A Tale Of Two Bridge Projects

by Kerry Dougherty

Some would say it’s not fair to compare the rapid repairs to a hurricane-damaged bridge in Florida to the desultory progress of the Laskin Road bridge project in Virginia Beach.

I don’t care.

For those of us getting our cars realigned every few months and learning to zigzag as we attempt to navigate the moonscape that Laskin Road has been for three years – with no end in sight – it was impossible not to marvel at the miracle in Florida.

And pine for Pine Island.

Let’s back up.

When Hurricane Ian unexpectedly slammed Into Lee County on the Gulf Coast, the largely rural Pine Island communities saw their only bridge to the mainland buckle. It appeared that the several thousand permanent residents of the coral island would be marooned for some time.

But then this happened:

Gov. Ron DeSantis, who took charge of the project after experts planned to run ferry services to the residents, said the bridge repairs were temporary, but a necessary way for residents to get food and fuel and for linemen to access the island to restore power.

An October 5 press release from the governor’s office explained:

On Sunday, Governor DeSantis directed FDOT to work with Lee County to expedite work and complete repairs by Saturday, October 8. Work began on Monday and FDOT crews worked hard to finish the repairs in monumental timing – less than three days.

“Within 24 hours after I asked FDOT to get involved, we had more than 130 trucks rolling in and crews got to work,” said Gov. Ron DeSantis. “We made it a priority and we didn’t just get it done – we got it done quick. I want to thank the dedicated FDOT crews for working around the clock to restore the community’s access to Pine Island.”

“Hundreds of loads of sand and rock, various pieces of heavy equipment, and dedicated crew members have literally helped pave the way to recovery for this community.”

Bravo.

If only that can-do spirit infected VDOT.

In 2019, Virginia began to dismantle the feeder road system that runs along Laskin Road, bedeviling tourists and locals alike.

Confession: I like the free-wheeling feeder roads. They’re an anything-goes ribbon along a heavily traveled road. Our Little Autobahn where speed limits and rules of the road seem suspended. I use them constantly.

Once the project is complete Laskin Road will be an eight-lane freeway to the Beach, with a new bridge over Linkhorn Bay.

Initially, the project was set to finish next spring. Anyone with eyes knows that isn’t going to happen.

A spokeswoman with VDOT told me yesterday that the Laskin Road Bridge Replacement and Widening Project will now wrap up in the spring of 2024 — a year late — due to “various field conditions that were unknown during the time of initial scheduling.”

That will be five years after ground was broken on the project, whose cost has risen to $141.7 million. News reports in 2019 estimated the price tag at $83.2 million.

It’s just tax money.

In the meantime, businesses along that heavily traveled corridor will continue to experience massive disruptions — in commerce and utilities — and drivers will continue to dodge potholes and serial road closures.

Here’s an idea: Virginia Beach city officials should change the image on the official seal from a lighthouse to an orange and white striped construction barrel. After all, there are two lighthouses in the city and thousands of barrels.

Most of them along Laskin Road.

This column has been republished with permission from Kerry: Unemployed & Unedited.


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

14 responses to “A Tale Of Two Bridge Projects”

  1. Carter Melton Avatar
    Carter Melton

    DeSantis was a navy seal. Seals don’t have committee meetings

  2. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
    Dick Hall-Sizemore

    Putting a temporary bridge to Pine Island in three days is an impressive feat. And, Kerry may be justified in her complaints about the slow progress on the Laskin Road project. However, the two projects is not comparable.

    On the Pine Island project, apparently over 100 truckloads of sand and stone was brought in to build the temporary structure. Because it was an emergency situation, the usual procurement process used by the Florida highway department was undoubtedly suspended, as were various inspections and permits. The replacement of the temporary structure with a “permanent” bridge will take much longer.

    As for Laskin Road, that project involves completely changing the overall design of the highway over a considerable stretch of miles. Significant engineering and planning has been required and, likely, the acquisition of additional right-of-way. In addition, this project is being designed and built to be in place for the foreseeable future.

    It is tempting to point to a project completed in three days and say, “Why can’t you move that fast?”, but they are two entirely different projects with different sets of problems

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      And the Laskin Road project is an ungodly mess.

      1. Nancy Naive Avatar
        Nancy Naive

        Is the road closed?

  3. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    I am sure Florida under De Santis has no behind schedule and over budget highway projects… smh…

  4. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    I am sure Florida under De Santis has no behind schedule and over budget highway projects… smh…

  5. how_it_works Avatar
    how_it_works

    Florida seems to be bucking the trend about “southern efficiency”.

  6. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Hoover and beaver dams differ too.

  7. how_it_works Avatar
    how_it_works

    The Joplin Rd bridge in Prince William County was washed out on Aug 13, 2020.

    VDOT awarded an emergency contract to Lane Construction for repairs. This was not reported until Nov 19, 2020.

    The bridge did not open up until April 2, 2021.

    I guess taking 3 months to award an emergency contract is breakneck speed by Virginia standards.

    1. Dick Hall-Sizemore Avatar
      Dick Hall-Sizemore

      What do you mean by “not reported”? If you mean that the contract award was not announced until Nov., perhaps some design and engineering work had to be done before the contract was awarded.

      1. how_it_works Avatar
        how_it_works

        It was not reported by VDOT or the media until Nov.

      2. how_it_works Avatar
        how_it_works

        Thought you’d be interested in some of the work the “best run DOT in the country” is doing lately:

        https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/96350960212c1de9ac08b489f9efaf3451399775bf970270c7466f9610193a2d.png https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/fd7d98067b354e788624c5016a048786f4933eecec6ba7136e8c553692eaf9a6.png

        If you can’t figure out what the problem is, congratulations, you could come out of retirement and go work for VDOT.

        And the problem is there are no flashers on the sign, no electronics to control any flashers, no flashers nearby, nothing.

        It’s stuff like this that makes me think VDOT exists solely to keep retards with names like “Jethro” and “Cletus” employed.

  8. Ken Reid Avatar

    This is an apples to oranges comparison. The Pine island bridge is temporary; probably uses materials (maybe railroad flatbed cars) that the Army corps of Engineers allows for military purposes . But unfortunately because of our intense federal and state regulations and road/bridge building standards, we never get bridges or roads fixed or built over a weekend. I blame the Trump administration and prior GOP administrations for NEVER seeking legislation to modernize the NEPA, Clean water act sec. 404 reviews and curbing the power of the Corps of Engineers to review bridges nad roads that go over waterways. Section 4f is a killer, too. Trump instituted executive actions at USDOT< but Biden scuttled them. Unless Congress changes the law, it will still cost more and take longer for transportation infrastructure to be built in the US vs. any Western democracy, and it's all because of antiquated environmental review requirements, flood plain and drainage requirements and standards designed to thwart the worst case scenario for road accidents. So, we motorists and the truckers have to sit and wait and sweat for projects to be approved , designed and built. I presume the I 264 Witchduck Road interchange is not done yet? IF so, that took over five years to build -- in large part, to deal with property owners who fought over condemnation and utility relocation. My guess is the environmetnal reviews for the Pine Island replacement bridge will be extensive and the permanent bridge costly to build.

Leave a Reply