard working citizens who have endured your chaotic term as governor.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      I agree with you on legalizing and taxing marijuana. I don’t like the idea of casinos, but, if we are going to have them, I agree with you that the state should dictate their number and location. The market will do that.

      You will be happy to know that the GA did legalize sports betting. (SB 384) And it imposed heft license fees and taxes, as well.

      As for the “games of skill”, I am like you; I am not aware of ever seeing one. I have been told that they are in many convenience stores and truck stops. I have not been in a 7-11 lately, but I do mean to check one out. The only way to understand the GA hostility to these games is their deference to the lobbyists for the casinos, who thought the “games of skill” would compete with their slot machines. They probably hope that, now the casinos’ camel’s nose is under the tent, they can change the law in the future and put their slot machines everywhere.

  6. djrippert Avatar
    djrippert

    I’ve long heard a rumor that it’s illegal in Virginia for gasoline station owners to display the amount of tax being charged on gas pumps. True or just another urban legend?

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      I was intrigued by this question, so I did a little digging. It is not illegal for gas stations to display the amount of taxes being charged. Sec. 3.2-5631 states in part: “Whenever the price of petroleum products is advertised or posted at retail, the amount of any taxes may not be shown separately in such advertising or posting unless the words “plus tax” and the numerals expressing the taxes are prominently displayed in letters and numerals of the same general design and style as, and at least one half the height and width of, the numerals representing the price as specified in this section.” If the amount of tax is not required to be shown, it is easier for the gas pumps to not show it, especially when, as in the past, the amount of state tax was based on the wholesale price.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        We’ve done a fair amount of traveling / camping the last few years – out west.. several times… and I do not recall seeing on ANY of the gas pumps, the taxes… not saying they weren’t there but if they were, it
        was not explicit as the total tax for the gas purchase.

        What you DO need to be aware of is that some western states – regular is 85 octane not 87.. and that makes a difference for some cars…and trucks so you have to buy mid-grade which is a hefty increase sometimes.

      2. djrippert Avatar
        djrippert

        OK, thanks for looking that up. Seems more intended to keep gas station owners from advertising a low pre-tax price to get people to pull into their station. Probably a good idea.

    2. DeptOfTyranny Avatar
      DeptOfTyranny

      Its been awhile, but I’ve seen stickers on pumps that break-out the cost of gasoline including the taxes. Maybe it was another state.

      1. djrippert Avatar
        djrippert

        I thought I recalled those stickers from the “good old days” in Virginia but maybe I’m just Bidening that memory.

      2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        Yes, I remember pumps in Virginia breaking the total price into cost for gas and cost for taxes. I don’t remember when that stopped.

  7. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
    Reed Fawell 3rd

    Typically, “you get what you pay for.” Virginia has deftly turned that proverb upside down.

    In Virginia, your rulers, and their cronies, get what you pay for. The great majority of the cronies can be broken into several categories – lawyers, rulers of Virginia health care systems, rulers of higher education, rulers of grievance and race hustler groups, rulers of K-12 education, and large donors and bundlers of cash given to Virginia politicians in return for favors that are paid for by everyday citizens.

  8. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    With some exceptions, these tax increases were neither hidden nor invisible nor nontransparent. They were included in legislation that was introduced and debated in the General Assembly. They were reported on in the general press. Furthermore, the increases in local taxes are authorizations for counties to exercise their option to adopt those taxes. Accordingly, there will be additional, transparent actions needed by local governing bodies to impose these taxes. In some cases, particularly the regional gas taxes and the increases in local sales taxes, the localities requested the increases or authority.

    I agree that the carbon tax, the electric usage tax, and the tobacco tax increases included in the budget bill were not enacted in the most transparent fashion and could be considered hidden.

    In the end, however, it is fair to take issue with the taxes on their merits, but calling all of them “hidden” is unfair.

    1. Steve Haner Avatar
      Steve Haner

      By hidden I mean invisible to the payer. Fuel taxes are imposed at the rack. Excise taxes on cigarettes collected by the wholesaler. Few notice the sales tax totals on receipts. Everybody most hates taxes they pay directly, like property taxes.

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        With that definition, most taxes are hidden. Most people don’t see the federal, Social Security, and state taxes that are taken out of their pay before they get the paycheck. Even property taxes are rolled into mortgage payments.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          We’ve done a fair amount of traveling / camping the last few years – out west.. several times… and I do not recall seeing on ANY of the gas pumps, the taxes… not saying they weren’t there but if they were, it
          was not explicit as the total tax for the gas purchase.

          What you DO need to be aware of is that some western states – regular is 85 octane not 87.. and that makes a difference for some cars…and trucks so you have to buy mid-grade which is a hefty increase sometimes.

        2. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          One of the ones you DO notice is in the purchase of a new car!

          OUCH!

          Most folks don’t notice taxes in the purchase unless the are anti-taxers!

          My wife is constantly reminding me when we used to eat out that I should NOT include the percentage tip on the total bill because it had meals tax added!

          If people are traveling, for sure – they do not notice. You pull in to get your gas and some fast food and whether the burger is $1.50 or 3.00 – most folks just order and pay… and really it’s don’t matter if the extra cost was tax or a higher wage for the workers…

          I think if you asked most people if they’d rather pay taxes on things they buy rather than getting a tax bill twice a year… they’d vote for the continuous taxes on stuff theybuy.

        3. DeptOfTyranny Avatar
          DeptOfTyranny

          and then there’s the the hidden cost of regulations and the administration thereof. People don’t see it, but wonder why stuff keeps getting more expensive and why they can’t get ahead.

          Must be the evil, greedy guy behind the tree

        4. TooManyTaxes Avatar
          TooManyTaxes

          An honest politician would push for complete disclosure on taxes. The tax per gallon of gas should be posted. The new green energy taxes should be itemized on consumer bills.

          And as far as regression is concerned, the Democrats are raising the price of electricity, in part, to pay for the lowest income people. But how about the impact on people who don’t make that much money but don’t get food stamps or Medicaid and have to subsidize the “poor”?

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            re: ” And as far as regression is concerned, the Democrats are raising the price of electricity, in part, to pay for the lowest income people. But how about the impact on people who don’t make that much money but don’t get food stamps or Medicaid and have to subsidize the “poor”?”

            Are you sure the GOP did not also do that? Fair and balanced? not so much, eh?

        5. idiocracy Avatar
          idiocracy

          I suppose most people don’t bother to look at their paystub, where the Federal, social security, and state taxes deducted from the pay check are listed.

      2. djrippert Avatar
        djrippert

        Sounds like a great project for the Thomas Jefferson Institute – what would the income tax rate be in Virginia if all taxes paid by individuals were eliminated except for the state income tax. Maybe before and after the last General Assembly session.

        In deference to Dick I’ll call Virginia’s taxes semi-opaque. People don’t tend to notice these semi-opaque taxes which is why politicians love them. But do the Democrats ever worry that almost all of these semi-opaque taxes are regressive?

        1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
          Dick Hall-Sizemore

          That is a good point about the regressive nature of many of these taxes. However, another point that is overlooked is that many of these taxes are paid not just by Virginians, but also by visitors or folks passing through. Gas taxes, transient occupancy taxes, and sales taxes are the primary ones that fall into this category.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            A major aspect of the economy is aggregate demand – and in that context – the govt is basically taxing transactions – each time the money changes hands.

            And if we think about it – what the govt is doing with stimulus is trying to get it to work like aggregate demand – i.e. to the pockets of people who will then spend it , not hold onto it.

            To a certain extent – it IS “regressive” but there are attempts to NOT tax (or tax lower) things like food and medicine AND tax higher – things like restaurants and hospitality, which presumably taxes those who are not so poor than they can afford to eat out, stay at motels, etc.

            I don’t know if TJ or anyone else has actually done a study more clearly understand how aggregate demand works with regressive taxation and efforts to lighten the tax burden on necessities but not discretionary purchases.

            TJ and their brethren seem to be more pointed at taxation more as an onerous evil than how to fairly allocate the costs of services that the govt provide nor the central role of aggregate demand in the economy itself.

            What we are seeing right now – is a collapse of aggregate demand that is extending out beyond just the damage to the service economy… without that aggregate demand , many other industries beyond the service sector are being impacted.

            What’s really perverse is that food that normally went to restaurants and schools is no longer in that pipeline and apparently is now “surplus” and killing the producers like farmers even as people are slamming the food banks.

            How in the world do the farmers go broke for overproduction at the same time we have millions of people who need food?

  9. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    Who can forget this: ” Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell Signs Largest Tax Hike in Virginia History into Law” ?

    😉

    Tax increases that fund specific things like COVID19 or cigarette taxes for Medicaid are WAY better than general tax increases to fund general govt.

    And local option taxes have to be the most transparent and accountable of all tax increases. You can actually vote the guy/gals out that do it and they, in turn, can fairly easily get a whiff of voter sentiments.

    And I know this is blasphemy but in some counties taxpayers actually are willing to pay higher taxes for local roads and local education. What a concept!

    1. Steve Haner Avatar
      Steve Haner

      Considering that the 2013 tax hike was based on the price of gas, which promptly fell to the basement, that headline was a lie. But yes, Larry, this nickel and dime approach is an effort to avoid that kind of headline (but still reap some big bucks…)

      As to willing or unwilling, what I wrote was basically just a straight list of what and when, with no commentary.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        yeah, but it made no difference to the anti-taxers pillorying McDonnell.

        no commentary? hmm… ” nd their phased imposition will also keep many taxpayers from noticing them.”

        that’s commentary, no?

        I think the premise put forth is that taxes have been raised “secretly” and taxpayers will feel the bite.

        In reality, a LOT of them are local-option and at least some of the others are dedicated to specific things as opposed to general taxes increases for non-dedicated spending.

        I KNOW from your POV that ANY tax increase is taking even MORE of your money… right?

        I don’t like them either especially at the local level… where they are relentless at OVER-assessing property… a 5 acre lot – raw land without water/sewer and uses NO services – no matter 100K…

  10. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
    Reed Fawell 3rd

    Rippert says:

    “There’s a reason that the MGM Grand in Maryland was built so close to NoVa that you can see it from Old Town Alexandria. Virginians gamble there and the taxes go to Maryland. Regularly scheduled buses leave Richmond all the time headed to that casino.”

    He’s correct. Plus that project on Md side of the Potomac River also creates the longest traffic back-ups on the Eastern Seaboard – gridlock that can close down the entire 495 Capital Beltway, all 64 miles of that noose round DC, plus another 50 miles south down I-95 to Richmond Virginia, plus another 45 miles Northeast up Rt 50 to Chesapeake Bay Bridge, plus another 50 miles Northwest up I-70 to Frederick Md. plus due North up I-95 Rt. 95 to Baltimore Maryland. Pilgrims been stuck for days in this gridlock. And it took a Fairfax County developer to built it, only a Fairfax County Virginia Gentlemen had the “know of and brass ones,” to build such a monstrosity that could stop even the US Marine Corps Birthday Ball dead in its tracks.

  11. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    re: ” Its been awhile, but I’ve seen stickers on pumps that break-out the cost of gasoline including the taxes. Maybe it was another state.”

    We USED to see them. I think these days it functions much like a VAT tax.

  12. John Harvie Avatar
    John Harvie

    Betcha the repeal of W-2 withholding and returning to the ritual of an annual income tax payment would garner some attention.

  13. […] highway user fee was not on the list of all the new taxes approved by the 2020 General Assembly.  It is now […]

  14. […] bag tax is one of the smaller of the myriad tax increases approved by General Assembly Democrats with their new majority, and you may recall it only barely […]

Leave a Reply