Do Not Extend Ban on Elective Procedures, Hospitals Urge Governor

Sean Connaughton

by James A. Bacon

Citing ample hospital capacity and the deferral of 15,000 medical procedures each week, the Virginia Hospital and Healthcare Association is calling upon Governor Ralph Northam to allow hospitals to resume non-emergency procedures across Virginia.

“Significant progress has been made in combating the COVID-19 pandemic and treating those afflicted with the virus,” wrote President Sean Connaughton to the governor in a letter written five days ago and released today.

Northam’s March 25 executive order prohibited inpatient and outpatient surgical hospitals from performing elective procedures in order to free up more hospital beds and personal protective equipment. That directive expires April 24, and Connaughton urged the Governor not to renew it. In place of that order, hospitals have agreed to abide by a “Framework for Reopening Virginia’s Hospitals.”

Northam’s emergency measures accomplished what they were meant to do, and now it is time to move to the next step, Connaughton said.

Working together, we have distributed personal protective equipment (PPE) to frontline health care workers, expanded the Commonwealth’s capacity for testing suspected COVID-19 patients, increased capacity to treat COVID-19 patients, and modeled projected surge at our hospitals. These efforts, combined with your administration’s directives on social distancing and Virginians’ commitment to staying home, have helped stem the impact COVID-19 has had on the Commonwealth.

While the crisis is far from over and COVID-10 will continue to be the primary focus of our hospitals and health care providers for the foreseeable future, we are mindful of the tens of thousands of Virginians who have deferred care for chronic conditions and other non-urgent medical needs. We are concerned that continuing to delay their care while we have available capacity to address and/or stabilize their condition will have long-term negative impacts on health across the Commonwealth.

The shutdown of elective procedures in Virginia also has contributed to the layoff of thousands of healthcare workers as well as a devastating loss of revenue for hospitals.

As of April 18, 1,301 COVID-19 patients (confirmed and pending test results) were being hospitalized. Only 21% of the ventilators were in use, Connaughton wrote. “Critically, these numbers have remained consistent since the end of March.” (As of this morning, Virginia hospitals were treating 1,379 COVID-19 patients, have 5,327 beds available, and have 2,264 ventilators available to provide respiratory support to patients.)

“In the meantime,” wrote Connaughton, “it is estimated that 60,000 Virginians have had their non-urgent inpatient and outpatient medical procedures canceled over the past month and 15,000 procedures will be canceled every week going forward.”

Allowing the order to expire would put Virginia on similar footing with at least 17 other states, which have lifted restrictions on non-emergency procedures: Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Nebraska, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, and West Virginia.

According to the VHHA Framework, the Commonwealth has more than 6,000 hospital beds, many of which are medical/surgical beds. Additional beds can be added if needed. “Given the large number of available beds and the ability to track them, we believe hospital bed usage can be managed both regionally and statewide,” the document says.

The supply of personal protection equipment “remains a challenge,” says the Framework. But the ban on elective procedures has made only a nominal difference.

This is in large part due to the different PPE requirements for infectious disease patients compared to requirements for surgery and other medical procedures. The supply chain for most standard PPE for surgery has not been impacted to a significant degree due to COVID-19. Health care professionals performing surgeries have supplies to safely care for patients.

Meanwhile, the number of facilities reporting PPE shortages for COVID-19 patients “has decreased over the past week.”

Availability of staff is not an issue, says the Framework. Only one of 115 hospitals has reported data indicating potential staffing challenges. At the same time, many hospitals have furloughed staff not engaged in urgent care treating COVID-19 patients.

Testing, while still an issue, is improving. Health systems and private labs have increased their testing capacity. “Hospitals report that processing times are declining from 7-10 days to 24 to 48 hours.”

COVID-19 is impacting each region of the state differently. The VHHA advocates taking a regional approach based on Regional Healthcare Coalition boundaries, tracking critical metrics for each region, and committing to “a circuit breaker philosophy” should any of the metrics be exceeded. If shortages of beds, staff or protective gear crop up, non-urgent procedures can be postponed until the indicators stabilize.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

23 responses to “Do Not Extend Ban on Elective Procedures, Hospitals Urge Governor”

  1. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
    Reed Fawell 3rd

    This Virginia Governor’s passive aggressive conduct astounds.

  2. Of particular note is the VHHA’s take on personal protective equipment. I haven’t seen this reported anywhere. The ban on elective procedures has made only a nominal difference in the supply of gear needed by health providers treating COVID-19.

    This is in large part due to the different PPE requirements for infectious disease patients compared to requirements for surgery and other medical procedures. The supply chain for most standard PPE for surgery has not been impacted to a significant degree due to COVID-19. Health care professionals performing surgeries have supplies to safely care for patients.

    The purpose of the executive order prohibiting elective surgeries was (1) to increase the supply of available beds, and (2) to conserve the supply of PPEs. It’s been apparent for more than a week now — I’ve been blogging about it — that hospitals have more than enough beds. Now it turns out that the executive order is making little difference in the availability of PPEs.

    I don’t see how Northam can NOT let the executive order expire. There is ZERO justification for extending it.

  3. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    I think at one point ANY PPE was considered strategic – better than re-use or nothing had the hospitals run out.

    We want to open up elective surgeries. Do we know the patients are COVID-19 free? I presume these folks will be tested probably more
    than once…

    Also, I have a friend who is recovering from a shoulder surgery and he says rehab shut down and is not open… so for those folks getting shoulders, hips and knees… do they need rehab?

    1. Steve Haner Avatar
      Steve Haner

      If I go in-patient can I get a haircut? Part A, Part B….Medigap…can I afford an inpatient haircut? This can’t be the only area where he relents a little….

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        Nice try. Let me know if it works. I’m getting a little shaggy.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          ponytails?

          1. Anonymous Avatar
            Anonymous

            Just please no more “man buns”.

        2. djrippert Avatar
          djrippert

          Now that I can see.

      2. djrippert Avatar
        djrippert

        I’m looking at your picture and wondering how a haircut is so high on your priority list. I can use a long pair of BBQ tongs and the electric razor I used on my kids back when they all had buzz cuts if that will help.

        1. Nancy_Naive Avatar
          Nancy_Naive

          Maybe,… just maybe, he meant a Brazilian.

  4. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    You want Medicare to pay for an outpatient surgery haircut?

  5. LGABRIEL Avatar

    Regarding rehab. There must be hundreds of people who had knee, hip, shoulder, etc. surgeries or just needed rehab services in the weeks just prior to the shutdown. Does anyone know, or care, what they have been doing? I know when I had some pins put in my hip, there was a week in-patient therapy followed by about a month of home therapy visits.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      My friend got some advice on how to set up his own DIY equipment and exercises.

      But if I were a surgeon getting ready to cut someone up and I knew there would be no rehab what would I do, what should I do?

  6. Peter Galuszka Avatar
    Peter Galuszka

    Yoassir. Br trashes connaughton’s advocacy group, then embraces it. What are you guys thinking? Response to dog whistle?

    1. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
      Reed Fawell 3rd

      My severe aggravation, so plainly expressed here, at Sean Connaughton go back to his tactics and methods during his tenure as Virginia Transportation Secretary from 2010 until 2014. Here, however, he is right. Virginian’s health, and financial health the hospitals and clinic on which Virginians depend, are now being put at ever greater risk every day that these facilities are shut down for non-emergency procedures including so called “elective” surgery.

  7. sherlockj Avatar
    sherlockj

    Re: Sean Connaughton – stopped clock theory proven once more. His organization is the poster child for political rot in Richmond.

  8. Peter Galuszka Avatar
    Peter Galuszka

    So, Reed, the problem with the virus is over? Really?

    1. Anonymous Avatar
      Anonymous

      Yep, Peter. That’s exactly what Reed wrote. You got it in one, so there’s no need to continue the conversation.

  9. sherlockj Avatar
    sherlockj

    Re: Sean Connaughton. His compensation from the Virginia Hospital and Healthcare Assn., a tax exempt organization, was $682,137 in 2018, the last year for which its Form 990 is available. He doesn’t get that for signing letters.

    1. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
      Reed Fawell 3rd

      Not surprised.

      But I would rather have hospitals and clinic bailing themselves out by performing non emergency surgeries than by taxpayer bailout money. That and with higher education bailouts, are surely coming. Meanwhile, there are a whole lot in innocent victims piling up here and all around, homes, jobs, health, families, schools, livelihoods, communities, being destroyed slowly, some never to return, for the lack of taking calculated risks, or being allowed to take them. Living is a calculated risk, for the greater good, or your own, that is what life is all about. We’ve lost that art and craft it seems. We’re either reckless, or frozen, it seems, in Virginia, and many other places. But we’ll see on this issue on the 24th.

      1. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
        Reed Fawell 3rd

        About the art and craft of calculated risks:

        Right now we should be spending just a much time and effort at finding ways to open America back up, by efficiently creating and managing calculated risks, as we are spending today on defeating the Coved-19, or rather in lowering the coved-19 risks to acceptable levels, levels that many places in America likely will soon arrive at, if they are not already there, particularly when those risks are weighted against the economic risk and damage that is mounting to monster levels now, and growing higher every day without any abatement at all.

        There, however, are market adjustments happening all over by reason of crisis (coved-19) that we are creating to meet new realities. This too deserves great study to enhance our quicker more efficient recovery.

  10. djrippert Avatar
    djrippert

    I don’t know. If it’s safe enough for elected surgery then it’s safe enough for me to recover my barstool (third from the end) at Big Mook’s BBQ and Beer Palace in downtown Great Falls. I promise to wear a mask and drink out of a straw. Oops, I forgot – straws are politically incorrect.

    1. Reed Fawell 3rd Avatar
      Reed Fawell 3rd

      I must admit that one other thought occurred to me. How can you be sure the hip replacement you’re doing on guy you got lying out on OR table ain’t got Coved-19? Can you fix him in your Coved-19 suit? How about the whole crew in OR?

Leave a Reply