Another Milestone in Virginia’s Evolving Self Image

There once was a time when Virginia celebrated heroes of the Civil War like Robert E. Lee, Stonewall Jackson and JEB Stuart. Virginia has, by and large, moved beyond its nostalgia for the Lost Cause, rightfully honoring heroes of the American Revolution, such as Thomas Jefferson and Patrick Henry, and the Civil Rights era, such as the recently deceased Olive W. Hill.

Now, it appears, the Old Dominion may be transitioning to a new era, honoring a far more controversial figure, as evidenced by the little-noted action of Gov. Timothy M. Kaine informally pardoning Gabriel Prosser.

Who, you may ask, is (or was) Gabriel Prosser? He was the leader of an aborted slave rebellion who was hanged, along with 34 other slaves, in 1800. “Gabriel’s Rebellion” is well known to students of African-American resistance to the institution of chattel slavery. The 25-year-old slave, inspired by Biblical stories of the Jews’ flight from slavery in Egypt and the teachings of the American Revolution, organized an uprising by thousands of slaves. His plan: to massacre all whites (excepting Methodists, Quakers and Frenchmen) and to install himself as king of a new nation.

The plot was revealed at the last moment, and the congregation of rebels outside Richmond was disrupted by a torrential downpour of rain. Prosser delayed the attack until the next day, but by then the whites, alerted to the threat, were well organized to suppress the rebellion. Prosser fled to Norfolk, where he was betrayed by his fellow slaves, brought back to Richmond and hung.

In restoring Prosser’s “good name,” Kaine noted that he was motivated by the rebel’s “devotion to the ideals of the American revolution.” Said Kaine: “It was worth risking death to secure liberty. … History favorably regards Gabriel’s cause while consigning legions who sought to keep him and others in chains to be forgotten.”

Kaine’s pardoning of Prosser fellows a similar pardon last year in clearing the name of accused 18th century witch Grace Sherwood, of Virginia Beach, reports Jeff Schapiro in the Times-Dispatch. (Sorry, folks, I’d like to the story but I can’t find it in the T-D archives.)


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

8 responses to “Another Milestone in Virginia’s Evolving Self Image”

  1. not jim bacon Avatar
    not jim bacon

    Kaine thinks a “massacre” and a “king” show “devotion to the ideals of the American Revolution”?

    Help me out here. Jim, you want to deport poor Hispanics who drive in Virginia without a license Virginia won’t issue.

    Now you are endorsing a pardon for a guy who wanted to massacre Virginians and install himself as the new dictator?

    I wonder if you will still be blogging when some future Virginia Governor pardons all those Hispanics who were jailed for driving without a license.

    They were willing to risk jail and deportation to “secure liberty” for themselves and their families, and last time I checked they weren’t massacring non-Methodists.

    Cheers for the world’s oppressed who secure liberty peacefully.

  2. Things must be pretty darn good in Virginia!

    The governor has time to work on pardoning would be rebels who have been dead for 200+ years. Oh yeah, and witches too.

    Budget shortfall?
    Transparency in government?
    Transportation crisis?
    Abuser fee debate?
    Illegal immigration?
    Economic development?
    Energy?

    No, Gov. Kaine doesn’t have time for those petty issues.

  3. Jim Bacon Avatar

    Not Jim Bacon, I’m not endorsing Kaine’s “pardon,” merely noting it as a sign of the times. I do, in fact, have reservations about exonerating a guy whose goal was to massacre whites and set himself up as king, no matter how extreme the provocation of slavery. We should be honoring the likes of Frederick Douglas, the organizers of the underground railroad and the freed slaves who fought in the Civil War.

    But, then, Kaine didn’t exactly “honor” Gabriel Prosser. He merely restored his “good name.” So I didn’t think it worth making a stink about.

    As for your question about pardoning Hispanics driving without licenses…. You’re the one making it a racial issue by specificying “Hispanics” as opposed to illegal immigrants, not me. My question for you is this: Which laws do you think are worth obeying and which ones should be disobeyed? Are laws something to be left up to the individual conscience to follow — we get to pick and choose the laws we obey, cafeteria style — or should we be subject to all laws of the nation as a condition of living in that nation?

  4. The Gabriel Prosser “pardon” can be explained simply and completely by Governor Kaine’s extraordinarily strong ties to the African-American community, especially in Richmond.

    Groveton, though, cuts to the heart of the matter.

  5. Anonymous Avatar

    Looks like if Prosser was alive today they would be trying to revive the “baggy pants” legislation.

  6. Anonymous Avatar

    Interesting comment that Lee, Jckson and Stuart are not “controversial.” Maybe to Southerners they are not. But to Northerners, these men led a rebellion for questionable, racist goals that led to an extreme bloodletting in our own land.

  7. Anonymous Avatar

    “not Jim Bacon” sounds a lot like “not Ed Risse” –shooting flyspecks with a 12 guage, looking for ways to make intelligent discussion into a partisan conflict, undermining democracy and free markets.

    Anon Zeus

  8. not jim bacon Avatar
    not jim bacon

    Anon Zeus sounds a lot like E M Risse who keeps throwing out the canard that “democracy and free markets” will only survive if he gets to decide the future course of human settlement patterns.

    Everyone should get to decide by their own individual free actions.

    Where is the partisanship?

    And speaking of “shooting flyspecks with a 12 guage”, it was Jim Bacon who proposed using the government’s power of the gun to deport hardworking immigrants whose only crime is driving to work without a license Virginia won’t issue.

Leave a Reply