Bylined Utility Puffery in Richmond Times-Dominion

by Steve Haner

I guess what shows up in the driveway every morning is now called the Richmond Times-Dominion.

On yesterday’s front page, and today picked up and spread across the state by the Virginia Public Access Project, was a long, puffy public relations piece about Dominion’s proposed Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project. It was written by the paper’s climate-alarmism correspondent Sean Sublette. It was a byline on a company news release, not something real newspapers do.

What the casual observer will miss is that it also represents a trend. The same writer, who came to the paper from a climate alarmism non-profit, about a week earlier wrote a similarly one-sided report based on Dominion’s claims of coming success in its rollout of utility-scale battery projects. Back on April 1, he quoted the company’s own cheery take on a recent State Corporation Commission approval of various solar and storage projects.

All three articles quoted only company spokesmen and provided only the company spin.  Readers who stopped there would know nothing about any disputes during the SCC proceedings, long-term costs to consumers, or any of the widespread doubts about the reliability of the underlying technology.

One such story earns a yawn. Three in three weeks, and now with the longest one getting picked up and treated as actual journalism by VPAP, requires the throwing of a flag. This is the same VPAP which continues to refuse to share any of my extensive reporting on the wind project application or the recent solar projects. Re-writes of pure company PR pass muster instead.

And for an example of quality work, look in the same VPAP string for Laurence Hammack’s very balanced report on the similar renewable projects application pending from Appalachian Power Company, which serves The Roanoke Times territory. It is possible that two recent posts of mine on Bacon’s Rebellion alerted that paper to the fight down at the SCC, but the reporting is all his, including, apparently, some time monitoring the (very dry) hearing last week.

Hammack also picks up on the debate over secrecy in the company filing (and also in Dominion’s), which may soon draw a ruling from the SCC hearing officer. The other “real” newspapers in the state, perhaps also under Dominion’s thumb, so far show no concerns about the widespread hiding of data on consumer costs and ratepayer risk. When the company press releases arrive, they will rearrange a few paragraphs and slap on bylines.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

29 responses to “Bylined Utility Puffery in Richmond Times-Dominion”

  1. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Can Virginia Press Association awards for this guy come next? Do that and Dominion will sponsor the dinner! (Wait, maybe it already does…)

  2. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    Can Virginia Press Association awards for this guy come next? Do that and Dominion will sponsor the dinner! (Wait, maybe it already does…)

  3. DJRippert Avatar
    DJRippert

    Steve – I can understand why Virginia’s politicians are in Dominion’s pocket. The unlimited campaign donations coupled with minimal campaign donation spending reporting tell the tale.

    But why would the newspapers be beholden to Dominion?

    Just laziness?

    1. energyNOW_Fan Avatar
      energyNOW_Fan

      Liberal bent advancing the notion that preventing Armageddon requires supporting all renewable projects and shutting down fossil fuels.

  4. DJRippert Avatar
    DJRippert

    Steve – I can understand why Virginia’s politicians are in Dominion’s pocket. The unlimited campaign donations coupled with minimal campaign donation spending reporting tell the tale.

    But why would the newspapers be beholden to Dominion?

    Just laziness?

  5. An obvious question: How much advertising does Dominion do in the RTD?

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      During session, at least, full-page ads touting renewable energy were commonplace. All of Dominion’s required public notices for SCC proceedings are printed there, probably at far greater expense than regular display rates. it is a big advertiser I’m sure. I strongly suspect this particular staff position is sponsored in some way with outside dollars, although until this I didn’t think it might be Dominion helping to pay his salary.

      When AG Miyares filed testimony challenging some aspects of the wind program, the RTD had a story on that from Patrick Wilson. But that was the last coverage it has given the case, including no report so far on the SCC staff analysis that challenged the basic LCOE calculation and laid the groundwork for a rejection. That was….news. Yet was largely ignored.

  6. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    I don’t read the RTD’s articles on Dominion. I depend on your reporting.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Well, I feel better when Ivy Main also gives her perspective.

      here’s a good example – very informative:

      https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/a8f15b9cd8b315cbc7f39ccb6670d9331be5731efa0ff50e5c38c4109b5a0e95.jpg

      https://www.virginiamercury.com/2021/06/02/whats-with-the-scary-ads-about-threats-to-your-power-service/

      By the way, as much as Steve seems to dislike RTD these days, he also does not appear to love Virginia Mercury or WaPo either.

      what are we going to do? there is no good media!

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Ms. Main writes mainly commentary, as I do. I read her too. And as much as I can disdain the Virginia Mercury, its reporters put it far more effort than Sublette did to see if there is another point of view. Mercury’s bias is mainly displayed in what it chooses to ignore (as it has ignored this wind case so far.)

      2. David Wojick Avatar
        David Wojick

        Happily, Newspapers are a small and hopefully shrinking part of media. Social media dominate for many people. I never read newspaper articles unless they are being discussed on social media, here for example.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          yepper, social media is how to get educated for sure… not surprised you favor it…

          1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
            Eric the half a troll

            Jesus… but unsurprising…

  7. Moderate Avatar

    It has been years since the RTD has published an op-ed that I’ve written in an attempt to get other ideas out there. I haven’t even sent them anything recently. There’s no point.

  8. Ronnie Chappell Avatar
    Ronnie Chappell

    Makes me long for the days of Democratic gubernatorial candidate Herry “Keep the Big Boys Honest” Howell who in three unsuccessful election bids proclaimed that “It’s wrong for people in North Carolina to pay less for electricity generated in Virginia than the people of Virginia.

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Last time I checked, Dominion’s NC rates were indeed lower. Much of this VCEA nonsense will be VA jurisdictional customers only.

      1. Steven Curtis Avatar
        Steven Curtis

        It is always easier to show lower rates when subsidies prop up the back end. Let’s see what they are without subsidies.

    2. DJRippert Avatar
      DJRippert

      Howlin’ Henry Howell was ahead of his time.

    3. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      You are showing your age.

  9. Steven Curtis Avatar
    Steven Curtis

    Everything the Government “funds” is a failure. It is then boosted by more “funding”, all without any set project plans, timelines, or even milestone accomplishments with penalties. If the Government wants to be in business, at least they should be responsible for the result. But, no. They pass that risk to us and we smile gladly and accept it. Does Dominion want offshore wind? Fine. Let them get capital investors and take all the risk off the taxpayers back. If that does not sound good to them, why should it sound good to us? Free enterprise is inherently honest. You can lie and believe all you want, but you will get poor very quickly if you do not produce something worth buying. It is scary when we allow companies to dictate what and how our Government spends the money of “we the people”, especially when they stand to make a profit, particularly when it drives the creation of a monopoly. “Pay me now, or pay me later”, I guess, but taxation without representation for our grandchildren seems unethical to me.

  10. David Wojick Avatar
    David Wojick

    We journalists call it “regurgitating the press release”. And yes the sure sign is the fill up of happy company quotes from execs. AP does a good bit of this. It saves a lot of time. If I work from a PR I at least add my own thoughts, sometimes inventing an anonymous commenter to say them. Much fun that.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      in another thread you say you favor social media then in this thread you claim to be a journalist… Is it a revelation that media touts some business and industry and has for decades?

      1. f/k/a_tmtfairfax Avatar
        f/k/a_tmtfairfax

        No problem with that so long as they don’t claim to be honest brokers of news, reporting everything as fairly as possible.

        Peter says that’s an obsolete model of journalism. The Media needs a point to make. If so, why isn’t social media just as good? One can read an account of some event on multiple sources and, over time, get a fell as what’s a good source and what is not.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar
          LarrytheG

          Would you characterize social media any differently than you might the many other blogs on the internet in terms of whether the information is reliable and not disinformation and conspiracy theories?

          how do you vett the information?

          I know it’s popular to point out that media like the WaPO IS biased but how many folks believed the election was stolen and went to DC to take it back?

          How many people BELIEVE conspiracy theories and things simply not true and claim that traditional media lies and social media and blogs is where the truth is?

          if you don’t believe the traditional media who do you believe and how do you know it’s actually true?

      2. Eric the half a troll Avatar
        Eric the half a troll

        “We journalists…” ROFLMAO….😂🤣😂🤣

  11. Ruckweiler Avatar
    Ruckweiler

    Get so tired of these Chicken Little lefties and their hysteria on any given subject. Time to figuratively kick them in the teeth to stop this lunacy.

  12. I think Dominion Times-Dispatch rolls off the tongue more smoothly than Richmond Times-Dominion

    1. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Maybe it will pick up this decent AP report on the status of the application, which appeared yesterday. As the hearing approaches perhaps more coverage will develop:

      https://apnews.com/article/business-environment-virginia-atlantic-ocean-bfc8d0af045261111376987f80aca1a1

  13. William O'Keefe Avatar
    William O’Keefe

    Sean Sublette is a hack masquerading as a meteorologist. My guess is that he publishes little that is original. I started subscribing to the RTD almost 2 decades ago and until earlier this month watched it go down hill but rise in cost. As a subsidiary of Dominion, it’s lack of quality may tell us a lot about what we will get from 176 windmills!

Leave a Reply