Even Western Virginia Has Police Shortages

A criminal justice academy in Salem

by James A. Bacon

Police departments in Virginia’s major urban centers are not the only law enforcement agencies where police officers are quitting in large numbers. Roanoke County in western Virginia saw 28 officers leave during 2020, about one fifth of the department, The Roanoke Times has reported. That was twice the number the department would experience in a normal year. The City of Roanoke has 38 vacancies, about 15% of its force.

Neighboring Montgomery County has lost 26 deputies, about 23% of its manpower over the past 12 months. That compares to only four officers departing in 2019, and two in 2018.

The Town of Christiansburg (in Montgomery County) has similar issues. “In years past we would typically receive between 50 and 100 applications when we advertised an opening,” Assistant Chief Chris Ramsey wrote in an email. “Now we are lucky to get ten or fifteen applicants for multiple openings. Only a fraction of those will meet the minimum qualifications and actually appear for applicant testing.”

The shortages mirror difficulties police departments are having nationally. A survey of nearly 200 departments nationally cited by the Roanoke Times said that resignations were up 18% over the prior year, and retirements had surged 45%. Recruitment and retention has been a chronic problem for police departments and sheriffs offices for years, but manpower issues intensified  last year amidst the George Floyd protests and the defund-the-police rhetoric.

“The perceived lack of support in conjunction with proposed policing reform initiatives such as the elimination of qualified immunity has created an atmosphere where deputies are looking to change careers by seeking employment within the private sector,” Sheriff Hank Partin and Chief Deputy Brad St. Clair told the Roanoke Times in an email.

Bacon’s bottom line: I find these numbers shocking. It would surprise no one to see spiraling police morale in the major metropolitan areas where the anti-police protests were most violent, the anti-police rhetoric the most heated, and police were most likely to held accountable by a new generation of commonwealth attorneys committed to “social justice.”

Roanoke and Montgomery County (where Blacksburg is located) are smaller urban areas where restiveness never approached that seen in Richmond, Portsmouth and Fredericksburg. Moreover, Virginians west of the Blue Ridge are generally are generally more conservative and supportive of law enforcement. Evidently, the debate over police practices in the nation’s biggest cities is having a spillover effect nationally.

Roanoke and Roanoke County are raising pay for public safety personnel and recruiting more aggressively. But it takes time to train new officers. In the meantime, localities are shifting manpower from peripheral assignments such  as animal control and schools to keep more officers in the field. Hopefully, Western Virginia will not experience the same surge in homicides we have seen in Virginia’s major urban centers.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

19 responses to “Even Western Virginia Has Police Shortages”

  1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Maybe there is something at work beside the supposed lack of public support. Maybe it has to do with the underlying cause of that lack of public support.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Indeed but it’s a classic Conservative “law & order” thing that works every time for their base and they can’t help themselves – it’s what they do!

    2. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Can’t shoot people. Where’s the fun in that?

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        well, it’s the body cams – they’re royally screwed up old school policing……..

  2. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    re: ” Evidently, the debate over police practices in the nation’s biggest cities is having a spillover effect nationally.”

    That’s the conventional Conservative rhetoric but call me a bit of a skeptic, especially for rural America.

    To be fair, it’s a demanding job with low pay in a lot of rural places but jobs are scarce also so one wonders where the departing deputies are going for other work.

  3. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Don’t worry. Those rural jobs will get filled by those quitting the cities because of poor records on brutality.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      In a way, this could lead to a better outcome if folks leave that ought not be doing policing to start with and others become interested because they know reforms are ongoing. Change is opportunity… at least that’s what some Conservatives often say…….at least when they’re not blaming someone….

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        “Change is opportunity… at least that’s what some Conservatives often say……”
        When? They’re opposed to change.
        Now, I have heard them say, “There’s profit in confusion,” but that’s not the same.

    2. BS, it’s really easy for you Larry and Eric the half wit to take your shots on this issue as you know little to nothing about the actual dynamics behind staffing problems.

      It’s much more complex than your reflexive, shallow comments would suggest. That being said, Larry is right on one thing, as soon as a smaller or rural local jurisdiction trains a LEO, they’re off to join a higher paying job in places like Fairfax or the TSA. Fairfax is smart enough to realize that even it is not immune to personnel poaching and makes those that leave pay a pro-rated portion of their training expense if they don’t complete a measure of time in service, five years I think. I raised that with the PWC Chief at one time and my concerns about no similar policy in the county were summarily dismissed as his attitude was that if they didn’t want to be here then he didn’t want them, effectively ignoring the millions spent on training those officers for service in other jurisdictions.

      As to the current exodus, it has many reasons, some of which are limited to specific jurisdictions. In no particular order here are a few, threats to qualified immunity, incessant “racial” issues, influence of BLM, etal on local elected leaders, Defund/rightsizing efforts, a perceived additional level of danger on the streets, pay not requisite with risk, lack of material support (proper radios, computers, etc.), racial “equity” measures that impact promotion potential, a revolving door in many Chief’s offices, uncertainty with their role given the shallow understanding of the policing by many elected officials, etc., etc., etc. the list is a lengthy one.

      But the part of your blather that really pisses me off most is the assertion that “rural jobs will get filled by those quitting the cities because of poor records on brutality”. Nothing could be further from the truth due to several legislative changes that took effect earlier this year. Believe me, I have seen this first hand from both the “hiring”, “firing” and follow up on past employees standpoint.

      You are correct to some degree in that many of the vacancies in rural and smaller jurisdictions will be filled by those quitting the cities, not because of any record of brutality but due to the impression, largely a correct one, that the smaller and more rural jurisdictions are more community p0licing oriented, safer for the officer, less stressful and largely absent much of the bullshit in the urban departments.

      The three of you largely owe 98% of the Commonwealth’s LEOs and apology for y0ur diarrhea of the mouth on topics you know little to nothing about.

  4. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    In those areas, always worth asking if the officers are leaving for larger departments with better pay, or some state job (say at VA Tech or Radford) or corporate security. Maybe not, but worth asking. Many of the security personnel at the shipyard had been with a local department.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      I don’t know about rural but in the exurban counties up our way – as soon as the LEO gets trained, they’re off to join a higher paying job up north. It’s like we’ve become the training arm for Fairfax and region.

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Well, if departures and retirements ARE accelerating in the larger urban areas, only logical the process of recruiting from smaller departments would also accelerate.

        It shouldn’t surprise anyone that police are looking to leave if both the local elected officials and the local prosecutors are posturing for votes by not prosecuting various crimes or even blaming police. I think the backlash has already begun, though, and even liberal Democrats have figured out they’ve gone too far. Their own voters will pull them up short. “Defund the Police” is echoing far less.

        Eight shootings and nine deaths over the holiday weekend in the Greater Richmond area. Not sure but I have a good idea they are not happening in middle class, red-voting neighborhoods. The police don’t show up or are reluctant to act, who really suffers? Pretty clear. (Can a story blaming climate change be far behind…?)

        1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
          Eric the half a troll

          ‘”Defund the Police” is echoing far less.’

          Yes, only heard now in Conservative echo chambers.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            yep – What’s a Conservtive these days without wedge issues…???

  5. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    The starting salary for Town of Warrenton police officer is 32 grand. You can make 22 an hour at the new Royal Farms gas station just down the road. I don’t know where we will find a qualified and willing officer.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Always thought the pay for rural LEOs was terrible but many have a captive workforce. I presume the $22 is for the manger… not clerks…though…

      1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
        James Wyatt Whitehead

        22 an hour for being a worker bee.

    2. Actually, it is just shy of $45,000, 40% higher than your estimate. Not great pay but better.

Leave a Reply