by Dick Hall-Sizemore

Here is a quiz. Below is the description of a crime that was released by the public information office of a Virginia locality. The killer pled guilty to charges of first-degree murder, attempted robbery (2 counts) and use of a firearm (3 counts). The judge sentenced him to 63 years in prison with 33 years suspended, leaving 30 years to serve. As the news release noted, “This was the maximum sentence allowed under the plea agreement.” See if you can guess the jurisdiction and Commonwealth’s attorney that accepted such a plea agreement for a murderer, rather than go to trial.

On the morning of November 29, 2018, the victim, Devin Bell, was alone in his home. Bobby Cason, who was unknown to Bell, knocked on his door. Bell did not open the door but had a strange conversation with Cason, and then noticed that Cason continued to hang around the condominium complex. Bell contacted some friends to come to help him check out the situation.

After Bell’s friends arrived at the complex, Cason ran up to one of them, armed with a handgun with an extended magazine, and demanded the man’s property. The man had nothing but a cup of coffee, so Cason turned toward Bell and said he “needed something.” Bell pulled out his cell phone and told Cason to take it. Cason then pulled a second handgun from his pocket and demanded that Bell take him inside his house. A struggle ensued during which Cason shot Bell. Bell collapsed a short distance away, where he died. Cason fled the scene with both guns. The medical examiner determined that the muzzle of the gun was pressed against Bell’s neck when he was shot.

Cason was linked to the crime through Ring doorbell footage. He was wearing latex gloves at the time. Police found a latex glove near Bell’s body, which was later analyzed by the Department of Forensic Science. Cason’s DNA was found on the glove.

Although no handguns were recovered, police found at Cason’s grandparents’ house a magazine containing bullets of the same type as the shell casing found near Bell’s body. At his grandparents’ and parents’ houses, police also recovered shoes and a latex glove matching Cason’s attire in the Ring doorbell footage.

Did you guess one of the “Soros” prosecutors who have been the subject of much criticism on this blog, such as Descano of Fairfax County, Deghani-Tafti of Arlington, or, maybe, Biberaj of Loudoun? If so, you would have been wrong. It was that woke prosecutor Colin Stolle of Virginia Beach.  Strangely, however, I never heard this case being mentioned in any of Attorney General Jason Miyares’ criticisms of plea deals being reached by prosecutors. Could this have been because Stolle was Miyares’ former boss? See press release and media story here and here.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

49 responses to “Ah, Those Woke Prosecutors!”

  1. walter smith Avatar
    walter smith

    And? The point is you want the perp to fry? Now do the same for all perps. Oops…the Soros DAs are a problem, then, aren’t they? Were there difficulties in the evidence and the proof required? A defense lawyer would point out there are millions of those types of bullets. Was jury nullification a risk? (Excuse me all you Lefties – look at DC. RUSSIA! was a hoax and the juries have excused lying for political purposes, while trespassers on J6 get 5 years in jail and illegal invaders get welcomed with open arms. This is a huge problem. Besides the FBI acting like the Stasi…)
    Was Stolle doing a favor for political connections or friendship? Doubtful. So what was the assessment of the case? Was this the best that could be done given costs and likely outcomes? Maybe that indicates we need some reforms in the process. On the other hand, we do need those Constitutional protections (which are being denied in the J6 trials and jails and by the Biden Stasi, but I repeat myself!)…

    1. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      Woke juries “excused” lying??? Straw man question: was the prosecutor doing a favor? Doubtful”? Only the Shadow knows these mysterious occurrences. J6 prosecuted as “trespassers”? Shame on the woke DOJ.

      1. walter smith Avatar
        walter smith

        Huh? Jury nullification where clear cut guilt can cut both ways. Is lying bad? Rs say yes. Dems say “Not when we do it.” All power to the State.

        1. James McCarthy Avatar
          James McCarthy

          Durham presented weak cases and the judge and jury concluded that he failed to meet the burden of proof. Not nullification. Lying has become the art of the R’s especially those in the cross hairs. No power to the Bannon’s, Flynn’s, Stones.

          1. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            Uh-huh…
            J6 is an insurrection and Floydapalooza was mostly peaceful protests…
            The defendants were dead to rights in the Durham cases. The jurors in the first case said they just didn’T believe he should have been charged. Sounds like jury nullification to me…

          2. LarrytheG Avatar

            all you righties BEFORE Durham prosecuted said it was clear and obvious and Durham would PROVE the “Russia” thing was a left-wing / FBI conspiracy. Apparently the “evidence” was super-weak and no dice.

            Nope.

          3. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            So RUSSIA was real there Larr?
            And the FBI did not know it was a fake?
            And the $40 million to PERSECUTE political enemies was A-OK with you?
            How about the 50 defense experts saying that Hunter’s laptop had all the earmarks of Russian disinformation?
            See the problem yet?
            Everything you Lefties do has all the earmarks of Russian disinformation…because it is. Why you have to suppress dissent and lie repeatedly.
            Here’s another example from that known Right-Wing journalism source – https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/fbi-raid-abc-news_producer-1234613619/

            But trust Larry and the Libs and if you don’t you’re wackadoodle!

          4. LarrytheG Avatar

            Wasn’t there an investigation of a possible connection to Russia that concluded there was none then Durham came along to claim something nefarious and it fell flat?

            Sounds a lot like that Bengasi “investigation”. NO beef.

            https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/cd18b3c1b8f66bc78a05a961fcb1654ea24059751792718d40c1827bd5d04ad6.jpg

            Hunter Hunter Hunter

            Benghazi Benghazi Benghazi!

          5. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            Do you read anything besides your DNC talking points?
            I hope you get paid plenty to be wrong all the time, but I would advise that is a very short term outlook…
            Someone said something like “What does it profit a man…” – can’t quite put my finger on it… But you might want to try actually getting things right, instead of repeating the blather. Everyone not you knows it is blather… Get on the train before it runs over you.

          6. LarrytheG Avatar

            I don’t read any DNC, I just react to the conspiracies theories the wackadoodles cling to.

          7. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            Larry – then you are a bot?
            I know you don’t read anything from a source that has the possibility of being true, but you don’t even read your DNC talking points?
            Are you an AI droid like Fetterneck?
            IS it OK for the government to censor speech it doesn’t like?
            https://legalinsurrection.com/2022/10/court-fauci-must-testify-under-oath-about-involvement-in-social-media-covid-censorship/

            If you were telling the truth, you would not need to shut people up… And it might be good to try stop lying…but they go hand in hand…

          8. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            See, it’s not just me. The problem is you authoritarian Leftists, who know your arguments are losers, so we get perversion of truth, justice, etc, while you project like an IMAX…
            This could be too dangerous to read –
            https://jeffgoldstein.substack.com/p/the-age-of-boutique-authoritarianism?utm_source=direct&r=gpupi&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

  2. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    My only comment… Geez, how many Stolles are there? They have been the VB legal structure since I was a kid.

    1. LarrytheG Avatar

      way too many, they’re an infestation!

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        I do not agree with this characterization. While I was at Planning and Budget, I had a
        lot of opportunity to observe Sen. Ken Stolle when he chaired the Public Safety
        Subcommittee of Senate Finance. He is
        smart, personable, articulate, and moderate. It is my impression that he has been a good sheriff. He has even shown some “progressive”
        traits, pushing for alternatives to incarceration, particularly for offenders with mental health problems. I did not have any interaction with Del. Chris Stolle, but it was my impression that he was a reasonable politician. Sen. Dunnavant
        is my state senator, but I will be in a different district next time around due to redistricting. While I do not agree with all her positions, I have found her to be forthright, reasonable, and
        amenable to compromise. I voted for her
        at the last senatorial election. The Commonwealth could do well with more much “infestations”.

    2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      There are four, so far: Ken Stolle, former Virginia Beach state Senator and now Sheriff; Colin Stolle, Virginia Beach Commonwealth’s Attorney; Chris Stolle, former delegate from Virginia Beach; and their sister, Siobhan Stolle Dunnavant, state senator from Henrico

      1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
        Kathleen Smith

        A family affair.

      2. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Still fewer than Kellams and Vakoses. Changing of the guard..

      3. walter smith Avatar
        walter smith

        I did not know about Dunnavant…
        There is too much familial/apparatus continuation in politics at all levels – both sides, all States

        1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
          James C. Sherlock

          Objectively? Have they done things wrong? Are they not the best candidates? Or just a feeling on your part?

          I know all four of the Stolles Dick mentioned.
          – Two physicians who served in the General Assembly. One still does. She gives of her time unstintingly while maintaining an active practice in Richmond.
          – One attorney who served in the state Senate until a medical problem forced his retirement and now serves as our sheriff.
          – One gifted attorney who has served with distinction as our Commonwealth’s Attorney for many years. He has worked at the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney for the City of Virginia Beach in 1992. He could have made far more money in the private practice of law.

          They are all superb public servants who don’t need to do it.

          Dedicated and hard working, they always color within the lines of both law and ethics while advancing public interests. Even Democrats around here will admit that.

          We are lucky to have them and should thank them for their service. I certainly do.

          1. I am curious: What kind of medical problem would preclude one from serving in the state senate, while at the same time not preclude one from serving as a sheriff?

          2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
            Dick Hall-Sizemore

            Stolle has Parkinson’s disease.

          3. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
            Dick Hall-Sizemore

            Stolle has Parkinson’s disease.

          4. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
            Dick Hall-Sizemore

            I agree with you. See my response to Larry above.

          5. walter smith Avatar
            walter smith

            Nothing against any of them. I don’t like the familial seats… Murkowskis, the Dems in Michigan, etc.
            So nothing against them personally.
            Against things staying in the family with 330 million people…
            The 535 in Congress are the best we can do? Joe Biden? HIs feckless appointees? The bureaucracy? Academia? The press (except for JAB)? All the people married and hiding behind different last names?

  3. LarrytheG Avatar

    Dick is performing a valuable service by adding “context” to BR discussions that often feel like partisan swipes rather than
    an honest discussion about the issues.

    Conservatives are gonna ride that “woke” horse for as long and far as they can in hopes to sway independent voters to joint their base.

    1. Context my eyeball, Larry. Dick’s the one who brought up “wokeism” for you to get a slap in at conservatives.

      The now 22-year old confessed murderer is sentenced to 30 years. The murder weapon was not recovered. Couldn’t that have have caused problems at trial? Whatever the reason to accept the confession and plea, the man wasn’t freed to
      run the streets. I’m confident there have been a lot worse results from our NoVa DAs.

      1. LarrytheG Avatar

        Carol , how many times have you seen “woke” in BR that was NOT written by Dick INCLUDING on prosecutors?

        How much do you actually KNOW about NoVa prosecutions beyond the cherry-picked examples that Conservatives and BR like to demonize?

        1. Are these statements I picked up in a 10-second search incorrect? Quoted from https://www.heritage.org/crime-and-justice/commentary/meet-steve-descano-the-rogue-prosecutor-whose-policies-are-wreaking

          “Want to know what crimes you can now commit in Fairfax County without being prosecuted by Descano’s office? Here’s a sampling:
          “You can steal or shoplift goods valued at up to $1,000.
          “You can assault most individuals in the commonwealth, including schoolteachers and health care workers.
          “You can commit arson to defraud your insurance company as long as the property you burned was worth less than $1,000.
          “You can willfully and intentionally set off a smoke bomb in a school, theater, store, office building, shopping mall, coliseum, or arena.
          “You can commit prostitution or solicitation of prostitution without any repercussions.
          “You can participate in a riot.
          “You can obstruct legal process.
          “You can obstruct emergency medical services personnel from delivering emergency medical services after the EMS personnel have requested that the obstruction stop.
          “You can accept a bribe as a legal process server to delay or omit service.
          “You can obstruct justice—even by threats or force.
          “You can knowingly and willfully make a materially false statement to a law enforcement officer.
          “You can resist arrest.
          “You can knowingly make a false police report.
          “You can use a police radio during the commission of a crime.
          “You can commit some forms of jury tampering.
          “You can engage in some forms of extortion as a governmental officer.
          “You can fraudulently make a false entry or erase, alter, or destroy a record as clerk of court or other public officer.
          “You can aid the escape of a prisoner.
          “You can indecently expose yourself.
          “You can drive recklessly, so as to endanger the life, limb, or property of anyone else.
          “You can possess Schedule III, IV, V, or VI drugs.
          “You can also possess with intent to distribute certain illegal drugs.”

          And if this is cherry-picking, so be it:
          https://freebeacon.com/latest-news/virginia-progressive-prosecutor-freed-felon-who-went-on-to-murder-two-men/

          1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
            James C. Sherlock

            Actually, you do Descano an injustice. His dollar limit in Fairfax County property theft below which he will not prosecute is $1,500, not $1,000. Wholesale, not retail value.

            The storekeepers are not amused. But there are far more federal employees, Descano’s base, than storekeepers.

          2. how_it_works Avatar
            how_it_works

            There are many commuter lots in Fairfax County filled with federal employee’s vehicles. It would be a crying shame if someone were to smash all those windows looking for stuff to steal, and not get prosecuted for it.

          3. LarrytheG Avatar

            Carol –

            are these actual statistics that we can compare to other jurisdiction statistics or just
            the usual anecdotal conservative/right wing talking points from the likes of Heritage?

            You know, you COULD convince me if you provided a link to actual statistics that showed that NoVa was more lenient than other localities in Va.

            That would be much, much better than supposed anecdotal stuff.

          4. DJRippert Avatar

            It’s not anecdotal at all. It is Descano’s opaque but publicized policy.

            From the article:

            “In that same vein, Descano was apparently jealous of Rachael Rollins, the elected rogue district attorney in Boston, who is infamous for her list of 15 crimes you can now commit there with impunity, including breaking and entering, assault on a police office, and theft, among others.

            She’s a trendsetter of sorts because Descano followed her lead and is now refusing to prosecute many crimes in Fairfax County. He’s being less transparent about that fact, though, because, unlike Rollins who explicitly listed the crimes she would no longer prosecute, Descano has instead listedonly the crimes he will prosecute, which has the likely intended effect of hiding the shockingly large number of crimes he won’t prosecute.”

          5. James McCarthy Avatar
            James McCarthy

            A VA prosecutor “apparently jealous” of a Boston DA?? Publicly opaque??? How can you condone such trashy reporting?

          6. James McCarthy Avatar
            James McCarthy

            For one thing, the $1,000 item was a product of the woke GA not Descano.

  4. When people complain about prosecutors going soft on crime, I don’t think they are talking about 30 year sentences.

    1. Kathleen Smith Avatar
      Kathleen Smith

      To some extent, you are right. My concern is not with the sentence, nor the plea, it it the fact that these deals are made often on both sides of the sleeping cycle. Maybe the deals must be made to ensure someone is held responsible. We watch too much Law and Order.

      1. A lot of plea deals are made because there simply are not enough judges not enough assistant prosecutors, and not enough hours in the day to bring every single criminal case to trial.

        1. James McCarthy Avatar
          James McCarthy

          Pleas are more often in play because prosecutors are concerned that greater charges are not supported and getting a defendant off the street is a better outcome.

  5. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    Dick, the man pled guilty to First Degree Murder, Attempted Robbery (2 counts) and Use of a Firearm (3 counts). The man pled guilty to first degree murder.

    Are you seriously trying to pass that off as an example of soft on crime?

    – Just like permitting a plea to a misdemeanor instead of a felony and releasing the perp on an alternative to jail sentence, right?

    – Just like letting repeat offenders back out on the streets on OR. Sure, this time after a minimum of 30 years with 33 years suspended. But same principle?

    A few more questions.
    – How many ways are there to lose a case at trial with that evidence and no gun or GSR?
    – How many ways for a jury to bring back a guilty finding on a lesser charge than murder 1.
    – How many ways to get a court verdict or sentence overturned on a technicality?

    Perhaps Cason was really the victim. Yeah, that’s it. Go with that.

    1. James McCarthy Avatar
      James McCarthy

      Once again, a distorted restatement of another’s presentation to contribute to a talking point. The plea has no correlation to the prosecutor’s hardness or softness on crime. It’s a judgment by the defendant and his attorney with the consent of the prosecutor.

      1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
        James C. Sherlock

        My questions were to Dick. I note you chose not to answer them.

        But thank you for making my point.

        The prosecutor had such a strong case that the accused pled to murder one. Punishment for conviction in a trial of murder one, a Class 2 felony in Virginia, is imprisonment for life or for any term not less than 20 years. The CA got a minimum of 30 years without having to go to trial.

        I am not sure how many times a murder one plea occurs in Virginia every year, but I suspect we can count it on one hand. The people benefited because the prosecutor avoided the risks of a trial. End of story. For everyone but Dick.

        1. James McCarthy Avatar
          James McCarthy

          Your questions were relevant only to you. The plea was not dependent upon the wokeness of the CA.

        2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
          Dick Hall-Sizemore

          I don’t fault Stolle for entering into the plea deal. The point I was trying to make is that it is not only the “progressive” prosecutors in Northern Virginia who engage in plea deals, despite the sharp criticism of Miyares and some on this blog of those plea deals. It is a common practice and your comments well illustrate the reasons that prosecutors do it–the people benefit because the prosecutor avoided the risk of a trial.

  6. Lee Faust Avatar

    30 years seems OK — without parole.

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Punishment for conviction in a trial of murder one, a Class 2 felony in Virginia, is imprisonment for life or for any term not less than 20 years. The CA got a sentence of a minimum of 30 years without having to go through the risks of a trial. So yes, it was a good call.

      1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        Of course, you ignore the fact that he also pled guilty to three counts of using a firearm in the commission of a felony. Each of those charges carry a mandatory minimum sentence of 3 years. Then there were the two counts of attempted armed robbery, each of which carries a minimum sentence of 5 years. All in all, both sides got a pretty good deal.

      2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
        Dick Hall-Sizemore

        Of course, you ignore the fact that he also pled guilty to three counts of using a firearm in the commission of a felony. Each of those charges carry a mandatory minimum sentence of 3 years. Then there were the two counts of attempted armed robbery, each of which carries a minimum sentence of 5 years. All in all, both sides got a pretty good deal.

  7. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Plea deals are great if and only if the defendant is guilty.

Leave a Reply