Image credit: MyVaccineUpdate.com

by Joe Fitzgerald

About one in 16 American adults suffer with chronic pulmonary disease. Serious health guidelines say they’re the primary ones who should not wear masks. Some of them still can, but a figure of 6% is about the maximum of adults who shouldn’t wear them.

The governor of Virginia, elected to eradicate a subject that isn’t being taught, has decided that removing masks from public schools is the hill he wants to die on.

The two possibilities are that he truly believes life-saving mask mandates in public schools threaten personal freedom, or that he wants to pick a fight early on to exhibit his strength as governor.

The latter seems more likely. And while even some people are his side of the aisle are smart enough to see what he’s doing, a lot of the people who voted for him aren’t. They elected a reality TV star as president and now a financial speculator as governor. Somehow the image of a private equity manager struck them as more John Wayne than Jacob Marley.
How much of a logical leap is it to say a governor’s belligerent stance on masks enabled the woman who said she’d bring a weapon to a public school to keep her child from having to wear a mask?

The anti-maskers belong in the same category as those who say that fluoridation of water is a political conspiracy or that vaccines cause autism. I shudder to think what damage those ideas could have done if they’d been introduced for the first time in an age of NewsMax, Breitbart, Fox & Friends, and opportunistic, rapacious businessmen running for public office.

Follow-up stories and posts about the woman threatening the School Board said that she apologized. What could she have said? I didn’t realize offering to oppose a public-health precaution at the point of a gun in a school full of children was illegal? Or maybe she thought she was carrying out the will of her governor, just as those who trashed the temple of democracy a year ago thought they were working for the then-president.

The business the governor ran sought profit. That was its job. It didn’t seek decency and fairness for humanity. That wasn’t.

The mission of a state government is vastly different from the mission of a financial speculation firm. Understanding, leading, and improving life for nine  million Virginians requires a different skill set from increasing profits. And yet people keep voting for those who translate their skill at growing and leveraging money into growing and leveraging power.

Parents across Virginia are being encouraged today to disrupt public schools tomorrow, to accompany their children to school, empowered by a sense of entitlement and grievance, and a mandate from their governor.
There are people who see this as leadership. There will be many watching the turmoil and thinking that’s not what they voted for. But they did.

Joe Fitzgerald lives in Harrisonburg, where he served as mayor. This column has been republished with permission from “Still Not Sleeping.”


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

65 responses to “Belligerence as Leadership”

  1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    Q. “How much of a logical leap is it to say a governor’s belligerent stance on masks enabled the woman who said she’d bring a weapon to a public school to keep her child from having to wear a mask?”

    A. A world record.

  2. LarrytheG Avatar

    No question that cloth masks are not as effective as N95 but also no question if you visit the doctor or a hospital, you WILL wear A mask and cloth masks ARE acceptable and there are studies that confirm it and the CDC agrees.

    This is like arguing if seat belts are effective or not or by what percentage or citing cases where a seat belt (or air bag) actually caused a death.

    Yeah, you can play that game if you really want to be that stupid and I see few folks suing over seat belts and air bags these days although we know they’re “out there”.

    1. killerhertz Avatar
      killerhertz

      Are you really going to double down on masks? What study? None such exists. Our school has 1/3 of the students out on quarantine because cloth masks are THAT good! Not to mention all of the irreparable mental harm being done for 2 years now…

        1. killerhertz Avatar
          killerhertz

          I’ve seen this 2015 study. Did you even read it? How does this support masking?

          “This study is the first RCT of cloth masks, and the results caution against the use of cloth masks. This is an important finding to inform occupational health and safety. Moisture retention, reuse of cloth masks and poor filtration may result in increased risk of infection.”

          1. LarrytheG Avatar

            It’s one of several and yes I did read it
            and it’s not 2015 – ” 2020 Oct; 26(10): e200948.” don’t spout lies and misinformation, guy.

          2. killerhertz Avatar
            killerhertz

            This is just a summary paper that references their 2015 study on healthcare workers in Vietnam. The study makes an observation that cloth masks in HCWs is probably detrimental due to the poor qualities. Also surgical masks have very little impact for viruses and respiratory illnesses. They didn’t even study mask wearing for gen pop.

            Nobody has done a controlled trial on the general population, let alone children in a school.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar

            not the only study by a long shot.

            You are promoting lies and misinformation on the masks…

          4. killerhertz Avatar
            killerhertz

            I am not. As a proponent of masks, the onus is on you to provide evidence that cloth masks are effective.

            You also just provided evidence contrary to your claim!

            I know N95s work. They were designed for occupational use explicitly for blocking fine particulate. They’re also suffocating. Nobody is seriously advocating everyone wear N95s all day, let alone children in schools.

          5. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            “Nobody is seriously advocating everyone wear N95s all day, let alone children in schools.:

            For a differing view, see Biden, Joe.

          6. killerhertz Avatar
            killerhertz

            I am not. As a proponent of masks, the onus is on you to provide evidence that cloth masks are effective.

            You also just provided evidence contrary to your claim!

            I know N95s work. They were designed for occupational use explicitly for blocking fine particulate. They’re also suffocating. Nobody is seriously advocating everyone wear N95s all day, let alone children in schools.

    2. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Uh, Larry, the national, enforced standards on installed seat belts mean all of them are automotive “N95s.” You can’t use a shoe string and claim that’s a seat belt.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        Nope. They are clearly NOT 100% effective! And, in fact, can cause death!

        1. Nancy Naive Avatar
          Nancy Naive

          Only drunks and Republicans loop them once around the neck before buckling them… and women like to put the shoulder harness behind their backs so not to muss their dresses.

  3. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    It’s a Darwinian issue.

  4. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    It’s a Darwinian issue.

  5. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    Washington Post headline: “Prices are rising all over the world, and leaders see no quick fix.” Another sandbag in the narrative “it’s not the fault of the President and the Democrats”. Perhaps a mask mandate will work.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      The POTUS is responsible for worldwide? gadzooks!

  6. “Financial speculator”? Youngkin was Co-CEO of Carlyle, certainly different than running a state, but a massive job. To call into question his capabilities, judgement, and decision-making skills and his ability to apply them to being Governor lacks credibility. As does implying that he’s responsible for the wack-a-doodle mom.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      How does the argument that different skills are needed in running a hedge fund, as opposed to governing a state, lack credibility?

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        It doesn’t. It is a relevant issue.

      2. Calling him a financial speculator carries no credibility because it shows complete ignorance of his job as co-CEO and Carlyle itself.

        From the company’s website: Carlyle is one of the world’s largest and most diversified global investment firms, with $293 billion of assets under management across 3 business segments and 433 investment vehicles. Founded in 1987 in Washington, DC, our global team today is comprised of more than 1,800 professionals operating in 26 offices across 5 continents.

        He’s handled a lot more than being VA Governor, which is another reason why the claim carries no credibility.

      3. How does the argument that different skills are needed in being a bag-man for the Clintons, as opposed to governing a state, lack credibility?

  7. The 3rd option is that he understands that masks on children – who do not spread the virus to vaccinated teachers – does more harm than good for the educational and social development of said children.

  8. VaNavVet Avatar

    One would hope that Governor Youngkin’s miss-steps are due to inexperience in the public sector. Perhaps he was listening to his political advisors rather than to policy experts. If he has political aspirations beyond Governor then his pursuit of profit could lead him in that direction. Should that be the case, the Commonwealth may well be in for a long four years.

    1. vicnicholls Avatar
      vicnicholls

      So far I see nothing devasting like what the current POTUS is doing.

    2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Missteps?

      1. VaNavVet Avatar

        As the article said he stepped right into this brier patch with masking in schools and has added to the hysteria. Still waiting for a response from the Gov on how to settle things down and not resort to bringing loaded guns to school.

  9. vicnicholls Avatar
    vicnicholls

    Pitiful post. CRT’s concepts are already being taught, https://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?211+sum+HB1904, https://nypost.com/2021/10/30/va-education-department-boosts-critical-race-theory-despite-mcauliffe-claim/, https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/virginia-education-department-promotes-pro-crt-book-despite-mcauliffe-s-claims-the-curricula-isn-t-taught-in-the-state/ar-AAQ4tfO, https://twitchy.com/brettt-3136/2021/10/30/christopher-rufo-debunks-terry-mcauliffes-claim-that-crt-isnt-taught-in-virginia-schools/ and of course https://stoplcpscrt.com/.

    Funny how people deny it but fight hard to stop you from legislating it out of schools.

    Masks? Each person does his own thing. Haven’t seen any medical research, papers, references, etc. addressing your position and the opposite side of the argument.

    England, Denmark, Sweden, Balkan countries, all without the covid protocols, so how do you explain that? They hate their kids?

    Childish ad hominem attacks on how stupid people are. Another reason why the left/progressives look so bad.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      Glenn Youngkin must not have gotten the message. He recently admitted that CRT is not being taught in Virginia schools. https://crooksandliars.com/2022/01/glenn-youngkin-admits-crt-not-being-taught

      1. vicnicholls Avatar
        vicnicholls

        Good Lord Dick that is the same thing. The precepts are taught, doesn’t matter what you call it. If it isn’t being taught then not a peep should be heard from the progressives.

  10. walter smith Avatar
    walter smith

    Wow. Left wing name-calling agitprop much?
    How about describing lifelong grifter Terry McAwful? How about let me denigrate the sources of “news” you must like, like MSDNC or the New York Slimes or the Washington Compost, cuz they never lie, amirite? (Cough, cough, RUSSIA!)
    Let’s try facts.
    Show me a single study that says the cloth face diaper actually works to reduce transmission AND is worth the cost. We know there have been horrible costs imposed on children WHO ARE NOT AT RISK. Do you hate children?
    I am really sick of people pontificating who don’t know what they are talking about. I have lots of questions about everything that has been done, and that would be a normal scientific process – to posit a theory and to test it against results.
    Jim Bacon has cited the VaTech professor who says masks are 50% effective, and I think her article was designed to mislead as I read a huge difference between 50% effective at blocking particles which I do not think translates to 50% reduced transmission. I have no doubt it blocks some particles. The questions are AT WHAT COST and TO WHAT EFFECT? Here is a scientific question – for someone who is sick, does wearing the mask and re-breathing your virus make you sicker? Is it OK with you Larry to wonder about that? How about the re-breathing air? What consequences for healthy people? Is it OK for me to doubt the basis for changing generations of prior accepted medical behavior without more than “trust me” from the CDC? What is the CDC’s job these last 50 years? How is it doing? To demand to see proof, other than lying bureaucrats telling me to trust them when they have flip-flopped on everything and been so wrong that I believe they are affirmatively, intentionally lying? Did Fauci fund gain of function research or not? (He did). Did he and Collins respond scientifically to the Great Barrington Declaration, you know, like scientists, or did they smear it like petty bureaucrats covering their arses?
    How come we have had VAERS for years and the government bragged about it and admitted it was under-reported, but now it sucks?
    How come NO ONE – looking at all you medical tyrants here – will acknowledge that the Covid vaccine which is not a vaccine is an experimental medical product and that federal law and the Nuremberg Code prohibit mandating participation in a medical experiment without the informed, willing consent of the patient? How come the denial of natural immunity?
    Try convincing me that masks work. Show me. Trust but verify, except I am no longer willing to assume trust for people who lie. Given that lack, I vote that parents know better for their own kids. Wear the damn face diaper if you want to virtue signal that you are not knuckle-dragging, Bible-thumping science denier and are acceptable at the country club with PLUs. Get the shot, shot, shot, repeat as necessary if you want. Meanwhile, the average parent has come to the conclusion that the medical emperors have no clothes…cuz they don’t. I am pleasantly surprised that Youngkin seems to have taken parents’ concerns seriously – and he isn’t going to kill a single person – in fact, he will likely save teenage girls’ lives (you do know about the increase in self abuse, depression, drug use, right all you SCIENCE! people?).

  11. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    What a refreshing post! I always enjoy Joe Fitzgerald’s offerings. Obviously, lots of folks on this site are not accustomed to hearing a different view from the outside. They are too used to Kerry and Shaun from the Republican Standard

    1. vicnicholls Avatar
      vicnicholls

      We’ve seen Dick. Just that we’re not going to take the “moral superiority” that has destroyed America, its economy, its children, any longer. Btw, I have D friends. I watched D’s allow porn and grooming materials and vote to keep it in libraries for kids. Since when has 50 years or more D professions helped out minorities in cities like Baltimore or Chicago? When you live the devastation from the policies, from the “morals”, not hard for the regular hard working folks to say we aint putting up with this no more.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        annnnnddd…. we’re OFF to the RACES once again!

  12. James McCarthy Avatar
    James McCarthy

    The allegation that CRT is being taught in VA schools represents the proverbial and actual red herring. Even if it were, in fact, being taught what would be the harm learning a method of inquiring into social structures? The realty has been revealed like that of the Wizard of Oz. It’s not CRT it is “divisiveness” that the new governor has banned by executive order. That move has been echoed in Florida where that governor supports legislation to prohibit teaching concepts that cause “discomfort.” Good grief, Charlie! Where is the beef? Discomfort? Divisiveness? It is understandable that parents (not so much children) are discomforted about the possible existence of systemic racism in the culture. It was so divisive and uncomfortable to acknowledge racism that a Civil War was fought.

    1. vicnicholls Avatar
      vicnicholls

      and yet another person who, given evidence to the contrary, still refuses to see the truth. What’s the harm? You mean like sex acts in books that have to stay in so kids can see them and not censor them, when even the attorney indicate its grooming materials? Is it any wonder that behaviors and mental health issues are running awry when folks go ‘nothing to see move along’.

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        CRT has nothing to do with sex acts.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          except in the minds of some……..who apparently can’t tell the difference…..

        2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
          James C. Sherlock

          Some would suggest that what it is doing to children is akin to a sex act.

        3. vicnicholls Avatar
          vicnicholls

          I’m drawing a parellel.

  13. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Belligerence is a two way street. I seem to remember plenty of that in the past 8 years. Youngkin has the biggest bat in the state. Looks like he is going to use it. We shall see if it is good as Ruth’s 54 ouncer. Still the heaviest bat ever used in the Majors.
    https://storage.googleapis.com/afs-prod/media/6ed27086625749dbb0ffe279f1af0051/2920.jpeg

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      I heard the man was a smoker, too…

  14. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    We went to Texas in May and upon return I had a major cold (could have been COVID-D, the Delta thing was just getting going, but never tested.) We went to Texas over the New Year and upon return I had another cold, and this time did get tested and bingo, COVID-O. I honestly wonder if the long travel days through ATL wearing that mask actually contributed to rather than protected from…They are the only times I wear the bloody thing that long a period….In a couple of years the politics will fade and the real data will emerge, and my bet is the non-N95 masks were pretty worthless. So says my daughter the NP.

    I’m in general polite and will abide by the rules, but I resent your insulting implication that I belong in a tinfoil hat. I think you are the one who puts politics over medical evidence. As I’ve said all along, this has been the worst aspect of this pandemic, the outright political warfare that both sides seem to just love.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      5 hours in an airplane. I’d be willing to bet that saline spray, and nose breathing does more to prevent infection as a cloth mask. Keep the snot flowing!

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        It’s the same with a classroom. Five hours, masks or no masks, what one kid has they all do.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          probably much closer proximity on a plane that a classroom and longer contact time.

          the real point is that MOST people who sit for hours on a plane with a mask on do NOT get COVID, right?

          If they all sat without masks…. would it be worse? Very likely – much like a super-spreader even or eating in a crowded restaurant.

        2. Nancy Naive Avatar
          Nancy Naive

          The airplane is all about what is sitting right next to you. Even a surgical mask with flow from your vent will be a big reduction in transmission.

          Kids? Petri dishes. More body fluids exchanged in a school than a, er… um… BLOODMOBILE! Yeah, that’s the ticket! A bloodmobile.

          There, anything that stops kids spraying in each other’s face has got to help.

          Remember, “Once it dries, it dies!”

  15. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    I note that David Leonhardt of The New York Times has noted, the last two years entailed a “trade-off” in which officials tried “to minimize the spread of Covid — a worthy goal absent other factors — rather than minimizing the damage that Covid does to society. They have accepted more harm to children in exchange for less harm to adults, often without acknowledging the dilemma or assessing which decisions lead to less overall harm.”

    So what is the tradeoff? Sen. Siobhan Dunnevant, a practicing physician, has answered that question. “Today, we know that the risk of hospitalization for children is almost none. In fact, of Virginia’s estimated almost 1.9 million children, .07% have been hospitalized with Covid-19 since March 2020. At the same time, the use of masks in school presents risks of learning loss, social emotional challenges, and other issues. Parents, constitutionally and logically, are the best people to do an analysis of what’s best for their child.”

    So thanks for the rant, Joe, but save it for people that have no other source of information.

    1. killerhertz Avatar
      killerhertz

      I really hope the leftists keep pushing masks. The more they do it, the more people will continue to move further away from this idiocy and start opting out of government reeducation camps.

      “we have to recognize kids belong to whole communities”

      they WILL lose

      https://twitter.com/Basil08521/status/1484203380864176133

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        They learned nothing from Nov 21. Let’s see if Nov 22 teaches them anything.

        1. Nancy Naive Avatar
          Nancy Naive

          Dead don’t learn either.

    2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      So what if Siobhan Dunnevant, a doctor, doesn’t want kids to have to wear masks. The folks at CDC are doctors, too. So are folks running the American Academy of Pediatrics, who say, “universal indoor mask use should continue in all K-12 for all students, teachers, staff and visitors.” https://www.healthychildren.org/English/health-issues/conditions/COVID-19/Pages/Cloth-Face-Coverings-for-Children-During-COVID-19.aspx?_gl=1*1i93l8r*_ga*MTg3MDYzNjg2OS4xNjQyNTE5NDM3*_ga_FD9D3XZVQQ*MTY0Mjk1NjM2Mi4yLjEuMTY0Mjk1NjQyMS4w&_ga=2.141639924.798827487.1642956364-1870636869.1642519437

      I think those authorities would outweigh the opinion of one doctor who is a OB-GYN doctor.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        they tend to latch onto A study that supports their biases and ignore the others… IOW, they choose to believe what they wish not what the consensus/findings of multiple studies are.

      2. vicnicholls Avatar
        vicnicholls

        AAP – the same ones pushing transgender policies that have backfired to the point that there is a groundswell to stop them because of how many folks are looking to detransition?

        1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
          Dick Hall-Sizemore

          How many, or what percentage, of folks are “looking to detransition”?

          1. vicnicholls Avatar
            vicnicholls

            Last I heard 40%. That’s sizeable. Given the comments of those transitioning, and you can look at Walt Heyer to give you those stats. Plus what I’ve heard in the medical community.

      3. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        So, Dick, the AAP also says in the same statement:

        “Universal masking will also protect students and staff from other respiratory illnesses that could keep kids out of school”.

        From the CDC:

        “Flu illness is more dangerous than the common cold for children. Each year, millions of children get sick with seasonal flu; thousands of children are hospitalized, and some children die from flu. Children commonly need medical care because of flu, especially children younger than 5 years old.”

        “Influenza
        Other names Flu, the flu, Grippe
        EM of influenza virus.jpg
        Influenza virus, magnified approximately 100,000 times
        Specialty Infectious disease
        Symptoms Fever, runny nose, sore throat, muscle pain, headache, coughing, fatigue
        Usual onset 1–4 days after exposure
        Duration 2–8 days
        Causes Influenza viruses
        Prevention Hand washing, flu vaccines
        Medication Antiviral drugs such as oseltamivir
        Frequency 3–5 million severe cases per year
        Deaths >290,000–650,000 deaths per year
        Influenza, commonly known as “the flu”, is an infectious disease caused by influenza viruses. Symptoms range from mild to severe and often include fever, runny nose, sore throat, muscle pain, headache, coughing, and fatigue. These symptoms begin from one to four days after exposure to the virus (typically two days) and last for about 2–8 days. Diarrhea and vomiting can occur, particularly in children. Influenza may progress to pneumonia, which can be caused by the virus or by a subsequent bacterial infection. Other complications of infection include acute respiratory distress syndrome, meningitis, encephalitis, and worsening of pre-existing health problems such as asthma and cardiovascular disease.”

        But, curiously, the CDC does not recommend masks as a protection against the flu. Just vaccines.

        Where is the consensus on what to do to protect kids from flu?

        So tell me your assessment of how there will ever be an off ramp from masking for kids now that we have made the leap. The regulatory state will be loath to take the risk.

        1. LarrytheG Avatar

          re: ” But, curiously, the CDC does not recommend masks as a protection against the flu. Just vaccines.”

          geeze…they must think COVID is more serious than flu? geeze… pesky stuff..

          1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
            Dick Hall-Sizemore

            Also, more transmissible.

  16. Donald Smith Avatar
    Donald Smith

    I wonder if Governor Youngkin is trying to goad the progressives who lead Virginia’s Democrats into doing and saying something stupid. Some of them do seem prone to shoot off their mouths and go off half-cocked in their actions.

    Let’s say Youngkin loses this fight. Let’s say that Fairfax County finds a progressive judge or two to back its defiance of the governor’s order. The afore-mentioned progressive Democrats will shriek with joy and gloat insultingly, and the Washington Post and MSNBC will celebrate.

    And Youngkin and Sears and Miyares can start telling Virginians that, if they want sanity to return to Virginia government, then they need to put the GOP in charge of the Senate, and keep the GOP in charge of the House, two years from now. They can make it clear that, in Virginia, the progressives and the Post are the problem.

    1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      Not as long as Republicans keep showing their hand in the bills they are proposing. Latest, 20 week abortion ban – no exceptions for rape or incest. The new transvaginal ultrasound bill.

  17. david Beauregard Avatar
    david Beauregard

    You will notice how the entire comment is denominated in the language of an amateur demagogue or one who appears to have sole possession of all the answers. You will further notice how this common demagogue implies that YOU do not know what you have done by voting for Governor Younkin. He has thrown off your vote as meaningless and without saying, has attributed your vote to your status as a deplorable. He has accused you of crimes against school age children and as a general danger to his self-interests or the world as he “sees” it.

  18. While some people who post to Bacon’s Rebellion are smart enough to write articles critical of Glenn Youngkin which are not rife with ad hominin attacks and gratuitous assertions, others clearly are not.

  19. Merchantseamen Avatar
    Merchantseamen

    Really funny weird may un-explainable. But of all the jabbed people I know family, friends most jabbed twice and or thrice are sick again some for the 3rd time. And they wear a mask. I know 6 people who are not jabbed for various reasons I will not go into. All on therapeutics Vit. D, C, and others. Not one has been sick with the covid. Makes you wonder……..

Leave a Reply