From Virginia Coal, An Abridged History.

by James C. Sherlock

When we talk of coal today, which is seldom, it is usually not treated well.

It is easy to forget (if some even know) that coal powered the industrial revolution, made America the richest nation in the world and fueled American war production that supported allied victories in both world wars in the 20th century.

Coal powered nearly everything starting in the early part of the 19th century. Power plants, trains, ships, and virtually anything else powered by steam used coal to boil the water.

The iron and then steel-making process depended then, and still does, on coking coal.

Coal — and the co-dependent railroads — played big roles in Virginia history.

I strongly recommend to you Virginia Coal, An Abridged History. It was published in 1990 by the Virginia Center for Coal & Energy Research at Virginia Tech.

Perspective on coal production. America wrestled industrial leadership from Great Britain when we exceeded that country as the world’s leading coal producer in the 1890’s.

The 1900 census recorded 350,829 coal workers — miners and helpers — in the Unites States. Most of them mined bituminous coal.

By the time of the 1902 mining census, coal mining was easily the most valuable extraction industry in the world. The value of 1902 coal production in the United States, adjusting for inflation, was over a trillion 2023 dollars.

The production was more than 3.5 tons per capita of the entire 83 million population of the United States.

Pennsylvania was by far the dominant coal producer. It produced over 100 million tons of coal in 1902. Virginia produced about 2 million tons.

That census kept track of the number of boys under 16 working in the mines. They were about 3% of the work force.

Immigrant miners. Most of the coal miners in the United States at that time, and those that started most of Virginia’s mines, were immigrants from Europe or their direct descendants. Most were from Austria, Germany, Ireland, England, Wales and Scotland.

My father’s family were Irish Catholic coal miners who immigrated to work the mines in Western Pennsylvania.

Catholic and Black miners were targeted by the KKK.

My father told of his mother, a school teacher, being banned from teaching in the public schools in their Pennsylvania county. The Ku Klux Klan had as many as 250,000 Pennsylvania members in its heyday in the 1920s.


The chartered train advertised above was going from Lykens Pa. to the national convention of the KKK in Washington D.C. in 1925.

Virginia. Virginia has three coal regions, only one of which, in Southwest Virginia, is still active.

Virginia coal and Virginia history are forever intertwined. Civil war battles were fought over Virginia coal.

You will read in Virginia Coal that as the frontier advanced, the coal fields in the Richmond area, then in Montgomery and Pulaski counties, then in the Appalachian region of Southwest Virginia developed.

credit https://www.energy.virginia.gov/geology/coal.shtml

Segregation, company towns, labor unrest, unionization, and culture clashes all followed coal development.

Along with the railroads.

Now Norfolk Southern carries 85% of Virginia coal, much of it to the export piers in Hampton Roads, the largest coal export terminal in the United States.  Virtually all of that coal now from Southwest Virginia.

Virginia coal production has continued to decline along with its economic value. Statistica reports Virginia had 5,261 coal mining jobs in 2011, 1,942 in 2021.

courtesy https://www.energy.virginia.gov/geology/coal.shtml

But it has been a hell of a run.

Virginia Coal offers those interested in Virginia history an important perspective.

It’s a great short read.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

53 responses to “Coal in Virginia”

  1. Lykens ain’t exactly near Harrisburg, but it is pretty country east of Millersburg, home of the last ferry across the Susquehanna.

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Fixed.

    2. Wasn’t picking at you, just familiar with the area. My wife bought a mule from a farm near Elizabethville, and I’ve got relatives around Harrisburg. Very pretty country as you get up the river, and riding the ferry was fun.

      1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        Little known trivia: The federal mining census in the 19th and early 20th centuries reported the numbers of mules associated with each mine.

      2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        Little known trivia: The federal mining census in the 19th and early 20th centuries reported the numbers of mules associated with each mine.

    3. Matt Adams Avatar

      Can be a very pretty area, I was a Railroad Supervisor up in that neck of the woods.

      Also, equally as pretty but desolate is up 120 (Renovo Rd) following the Susquehanna. Industrial runoff has been cut back and the river is crystal clear.

      1. 120 out of Lock Haven is rural, sorta like 87 out of Montoursville. The west branch of the Susquehanna is pretty territory.

        Stayed at a B&B in Marysville one time overlooking the bridge with a bunch of railroad buffs. Enola isn’t what it once was, but still a lot of rail traffic. That was fun.

        1. Matt Adams Avatar

          You just described my entire old territory, haha.

          Good ole Enola, our saying was “you know what it spells backwards, don’t ya”.

          ALONE.

          1. One grandfather and great uncle worked for the Pennsy at the Enola Yards, other relatives lived in Camp Hill, Enola and West Fairview. The other grandfather was a Methodist minister who had parishes scattered from Camp Hill to north of Williamsport. My mom grew up in towns along the Susquehanna.

            Some on her side tried to settle north of Williamsport in the 1730s. The local indians did not like that and ran them back to town. A decade later they tried again and their descendants still live there.

            It’s a chunk of country I love and miss. It’s getting to be awhile since I’ve seen those big water gaps headed north out of Harrisburg.

            You had great territory.

          2. Matt Adams Avatar

            Sounds like a very interesting family, family history is so interesting. Mine is from NWPA, I was a transplant for work. My wife’s family is near Breezewood.

            When I worked there I lived Linglestown. My area went from previous discussed out towards Carlisle and down to Columbia.

          3. Neat. Mom and Dad were married in Bedford when her dad had a church there. One of my Dad’s early jobs was putting in the radios that connected the then brand new Turnpike from end to end. They put repeaters on the mountains to relay the signals and rattlesnakes liked them because they were warm.

          4. Matt Adams Avatar

            Similar to crossing bungalow and control points in the railroad. They loved those as well.

            What a very small world.

    1. Mr. Bacon’s swelled head notwithstanding, Maverick Miner is well worth a read.

      😉

  2. William Chambliss Avatar
    William Chambliss

    https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=19044

    Not too far from my house

  3. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    General John Imboden published a book in 1872 advocating for the exploitation of coal and lumber in southwest Virginia. He is credited with not only covering Lee’s retreat from Gettysburg but opening the primitive southwest part of the state to the industrial revolution. An unlucky visionary who was swindled out of his share of wealth. His five wives were even more unlucky. They all died young.
    http://www.bigstonegappublishing.net/Imboden.pdf
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/39295c504cdbd2ea23250d131bf05500e507bcd6d80a7ac3b5dafc952965d8e7.jpg

    1. Matt Hurt Avatar

      He wasn’t the only person swindled SWVA concerning coal. Many a poor mountaineer sold their mineral rights (for next to nothing) to big companies which came back to bite their heirs years later.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        I’d be more suspicious of the 5 dead wives.

      2. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
        James Wyatt Whitehead

        I know exactly how you feel. My great grandparents were swindled out of 380 acres on Hazel Mountain in the Blue Ridge to help form Shenandoah National Park. 800 bucks is what the government gave them. Million dollar property today. Great views, flat land, and southern exposure.

        1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
          Eric the half a troll

          Swindled….?? How were they swindled?

          1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
            James Wyatt Whitehead

            Grab your hiking boots and I’ll take you up to Hazel Mountain and show you. The old cabin is still there.

          2. Eric the half a troll Avatar
            Eric the half a troll

            You don’t know how much I would enjoy that, James. Do you know why they sold the land and how much it was worth back then? Trust me, I believe the government is not above swindling and I have no doubt it happened but if they were paid a fair price by the standard of the day, you can’t really say they were swindled. The coal mine swindling is different because they knew how much the resources they were buying were worth and the seller did not. But when farmers in Loudoun sold their land to developers and got market value, you can’t say they were swindled because that land is so much more valuable today.

          3. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
            James Wyatt Whitehead

            I had to hunt for years to find the documentation that demonstrates Uncle Sam’s 800 bucks was a swindle. The apple orchard and the stand of timber, some of which was virgin, had greater value than what the Dept. of the Interior paid out. This story well documented Eric. The government took advantage of poor and illiterate subsistence farmers. Numerous books written about what happened along the Blue Ridge.

          4. Matt Adams Avatar

            “I’m from the Government, and I’m here to Help”

            The Fed acquired land for pennies on the dollar from poor farmers in the south. They became military installations.

      3. Especially after corrupt courts decided that mineral rights superseded surface rights.

  4. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    In addition to describing the contribution of coal to the Commonwealth’s wealth, I wonder if that history also explored the darker legacy of coal–miners killed in mine accidents, men’s lives shortened and made miserable by black lung disease, miners working hard all day in dangerous conditions and not getting anywhwere, and whole hillsides and mountains stripped away.

    Tennessee Ernie Ford summed up that legacy nicely:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pLVtJkpl_ug

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Read it.

      My own family’s history with coal mining in Pennsylvania was not a fairy tale.

      But I think that all aspects of the legacy were discussed in the VPI document. But it was not a book, but rather an overview.

    2. Matt Adams Avatar

      There is a stark difference between seam mining and strip mining. Lumping them together just shows a lack of knowledge.

      For all its faults that industry built this nation and I am a direct byproduct of both the coal and oil industry.

      We didn’t have the fancy cotton crop NWPA to grow our pocketbooks, like ya’ll in VA.

    3. The movie Harlan County USA was released in 1976. I was 12 years old. It is the first documentary film I sat through from start to finish. I saw it about three times. It moved me in ways that still have a profound effect on me today, not the least of which is a deep love and appreciation for blues, folk and bluegrass music.

      To this day, if I see that movie is being shown on TV I will sit down and watch it again.

      https://www.criterion.com/films/777-harlan-county-usa

      Speaking of blues, bluegrass, etc, my wife and I saw Billy Strings play in Charlottesville last night. As far as I am concerned the future of bluegrass and ‘acoustic’ music is in good hands with that young man. Some traditionalists may say he plays too loud, but as someone who has seen Metallica in concert it was not a problem for me. I rank him up there with Chet Atkins, Tony Rice and Doc Watson as an acoustic guitarist. I don’t think he is quite in Mississippi John Hurt’s rarified air yet, but he is still quite young.

      1. He’s great, but doesn’t hold a candle to Molly Tuttle. Kids are almost enough to make us geezers give up picking, but not quite.

        There’s a good youtube of Billy sitting by himself on stage at a west coast festival flawlessly picking Doc Watson tunes, mostly earlier ones. Young man’s done his homework. That’s where I began to respect what he was doing.

        John Hurt story from a friend I pick with. He and a buddy and their dates went to see Hurt in D.C., mid ’60s. They were the only customers in the venue. Hurt came over, asked if it was ok to sit at their table. He did his set sitting there with them. Quite an evening.

        C’ville’s got some good musicians coming through. Bromberg’s going to be there in the near future.

  5. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    An interesting read, Sherlock. The use of slaves in the early mining industry is something I simply was not aware of… but is not surprising if one thinks about it…

    While labor abuses by coal companies were touched on, I noticed there was no discussion of legacy environmental issues like acid rain, coal ash ponds, unreclaimed abandoned mines, and acid mine drainage. We are still paying the price for the profits made by the industry – rightly so, you might say, look at the benefits. I will note that there was $11 billion included in Biden’s infrastructure legislation to fund the Abandoned Mine Reclamation Fund (the original program was funded by a per ton tax on current coal companies but was never going to even scratch the surface of the problem). Can we agree, then, that at least this $11 billion is money well spent given the role these mines and the industry played in our country’s history? Seems like the least we could do, no…?

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      Coal mining also occurred and is occurring around the world which also helped bring those countries into the industrial age but also has had impacts on people who mined the coal, as well as the damage to the landscape and people who breathed the effluent in cities where it was burned for heat and electricity.

      We can look at coal in similar ways we look at other things that powered the economy, brought benefits to people as well as harm and ultimately we found better, less damaging ways to accomplish better outcomes.

      Tobacco is a clear example of something with tremendous economic benefits as well as damage. Lead in gasoline, paint and other things caused tremendous damage to humans even though it was a vital component in things like gasoline and paints.

      Asbestos is another. The list is long.

      We don’t look back and bemoan that we are moving away from these things. We look ahead to how we can benefit from far less damaging things.

      We learn and we make changes and go forward.

      Coal served an important role back when we had no alternatives. We know better know and are using coal less and less, even as we were promised “clean coal technology” at one point, it seems to have disappeared from the lexicon.

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        Fossil fuels, however, really do leave a legacy of problems behind that simply don’t go away without a significant liability being assumed by today’s (or tomorrow’s as the case may be) taxpayers. Yes, we still are remediating PCBs and some of the worst hazardous materials (asbestos, lead-based paint, mercury, etc) along with closed steel mills and other industrial plants but these problems are pretty much being handled by the private sector (under government oversight and regulation) and pale in comparison to abandoned mines, manufactured gas plants, abandoned oil and gas wells, abandoned pipelines and other fossil fuel legacies. Our kids will still be paying the price for the rest of their lives as will their kids, most likely.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          Other legacy industry issues also.

          A titanium mine on the Tye River. The tailings still leech into the river.

          Superfund sites throughout Virginia.

          In Hopewell, Allied Chemical and Kepone (still in the river)

          The Avtex plant in Front Royal that made stuff for NASA, asbestos, PCBs, acids, mercury, lead

          etc, etc..

          All of these things powered the local economy…. as Haner relates… banks, grocery, furniture, etc

    2. Randy Huffman Avatar
      Randy Huffman

      Don’t know the exact date for oil and gas but I know you could not open a mine since the mid 70’s without setting up reserves to reclaim it when mining is complete (and monitor water quality, etc.). Lots of abandoned mines that predate the 70’s of course, but at least for the last 45 years or so of mining companies are responsible for reclamation.

      I doubt (and I do not know, just speculating) you can say the same for India or China, and China burns about 10 times more coal than the US. That’s one of several reasons they can make stuff so cheap.

      1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        1977 is the date for the regulations requiring reclamation. The damage had already been done and continues today. I remediated one of the first oil refineries which was built in 1879 and operated for 100 years so that gives you an idea of the time frame. There are hundreds of thousands of orphaned oil and gas wells that remained unabandoned and unreclaimed in the US today. Even today, small oil and gas companies go belly up and give up their insufficient reclamation bond and leave the tax payers holding the bag. The liability these fossil fuel companies stuck us with is jaw dropping. China should not be our standard.

        1. Randy Huffman Avatar
          Randy Huffman

          Of course there are alot of issues from the past, but you ask about our children. If it had not been for our forefathers, our grandfathers/mothers and parents, and fossil fuels, where would we be? You try and take knowledge and technology from today and assume they would have been available to them, but they were not.

          You talk about what was stuck us, what about the Trillions in National Debt and massive deficit spending we are sticking our children with, just so we can live more comfortably?

  6. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    VPI still offers a BS in Mineral Engineering. Looks like a superior program. Many scholarships, guaranteed internships, and a high success rate in job placement. Mining still has a place in Virginia.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      None of the green intermittent, electrified nonsense will ever get built without far more massive mining, and some pretty awful environmental degradation. Worldwide. Larry and the others are completely ignorant. They are tools of the same economic forces that drove the past century.

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      None of the green intermittent, electrified nonsense will ever get built without far more massive mining, and some pretty awful environmental degradation. Worldwide. Larry and the others are completely ignorant. They are tools of the same economic forces that drove the past century.

      1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
        James Wyatt Whitehead

        VPI has a virtual mine! Sort of like a wind tunnel I think for aerospace engineers. Based on what I saw from the school website mining is very techy now. VT even owns one of those supersized Tonka dump trucks.

      2. Matt Adams Avatar

        As long as that mining and the ecological disasters don’t occur in their preview, they care not.

        Those industries will also not survive without generous subsidies that will dwarf what has been given to the fossil fuel industry.

        Oil, coal and they liked induced numerous bankruptcies and ruined people and families. The green energy crowd, just gets a government loan, closes shop and runs with the free billions.

  7. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    My grandfather the banker and his brother the lawyer made excellent livings in Tazewell County off the coal industry without ever entering the mines. The SCOTUS souvenir quill pens on my great uncle’s law office desk all came from coal industry cases he argued in that courtroom (I’m thinking four, but I may be exaggerating in memory). I still have two dollar bills my grandfather gave me, telling me his bank got them by the bushel and the coal firms would hand them out at payday, so the local merchants got a major reminder where the money came from that kept them alive, too. Everything is a mix of good and bad. But I still have stock in that bank and take my dividend twice a year, so the link to King Coal holds in my life.

    My other grandfather was in the natural gas business. Pretty fun to read everybody moaning about the fossil fuels which have created the greatest accumulations of wealth and most comfortable living standards in the history of our species, even as the population has exploded to 8 billion. Biting the hand….

    1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      Haner, we have and continue to pay dearly for the contributions fossil fuels have made to our country and standard of living. Nothing is free – was it worth it? That is really the question… I don’t have an answer… but rose colored glasses certainly won’t give you clarity on the subject…

      1. Coal powered the industrial revolution. Without it we would not be sitting high on the mountain of technology we enjoy today. So, worth it, hell yes, but is it a a good road for the future, no.

        We need to find better ways to generate and store power, and we are. It’s not simple, easy or quick, but it will get figured out a piece at a time and we will get there. Just gotta keep from cutting off our noses to spite our faces in the meantime. That may be harder.

        1. Matt Adams Avatar

          Right or wrong I’m of the opinion that unless people have skin in the game it wont advance, because their is no incentive. They get paid via the Government, if they fail so why succeed.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar

      do we bite the hand for other toxins embedded in products we need and use:

      Commercial Uses for PCBs
      Although no longer commercially produced in the United States, PCBs may be present in products and materials produced before the 1979 PCB ban. Products that may contain PCBs include:

      Transformers and capacitors
      Electrical equipment including voltage regulators, switches, re-closers, bushings, and electromagnets
      Oil used in motors and hydraulic systems
      Old electrical devices or appliances containing PCB capacitors
      Fluorescent light ballasts
      Cable insulation
      Thermal insulation material including fiberglass, felt, foam, and cork
      Adhesives and tapes
      Oil-based paint
      Caulking
      Plastics
      Carbonless copy paper
      Floor finish

      How about DDT?

      Lead in gasoline and paint?

      or any of the dozens/hundreds of materials that provided great benefits to us and the economy and later found to be deadly and had to be phased out?

      We’re not going back to PCBs, or leaded gasoline or any of the other toxic substances, we know better.

      And we’re not going back to most other substances we found to be hazardous and harmful.

      One of the differences today, is that if we find a new substance like lead and say it is dangerous, some people would not believe it and accuse science and govt of foisting a hoax.

      1. how_it_works Avatar
        how_it_works

        Conversely, if we have a substance we know is bad like vinyl chloride, and it spills in a small town in Ohio, and the government says there’s nothing wrong with the water or the air, some people would not believe it and accuse the govt of foisting a hoax.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          On most any disaster of this kind involving a private sector company and the govt, for as long as I can remember, decades, that kind of dynamic is possible. The govt has gotten blame on most of the superfunds sites for “allowing” those companies to do what they did that then resulted in a superfund site, then the govt gets blamed for administering the superfund site also.

          They are impugned for not carrying out tougher enforcement and regulation even though others will go after the govt for making things harder for the private sector companies.

    3. Take care of those $2 bills. They can be worth surprising money, up to $4,500.

      https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/finance-economy/big-money-$2-bills-could-worth-$4500

  8. Peter Galuszka Avatar
    Peter Galuszka

    For my take on coal, see my 2012 book “Thunder on the Mountain. Death at Massey and the Dirty Secrets Behind Big Coal” (St. Martin’s Press, West Virginia University Press).

    I also contributed to a documentary film “Blood on the Mountain” (2016) that ran on Netflix for a couple of years and can be streamed on Amazon.

Leave a Reply