Hark! A COVID Miracle!

by Kerry Dougherty

I tend to be cynical, but still I dismissed the folks who predicted that once Joe Biden was elected, the lockdowns and shutdowns that had crushed the American economy would start to fall away.

“Just wait till after the election,” they warned.

You’re insane, I thought. I believed — still do — that the Biden administration would pressure governors to close it all down, then, as the vaccine was widely distributed and warmer weather arrived, the new president could claim victory over the pandemic.

Maybe I was wrong. Look at what’s happened in just the past week even as COVID infections grow in many places, including Virginia.

Gov. Ralph Northam, the man who once outlawed sitting on the beach or playing loud music in the sand as bizarre COVID-curbing measures, and the first governor in the country to shutter schools for the entire 2020 school year, now says it’s imperative schools reopen because our kids are turning into dunces.

“Children are hurting right now; families are hurting; we hear it every day,” he said. “Test results are going down. …. We all need to collectively get our children back into school and that’s where they need to be for a lot of different reasons.”

You don’t say, Governor. Who could have predicted such a thing?

Kids have fallen so far behind, Northam said yesterday, that they may have to go to year-round calendar to let them catch up.

Great. That’ll do wonders for tourism in Virginia Beach.

Northam is not operating on new information. Last June 5th The Wall Street Journal pronounced virtual learning a disaster. And there was ample information available even then that kids were neither getting sick from COVID nor were they spreading it.

But the lockdown lobby relentlessly trotted out the specter of school children bringing home the virus to their parents and grandparents or giving it to their teachers. In the process, they managed to brainwash a sizable chunk of the population into some kind of voodoo view of COVID that was not based in science.

“Our schools are safe,” Northam declared yesterday afternoon. “The emphasis will change; instead of ‘schools should be closed,’ we’re going to approach it from the starting point of ‘schools need to be opened and here are the ways to do it safely,” said Northam.

Good luck undoing all the damage you did, Governor, with your hasty shutdowns. Now you have a political problem because you’ll have to battle with your biggest supporters: Virginia’s teachers. Their unions and associations have been drinking the COVID Kool-Aid for months. Good luck getting them to hustle back into the classrooms just because you pronounced them safe.

Remember, lose the teachers’ unions, lose elections.

Over in Chicago, Mayor Lori Lightfoot who shut down her city, including hair stylists while sneaking out for a haircut herself, discovered this week that restaurants tend to go out of business when they’re closed. Oh, and that outdoor dining is a tad impractical in the Windy City in January.

On top of that, CDC contract tracing shows few infections originate in restaurants, according to CBS.

Mayor Lori Lightfoot on Thurs

day said Chicago restaurants and bars need to be allowed to reopen “as quickly as possible” not just to help those businesses survive, but also to cut down on instances of private parties where people don’t take proper precautions against COVID-19.

Under the state’s virus mitigation plan, Chicago’s restaurants and bars were forced to halt indoor service in late October.

But the mayor said the ban on indoor dining and bar service has resulted in people engaging in risky behavior in private, holding underground parties at hotels, businesses, and elsewhere, without wearing masks or keeping a safe distance from other people to limit the spread of the virus.

She said reopening bars and restaurants would give people somewhere to go unwind where business owners can enforce the proper precautions.

Sigh.

Even Andrew Cuomo, responsible for the deaths of thousands of New York nursing home residents with his moronic executive order that forced long-term care facilities to accept Covid-positive patients, is now calling for New York to reopen.

As part of his annual State of the State address, Cuomo raised eyebrows on Monday for denouncing the economic restrictions that his own administration put into place in response to the coronavirus outbreak, reported Fox News.

“We simply cannot stay closed until the vaccine hits critical mass,” Cuomo said. “The cost is too high. We will have nothing left to open. We must reopen the economy, but we must do it smartly and safely.”

Shoot, it looks like the media, which rarely questioned the effectiveness of the draconian measures taken by government officials, is now reporting on studies that show lockdowns were worthless. Usually these reports go unreported.

In a piece headlined, “Covid Lockdowns Have No Clear Benefit Versus Other Voluntary Measures International Study Shows,” Newsweek reported yesterday that Stanford University researchers compared outcomes around the world and found that lockdowns made no difference in the spread of the virus.

Geez, just days before Biden takes office, some government officials and even the press are beginning to admit that shutdowns don’t work.

Coincidence? We report, you decide.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

68 responses to “Hark! A COVID Miracle!”

  1. Steve Haner Avatar
    Steve Haner

    As with the Old Testament and New, there are unseen source documents behind the text. In this case, before the election the Biden campaign was setting the tone and now the incoming Biden administration wants to avoid any economic dip in the early part of the term. If NY and CA suddenly open up, that alone will boost GDP. All the D Governors are getting their directives from some central source. Would be fun to read that memo….Hey, I’ve mentioned polling I was seeing about the level of fear, especially among voters who might otherwise go for DJT. All he had to do to win their votes was to wear the mask, avoid the super spreader events, etc. But NOOOOOOO, he’s smarter than the rest of us….

    Northam resisted that movement and our state’s economy didn’t crash like NY or CA or the others. Now he’s sitting on a wad of cash that previous governors in good times might envy, just got $900 million to play with from Stimulus Boodle Bill #4, and Biden is going to see and raise that in the first few weeks.

    1. idiocracy Avatar

      “Northam resisted that movement and our state’s economy didn’t crash like NY or CA or the others. ”

      It probably helps that our state’s economy is largely dependent upon Federal, not customer, spending.

      1. Matt Adams Avatar
        Matt Adams

        That and most federal agencies already worked from home at least 1 day a week. What’s the other 4 in a hill of beans.

        1. idiocracy Avatar

          It’s amazing how much better the rush hour is on Friday (which apparently the work-at-home day for most of the Fed workers).

          I personally think the best work-at-home day is Wednesday. Since that tends to be the day with the worst rush-hour traffic.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar

            Working on a citizens group that is looking at longer term transportation planning – roads and rail – and part of the initial process is to try to understand what kinds of changes made for the pandemic might continue and become standard practice.

            VRE is commuter rail – and they are also interested in what might happen because that then affects what kinds of future infrastructure and services would be feasible.

            The folks that run the toll roads on I-95, I-66, etc are also “concerned” because congestion levels are tied to their investment returns.

          2. Steve Haner Avatar
            Steve Haner

            Ooo. Some irony there…..

          3. Matt Adams Avatar
            Matt Adams

            I can assure you the rush hour on 95 hasn’t gotten any better, I presume 66 has opened up immensely though.

            I found that rush hour was more tolerable prior to the tolling of I-66 IBW. I don’t even you though, that stretch between 29 and 234 on 66 was always awful.

          4. Nancy_Naive Avatar
            Nancy_Naive

            Best green fees, which explains traffic while work-from-home too.

          5. LarrytheG Avatar

            Longer term, as NoVa grows, it will eventually grow back to prior levels and then some and the toll roads will again pick up business.

            My understanding is that 395 will soon be added if not already and that Maryland is also looking into some segments.

            As an area like NoVa grows – less and less undeveloped and/or cheap right-of-way is available – on a network basis.

            In other words, some places that are chokepoints already have no hope of fugure widening unless developed properties are taken.

            Even then , it won’t “fix” congestion levels for the most point and that is why VDOT decided to uses tolling – not so much to generate revenues but to manage congestion levels and keep the roads open even at peak hour. They essentially made a deal with the toll road companies to build out the last lanes for that purpose and that involved replacing many overpasses, bridges and interchanges.. to get the extra lanes.

            What VDOT is doing in NoVa is what a lot of other state DOTs are doing in their states Metro areas with peak hour congestion.

            In the end , few other options were really viable – fiscally or physically.

          6. Matt Adams Avatar
            Matt Adams

            Larry,
            395 already has an express (toll). However if you need to Exit towards the Ballston while traveling into the city, you’re out of luck it only goes towards the Pentagon.

  2. Steve Haner Avatar
    Steve Haner

    As with the Old Testament and New, there are unseen source documents behind the text. In this case, before the election the Biden campaign was setting the tone and now the incoming Biden administration wants to avoid any economic dip in the early part of the term. If NY and CA suddenly open up, that alone will boost GDP. All the D Governors are getting their directives from some central source. Would be fun to read that memo….Hey, I’ve mentioned polling I was seeing about the level of fear, especially among voters who might otherwise go for DJT. All he had to do to win their votes was to wear the mask, avoid the super spreader events, etc. But NOOOOOOO, he’s smarter than the rest of us….

    Northam resisted that movement and our state’s economy didn’t crash like NY or CA or the others. Now he’s sitting on a wad of cash that previous governors in good times might envy, just got $900 million to play with from Stimulus Boodle Bill #4, and Biden is going to see and raise that in the first few weeks.

    1. idiocracy Avatar

      “Northam resisted that movement and our state’s economy didn’t crash like NY or CA or the others. ”

      It probably helps that our state’s economy is largely dependent upon Federal, not customer, spending.

      1. Matt Adams Avatar
        Matt Adams

        That and most federal agencies already worked from home at least 1 day a week. What’s the other 4 in a hill of beans.

  3. I share Kerry’s cynicism, but I can’t believe that politicians and the media made conscious decisions to wreck their own economies in order to make Trump look bad. They also made themselves look like idiots. And as much as many politicians detest Trump, they love themselves more.

    I think it’s possible that some politicians have actually learned from experience. They followed the herd in rolling out their restrictive policies with minimal pushback from the media. Then reality set it. To be sure, it took months and months, but eventually the evidence became overwhelming, and they are responding. Thank goodness.

    When the history of COVID in Virginia is written, Northam will be faulted for two big things: Maintaining the restriction on elective medical procedures long after it was clear it was not needed, and failing to show leadership in keeping public schools open. His minions in the Department of Education were far more focused on imposing new social-justice standards on Virginia’s schools. His critics (including myself) now need to be generous and give him credit for seeing the error of his ways and changing direction.

    Now the jury is out on how well he is handling the distribution of the vaccines. Not looking good so far.

  4. I share Kerry’s cynicism, but I can’t believe that politicians and the media made conscious decisions to wreck their own economies in order to make Trump look bad. They also made themselves look like idiots. And as much as many politicians detest Trump, they love themselves more.

    I think it’s possible that some politicians have actually learned from experience. They followed the herd in rolling out their restrictive policies with minimal pushback from the media. Then reality set it. To be sure, it took months and months, but eventually the evidence became overwhelming, and they are responding. Thank goodness.

    When the history of COVID in Virginia is written, Northam will be faulted for two big things: Maintaining the restriction on elective medical procedures long after it was clear it was not needed, and failing to show leadership in keeping public schools open. His minions in the Department of Education were far more focused on imposing new social-justice standards on Virginia’s schools. His critics (including myself) now need to be generous and give him credit for seeing the error of his ways and changing direction.

    Now the jury is out on how well he is handling the distribution of the vaccines. Not looking good so far.

  5. Steve Haner Avatar
    Steve Haner

    “I can’t believe that politicians and the media made conscious decisions to wreck their own economies in order to make Trump look bad.” In, to borrow a phrase, A NEW YORK MINUTE! See, I don’t buy the stolen election crap, but this? No doubt at all. And partly because the polling indicated many voters wanted the lockdowns.

  6. Steve Haner Avatar
    Steve Haner

    “I can’t believe that politicians and the media made conscious decisions to wreck their own economies in order to make Trump look bad.” In, to borrow a phrase, A NEW YORK MINUTE! See, I don’t buy the stolen election crap, but this? No doubt at all. And partly because the polling indicated many voters wanted the lockdowns.

  7. The Lori Lightfoot restaurant anecdote in Kerry’s post is particularly illuminating. It illustrates the law of unintended consequences. Chicago shut down the restaurants but people, being human, began gathering for food and drink in hotels, homes, and other places that abided by none of the regulations. The result: The virus spread faster. Ah, the hubris of the social engineers.

    At least Lightfoot finally confronted the reality of things, thanks to findings by contact tracers that restaurants were not a significant spreader of the virus. … Which brings me to a point I have oft made on this blog. What has Virginia done to convert its contact tracing program, which seems ineffectual at slowing the spread of the disease, into a source of epidemiological intelligence that at least tells us which venues and circumstances contribute to the spread and which do not. I have seen zero evidence that Virginia has obtained actionable intelligence from this significant expenditure of resources to guide policy making. Talk about a lost opportunity….

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Contact Tracing depends a LOT on cooperation from the public – the same public that some of won’t wear masks or socially distant and consider government the enemy…

      Be honest. No matter how much resources put into contact tracing, if the guy on the other end says F you and hangs up.. you’re dead in the water.

      1. djrippert Avatar

        Everybody I see in restaurants, supermarkets, etc are wearing masks. Everybody. No exceptions. Your argument about significant numbers of people refusing to wear masks seems to be wrong or, at least, vastly overstated.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          It is NOW. It was not before and you know it DJ. And even now, there are folks who refuse to and cause trouble. It’s a lot of the same folks who said restaurants and schools shouldn’t close AND we did not need masks or social distancing.

  8. The Lori Lightfoot restaurant anecdote in Kerry’s post is particularly illuminating. It illustrates the law of unintended consequences. Chicago shut down the restaurants but people, being human, began gathering for food and drink in hotels, homes, and other places that abided by none of the regulations. The result: The virus spread faster. Ah, the hubris of the social engineers.

    At least Lightfoot finally confronted the reality of things, thanks to findings by contact tracers that restaurants were not a significant spreader of the virus. … Which brings me to a point I have oft made on this blog. What has Virginia done to convert its contact tracing program, which seems ineffectual at slowing the spread of the disease, into a source of epidemiological intelligence that at least tells us which venues and circumstances contribute to the spread and which do not. I have seen zero evidence that Virginia has obtained actionable intelligence from this significant expenditure of resources to guide policy making. Talk about a lost opportunity….

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Contact Tracing depends a LOT on cooperation from the public – the same public that some of won’t wear masks or socially distant and consider government the enemy…

      Be honest. No matter how much resources put into contact tracing, if the guy on the other end says F you and hangs up.. you’re dead in the water.

      1. djrippert Avatar

        Everybody I see in restaurants, supermarkets, etc are wearing masks. Everybody. No exceptions. Your argument about significant numbers of people refusing to wear masks seems to be wrong or, at least, vastly overstated.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          It is NOW. It was not before and you know it DJ. And even now, there are folks who refuse to and cause trouble. It’s a lot of the same folks who said restaurants and schools shouldn’t close AND we did not need masks or social distancing.

  9. LarrytheG Avatar

    Might need to check the polls on some of this. There clearly is a general conservative viewpoint but is it really how most folks feel?

    Many folks are relieved that we can now try to put things back together and they are not expecting it all to be fixed , much less right away.

    We had a pandemic. It pushed government and institutions to the point of not dealing with it a successfully as they would have liked.

    Northam is one governor. He’s not that different than many other Governors when it comes to the pandemic – Democratic or GOP – except in the eyes of more than a few conservatives who tend to be half-glass-empty types anyhow especially when the Dems are in control.

    We’re going to have more disasters – and we can count on certain folks to tell us about them!

    1. djrippert Avatar

      Northam screwed up the testing, screwed up the contact tracing, screwed up the COVID app and is now screwing up the vaccine rollout. Other than that … a job well done.

  10. LarrytheG Avatar

    Might need to check the polls on some of this. There clearly is a general conservative viewpoint but is it really how most folks feel?

    Many folks are relieved that we can now try to put things back together and they are not expecting it all to be fixed , much less right away.

    We had a pandemic. It pushed government and institutions to the point of not dealing with it a successfully as they would have liked.

    Northam is one governor. He’s not that different than many other Governors when it comes to the pandemic – Democratic or GOP – except in the eyes of more than a few conservatives who tend to be half-glass-empty types anyhow especially when the Dems are in control.

    We’re going to have more disasters – and we can count on certain folks to tell us about them!

    1. djrippert Avatar

      Northam screwed up the testing, screwed up the contact tracing, screwed up the COVID app and is now screwing up the vaccine rollout. Other than that … a job well done.

  11. Nancy_Naive Avatar
    Nancy_Naive

    Damn! I’m feeling downright optimistic Having just been outflanked on the cynic front, I’m not sure I like this feeling.

    1. You could always take measures to become more cynical…

  12. Nancy_Naive Avatar
    Nancy_Naive

    Damn! I’m feeling downright optimistic Having just been outflanked on the cynic front, I’m not sure I like this feeling.

    1. You could always take measures to become more cynical…

  13. James Wyatt Whitehead V Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead V

    363 days left until the end of the reign of His Excellency, Ralph Northam.

  14. James Wyatt Whitehead V Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead V

    363 days left until the end of the reign of His Excellency, Ralph Northam.

  15. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I just want to point that, contrary to Kerry’s assertion, the Governor of Virginia does not the authority to shut down all the schools. Local school boards have the authority to open and close schools.

    1. Dick, you are correct to say that Northam does not have the authority to open and close schools. Local school boards make those decisions. It’s more an issue of leadership. Northam has the bully pulpit. He could have made the case for keeping schools open. He could have mobilized state resources and federal CARES funding to address local concerns. But he did not, and his leadership team in the Department of Education did not.

      1. SuburbanWoman Avatar
        SuburbanWoman

        Taxpayers need to push to see detailed statements regarding the use of CARES money.

      2. LarrytheG Avatar

        If Northam had that power, Kerry and Bacon and others would have been on him about one-size fits all.

        Instead, he did allow the individual districts to make that decision.

        So now.. he’s condemned because he didn’t use his “bully-pulpit”?

        come on… ya’ll are going to be on him no matter what he does.

    2. djrippert Avatar

      Really? He certainly thought he had the authority to close all the public schools last March.

      https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2020-03-23/virginia-gov-ralph-northam-closes-schools-for-the-year-amid-coronavirus

      1. idiocracy Avatar

        Governor Almond closed schools as part of “Massive Resistance”. It wasn’t legal, but the legality of an action has never been much of a consideration for some politicians.

      2. Errr…. good point, Don.

  16. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I just want to point that, contrary to Kerry’s assertion, the Governor of Virginia does not the authority to shut down all the schools. Local school boards have the authority to open and close schools.

    1. Dick, you are correct to say that Northam does not have the authority to open and close schools. Local school boards make those decisions. It’s more an issue of leadership. Northam has the bully pulpit. He could have made the case for keeping schools open. He could have mobilized state resources and federal CARES funding to address local concerns. But he did not, and his leadership team in the Department of Education did not.

      1. SuburbanWoman Avatar
        SuburbanWoman

        Taxpayers need to push to see detailed statements regarding the use of CARES money.

    2. djrippert Avatar

      Really? He certainly thought he had the authority to close all the public schools last March.

      https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2020-03-23/virginia-gov-ralph-northam-closes-schools-for-the-year-amid-coronavirus

      1. idiocracy Avatar

        Governor Almond closed schools as part of “Massive Resistance”. It wasn’t legal, but the legality of an action has never been much of a consideration for some politicians.

      2. Errr…. good point, Don.

  17. djrippert Avatar

    Virginia is experiencing, by far, the highest numbers of COVID cases and the highest number of daily COVID deaths right now. Right now. But Biden won and Ralph Northam has decided that the draconian measures he insisted upon in the past (when the disease was less severe) can now be ended. What an asshat. He doesn’t care whether Virginians live or die so long as Democrats look good and Republicans look bad.

  18. djrippert Avatar

    Virginia is experiencing, by far, the highest numbers of COVID cases and the highest number of daily COVID deaths right now. Right now. But Biden won and Ralph Northam has decided that the draconian measures he insisted upon in the past (when the disease was less severe) can now be ended. What an asshat. He doesn’t care whether Virginians live or die so long as Democrats look good and Republicans look bad.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      Oops! I stand corrected.

      1. You said “the Governor of Virginia does not [have] the authority to shut down all the schools”. I do not think you were wrong.

        Just because we let him close the schools does not mean he had the legal authority to do so.

        1. Nancy_Naive Avatar
          Nancy_Naive

          Room taken is room freely given.

          1. idiocracy Avatar

            It’s easier to beg for forgiveness than to ask for permission.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      Oops! I stand corrected.

      1. You said “the Governor of Virginia does not [have] the authority to shut down all the schools”. I do not think you were wrong.

        Just because we let him close the schools does not mean he had the legal authority to do so.

  19. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I do not think he has rescinded any of the most recent restrictions. As for schools, we now have much better knowledge about the effect of COVID on children and the role of young children as spreaders than we had last spring.

    1. djrippert Avatar

      We had that knowledge this fall. Europe almost entirely kept their schools open. I can excuse Northam closing the schools in March but refusing to reopen them this fall was just another example of Northam’s incompetence.

  20. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I do not think he has rescinded any of the most recent restrictions. As for schools, we now have much better knowledge about the effect of COVID on children and the role of young children as spreaders than we had last spring.

    1. djrippert Avatar

      We had that knowledge this fall. Europe almost entirely kept their schools open. I can excuse Northam closing the schools in March but refusing to reopen them this fall was just another example of Northam’s incompetence.

  21. SuburbanWoman Avatar
    SuburbanWoman

    School Boards are suddenly voting to open schools even in areas with rising Covid case numbers. The parents celebrating believe they made it happen… in all honesty did the liberal school boards suddenly have a “change of heart”??

  22. SuburbanWoman Avatar
    SuburbanWoman

    School Boards are suddenly voting to open schools even in areas with rising Covid case numbers. The parents celebrating believe they made it happen… in all honesty did the liberal school boards suddenly have a “change of heart”??

  23. DLunsford Avatar

    Definitely a miracle! I had no idea those Delmarva farmers had such power over the space-time continuum. Look for him to soon raise from the grave the the VMI Ten. Surely their names are burned into memory from his days at the Institute!

  24. DLunsford Avatar

    Definitely a miracle! I had no idea those Delmarva farmers had such power over the space-time continuum. Look for him to soon raise from the grave the the VMI Ten. Surely their names are burned into memory from his days at the Institute!

  25. LarrytheG Avatar

    Schools across the country are in various different configurations and they have evolved as more has been known about COVID.

    Some schools in the US and other countries have had covid outbreaks and teachers and others like school bus drivers have contracted Covid and died and some schools went back to virtual from in-person.

    Virginia is not that different in it’s experience that most other states.

    It’s been political, no question, but those who say that the schools could fully re-open without risk of covid – have been proven wrong,

    The CDC has issued guidelines for schools, If not mistaken, those guidelines are what the State recommends each locality use in making decisions.

  26. LarrytheG Avatar

    Schools across the country are in various different configurations and they have evolved as more has been known about COVID.

    Some schools in the US and other countries have had covid outbreaks and teachers and others like school bus drivers have contracted Covid and died and some schools went back to virtual from in-person.

    Virginia is not that different in it’s experience that most other states.

    It’s been political, no question, but those who say that the schools could fully re-open without risk of covid – have been proven wrong,

    The CDC has issued guidelines for schools, If not mistaken, those guidelines are what the State recommends each locality use in making decisions.

Leave a Reply