Dominion Energy Scholarships Define “Communities” by Race

By Carol J. Bova

Dominion Energy is offering 60 undergraduate Equitable Education Scholarships totaling $500,000 for “students from historically underrepresented communities.”

The rules exclude White students (unless they identify as Hispanic), no matter what “community” they’re from, because to be eligible, applicants must:

— Self-identify as Black or African American; Hispanic or Latino; American Indian or Alaska Native; Asian; or Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander with higher education expenses;

— Be high school seniors or graduates or current college undergraduates residing in Connecticut, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Idaho, Wyoming, or Utah, with plans to enroll full-time at an accredited two- or four-year college, university or vocational-technical school for the entire upcoming academic year.

The press release quotes Robert M. Blue, Dominion Energy’s president and chief executive officer, who said: “We have already seen a tremendous return on investment supporting students obtaining higher education. Dominion Energy remains committed to investing in students’ access to higher education, strengthening our communities and future generations, and building a sustainable workforce.”

Scholarship America, a nonprofit specializing in managing scholarship and tuition assistance programs, says it “will support Dominion Energy in the selection of finalists.” Scholarship America says:

We have the power to build equity, diversity and inclusion into the fabric of our organization, and to help everyone feel like they belong. We can design meaningful solutions to address systemic inequities for students, with work that elevates and more purposefully advances social, economic and racial equity.

How equitable? Let’s look at the demographic breakdown of young adults 18 to 24 in the U.S. according to kidscount.org and the percentage within those groups who enroll in college according to the National Center for Educational Statistics.

Native News Online corroborates the dramatic drop in enrollment of American Indian and Alaskan Natives and points to the pandemic and recession as reasons.

Dominion Energy doesn’t explain why it considers it equitable to refuse potential scholarship help to needy White students whose communities have been historically under-represented in colleges and universities.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

63 responses to “Dominion Energy Scholarships Define “Communities” by Race”

  1. Bummer if you live in Appalachia and your dad is an out of work coal miner….. maybe they can learn coding from Phoenix?

    1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      Learn coding or take pot shots at Dominion substations. What a crooked company!

      1. how_it_works Avatar
        how_it_works

        They have enough trouble keeping the power on without people taking pot shots at their substations!

  2. DJRippert Avatar

    Dominion is a mess. Basically a monopoly government entity where the executives earn millions of dollars per year.

    Fascinating that Asians are allowed to receive the scholarships despite Asian Americans being wealthier and better educated than White Americans.

    Given inept programs like this, why do people assume Dominion can pull off the offshore wind farm boondoggle to nowhere?

    1. Maybe because the average person doesn’t know the facts and just sees the press release highlights.

  3. I wonder if a bond-haired, blue-eyed, pale-skinned Asian American would qualify.

    1. Rules just say they need to self-identify.😊

      1. Ah. Good point. Reality apparently does not matter any more.

        1. James McCarthy Avatar
          James McCarthy

          Reality for persons of color and/or ethnic origin is decidedly different in the access and competition for higher education. An equitably based scholarship program addresses that difference.

          1. Exactly. That is why people should not be able to simply “self identify” as a particular ethnicity in order to qualify for inclusion in the program.

          2. James McCarthy Avatar
            James McCarthy

            Why not? That is the object of the program. If an applicant fudges race or ethnicity, it’s Dominion’s problem creating a different equitable problem. Look how far George Santos progressed.

          3. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Used to be a word… passing. It involved more than self-identifying.

          4. James McCarthy Avatar
            James McCarthy

            Why not? That is the object of the program. If an applicant fudges race or ethnicity, it’s Dominion’s problem creating a different equitable problem. Look how far George Santos progressed.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Fair enough. Used to be that minorities that could community-identify as white, did.

  4. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    The project is labeled “equitable” not equality. As in jurisprudence, equitable decisions may compromise idealized or arithmetic equality in recognition of a just result. For example, ESL is an equitable determination to assist a language disadvantage. There’s no commandment or statute barring Dominion’s equitable scholarships. Equity and equality are too often misunderstood or perceived as equivalents.

    1. Most definitely are not equivalent.

      1. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        Indeed. Thus Dominion has made a choice in its wisdom to create scholarships for some based upon race, not necessarily merit.

      2. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        Indeed. Thus Dominion has made a choice in its wisdom to create scholarships for some based upon race, not necessarily merit.

  5. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Dominion is free to do what it wants with its own money. I doubt (can’t be sure) if the SCC allows it to charge off this particular charitable activity to ratepayers, and $500K is a small part of its budget for those things (always politically strategic, BTW.)

    One note for future reference. This seems to be about $8K per recipient. In the coming argument over the proposed K-12 ESA vouchers, opponents will whine that the amounts involved are not really enough money to allow a low income family to put the kid in a private school. Only partial payment. Well, isn’t that also the case here? Few can attend a 4-year uni for $8K. I think help is help and should increase access in both cases.

    1. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      On its face, the Dominion program appears not to be solely need based. Otherwise qualified students are likely to be eligible for Pell grants making the Dominion contribution a factor in choice of institutions – public or private.

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        I think the quickest way to get one of these scholarships will be a letter of endorsement from a legislator. Yes, I think that little of the company’s current management. I wish I didn’t.

        1. James McCarthy Avatar
          James McCarthy

          Be clear, I offer no defense of Dominion’s character or reputation.

  6. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    What’s the big deal? Lots of organizations and companies have scholarship programs aimed at specific groups. The United Daughters of the Confederacy has scholarships for stundents whose ancestors fought in the Confederate Army. The Ethyl Corporation used to have a scholarship program for students in the Richmond area who planned to major in science. There are organizations who grant scholarships to Asians, and so on.

    1. So a possible scholarship excluding only one race is acceptable in your view? I see that as different than one offered to one ethnicity.

      1. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        Any scholarship offered upon a racial or ethnic basis by definition excludes others.

      2. M. Purdy Avatar

        Offering benefits to one ethnicity has a sordid history in this country.

        1. While excluding one is fine by you?

          1. M. Purdy Avatar

            No, not necessarily. I would have included all traditionally under-represented communities, including poor rural communities that tend to be largely white. But use of the term ‘under-represented minority’ pretty commonly refers to African American, Latino, Native American. (Including “Asian” is weirdly broad at best.) It’s simply not that big a deal, because those minorities are traditionally under-represented. This is adding $$ to the pot, so good for them.

          2. It doesn’t say minorities…it says communities.

          3. M. Purdy Avatar

            “As part of the company’s larger commitment to underrepresented minority students…” Second para of the press release.

          4. that was in 2021. Jan. 13, 2023 release was just posted. It does not say minorities.

          5. M. Purdy Avatar

            I think it’s reasonable to infer that they mean the same thing. They replaces that one word, but still discuss historical underrepresentation.

    2. So a possible scholarship excluding only one race is acceptable in your view? I see that as different than one offered to one ethnicity.

    3. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      Have you ever come across the story of Mattie Clyburn Rice? She is a member of the UDC. Her father, a black man, served in the 12th SC Infantry. Ms. Rice’s daughters are members as well. Grand daughters and descendants thereafter are eligible for the UDC scholarship.
      https://www.npr.org/2011/08/07/138587202/after-years-of-research-confederate-daughter-arises

      1. M. Purdy Avatar

        Looks like her father was actually a slave for someone serving in the SC infantry. He would not have been allowed to serve, in fact.

        1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
          James Wyatt Whitehead

          Muster rolls and all. Collected a pension from the state of South Carolina. The world is flat.

      2. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        While the Dominion application procedure is not well detailed, it is interesting to review the availability and procedures for scholarships sponsored by the United Daughters of the Confederacy HQ in Richmond:

        https://hqudc.org/scholarships/

  7. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Maybe the railroad companies should follow suit and offer scholarships to Asian Americans?

  8. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    The Native News Online link then led me to this:
    https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d20/tables/dt20_306.10.asp

    Compare 1976 to 2019 and the change is stunning. But among identified Native Americans it has been quite steady, just under 1 percent of total enrollment. Black enrollment as a percentage of total is up a bit, but the Hispanic percentage has really soared over that 40+ years ago.

    1. The 2019 doesn’t break out the percentages enrolled within groups of 18-24s. In 2020, the percentage of American Indians in that age group in college dropped from 44 to 22%, even though they were still 1% of the total. Charts added above show 2010 to 2020 changes.

    2. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      Be careful. Researchers have been cautioning for years now that race/ethnic origin data is in flux, especially that involving indigenous peoples.

    3. Yes. In 1970, 27% of 18-24s were enrolled; in 2020, it was 40%. This gives you the 1970-2020 numbers by racial/ethnic group. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d21/tables/dt21_302.60.asp

  9. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    The press release link is to one dated 08/03/2021 and does not indicate an exclusion of any race or ethnicity. Rather, the purpose is stated as:
    “As part of the company’s larger commitment to underrepresented minority students, the HBCU Promise.”
    With the exception of government grants for college assistance, virtually every scholarship granting organization will – by definition – exclude someone or group. It appears that the scholarships are limited to US residents/citizens. That excludes a whole lotta folks.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      yep, saw that HBCU Promise…

    2. That was a mistake picking up the notice for 2021 instead of the press release for 2023 I received last week which did not say the same thing. Read this one:

      https://news.dominionenergy.com/2023-01-13-Dominion-Energy-Encourages-Eligible-Students-Apply-for-Educational-Equity-Scholarship

      1. James McCarthy Avatar
        James McCarthy

        Hmmnnn! The earlier PR only notes students “hail” from 7 states. This later one indicates the students must be from the 10 states listed. Methinks there is some rub to quote the bard of Avon. Nor is HBCU promise referenced.

        1. Yes, that’s exactly right. 2023 is different from the 2021 information.

          1. James McCarthy Avatar
            James McCarthy

            And different from the 2020 PR. What to believe??

  10. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Section 8A set aside. Contracts for minority- and woman-owned businesses. Pretty sure the State has the same/similar program, and wouldn’t be surprised if Dominion or other entities doing business with the State or Feds have similar programs for contracts.

    Not a big deal.

    1. how_it_works Avatar
      how_it_works

      It’s interesting how many of those SWAM businesses are owned by the wife but run by the husband…

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        That and much less easily justifiable arrangements.

        1. how_it_works Avatar
          how_it_works

          Annual ethics training for the company I work for says that the company is not to hire a subcontractor that isn’t capable of doing the work just to meet a SWAM requirement.

          Which makes me wonder how often that does happen…

          1. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            I doubt your company came up with that all on their own, but the other way ‘round is the usual arrangement. “Big company seeks §8A to act as prime. Object matrimony.”

          2. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            There’s actually a Federal regulation that SWAM companies can’t be owned by someone who has no role in the daily operation of the business.

            So if she owns an IT company and her day job is a hairdresser, that isn’t allowed.

            Probably never enforced, though.

          3. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Not what I meant. We formed a team with a +500 employee company. We were small, not 8A, but qualified for small business set asides. When the RFP was an SBSA, we were prime, otherwise we were the sub. Could have gone it alone on the SBSAs, but having a piece of big contracts made it worthwhile to have a big buddy.

            A lot of 8As and other small businesses form legitimate relationships with big companies.

          4. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Well, there’s enough that aren’t legit that the ethics training has to cover it.

  11. 1/13/23 Press release

    Dominion Energy Encourages Eligible Students to Apply for its Educational Equity Scholarship

    – Third year of a six-year, $10 million scholarship program

    – Students can apply for scholarships until Jan. 25

    RICHMOND, Va. — (Jan. 12, 2023) Dominion Energy is accepting applications for its Educational Equity Scholarship Program, a six-year, $10 million initiative that provides financial assistance for students from historically underrepresented communities pursuing undergraduate degrees across the company’s service area. Eligible students are encouraged to apply now through Jan. 25, 2023.

    “We have already seen a tremendous return on investment supporting students obtaining higher education,” said Robert M. Blue, Dominion Energy’s president and chief executive officer. “Dominion Energy remains committed to investing in students’ access to higher education, strengthening our communities and future generations, and building a sustainable workforce.”

    The scholarship application is open for students to apply through Jan. 25 at 4 p.m. EST.

    To be eligible, students must:

    Self-identify as Black or African American; Hispanic or Latino; American Indian or Alaska Native; Asian; or Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander with higher education expenses.

    Be high school seniors or graduates or current college undergraduates residing in Connecticut, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Idaho, Wyoming, or Utah, with plans to enroll full-time at an accredited two- or four-year college, university or vocational-technical school for the entire upcoming academic year. Schools in which students are enrolled are not required to be located in the Dominion Energy service area.

    Have a minimum grade point average of 3.0 on a 4.0 scale (or its equivalent).

    Of the 60 scholarships totaling $500,000, 20 scholarships of $5,000 each will be made available for students enrolled in two-year schools. Students enrolled in four-year schools will receive $10,000 each. Recipients can renew scholarships as they progress in school, provided they meet specific criteria, such as GPA requirements and residence in an eligible state.

    The program is administered by Scholarship America, a nonprofit specializing in managing scholarship and tuition assistance programs. Scholarship America will support Dominion Energy in the selection of finalists.

    Students can learn more and apply at DominionEnergy.com/EquityScholarships.

  12. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    Perhaps the 09/17/2020 PR from Dominion clarifies the citations from two later releases:

    In 2020, Dominion Energy committed $25 million to be shared by 11 historically black colleges and universities in Virginia, Ohio, North Carolina and South Carolina. The six-year program will support endowments, capital projects, operating expenses and educational programs in clean energy.

    As part of our promise, we have created an additional $10 million scholarship fund for African American and underrepresented minority students across our service area.

    1. Clarifications follow statements; they don’t precede them. If the previous statement applied, it would be referenced in the current document. As it was pointed out, other requirements, such as state of residence, are different in 2023 than in 2020.

  13. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Do we also take umbrage with Wells Fargo and many of the other scholarship sponsors who discriminate against those who do not have disabilities…?

    https://newsroom.wf.com/English/news-releases/news-release-details/2019/Wells-Fargo-Scholarship-America-Launch-2020-21-Disability-Scholarship-Program/default.aspx

    1. Not the same as using race to define “communities” and exclude one race only. If they excluded any other race, it would be called out as discrimination.

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        There are many, many scholarships which target minority students. And here are a whole bunch that exclude one sex:

        https://www.nitrocollege.com/blog/ultimate-guide-stem-scholarships

        Should we be against scholarships that encourage STEM education for women?

    2. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      Umbrage or the lesser form penumbrage where Justice Douglas found privacy rights?

Leave a Reply