Food Pantries, the Latest College Craze

An increasing number of college food pantries in Virginia provide emergency rations to hungry students. Photo credit: VCU's Rampa
An increasing number of college food pantries in Virginia provide emergency rations to hungry students. Photo credit: VCU’s Rampantry

There’s a new wrinkle on the college affordability crisis. Some students are so strapped for cash that colleges are setting up food pantries. As CNN reports, membership in the College and University Food Bank Alliance has quadrupled in the past two years to 398 members.

“Even if you don’t hear about hunger being a problem, there’s probably a population on campus in need,” said Megan Breitenbach, a student who volunteers at the pantry at Montclair State in New Jersey.

Food Bank Alliance members include these Virginia institutions:

Virginia Commonwealth University. The mission of Ram Pantry is to “to provide VCU students with healthy, culturally appropriate, emergency food.” Due to limited resources, the website says, the pantry can no longer service VCU faculty and staff!

Virginia Tech. Tech won reknown for its No. 1 ranking in the “best food” category of “The Princeton Review’s” 2015 best colleges review. But in December 2015, according to the Roanoke Times, the food pantry was serving 50 to 75 students per week.

Old Dominion University. ODU launched Ignite Pantry in October.

Northern Virginia Community College and Eastern Shore Community College also operate food pantries.

Bacon’s bottom line: In their never-ending quest to recruit more elite student bodies, Virginia colleges and universities are placing more emphasis on the kind of food that kids from affluent families are accustomed to. Virginia Tech is a case in point. As I blogged last month when discussing the rising cost of food services at the University of Virginia:

Upgrading from the crappy cafeteria food I ate back in the 1970s to trendy, locally sourced food is expensive, and the lower-income and middle-class students whose families live on McDonalds or Olive Garden budgets are hard-pressed to pay for it.

Little did I realize that the situation was so bad that colleges and universities were setting up food pantries!

With every passing day, it seems increasingly evident that colleges and universities in Virginia (and across the nation) are engines of exploitation, running up the cost of attendance (tuition, fees, room, board), encouraging indebtedness, and sending their graduates into the workforce deeply in hoc — all to acquire the resources to boost institutional prestige in a never-ending race with other institutions doing the same thing. Starving students are the latest symptom of a system that is terribly broken.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

7 responses to “Food Pantries, the Latest College Craze”

  1. kvdavis2 Avatar

    The need for food pantries by indebted and low-income (at least during college) students has zero, nada, zilch to do with the campus food service trend towards higher quality – and sustainable and locally-sourced and all that, food.

    Only freshman year students are required to live in the dorms (UVA and VT, at least; can’t reasearch the others, but my D is at UMich), and are therefore required to have a meal plan. Those can indeed be pricy, but if you have a meal plan, you don’t need to go to a food pantry.

    In my experience, non-dorm students almost NEVER go to the campus dining halls.

    So as attractive as locally-sourced organic kale salad is to conservative bloggers, the kids going to food pantries are *not* suffering from trendy high-priced dining halls.

    College debt is such a profound issue in the U.S. today. Washington College President Sheila Bair – who saw the housing bubble crash coming – is doing some excellent work on this:

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2016/08/03/how-washington-college-president-sheila-bair-plans-to-tackle-college-affordability/?utm_term=.8260ec813986

    1. Fair point. It would be interesting to know how many of the food-pantry students live in dorms and how many live off-campus. Would they be interested in lower-cost, lower-quality food plans if they were available?

      But you miss a larger point. Even students living off campus are paying so much in tuition, fees, textbooks, etc. that they may feel they need to save money by shifting to a Ramen Noodles diet.

  2. kvdavis2 Avatar

    You may wish to fact-check with several Virginia universities the basic assumption of your blog: that there are students living in dorms–who you may have, understandably, only just learned, are required to have meal plans–use food pantries. It just doesn’t make sense. The meal plans are usually close to all-you-can-eat. I mean maybe a few kids, but not the majority of frequenters of food pantries live in the dorms.

    Maybe call some of the food pantries you wrote about? (They will not consider it the “latest college craze”, like raccoon coats, tho.)

    The idea of “choice” based on preference for lower costs: There are usually maybe 3 food plan price tiers, based on amount of meals desired. Having 2nd and 3rd class diners based on food quality…..hmm, that just doesn’t sit quite right in a college environment.

    Trust me, tho, I did NOT miss the “larger point” about the high costs of college. I have a daughter who’s graduating (YAAAAAYYYYY!!!) from University of Michigan in April. Long story, but our economic status means she got no aid except really basic federal. She also waits tables 15 hours/week (at a place that serves alcohol, so, tips!) – did you know that servers have to find someone to cover their shifts when they can’t make it, for like, exams or illness or Thanksgiving week?

    At Thanksgiving, as we went around the table saying what we were thankful for, she said “I’m thankful this was the last semester my family had to pay a full Michigan tuition!” (She’s down to p/t status next semester.)

    Jim, you and I have had the pleasure of meeting several times. You have written often on campus issues. If you need a pro-bono consultant on current state of affairs re campus life, college costs, sexual assault, etc., these days, feel free to get in touch! 🙂

    1. You are fortunate that your daughter appreciates the sacrifices you are making to send her to college. Her appreciation is all the more remarkable considering the fact that she has to work 15 hours a week. But then… maybe contributing toward the cost of her education in that way probably makes her appreciate a lot of things that other kids wouldn’t.

  3. LarrytheG Avatar

    I’m pretty skeptical also. Most pantries give out things that have to be cooked…not microwaved, not ready-to-eat, like canned good, boxes of pasta…, etc… and in the Roanoke paper it said that pancake mix was in short supply? really?

    You have to ask also WHERE they are getting the food. Most areas that have Regional Food Banks.. have to certify that their clients legitimately qualify for food stamps and public assistance. You just can’t walk up and say you’re “hungry”.

    If someone told me that students tend to be cheap and will scarf up whatever is free and give great stories of penniless woe so as to garner even more free stuff.. I would be SHOCKED! SHOCKED!

    Remember these are the same folks who are willing to go tens of thousands of dollars into debt rather than take a part-time job to help pay for their school costs – and they can’t work in the dining halls to earn their keep? really?

    I think we should submit this to Politifact or Snopes…. !!!

    FAKE NEws is running AMOK!

  4. KVD2, you are right about the mandatory meal plans for those in the dorms — but JB’s post features VT and VCU and ODU and my neighbor NoVaCoCo — those are majority-commuter schools, most of whose students (including nearly all grad students) live spread out through the community, in shared homes or cheap apartments or maybe their parents’ homes. And all of those schools built cafeterias intended to provide a la carte meals for commuting students as well as meal plans for the dorms. I take it that it’s the a la carte diners who are turning to food kitchens instead of paying cafeteria prices, even while the dorm-based meal-plan diners (only a year away from living in town and cooking for themselves) demand non-organic and non-local ingredients. That’s laughable! But I can certainly remember my kids acting that way — until they began paying the incremental price of their own food choices. Perhaps your daughter was lucky and was able to live in the dorms all the way through UM?

  5. Acbar, you are right, I don’t know if local students choose to eat at the dining halls much. The point is, they have options, and they can choose where to spend their food dollars, including the dining hall with its progressive-food-values.

    It’s just the whole narrative of this blog post on food pantries is based on false assumptions.

    …Daughter lived in the dorm first year, then apartments, which she demonstrated via spreadsheet was cheaper… She has always been frugal and more accountable to us than we asked! I partly credit the Personal Economics class she took at Osbourne Park.

    And yes, Jim, she is remarkable :), but it’s not that rare! Kids from rich families often show their privilege and entitlement, but they’re not impoverishing anybody – they’re just fortunate.

    She also HATES articles about college students written by anyone but college students! I can understand how she feels. Some of these tropes have their own political agendas….

Leave a Reply