Dominion Proposes to Bury Problem-Plagued Electric Lines

Downed power line in Arlington. Photo credit: ARLnow.
Downed power line in Arlington. Photo credit: ARLnow.

Dominion is pushing a bill that would allow the electric utility to raise rates to pay for moving interruption-plagued power lines underground. The plan calls for burying 350 miles of line per year until 4,000 miles have been relocated, reports the Washington Post. The task would cost about $175 million per year, to be recompensed by charging residential customers from $.70 monthly extra on average to $4 monthly over the duration of the project.

Nearly a third of Dominion’s 58,000 miles of distribution lines (local lines carrying power to individual houses) is underground today. Putting the entire electric grid underground would be cost prohibitive the power company maintains. But putting the “worst offenders” — 20% of power lines underground — would cut the time it takes for all power to be restored by as much as 50%.

Bacon’s bottom line: We’re talking about an investment of roughly $1.75 billion. Presumably, there would be an economic payback to Dominion through reduced maintenance costs (tree trimming and the like) and reduced work restoring downed lines. Presumably, those lower costs eventually would be rebated to consumers. Dominion doesn’t provide estimates for those benefits; it would be interesting to see them.

In addition, the selective burial of troublesome power lines would spare residential customers a lot of grief. I don’t know how much economic value you place on quicker restoration of electric power but, as a fairly frequent victim of outages, $4 a month sounds like cheap insurance. However, I’d still like to see the numbers. How many house-days of electric service loss will prevented? What economic value can we assign to that prevention?

My gut tells me that this is a great idea but Dominion can make a stronger case than it has so far.

— JAB


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

10 responses to “Dominion Proposes to Bury Problem-Plagued Electric Lines”

  1. I’m not sure the numbers add up. Consider:

    * 58,000 miles of distribution lines
    * One third are underground already, leaving about 40,000 miles above ground
    * Dominion wants to put the worst 20% underground — that would be 8,000 miles
    * But Dominion also says it plans to put only 4,000 miles underground.

    What gives?

  2. NewVirginia Avatar
    NewVirginia

    It would also look nice. I don’t know how many of these lines are in prominent civic areas, historic neighborhoods, or commercial corridors (probably not many), but burying power lines is often the first thing on the bill when cities start streetscape beautification projects. And it’s not cheap.

    Maybe Dominion could ask around and see if it could go halfsies with localities if any of these lines are on their burial wish lists.

    1. Good idea. Dominion could partner with localities… or homeowners associations. As the newly elected president of the Countryside Homeowners Association (no one else wanted the job — I objected less strenuously than the others, so I got it) I would consider contributing association funds to get our electric lines buried.

    2. LifeOnTheFallLine Avatar
      LifeOnTheFallLine

      Yes, this please. I would much rather Richmond spend some money to help Dominion bury power lines than on stadia and training facilities for professional sports teams.

  3. 70 cents monthly? is that right?

    is that just for the ones that live where lines would be buried or Virginia customers?

    we live about a 1/4 mile from a Rappahannock Electric power line corridor..

    they spend a bunch of money keeping that corridor open and two years ago, they replaced the wood poles with even higher metal pole.. but every two years or so they send crews down that right-of-way to cut trees…

    My thought is that this kind of corridor is not the kind they would bury… but instead the lines that are near or in residential areas where people would be up in arms if they took down trees to keep the power lines open.

    This summer Verizon showed up to put in buried cable for their FIOS service and they used a machine that used water to “tunnel” . The cable itself was about 3-5 inches in diameter (big!).They did a mile of this in about a week and did not cut a single existing cable for electric, phone and cable and did not ditch any roads. I was impressed!

  4. Dominion won’t save any money by reducing tree-trimming costs since it rarely trims trees – at least in Fairfax County.

    1. DJRippert Avatar

      They finally came through my neighborhood and cut back all of the trees. For the first time our electricity stays on through thunderstorms and snow showers. Maybe Dominion could improve reliability by just trimming the trees.

      1. Apparently, a lot of people go bonkers when Dominion cuts their trees.

  5. DJRippert Avatar

    Build bike trails while you are digging up the street to bury power lines.

  6. Breckinridge Avatar
    Breckinridge

    They won’t be building bike trails but they will be using the same conduit for cable and other connections, if those companies want to piggyback.

    I wouldn’t wait around for any rebates from Dominion however. Please.

    They have two choices — charge all their residential customers for this or charge just those getting the benefit, neighborhood by neighborhood. Many residential customers already live in subdivisions with underground lines but they are being asked to pay as well because 1) it keeps the per household cost down and 2) in theory they also benefit from faster restoration of an outage.

    This is the first time one of these “rate adjustment clauses” has been used to pay for a transmission project. They were created to pay for power plants. The next time we see a RAC to pay for transmission, it will be a whopper and will be to pay for the connection to an off shore wind field. Some readers will love that, but as I said, it will be mucho dinero.

Leave a Reply