Dominion “Bill Relief” Disappears September 1

By Steve Haner

Homeowners willing to cut back power usage when Dominion Energy Virginia asks them could earn rebates of up to $28 a year. So reports the Richmond Times-Dispatch, citing yet another final order from the State Corporation Commission.

The Richmond paper is always bringing us such great news about the folks at the giant utility looking out for us. The headline in the print edition today is even more positive: “New Rebate Program Could Lower Power Bills.”

Who is actually going to provide the $28 in hard cash? Yep, Bacon’s Rebellion readers get it on the first try. Dominion will raise the rebate money given to the few by raising its cost of electricity to everybody. Even the people getting rebates will pay the surcharge. But your bill just goes up a bit — so little you won’t notice the increase starting on September 1.

You also won’t notice it because the increase in the energy efficiency program’s rate adjustment clause (a separate charge also known as a RAC or rider), is just one of several such increases, all hitting September 1.

The higher bill totals will be creeping into your email and snail mail inboxes along with all the campaign brochures about how the 2023 General Assembly provided “bill relief.” That is gone in a puff of smoke. Come September 1 Dominion customers also start paying for, or start paying more for:

  • The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. As previously reported, the utility reversed course again and is now going direct to its customers to cover its carbon tax bills. The Return of RGGI will add $4.43 cents to a residential customer using 1,000 kilowatt hours for a month, and this time of year plenty do. Look for Rider RGGI on the actual bill.
  • Transmission Costs. This is the long-standing Rider T on monthly bills, and what Dominion is doing as of September 1 is merely increasing the amount collected. For that exemplar homeowner who sticks to one megawatt hour a month the addition works out to $2.67.
  • Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind. Again, Rider OSW already exists, but for the early stages of the turbine project Dominion hasn’t been asking much cash up-front every month. That changes as of September 1. Where it was charging Mr. Homeowner One-K $1.45 a month, that is going up to $4.74 – an increase of $3.29. As construction really begins in earnest in 2024 and 2025, that will really go up for a period of time. And don’t forget, they want a second phase.

Those amounts are actually much higher than the cost of the revised energy efficiency programs just approved, including the new demand reduction payments for residential customers. It is only going up an additional 24 cents per month on that mythical 1,000 kilowatt hour bill (the actual average residential bill is bigger.) Add the four of them together, however, and the net change is an increase of more than $10.60 (almost $128 over 12 months.)

And there is at least one more increase pending, but in this case delayed until November 1. That is for the low-income subsidy program previously discussed (often) on Bacon’s Rebellion, called the Percentage of Income Payment Plan, or PIPP. Dominion is predicting fairly small participation in PIPP at first, so is only asking to increase the monthly charge to 76 cents per month on that 1,000 kilowatt hour bill. The current PIPP placeholder, however, is 3 cents, so the difference is noticeable.

Tally those five changes and by November 1 the bill is up more than $11.35 per month, or $136 per year. That is the figure for small residential customers. Business customers, especially the large industrial users, often face higher percentage increases. Some of these charges are even imposed on customers who have fled to competitive suppliers.

These aren’t all the moving parts. There are other cost elements in electric bills changing all the time, up or down. You will recall that the recent drop in the fuel charge is very temporary, an election-year trick to mask the impact of all these other additions, and ultimately adds to customer cost. Odds are still overwhelming that the way Dominion folded three other rate riders into its base rates mainly prevented a possible reduction in its base rates, but that accounting is still underway. The one-handed applause granted to this year’s politically motivated claims of “bill relief” was being too generous.

Inflation, the ever-increasing demands of the Virginia Clean Economy Act, and Dominion’s continued influence over our legislature (and media) will continue to work together to apply upward pressure for years. And be thankful that despite all the hype, this has actually been a fairly reasonable summer so far. That has actually lowered bills.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

16 responses to “Dominion “Bill Relief” Disappears September 1”

  1. The Dominion rebate sounds analogous to the claim that lowering the amount of a tax increase is “tax relief.” Smoke and mirrors and verbal prestidigitation.

  2. Thank you for your reporting. Where’s the outrage? Once upon a time, Virginia’s newspapers and TV stations used to compare about electric bills. The media don’t care. Nobody seems to care. Nobody seems to care about taxes either. The body politic seems anesthetized.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      It could be a full time job for me if I let it, just following the stuff at the SCC alone. Pro Tip: This law firm run by someone I’ve come to highly respect does a good job of keeping up with the highlights on a blog of its own:

      https://reisingergooch.com/news-blog/

      1. William O'Keefe Avatar
        William O’Keefe

        I agree with Jim. Your reporting is excellent but until the media and voters do their jobs Dominion won’t feel the heat and therefore won’t see the light.
        Where’s Gov. Youngkin on this?

  3. Thank you for your reporting. Where’s the outrage? Once upon a time, Virginia’s newspapers and TV stations used to compare about electric bills. The media don’t care. Nobody seems to care. Nobody seems to care about taxes either. The body politic seems anesthetized.

  4. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Nobody cares says James. Rebates ain’t “woke”. That’s why.

  5. A rebate of up to twenty-eighty dollars a year for allowing Dominion to control my power usage?

    Is this a joke?

    1. it’s Bidenomics

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Aren’t you afraid of the Climate Catastrophe? Do your part!! The Mississippi will never flood again if only we do this!

      1. Several years ago we tried the program where Dominion get’s to remotely shut off our air conditioning. I think we did it for one year, then dropped it. Not worth whatever the incentive was to lose cooling at the worst possible times.

    3. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      I thought the idea is they text you and you choose to turn off things that you are using then (like AC or washer/dryer). If you do, you get a rebate. Your choice.

  6. A customer is entitled to use as much power as he wants, including to run airconditioning or a heat pump on extremely hot days. But the customer can agree contractually to limit his control over his electrical “demand” in exchange for a payment by the utility.

    Why, you many ask, would Dominion offer such a deal to its customers? Because Dominion can sell the sum total of all those simultaeous interruptions in the wholesale electric marketplace, as the equivalent of generated power. You see, in order to balance generation with load a reduction in load is just as valuable to the grid operator as an increase in generation.

    Now Dominion’s payments to its customer should total less than the wholesale market’s payment to Dominion, or else Dominion struck a bad bargain with its customers who signed up for the interruption program. But, as SH said, Dominion has a reputation for striking good, cost effective, bargains.

    Why would it strike a bad bargain? I can think of two reasons.

    Dominion intended the interruption program to pay for itself, but overestimated the wholesale price for sales of load reduction into the wholesale marketplace. Or,

    Dominion deliberately overpaid for the right to interrupt its customers in order to appear successful to the politicians in promoting “green” energy policies, knowing that its overpayments would draw in a lot more participation, and also knowing that its losses on the program would be more than reimbursed by automatically-increased energy-efficiency RAC charges on all customers’ bills.

    Now I cannot discern which of these reasons is the correct one. Perhaps the SCC could not figure it out either.

    This is an example of why we need an SCC that’s shielded from political interference and political restrictions on its investigatory and ratemaking powers. And why politicians do a lousy job of directly regulating utilities. And specifically, why utility cost recovery through base rates plus a bunch of confusing RACs (rather than through base rates covering all costs) can make it extremely difficult for the SCC, let alone the public, to figure out which utility programs are truly cost effective and which simply benefit one set of customers at the expense of another.

    And if the public can’t figure it out, the politicians who receive all those Dominion political donations have no incentive to let the SCC do so, either.

    Ah, but this is the Virginia Way. That excuses it, right?

  7. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Once again, the advantage of a residential solar net metering system is evident. The absolute best way to go if you can.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      With the rules as they are, I can’t argue with that if you have a location with good sun and enough space for panels.

  8. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    I’m guessing that someplace out there a Dominion customer is calling to inquire as to whether their mother-in-law’s respirator can be put on this rebate plan.

    “Hang in there Helen. When the neighbor’s AC cuts off, your respirator should start up again.”

    You guys focus too much on the downside.

  9. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
    energyNOW_Fan

    I am confused. For some years I have been already getting $40/yr discount for letting D control my AC on hot days. This year so far I have not noticed any AC cut backs.

Leave a Reply