Bolling Defends Incentives for Job Creation

Bill Bolling at Virginia Blogger Day conference.

Governor Bob McDonnell, like governors before him, issues a statement  touting jobs created and capital invested every time the Virginia Economic Development Partnership (VEDP) is involved in a corporate investment project. The closing paragraph of seemingly every press release notes that the deal was cemented by a contribution from the governor’s “opportunity” fund or some other government entity. When the giveaways get too extravagant, free market purists like Norm Leahy over at Bearing Drift and me erupt in ritual denunciation, even though we know that no one is likely to pay any heed.

Given the frequency of the press releases, one might be forgiven for thinking that no corporation makes an investment in Virginia without extracting its pound of flesh from the taxpayers. It is somewhat reassuring to discover that the subsidies are not as ubiquitous as I had feared.

Economic development projects receiving incentives account for only 13.7% of all “announced projects” of 20 jobs or more and less than half of all projects involving the VEDP since the beginning of the McDonnell administration, according to data released by Lieutenant Governor Bill Bolling’s office. But they have a big impact, accounting for 25.9% of all net job creation in Virginia and 36.4% of all investment.

Bolling distributed the data and defended the administration’s track record on job creation during “Virginia Blogger Day,” an event for Republican and/or conservative bloggers (I’m not sure which category they had me confused with) that involved give-and-take with Bolling, senior legislators and political pundits, and was capped off by a reception in the governor’s mansion attended by McDonnell and several members of his cabinet.

“Our focus has been taking our conservative principles and applying them to things that need to be done,” said Bolling. The “McDonnell/Bolling administration” rolled back state spending to levels prevailing in 2006 even while re-prioritizing that spending, investing more than $100 million in economic development programs, raising funding for higher education and pumping $4 billion into transportation projects.

Tucker Martin, McDonnell’s director of communications, was on hand to confirm that the governor views Bolling, who faces a stiff challenge from Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli for the Republican nomination for governor, as an integral member of his team. McDonnell has anointed the lieutenant governor as the state jobs czar. Meanwhile, Bolling’s visibility has increased markedly since he has been called in as the tie-breaker on numerous votes in the state senate stocked with 20 Rs and 20 Ds.

Bolling vigorously defended the use of incentives as a tool to bring jobs to Virginia. “We are not throwing incentives at every economic development deal. We target them very carefully,” he said. Only 14% of major projects receive incentives, and corporations must commit contractually to create the promised jobs and investment or face clawbacks when they don’t deliver.

“In a perfect world, we wouldn’t have to incentivize anyone,” said Bolling. “But I don’t live in a perfect world . … We could do away with corporate incentives tomorrow but we’re not going to get these incentive-driven deals.”

Bolling came across as informed, well spoken, likable and a man who can be reasoned with. I expect that the Main Street business community wing of the Republican Party will be very comfortable with him. He is very much in the mold of Mitt Romney, whom he supports for president. But with his gray hair, extra pounds and low-key demeanor, he sometimes fades into the background. His blandness spares him the barbs and invective that Democrats hurl at Cuccinelli, but he lacks the intensity and charisma that enables the Cooch to fire up the GOP faithful. It will be interesting to see what mood Virginia Republicans are in a year from now and what kind of gubernatorial candidate they will be looking for.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

2 responses to “Bolling Defends Incentives for Job Creation”

  1. DJRippert Avatar

    From Bill Bolling’s web site:

    “Increase teacher pay to the national average
    Provide incentive pay for teachers teaching in high demand specialties and in high risk school districts
    Merit pay to reward our best teachers and make certain that teacher compensation is tied to performance
    Eliminate teacher tenure”

    There are about 71,000 public school teachers in Virginia. They make about $6,000 per year less than the national average. Getting Virginia’s teachers up to the national average wil cost about $426M per year. Add salary based costs, the merit and incentive pay and we can round it off at $500M per year.

    Also from his web site:

    “Tax credits for parents who choose to send their children to private, parochial or home schools”

    Ok, there are about 113,000 Virginia students attending private schools. How much of a tax credit would be meaningful? $500? That’s $65M in lost taxes.

    “More AP, IB and dual enrollment classes for students who want to pursue a college education”

    Ok, who knows what this might cost. How about $35M per year?

    Billy Boy just added $600M per year to the state bar tab.

    Let’s go to public safety:

    “Putting more law enforcement officers on our streets by increasing state funding for local law enforcement positions from 1:1500 to 1:1000 citizens
    Increasing the salary and benefits of Virginia’s law enforcement professionals”.

    Virginia has 8M citizens. So, we must have 8M/1500 law enforcement officers. That’s 5,300. We’ll need 8M/1,000 or 8,000. That’s an addition of 2,700. Let’s say the Virginia average salary is $40,000. Plus benefits, squad cars, guns, bullets, etc. We’ll call it $60,000. That’s another $162M per year.

    What are we up to? $762M?

    Jim, you sure this guy’s a Republican?

    And we haven’t even talked about transportation or health care yet.

    I don’t have any problems with Bolling’s ideas other than where he’ll get the money to pay for them.

    Will he be the first Republican in Virginia history to admit he’ll raise taxes if elected?

  2. these are substantive ideas… they will definitely upset the status quo applecart!

    re: tax credit

    I would presume that people who homeschool or sent their kids to private school would want ALL of their tax money back – and the state could do it by crediting them on their taxes and then taking that amount of money out of what the state sends to the school.

    Of all the blather about charter schools and the like – this one simple step would change the public school game.

    Any parent could pull their kid out of the public schools and get a tax credit for doing so.

    do we like that idea as is without any further strings attached?

    you can bet that local school systems and counties would descend on the General Assembly in droves to lobby against this.

    but if you believe that the public schools have or are failing.. then support for this one simple step would be a gamer changer.

    how about it. How many who comment here would support that?

Leave a Reply