Air Conditioning Is Not a Luxury

by Kerry Dougherty

I don’t know why more people don’t visit cemeteries when they’re on vacation. You can learn a lot by strolling among the old graves.

When my son went to school in Buffalo, New York I found my way to Forest Lawn Cemetery, a graveyard so beautiful that weddings are held there.

President Millard Fillmore’s final resting place is in the leafy park-like setting. So is Alfred Porter Smithwick’s, the dentist who invented the electric chair. But I walked up and down the rows of headstones looking for Willis Carrier’s. He invented the first electric air conditioner in 1902 and died in 1950.

God bless that man.

Every summer I try to scribble a little homage to Carrier. After all, without him summertime would barely be survivable in this tropical swamp of Southeastern Virginia.

I should know. I spent the summer of 1985 in a stifling garage apartment at the Virginia Beach oceanfront. Second floor. Low ceilings. Small windows. No air conditioner. My landlord insisted the ancient electrical system couldn’t handle the load.

As summer baked on, I bought fan after fan until they covered every surface, making it impossible to read a newspaper and putting my cat’s tail in perpetual peril.

The next summer, I defiantly bought a small unit and installed it in a rear window where no one could see it. If the wiring burst into flames I planned to jump out one of the tiny windows and enjoy the breeze on the way down.

It was fine and I was no longer slick with sweat from Memorial Day to Labor Day.

Yet instead of celebrating the invention that allows people in southern locations to live in comfort during the summer months, climate activists often point to AC as an energy-slurping luxury. They fear that rising temperatures will result in depleted energy sources.

The crazies want you to feel guilty about cranking up the AC. Don’t fall for it.

Get a load of what they think of AC at left-wing outlet, Vox:

What if the most American symbol of unsustainable consumption isn’t the automobile, but the air conditioner? In cool indoor spaces, it’s easy to forget that billions of people around the world don’t have cooling — and that air conditioning is worsening the warming that it’s supposed to protect us from.

There are alternatives: We can build public cooling spaces and smarter cities, with fixes like white paint and more greenery. …as the planet warms and more of its inhabitants have spare income, AC sales are increasing. Ten air conditioners will be sold every second for the next 30 years, according to a United Nations estimate.

Oh please. White paint is no substitute for AC.

Rolling Stone was even more hostile to our desire to remain cool. In a piece headlined “Our Air Conditioned Nightmare” last summer, they wrote this immortal line:

By cooling ourselves off, we risk cooking ourselves to death.

Now that we’re in the middle of a heat wave — hey, it’s July, heat happens — climate kooks are blaming the high temps on manmade climate change and insisting that the growing need for air conditioning will make it much worse.

They’ve got it backwards. Study after study has shown that it takes more energy to heat homes than cool them.

So the migration from northern states like New York to Florida in recent years should result in overall energy savings.

Several years ago Michael Sivak, writing for IOPScience, compared energy usage in the hottest city in America — Miami — to the coldest metropolitan area – Minneapolis.

The results indicate that climate control in Minneapolis is about 3.5 times as energy demanding as in Miami. This finding suggests that, in the US, living in cold climates is more energy demanding than living in hot climates.

So lower your thermostat and enjoy the refrigeration this summer. Tell the folks bleating about wasted energy that if they’re serious about conserving energy, they’ll shut off the heat next winter and bundle up.

This column has been republished with permission from Kerry: Unemployed & Unedited.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

38 responses to “Air Conditioning Is Not a Luxury”

  1. Climate change activists are the 21st century’s ascetics — we must metaphorically wear hair shirts by denying ourselves air conditioning to pay penance for our climate sins. Self-denial and suffering becomes a good in itself.

    Kerry raises a fascinating point that I had not seen before — that living in hot zones is more energy-efficient than living in cold zones. It takes more energy to raise the indoor temperature from 30 degrees to the comfort zone of 70 degrees (a 40-degree differential) than it does to lower the indoor temperature from 100 degrees to 70 degrees (a 30-degree differential). Everyone needs to move to Miami!

    I would like to see a discussion on the physics of heating and cooling to see if this logic holds up. If it does, it makes you wonder why climate-change ascetics don’t criticize home heating as contributing to climate change. After all, with home heating, we’re expending energy and emitting CO2 in order to create heat, usually by burning oil or gas. With air-conditioning, we’re using electricity (usually heat pumps) to transfer heat from the indoors to the outdoors, not create new heat!

    Prove me wrong!

    1. walter smith Avatar
      walter smith

      Prove you right
      1. They live in NY and need heat
      2. They hate normal people (our elites fly charter, say drive electric cars, have huge boats, have masked servants, get covid multiple times and thank the non-god they believe in for being fully vaxxed and double boosted and taking Paxlovid, which doesn’t work as well as the I word…you know…the horse de-wormer)
      3. Where will the electricity come from? How’s that Texas grid doing? Did you know winds die down in hot weather?

        1. walter smith Avatar
          walter smith

          Caught fire? That didn’t help!
          Do you have a theory on all the food manufacturing places catching fire, exploding? Purely statistically speaking (like SlowJoe’s victory), this is outside of the normal bounds of probability…

          1. LarrytheG Avatar
            LarrytheG

            who knew? no.. I have not been “following” that… at all.. are you sure they were not doing secret abortions and the pro-life folks found out and fire bombed them?
            ;-)… e.g. pizza-gate et al?

          2. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            Pizza gate has not been disproved yet! Groomers are real…
            And all the usual non-fact check fact checks – like this one from Reuters -https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-processing-fire-idUSL2N2WW2CY
            You see the trick? You say there is no evidence, but you don’t actually look for evidence first, and then you get a friendly quote, saying it is crazy, like all the “Donald Trump claimed, without evidence,…” stories. How come we don’t see that with all of SlowJoe’s confabulations? Like “Joey, that gas price hurts real people?” (When gas prices were stable) Or the oil slicks on windshields? Or everybody had cancer from it?
            Anyway, in the real world, there has been a markedly high number of fires, explosions at food processing plants? Just a coincidence? A 1000 year flood sort of thing?
            Do you still believe the vaccine works?
            Can you explain why UVA had a 1 in 8 case rate among the vaxed and only a 1 in 10 rate among the unvaxed, even though the evil, unpatriotic, selfish, care about themselves, bad citizen unvaxed were required to be tested weekly? What would SCIENCE! say about that? Wasn’t the “consensus” “safe AND EFFECTIVE?”
            So I think the Magic 8 Ball would do a better job of governing than the SlowJoe regime – it has 10 positive answers and 5 negative answers and 5 indeterminate answers. So there is a 25% chance, up front of a “No” answer, which would be the right answer for the US and the world. I’m not good enough at Stats to calculate the ultimate probability of stopping the bad ideas by re-doing after the indeterminate… My guess would be the Magic 8 Ball would kill 1/3rd of SlowJoe’s ideas…and that would be an improvement! I vote for installing the Magic 8 Ball as VP, and invoke the 25th Amendment on the Teleprompter in Chief (TOTUS)!

          3. James Kiser Avatar
            James Kiser

            Or that President Drool grew up in PA.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Well you are and so is Kerry who is working off of old/outmoded information –

      ” One of the most common complaints about heat pumps, experts said, was that they would stop providing heat on very cold days. But advances to heat pump compressors have made them more efficient, cost effective and successful at providing heat in colder temperatures.

      As heat pumps have improved, lawmakers and policy experts have tried to make the devices more mainstream. In the United States, a tax credit program provides about a $300 rebate for people transitioning their homes to heat pump technology. Amid Congress’s stalled climate agenda, one proposal increases the incentive to $600. States and local utilities also have their own rebate programs”

      https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/07/21/europe-heat-wave-heat-pump/

  2. The downside…. keeps Congress in session during the summer months.

  3. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    I’m surprised here than Conservatives who often remind us of how markets “work” don’t seem to understand or acknowledge the consequences of higher summertime temperatures.

    The increasing demand for electricity from the grid is forcing fuel prices UP. Natural gas prices are skyrocketing and those increased costs are showing up on people’s electric bills.

    That’s going to further hurt all those proverbial “poor folks”, right?

    but it will also cause everyone to CONSERVE , and for those who can afford it, buy more efficient equipment, etc…. a good thing.

    this will work the same way that high gasoline prices drive people to more fuel efficient cars.

    IF we reduce the use of gas – it’s a WIN-WIN – right?

  4. Paul Sweet Avatar
    Paul Sweet

    I survived 3 summers in an un-air conditioned attic apartment in Texas when I was in college. It was often 95 inside when I got home. Fortunately there was a huge fan in one gable, and Austin’s humidity wasn’t as bad as Virginia’s. Drinking a gallon or more of iced tea a day also helped me survive it.

    Heat pumps are basically air conditioners that can run backwards and warm the inside by cooling the outside air. They are more beneficial for energy savings in the winter than in the summer. However, in the winter their heat output decreases as the temperature decreases, while the heat loss of a building increases as the temperature decreases. At some point (mid 20s for newer well insulated houses to mid 40s for older homes with less insulation) it is necessary to turn on supplementary electric resistance heat which reduces their benefit.

    Retrofitting heat pumps in older buildings is also less beneficial because their output is limited by the existing ductwork, and an older building might not have adequate electric service for the supplemental heat.

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      Ah, I remember my first apartment with a heat pump. Fifteen degrees outside, and a comfortable 62 inside. Vent temperature was like having a little old lady breathing on your ankles. Things are vastly better with vent temperatures much higher than 100 degrees now.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      heat pumps have vastly improved. see this:

      Europe is overheating. This climate-friendly AC could help.
      Heat pumps are efficient and eco-friendly. So why are they so rarely used?

      https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/07/21/europe-heat-wave-heat-pump/

      technology is advancing.. but sometimes we seem to argue like before when we said cars can’t replace horses because of potholes and mud, etc… we do advance and we are now as before.

    3. WayneS Avatar

      I survived my entire childhood in Virginia Beach with no central AC in the house (one window unit in the living room which did nothing for the upstairs bedrooms, and un-airconditioned vehicles. My parents got their first air-conditioned car the year I went away to college (1982) and they had central AC installed in their house two years later.

      AC is a a wonderful thing, and I do not want to have to live without it, but truth be told, it is not essential to our survival.

  5. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Sir Peyton Skipwith of Prestwould Plantation never was bothered by the steamy summers of southside Virginia. I always thought his dinner table fan was brilliant! We are a wimpy group of people now.
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/512f86064ea6d0faf7ecada55511d3e52cd8153308e4e29d2baded4c86245b5f.jpg

  6. James Kiser Avatar
    James Kiser

    I call for all federal buildings to have A/C removed especially Congress and the WH.

    1. That’ll be step 2,546 in China Joe’s climate emergency proclamation immediately after the rule to stop exhaling

  7. James Kiser Avatar
    James Kiser

    One of the interesting things which isn’t addressed is high rate rate of attrition of heating and A/c equipment. I have friends who are on their 2nd heat pump in 10 years. My wife and had our heat pump fail in less than 2 years it was replaced but they wouldn’t cover the installation costs. Heat an air people tell me the newest units both air and heat will last at best 10 years at ten thousand dollars a unit in a few years most people won’;t be able to afford a/c or heat. No a/c is really hard on those with congestive heart failure or asthma and other lung diseases.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      Just got a new unit after 20yrs on the prior one and was told 10 years was the expected lifespan.

      What I see is competition where some companies will offer better systems with longer warranties sorta like what Toyota did the US car market where cars used to be “done” at 100K but not if you had a Toyota.

      So we need a “Toyota” for heat pumps and I have faith in the free market – just like Conservatives say they do, until they don’t!

      😉

    2. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      Yes. High failure rate. Difficulty in finding parts. Refrigerants have changed so keeping the older units alive is next to impossible now unless you can track down R 12 on the side. Heil seems to be one of the better ones at the moment. The key is keeping the coils clean. If you can get to them without too much trouble they are easy to clean. Just a few machine screws need to be removed from the sheet metal to access this. This one act alone will help you get the max life.

      1. James Kiser Avatar
        James Kiser

        Trouble is can you afford a 10-15,000 dollar outlay every 10 years. please my comments concerning what tech told me concerning copper versus aluminum.

        1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
          James Wyatt Whitehead

          The switch to aluminum is all regulations. I would go ahead and pick up the copper coil as a backup now. Or hit the dump and salvage on old coil that just needs cleaning. If you can find a guy to do it on the side you will cut that 10 year cost in half. No rocket science involved. DIY If you can handle a torch, braze, and know just the basics of wiring/pvc piping you can probably do it yourself. Don’t worry about capturing old refrigerant. Most of the techs pull that unit out for show. What they don’t tell you is how they crack the outlet cap to gradually bleed that stuff out without anyone knowing.

          1. James Kiser Avatar
            James Kiser

            thanks I will have to take some classes from a friend.

    3. Stephen Haner Avatar
      Stephen Haner

      Just listened to a discussion on the lifespan of the newer equipment on the radio. No question the shorter lifespans can be linked to regulatory mandates, although lack of maintenance and dirty air filters remain the big culprits.

      Heat pumps are great, but should be a customer choice, not a government mandate. (But, but, but…climate change!!! What a crock.)

      1. James Kiser Avatar
        James Kiser

        One technician told me an older guy in his 60’s said the companies use aluminum instead of copper which results in quicker leaks developing in the units due to corrosion.

      2. LarrytheG Avatar
        LarrytheG

        oh geeze… I bet you have a Japanese import for a car (or should)… do you think “regulations” have “harmed” them and yeah, they are one of the most regulated products in the market – for sure – but when I see cars lasting 200K , I REMEMBER the good old , bad days when 100K was really long in the tooth if you had a GM or Ford.

  8. YellowstoneBound1948 Avatar
    YellowstoneBound1948

    The younger generations do not know or cannot remember that until relatively recently no one had A/C. I remember trips to the local Sears on hot days and nights where we would go into the store and stand in front of the window units (the floor models), which was quite a bit better than standing in front of one’s open refrigerator (the “ice box,” as it is still called in many homes).

    1968 is remembered for several things, not just Tet. That was the year my parents bought their first window unit. They also bought a ’68 Olds that had A/C — our first air-conditioned car! I remember my mother writing me with the good news. However, it all came too late for my older sister and me: We had already left home.

    My wife and I built our “final” home in 1981-82. While we were waiting through the harsh winter (in Tennessee), we noticed a layer of ice had formed on the INSIDE of all the windows and sliding glass doors of the house we were temporarily renting. That was our LAST experience with heat pumps. We reverted to “wood stove” technology. There are also two furnaces, just in case, but they are strictly back-up.

    Does anyone here remember Arizona in the late 40s/early 50s? If you do, can you confirm that people used to sleep on their porches in the summertime, but only after hosing down their sheets with water? That supposedly created an A/C-like effect all night, but I never tried it.

    Is Lady Diana Skipwith a part of this conversation? Asking for a friend.

    1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      I think it is Lady Jean. She owned Prestwould after Sir Peyton died.

    2. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      not your fathers, olds nor heat pump anymore.

      used to be out west – swamp coolers , maybe still?

      I guess we’ll have to wait and see if this summer is a one-off or a sign of things to come…

  9. JayCee Avatar

    Love geothermal. Sleeping at 68 degrees is no sweat for this system when ground water is 67 degrees year round.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar
      LarrytheG

      If most houses went to geothermal and combined that with wind/solar, it would totally change the climate game.

      gonna happen…..

    2. YellowstoneBound1948 Avatar
      YellowstoneBound1948

      Dropped a transmission in Thermopolis, Wyoming in 2009. A lot of thermo there, I found out.

      1. WayneS Avatar

        That would not be my first choice as a place to lose a transmission.

        😉

  10. LarrytheG Avatar
    LarrytheG

    here’s an interesting article that says this is a problem even in the US and odd that JAB goes off on a tangent:

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/234a6d13653c6bcbfeeed11d13ce3a9a6aca9c5b92b156ed89bf5965deadca4e.jpg

    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/d3c6bdf9c7f8bd735eef366814d25c30d5664c8df11ef7868f8b644a04cf88bc.jpg

    “But the devices lack popularity in parts of the United States and Europe because of low public awareness and high installation costs. The United Kingdom fell far short of its yearly heat pump installation goals in 2021.

    Energy experts point to a couple of reasons heat pumps haven’t entered the mainstream. First is the name, which makes it difficult for people to recognize that it heats and cools. “It is confusing,” said Corinne Schneider, the chief communications officer for CLASP, an energy nonprofit.

    The high price of installation — systems can cost upward of $10,000 to buy and install — is also a hurdle for many users.

    “But with a heat wave forcing people to find ways to cool their homes, as Russia’s war in Ukraine sends energy prices soaring, experts say heat pumps are a natural solution: an all-in-one system that cools during heat waves and reduces reliance on gas in the winter.

    “It’s a home comfort issue. It’s a climate issue. It’s a security issue,” said Alexander Gard-Murray, a climate change researcher and economist at Brown University’s Climate Solutions Lab. “Any one of them would be enough to move aggressively on heat pumps, but taken together I think the evidence is insurmountable.”

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/07/21/europe-heat-wave-heat-pump/

  11. WayneS Avatar

    Rolling Stone was even more hostile to our desire to remain cool.

    I’ll bet their offices are air-conditioned.

    I’ll consider giving up AC when 75% of the democrats in California have had it permanently removed from their homes and cars, and when 75% of the democrats in Massachusetts have permanently removed all heating sources from their homes and cars.

  12. vicnicholls Avatar
    vicnicholls

    My regular driving car has no AC, hasn’t for 3 or 4 years. I’ll work on getting it replaced/infilled when I have money. I don’t live far from Kerry.

  13. Ruckweiler Avatar
    Ruckweiler

    As an example, air conditioning made the Desert Southwest livable for more than just the desert rats. You can be assured that the climate whiners aren’t going to sacrifice their cooling comfort just that the rest of us must. Nuts to such nonsense.

  14. Paul Sweet Avatar
    Paul Sweet

    Geothermal heat pumps would be great if the wells weren’t so darned expensive. I wanted to use a geothermal heat pump for the house I just built, but amortizing the initial cost of the wells would have cost more than I would have saved on electricity, compared to a conventional air-to-air heat pump. It might have ultimately saved some money as electric costs increase through the years, but something had to give with the way material and construction costs were increasing last year.

    Geothermal heat pumps work best when there is a good balance between heating and cooling BTUs. I’ve heard of a couple cases where buildings with a much greater cooling load than heating eventually raised the groundwater temperature in the well field and reduced the heat pumps’ output. It’s possible that a larger well field with more wells would have spread the rejected heat out farther and reduced the groundwater temperature rise, but that would have increased the initial cost still more.

Leave a Reply