Eating the World’s Most Delicious Philly Cheesesteak at the Reading Terminal Market


by James A. Bacon

When the Bacon family visited Philadelphia this weekend to watch the Eagles play the Baltimore Ravens, there was only one thing I wanted out of the trip. I had to chow down on an authentic Philadelphia cheesesteak sandwich. I’d tasted ersatz cheesesteak hoagies in Virginia but that was like ordering grits… in Connecticut. Or hamburgers… in Spain. (Trust me, I’ve tried the latter, and it doesn’t work.) I craved the real thing.

As it turns out, you can’t walk 20 feet in downtown Philly without bumping into a restaurant or food cart that sells the sandwiches. But I had the good fortune to purchase mine from Carmen’s Famous Italian Hoagies and Cheesesteaks. Not only is Carmen’s arguably the Maxim’s of the junk food world, it was located in the Reading Terminal Market, which is surely one of the busiest indoor food courts in the western hemisphere. Originating as a farmer’s market, the Market has evolved into something more: a popular tourist destination and fun place for native Philadelphians to hang out.

Making cheesesteaks is an assembly-line process at Carmen’s. When all you do eight hours a day is prepare hoagies and cheesesteaks, like these two guys, you get reaalllly good at it.

My half hour wait in line was worth the delayed gratification. Loaded with peppers, onions, mushrooms and Cheese Whiz — yes, Cheese Whiz is an indispensable ingredient, or so I was informed — my sandwich fully lived up to expectations. The popularity of Carmen’s and cheesesteaks generally also helped  explain why Philadelphia has the highest obesity rate of America’s largest cities.

The Philly Cheesesteak is a relic of the city’s glorious industrial past. These days, the knowledge-intensive Philadelphia region, with all of its universities and law schools, is being overrun with foodies and health nuts. Sunday morning, a half-marathon outside our downtown hotel attracted thousands of runners. The two sit-down restaurants where we ate served only organic food. And there is a major government-civic effort afoot to attack the city’s “food deserts” by inducing its ubiquitous corner markets to stock fresh fruit and vegetables.

My takeaway from Philadelphia for Virginia is this: Farmers markets are sprouting everywhere. That’s understandable: People love food and they love watching other people. Grocery shopping becomes a social event. It may be tempting to fashion a particular “vision” for these markets. Don’t. Let them evolve naturally in line with the character of the regions and neighborhoods they serve. In the Reading Terminal Market, Carmen’s coexists with Wan’s Seafood and an Amish dairy. There are sellers of herbs, purveyors of chocolates, cutters of flowers and vendors of free-range poultry. The result is culinary chaos — and a lot of fun.

The beauty of the Reading Terminal Market is that it has a roof and four walls, which provides a sense of permanence and encourages merchants to invest in counters, lighting, signage and displays that draw more patrons. Its location in a highly walkable, mixed-use downtown district also encourages loads of foot traffic. (Much of the traffic at Carmen’s was carry-out.) There are no national food chains there — all businesses are local and contribute to the regional economy. That’s a great business model for enterprising Virginia developers to emulate.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

  1. DJRippert Avatar

    “There are no national food chains there — all businesses are local and contribute to the regional economy. That’s a great business model for enterprising Virginia developers to emulate”.

    Yes, it is a shame to see Five Guys national food outlets in Virginia.

    Also, did you like the game? You know … that athletic event where Virginia-native Mike Vick ran the ball into the end zone with 1:55 left in the game to give the Eagles a one point victory?

    Dear Lord, Man – wipe that cheese whiz off your face and pay attention. Although the wrong team won, that was still one hell of a game.

  2. Yeah, it was a great game. A nail-biter until the end.

    My 14-year-old son is a huge Eagles/Michael Vick fan. The trip was his birthday present. He was a very happy camper.

  3. You did a good thing for your son. Except for the Cheeze Whiz part.

    🙂

    1. DJRippert Avatar

      Cheese whiz is fine, it’s being an Eagles fan that is frightening.

      As an aside, I really wanted Michael Vick to come to the Redskins. Way back in 2008.

      http://grovetonsvirginia.wordpress.com/2008/11/30/vicks-2009-season/

  4. Peter Galuszka Avatar
    Peter Galuszka

    Happy birthday, to Jamie. Good for all of you!

  5. […] from Carmen’s Famous Italian Hoagies and Cheesesteaks. Not only is Carmen’s arguably the Maxim’s of the junk food world, it was located in the Reading Terminal Market, which is surely one of the busiest indoor food […]

  6. My son and wife, and my daughter all live in the Rittenhouse Square area. I suggested several years ago that people here should look at the Reading Market as a model for the 17th Street Market when it was in first decline. But Jim said something that made me realize why it might not work. “Let them evolve naturally in line with the character of the regions and neighborhoods they serve.” The Reading Market is also a place where regular working folk of PHL do their weekly shopping. And they can pick up a gift for about any occasion. The nice thing about the 17th Street Market location is that its an easy drive. My kids have to drive to it from Rittenhouse Square if they buy any more than a couple of bags of groceries. And traffic in PHL is a nightmare. But, hey, it’s part of the adventure and being part of something very “Philly”. But Richmond is easy. Parking can be a hassle, but we don’t have the population to be that busy. Anyway, many would walk or bike there. Regardless, I always envisioned a market similar to the Reading Market at the 17th Street Market location, but then coming back around to Jim’s statement of something evolving naturally is really the only way it could be successful. Otherwise it’s like trying to force a square peg in a round hole. If it was there, would Bill’s Barbecue have a home? That could be be our Carmen’s.

    1. And now we don’t even have Bill’s Barbecue anymore!

      1. DJRippert Avatar

        There used to be some BBQ place off I-95 near Richmond. Like within a mile of the exit. Big place. Built out in sections over the years. Cafeteria style. It was pretty good.

  7. mohammed Avatar
    mohammed

    Bacon, the RTM is a wasteland when it comes to cheesesteaks. You are out of your depth pronouncing “the worlds most delicious”. Well informed grub seekers bypass steak sandwiches for roast pork when making a culinary pilgrimage to RTM.

    There is not a legit steak shop in the market. There is no shame in you not knowing but please don’t misinform others by speaking out of school.

    1. Sorry, Mohammed, I thought I was engaging in a little harmless hyperbole. Having sampled only one Philly cheese steak sandwich while in Philadelphia — the one that I praised as the world’s most delicious — I will readily concede that I am no expert on the subject!

Leave a Reply