Boom! Youngkin Drops a Bomb on Virginia’s Educational Establishment

by James A. Bacon

Signaling his intention to transform Virginia’s public school system, Governor-elect Glenn Youngkin announced today the appointment of outsiders to the positions of superintendent and assistant superintendent of public instruction — the top two officials in the Virginia Department of Education.

Jillian Balow, Wyoming Superintendent of Public Instruction

Jillian Balow, superintendent of Wyoming’s public schools, landed the top slot. Elizabeth Schultz, a senior fellow with Parents Defending Education and an outspoken foe of Critical Race Theory in Virginia schools, will be Balow’s deputy.

“Jillian and Elizabeth are going to be crucial in helping Secretary of Education Aimee Guidera restore excellence in education,” Youngkin said in making the announcement. “Under my direction, they will get to work on ensuring our schools remain safely open, ban critical race theory and political agendas from our classrooms, and rebuild our crumbling schools.”

Elizabeth Schultz, assistant superintendent

Wow. Youngkin’s campaign rhetoric wasn’t just campaign rhetoric. He’s not recruiting retreads from the Virginia public school system. Between Balow, Schultz, and Aimee Guidera, his pick for Secretary of Education, he’s putting in charge three outsiders not beholden to the educational establishment in any way.

Balow is a fifth-generation Wyoming native who graduated from the University of Wyoming. She taught in Wyoming classrooms for ten years. Among her accomplishments as superintendent of Wyoming’s public schools, says her profile page:

  • She led the transformation of the state’s early literacy laws “into some of the most rigorous in the country.”
  • Worked with tribal partners to enact “Indian Education for All” so that Wyoming students would learn about the history of the Northern Arapahoe and Eastern Shoshone tribes.
  • Hewing to the belief that “small government is best,” reduced in-agency personnel by 11% and agency operating funds by 15%.
  • Overhauled the state standards review process to be the most collaborative and transparent in the nation.

Schultz, by contrast, does have Virginia ties. A graduate of James Madison University, she served eight years on the Fairfax County School Board. As a senior executive in Parents Defending Education, she has been an outspoken critic of Northam administration education policy. You can get a flavor for her thinking in a column published in Bacon’s Rebellion: “The Left Is Lying: CRT Is Peddling Hate in Our Schools.”

Bacon’s bottom line: Glenn Youngkin will not be a “business as usual” governor. His cabinet picks are ample proof that he will not shy away from confrontation. I can promise you, the next four years will be eventful.

As an aside, I wonder if the media and punditry will credit Youngkin with appointing a team of three strong women to transform Virginia’s public schools.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

51 responses to “Boom! Youngkin Drops a Bomb on Virginia’s Educational Establishment”

  1. Three white women with conservative roots who use the English language to spell their names… so much for diversity.

    1. John Harvie Avatar
      John Harvie

      At least they are pronouncable…

      1. OK – you WIN!!!! best comment this month.

    2. vicnicholls Avatar
      vicnicholls

      I dont care the color as long as they get back to teaching where we could hold our own with Asian countries. Minorities are not stupid, and constantly saying you’re trash doesn’t help them to fulfill the high potential they have.

      1. You’re as competent as you believe you are regardless of your color, gender, or anything else!

  2. killerhertz Avatar
    killerhertz

    I didn’t see any men with female names so I call this a win.

  3. Virginia Project Avatar
    Virginia Project

    Youngkin is going to surprise everyone by being genuinely what he sold himself as

  4. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    So does this mean Youngkin will end the horrid practice of providing tampons to girls in our public schools…?!

    https://mailchi.mp/ea936076ac1f/200000-in-free-tampons-school-boundary-changes-for-equity-more?fbclid=IwAR293VVFtT7Uu6LXBoBtf8V_q-4NJcl52t36hZnJnTbZHngC8ZjKmRDVIrQ

    1. how_it_works Avatar
      how_it_works

      Hah. When I went to Virginia schools, you were lucky if there was even any toilet paper in the bathrooms. Didn’t improve my perception of this state any.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        trying to remember where you came from that was better than Virginia – was it New Jersey?

        1. how_it_works Avatar
          how_it_works

          Wasn’t New Jersey. More like “flyover country”.

          Oh yea, the non-airconditioned middle school was a nice touch too.

          1. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Can’t overfly NJ. The engines keep stalling because of chemical gas leaks.

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            so where was the better place you came from? 😉

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        I still think the TP is an issue but mitigated by corn cobs.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          and they easily mimic other items in the toilet and sewer system!

          1. Nancy Naive Avatar
            Nancy Naive

            Alligators?

    2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Just in the boys’ bathrooms.

  5. LarrytheG Avatar

    The Wyoming lady seems legit and has experience in dealing with marginalized populations so that’s good. The deputy is from a anonymously-funded organization – not a good thing in terms of transparency. Youngkin has a winner on this issue. The Dems have lost a lot of credibility on the CRT issue.

  6. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    State Superintendent in Wyoming is an elected position. Interesting. The thread tying much of this national reach together is the Heritage Foundation, which of course has also been home to the new Secretary of the Commonwealth, Kay Cole James. I bet she knew Balow.

  7. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    It will be a tall order to restore trust and confidence in public education.

  8. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    “The Weaponization of a State Bureaucracy” is the working title of a book I am working on to describe the use by Ralph Northman’s political appointees, the Secretary of Education, the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Board of Education, of Virginia Department of Education to advance radical progressive agendas. They have cut down everything in their path, including teachers, parents and children.

    I hope these women can begin to repair the damage. They will not be able to repair the irredeemable void in the learning of this generation of K-12 kids caused by the Union-driven shutdowns and the radicalization of the curricula, but they can help the next. God bless them.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      “Union-driven shutdowns”? You are confusing Virginia with Chicago. At the beginning of the pandemic, many parents were demanding that schools switch to virtual.

      https://www.chesterfieldobserver.com/articles/parents-teachers-petition-for-schools-to-delay-reopening-until-staff-are-vaccinated/

      http://www.connectionnewspapers.com/news/2020/nov/28/virtual-or-person-arlington/

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        and still and amazing that , that gets willingly ignored …. as if it’s not true!

        once more – Virginia ranks in the top 10 of the nation on public schools. It’s wrong-headed and untrue what conservative folks like Sherlock are claiming. It’s like they are in an alternative universe of facts and realities – like blathering about “unions’ in Virginia!

        And to point out, that several of the states that are higher in public school performance than Virginia – ARE actual true Union states.

        Some folks have myopic perspectives on public schools that don’t comport with the facts and realities but they just keep on like that don’t matter.

        1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
          James C. Sherlock

          See my reply to Dick. Another alternative universe.

          1. LarrytheG Avatar

            well, an alternative universe is calling an education association a union when it’s clearly not …. but that’s par for the course these days with some folks. A lie, repeated over and over becomes the truth for some.

          2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            You throw around the term “lie” with abandon.

            Are you really going to try to find a difference between the Fairfax Educators Association or the Fairfax County Federation of Teachers and a union?

            Define the difference. Take all the time you need.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar

            lying is misrepresenting the truth – not throwing that around – just plainly stated.

            And conservatives these days are doing it with abandon on a variety of issues.

            The ‘difference’ you speak of? Are they are recognized union with NLRB with exclusive bargaining rights with an ability to strike ?

            Now you need to come back and let me know is it’s a lie…. you KNOW it is.

          4. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            Go to The Fairfax County Federation of teachers website. https://www.fcft.org You will see this banner:

            “Fairfax County Federation of Teachers – Your AFT Union for Education Professionals”

            Scroll down. You will see the exhortation “Our union must win collective bargaining.”

            You may wish to contact them and tell them they are lying. And for heaven’s sake stop it.

          5. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
            James Wyatt Whitehead

            “Fairfax County Federation of Teachers is affiliated with the American Federation of Teachers and AFL-CIO.”

          6. A pandemic of the un-vaccinated is a great example LtG.

        2. Matt Hurt Avatar

          Virginia should rank at least 10th in education. The state ranks 8th in average household income. It is quite likely that Virginia’s educational outcomes are more linked to household income that educational policy or practice.

          1. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            Wonder what it would rank in household income without the contribution of “Occupied Northern Virginia”.

          2. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
            James Wyatt Whitehead

            Agreed.

      2. DJRippert Avatar

        Nice try. Cherry picking small, local groups.

        “As early as June 2020, following a nightmarish spring of remote learning, polling began to indicate that parents were fed up. Then, 56 percent of parents wanted to see children back in school full-time by the fall, according to Gallup.”

        https://www.msnbc.com/opinion/covid-school-closures-backfired-democrats-big-way-n1283734

        Yeah, from MSNBC.

        Parents weren’t the problem, teachers’ unions were.

      3. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        Fairfax County educators union wants schools to stay closed for remainder of school year

        By Ike Ejiochi and FOX 5 Digital Team Published October 20, 2020

        “FAIRFAX COUNTY, Va. (FOX 5 DC) – One of the two largest educators’ unions in Fairfax County says schools should remain closed for the remainder of the academic year. ”

        ” The Fairfax Educators Association wrote a letter to the school board and superintendent asking that the district “draw and hold the line by keeping Fairfax County Public Schools virtual for the remainder of the 2020-21 school year” because of the health threat represented by the COVID-19 pandemic.”

        “The union says data supports the case that no one should return to in-person instruction until a proven vaccine is widely available.”

        That union represented 4,000 Fairfax County Teachers.

        “Another union representing educators in Fairfax County – the Fairfax County Federation of Teachers – holds a differing position.”

        The FCFT is asking the district to “delay reopening until there is a clear plan in place and the district adopts our 11 Pillars of a Safe Reopening” plan.

        The union says data supports the case that no one should return to in-person instruction until a proven vaccine is widely available.”

        My Note. Catholic schools in Virginia opened in September of 2020 and stayed open.

        1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
          Dick Hall-Sizemore

          You give one example of “union” action. I gave examples of large numbers of parents calling on the schools to close in-person education. The shutdowns were not all union-driven as you implied.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar

      Good lord!

    3. Jake Spivey Avatar
      Jake Spivey

      In re: “…radical progressive agendas,” you left out Dr. Underwood.

  9. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    It is always good to have a fresh perspective. On the other hand, one of the pitfalls of bringing in someone new is the steep learning curve. It will be interesting to see how someone from the smallest state in the country adjusts to Virginia. Here are some contrasts:

    Total population
    Wyoming–576,851
    Virginia–8.6 million

    Largest city/county
    Wyoming–city, Cheyenne, 65,132; Laramie County (contains Cheyenne), 100,512
    Virginia–Fairfax County, 1.1 million (almost twice as many as in whole state of Wyoming). 17 cities or counties have larger population than Laramie Co.

    Percent nonHispanic White
    Wyoming–84
    Virginia 61

    Total K-12 student population:
    Wyoming–91,938
    Virginia–1.2 million total; Fairfax County–178,635; Loudoun and Prince William ADM about the same as the Wyoming state total

    There are a lot of other differences as well. For example, a significant portion of the financing for Wyoming schools comes from federal mineral royalties. Another difference: Wyoming is a one-party state, while Virginia is a competitive two-party state.

    Her approach to public education certainly seems to be in synch with Youngkin. I hope that she is successful in addressing the weaknesses in the Virginia public education system.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      I’m a bit of a skeptic also but willing to give a chance.

      Virginia has some of the best schools in the country. They send 70% of their kids to college.

      As a state, we rank 10th or better but if you took out the low schools, we’d rank up near the top in this country and in the top 10 in worldwide PISA Rankings.

      It’s the low kids that pull down our overall rankings.

      We don’t do a good job with kids who live in “at-risk” circumstances, often with a poorly-educated parents who earns low income often as a laborer and they live in a neighborhood with others like themselves and the neighborhood school reflects that demographic. If you look at the SOL scores for a given county, like Henrico or Fairfax, one can easily identify these low-SOL schools.

      When one looks at an individual school with low average scores – like 40-50%, the truth is even worse, there are kids scoring even lower than that and the higher-rated kids bring that average up a bit.

      Youngkins challenge – along with his appointed ED leaders is how to deal with these education problems with these demographics. I’m not sure they have issues like that in Wyoming except perhaps on Native American reservations which may be different than Virginia’s at-risk kids.

      At some point, soon, we’ll find out what Youngkin actually has in mind and how much is substantive and focused and how much is PR.

      It’s no mystery how most Dems see this problem.
      They want paid child care, Universal Pre-K AND they want continued supports for at-risk kids as they go through the grades – their problem can’t be fixed with one-shot fixes.

      Conservatives think different about the problem and have their own ideas. I don’t think charter schools are a magical answer and, in fact, Charters appeal to and attract higher income demographics and most of the Charters we already have – serve that demographic not the low-income at-risk demographic.

      Let’s see how Youngkin and crew carry that ball.

    2. Yep, being an outsider has its pros and cons. Balow has a steep learning curve ahead. We’ll find out quickly how quick a learner she is.

      1. Matt Hurt Avatar

        If you want the same outcomes, do the same thing. If you want different outcomes, try something different.

        1. DJRippert Avatar

          The Byrd Machine throwbacks in this state believe you will fall of the edge of the Earth if you venture past Virginia’s borders.

          The “Virginia Way” involves almost complete dependence on the federal government for the state’s economy along with a plan by the politicians to skim a meaningful piece of that economy into their own pockets.

          Youngkin is not a member of Virginia’s Plantation Elite (which Northam was/is). Youngkin can see the merit of looking outside of Virginia for ideas. Northam never could see that.

    3. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Basically, she has the same experience as the Superintendent of Norfolk City Schools. Well, better Wyoming than Kansas or Tennessee.

      1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        See my reply to Dick about the experience of Northam’s picks.

    4. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      How soon we forget.

      James Lane, Northam’s Secretary of Public Instruction, came from a job as Superintendent of Chesterfield County Public Schools. ADM 62,500.

      Northam’s Secretary of Education was a failed Democratic politician plucked from a Middle School classroom. ADM, 25.

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        I always thought Qarni was a strange and mistaken selection and was not very effective. It was one of Northam’s worst appointments, if not the worst. Lane came from one of the larger school divisions in the state and was familiar with the public school system of the Commonwealth. From what I could tell, he was a competent Superintendent, who was seriously hampered by the pandemic.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          I totally agree about Qarni… just totally weird..

      2. And Lane was only in Chesterfield for two years. Before that, Goochland – 2,600 students.

  10. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    Virtually every comment in this thread is a proxy for the loss of public confidence in political leadership which by politicizing issues exacerbates conditions. Elected officials are rarely heard to call for calm and advising that the crisis is being addressed. Nope. It’s easier to amplify the conflict. In this case by recruiting bona fide partisans or unknowns. Youngkin did not have to pledge to eliminate the non-existence of CRT from school curricula.

  11. Merchantseamen Avatar
    Merchantseamen

    “rebuild our crumbling schools.” I blame it on lousy maintenance practices. Billions of dollars poured into these school and the maintenance is terrible. Bust that overpaid union and get some people in there that know how to maintain.

Leave a Reply