by Joe Fitzgerald

More than 1 in 9 James Madison University students was infected with Covid-19 during the school year that ended in May. To date, the university has accepted little responsibility for those illnesses or for any associated spread in Harrisonburg and Rockingham County.

President Alger and members of the Senior Leadership Team have been predominantly silent about any mistakes the university may have made and what it will do to correct them this year as students return in the midst of the more virulent Delta Variant spread.

The university’s stance a week after classes began last year was “cautious optimism,” according to an email from Alger a few days before in-person classes were canceled. A few weeks later a university spokesperson, not Alger or any senior administrator, told the media, “There’s nothing at blame here except for the virus.”

Silence from the university and from Alger has continued this summer. The university has said it will require students to be vaccinated, but in effect the policy amounts to asking students to tell the university if they aren’t going to be vaccinated. Faculty and staff are explicitly not required to be vaccinated.

Students who don’t want to be vaccinated can fill out a religious exemption form, which requires notarization; fill out a medical exemption form, which requires a doctor’s letter; or fill out a form saying they don’t want the vaccine for personal reasons.

It’s tempting to call the vaccine “requirement” a paper tiger, but it’s barely a cardboard kitten.

In addition to not requiring vaccinations and saying they are, the university says it can’t release numbers of vaccinations and exemptions until Aug. 16, four days before freshman move-in and after most upper-class students have already returned.

Recapping: JMU is not requiring students, faculty, or staff to be vaccinated, and is not sharing what the school knows about vaccination rates or numbers.

JMU’s deans all co-signed a letter last year about renaming buildings. They should consider addressing the issues of vaccinations and information, or following the faculty senate’s lead on demanding mandatory vaccinations.

If you or someone you know has any influence with any member of Alger’s Senior Leadership Team or with any member of the board of visitors, this would be a good time to reach out to them.

This is not a time for cautious optimism.

Joe Fitzgerald is a former mayor of Harrisonburg, where he still lives. This column has been republished with permission from his Substack column, “Still Not Sleeping.”


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

17 responses to “Delta Dawn at JMU?”

  1. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    So is the Delta Variant real and will result in some significant changes and even convince some to do what they refused to do before – or is the Delta Variant just another MSM-created fear-porn?

    Thanks for the article highlighting the issue without demonizing the individuals or institutions involved.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      There is still an open bet whether you are real, Larry.

      Mr. Fitzgerald, most readers of this blog will be heartened that JMU is leaving all this up to individual decisions. I must say they cannot require something for students and not employees, that is the very definition of arbitrary. So they don’t. And I do not think JMU bears any “responsibility” for the spread of a world-wide very contagious virus in your charming city. That’s nonsense. Which is why Larry loves it….

      I think the school could legally decide otherwise, and do what others have to seek to force compliance, but frankly it will not be that effective there (watch) and JMU probably sees that now.

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      There is still an open bet whether you are real, Larry.

      Mr. Fitzgerald, most readers of this blog will be heartened that JMU is leaving all this up to individual decisions. I must say they cannot require something for students and not employees, that is the very definition of arbitrary. So they don’t. And I do not think JMU bears any “responsibility” for the spread of a world-wide very contagious virus in your charming city. That’s nonsense. Which is why Larry loves it….

      I think the school could legally decide otherwise, and do what others have to seek to force compliance, but frankly it will not be that effective there (watch) and JMU probably sees that now.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        Oh I’m sorta wondering if all is said and done yet as the Delta thing may still be playing out and some appear to be still hedging.

        Depending on who you believe, Delta may be a bit of a game changer and I thought Mr. Fitzgerald’s commentary alluded to that – in a mature and respectful way – a novel concept in BR some days.

        1. Stephen Haner Avatar
          Stephen Haner

          Delta is the transition from pandemic to endemic that so many have been predicting. The chance to crush this with vaccines has passed. Now we live with it and adapt.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            so we’re back to the wild wild west and everyone does their thing on the way to herd immunity?

            The vaccines keep you from getting seriously sick or dying even if you contract the virus – my understanding – still way better than not getting vaccinated and some now talking 3rd booster.

            Interesting how different folks end up with different information and facts….

          2. Stephen Haner Avatar
            Stephen Haner

            There will never be herd immunity. Never. There isn’t for flu or colds.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            Is that what Gottlieb says?

          4. Stephen Haner Avatar
            Stephen Haner

            There will never be herd immunity. Never. There isn’t for flu or colds.

          5. Eric the half a troll Avatar
            Eric the half a troll

            “The chance to crush this with vaccines has passed. Now we live with it and adapt.”

            If this is true, it did not have to be this way. The one’s responsible for politicizing and undermining our best chance to eliminate the threat need to be held accountable for their actions… again… They simply can’t seem to do what’s right… too interested in doing what is Right…

      2. Joseph Fitzgerald Avatar
        Joseph Fitzgerald

        Harrisonburg averaged 3.5 new cases per day in July 2020. The city averaged 42 per day in September after JMU brought back 22,000 students, almost 5,000 of them from Virginia’s Covid hotspots, with no particular restrictions on them other than “Y’all be good, OK?” The 12-fold increase wasn’t worldwide. It was here.

  2. StarboardLift Avatar
    StarboardLift

    Perhaps JMU is waiting to learn how dangerous Delta variant is, in terms of hospitalizations and mortality. Contagious, yes, but so is pink eye. Not yet clear that it is as dangerous as initial COVID-19. We do know that the US mRNA vaccines are not very effective against the Beta and Gamma variants.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Can Epsilon, Omega and then Charlie Foxtrot Zulu be far behind? Public attention will wane….

      1. vicnicholls Avatar
        vicnicholls

        more like lack of common sense will prevail …

  3. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Saw a news report about a popular DC bar that will require evidence of vaccination in order to enter. That is what needs to happen everywhere.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Ya Vohl, Mein Kommandant. Maybe a sign on their clothing if not…?

      Listen up, people, you are being lied to big time. You are being played. It was always obvious that the vaccines were not perfect, and vaccinated people could get COVID, or get it again. Those with a real case, symptomatic, are probably contagious despite the vaccine. This is not unexpected. If the vaccines are 95% effective, 5% of the 160 million fully vaccinated will get sick:

      That’s 8 million cases. Big whoop. Have we seen that so far? No. Probably a few hundred thousand.

      While people might become contagious (even CDC calls that “rare”) the vaccines are incredibly effective against severe disease. Yep, we might need a booster. When so advised, I’ll get mine. But I will not let the media and the fear porn politicians railroad me again. I’ve seen what the CDC is peddling and they have NO proof that vaccinated individuals with no symptoms are spreading this.

      Masks are of limited value, and useless for me IMHO, but easy to comply if they insist. You’ll notice none of the other nonsense has appeared yet — lockdowns, stay at home, closed indoor dining, crowd limits, etc. They are not (yet) sending the kids back to their computers. So this really isn’t serious, is it. Masks are just virtue signals.

      The CDC data does have some hints about differences with the vaccines, and the boosters may start with J&J users…

      If you think you have symptoms, vaccinated or not, even mild, assume it might be COVID and behave accordingly. Then stay home, do take out, wear a mask, etc. And go get a test so the folks at the CDC can get some real data.

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        “… the vaccines are incredibly effective against severe disease.”

        Hence, the vaccine requirement for the bar.

Leave a Reply