by James C. Sherlock

George Orwell

George Orwell, call your office. A copy of “Virginia’s (New) Birth-to-Five Early Learning and Development Standards” is on your desk.

For our readers, go here and click the March 19 VDOE press release to download.

The Commonwealth has publishedVirginia’s Foundation Blocks for Early Learning” since at least 2013. They were excellent but voluntary. 

Progressives cannot abide voluntary.

They have always considered parents the biggest obstacle to turning kids into little “social justice” warriors. Virginia’s General Assembly progressives have fixed that problem. The new program is mandatory unless you keep your kids at home until they must by law attend K-12.

Where your kids will get a “late” start on that journey.

Parents have no voice, much less rights in the matter. That is a progressive definition of heaven. (If that word has not been cancelled — hard to keep up.)

House Bill 1012 and Senate Bill 578 approved by the 2020 General Assembly transferred the authority to license and regulate child care programs from the state Board of Social Services and Department of Social Services to the Board of Education and VDOE, effective July 1, 2021.

It was the implementation of a plan pushed by Governor Northam. See here the changes to the law that go into effect July 1.  

A program with the same goals could be managed in a way that actually helps. It is a good idea to provide child educational guidelines for care givers. Virginia has been doing it for years. And doing so brings federal money with it. 

But there is absolutely no indication that the current Board will run this program either beneficially or competently. If experience and the new Standards are guides, it will bring the same dogma, heavy hand and chaos to child care centers, family day homes and preschool programs that the same Board has brought to K-12.

The Board’s new Standards “updated” existing standards that were two years old, clearly because the Board felt those standards did not sufficiently focus on “equity,” “cultural competency” and “culturally-responsive and inclusive standards.” If you think that was a problem, you will be happy with the new version. The new law also comes with new licensing standards and twice-yearly inspections of child care centers, family day homes and preschool programs.

The following was updated Mar 29 at 3:05 PM

The new “Virginia’s Early Learning and Development Standards (ELDS) Birth-Five Learning Guidelines”  validated my concerns. I quote (the parenthetical notations are mine):

“Culturally Responsive Caregivers and Educators:
– See cultural differences as assets;
– Validate the inequities impacting children’s lives (which means what exactly to a one year old?);
– Cultivate relationships beyond the classroom or learning space, anchored in affirmation, mutual respect, and validation (same question);
– Believe that ALL children can succeed and communicate high expectations for all children (valid one);
– Engage in reflection of their beliefs, behaviors, and practices (any particular religious baseline?);
– Utilize children’s cultures as vehicles for learning;
– Challenge racial and cultural stereotypes, prejudices, racism, and other forms of intolerance, injustice, and oppression (among three year olds?);
– Mediate power imbalances in classrooms and learning spaces based on race, culture, ethnicity, and class; (power imbalances among 2 year olds?)
– Communicate in linguistically and culturally responsive ways (anyone have any idea what that means?); and
– Collaborate with families and the local community”

“Achieving education equity- that is eliminating the predictability of student outcomes based on race, gender, zip code, ability, socioeconomic status or languages spoken at home – indeed requires that caregivers and educators engage in culturally responsive practice. It also requires that caregivers and educators are culturally competent, exhibit cultural proficiency and are fully cognizant of what culturally relevant pedagogy and culturally relevant/responsive teaching entails (see glossary for specific definitions that have been adopted by the Virginia Department of Education). To learn more about the Virginia Department of Education’s (VDOE) equity commitments (#EdEquityVA) visit the Virginia is For Learners website. There you will find information about Future-Ready Learning, how the VDOE is supporting early learning, and learn about #EdEquityVA initiatives.”

That quote linking early childhood education to the EdEquityVA dogma eliminates any doubt that critical race theory will be the baseline philosophy of the education of children from birth to five years old.

I repeat: From birth to five years old.

Those guidelines will be converted to Virginia Administrative Code regulations for the purposes of inspections and penalties. I looked yesterday and they were not codified yet.

 So, if you need child care in Virginia, your child will be immersed in critical race theory. From birth.  If you don’t like it, stay home with your kids.  Religious child development centers may face ethical obstacles.  Too bad.

We await programs to instruct in vitro.

The standards will be published as regulations by the Board. The inspections will be conducted by the Department of Education. I have asked the VDOE to let me know when they determine the qualifications for inspectors. Which I think will be interesting.

What could possibly go wrong?


Share this article



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)



ADVERTISEMENT

(comments below)


Comments

25 responses to “Virginia to Teach Critical Race Theory to Newborns”

  1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
    James Wyatt Whitehead

    Fascinating Captain! The links you provided led me to the Pre K Kindergarten Readiness Assessments. The test on Pre K math is interesting. Little kids are measured in some very sophisticated math for that age. In 2019 it was found that 37,000 Pre K students were not ready for the Kindergarten standards, 44%. The revised tests will provide a baseline to track student progress thru the many grades ahead. I wonder if any teacher is really taking a hard look at this or just giving it due attention.
    https://vkrponline.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2020/03/EMAS_Overview.pdf

    Early Childhood centers have a high turnover rate due to pay and a very demanding job. I saw that the VDOE is awarding $1,500 stipends to early childhood teachers that are practicing the standards and spending extra time with behind kids.

  2. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    The 77-page document is linked. Paragraph 3, “published.” https://www.doe.virginia.gov/early-childhood/curriculum/foundation-blocks.pdf

    I scanned it for anti-racist dogma and must say I came up pretty empty. Perhaps Sherlock could point to something? And how could they have missed this list of dead white European artists?

    “Read books about artists and their art, such as Claude Monet’s “Water Lilies,” van Rijn Rembrandt’s “Mona Lisa,” Edgar Dega’s “Ballerina,” and Vincent Van Gogh’s “Starry Night” or “Sunflower.”

    Might be overplaying your hand on this one. But show me….The push to move the regulation authority to DOE is not a new idea and is all about improving the educational content of those programs. I would recommend people read the thing before reacting. They won’t….

  3. The press release includes the following verbiage:

    “Equity for all young learners is central to Virginia’s Birth-to-Five Early Learning and Development Standards, both in terms of process and content. VDOE led a lengthy and inclusive process in developing the standards….

    “Establishing a culturally-responsive and inclusive set of foundational standards is critical to ensuring their use and applicability to all early learners and their caretakers,” Board of Education Vice President Jamelle S. Wilson said. “Because of this focus on inclusion, I believe these standards represent a key step toward eradicating inequities and disparities in child outcomes and will equip teachers and caregivers with the necessary tools to address the needs of all learners.”

    The progressive boilerplate is concerning, but it is not the same as teaching critical race theory to tots.

    Jim, do you have anything else to back up your headline?

    1. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      Check my comment. I updated the post and kept the title.

  4. Matt Hurt Avatar
    Matt Hurt

    The standards were approved by the Board of Education on March 18, and the draft the Board had can be found at the link below.

    https://www.doe.virginia.gov/boe/meetings/2021/03-mar/item-g-attachment-a.pdf

    I realize some folks on this blog may poo-poo the “culturally responsive” push, and it may be because they heard some far left zealot use those terms. However, as defined by reasonable folks, this is a very critically important aim. Some of our educators have very little idea what it’s like for some of our kids. Please indulge my example below.

    Once upon a time, a new teacher had a problem with one of her students, Johnny. Johnny had a bad attitude in class, and never brought in his homework. The teacher, frustrated to the end, could not fathom why he behaved in this manner. She thought back to her own childhood about how her parents expected her to try her best, and grounded her the time she did not turn in her homework. Finally, this new teacher confided her troubles to a veteran teacher. The veteran teacher knew the family, and explained to the new teacher that Johnny’s mother was frequently strung out on meth, and that there was a never-ending line of boyfriends she brought home who more often that not were very abusive to Johnny.

    After learning this, the new teacher took a different approach with Johnny. She became much more compassionate, and worked hard to build a better relationship with him. Over time, she convinced Johnny to work extra with her during his exploratory classes, and by the end of the year, Johnny had squeaked a pass on his SOL test.

    1. James Wyatt Whitehead Avatar
      James Wyatt Whitehead

      I hear you Mr. Hurt. Your example demonstrates what the VDOE is attempting to accomplish. It is a good goal to work towards. Here is what troubles me. I good teacher who is engaged with students, communicating with parents, and utilizing the guidance counselor is going to figure this out and take the right steps. To me a teacher that cannot engage at this level is doomed to fail and should probably move on. Plus the machinations of the educational bureaucratic process are simply going to get in the way and gum up the works.

    2. Matt, of course, if Johnny’s mother is strung out on meth, the teacher needs to make accommodations. But what does that have to do with being “culturally appropriate?” Is being strung out on meth the norm in some sub-cultures?

      Also, I wonder if being “culturally appropriate” extends to acknowledging the difference of white Appalachian sub-culture, which, if we believe “Hillbilly Elegy,” is a very different sub-culture than white suburban metropolitan sub-culture.

      1. Matt Hurt Avatar
        Matt Hurt

        It depends on the level of specificity that one wishes to analyze such things. My point was not that meth abuse is the norm in Appalachia, but that there’s a difference in general culture between many teachers and their students. In my example, education was highly valued in the childhood home of the new teacher. It was not valued in Johnny’s home.

        I do not think that we can effectively create a “culturally responsive” curriculum for educators that will provide a roadmap to help deal with all of the intricacies of “cultural norms”, if such a thing can be adequately defined. My point is that educators have to understand that there are differences in those norms, and that there’s ways to work around them. Back in the day when I was a teacher and then an administrator in a school, I learned that developing relationships with students and parents went a long way towards that end. They might not value education, but if we could convince them that we cared about the kid, the parents would typically support our efforts (at least verbally), and the kid was more likely to work with us.

        It all comes down to believing that education provides a path forward, genuinely caring about the student, and believing that the student can be successful if we help them in the way that they need it.

  5. Setting aside the CRT issue for a moment, this assumes that all pre-school children will be in the care of someone other than their parents who understands and uses these standards. If a parent is alcoholic or addicted to opiates and neglectful, and the child is not in a childcare setting, this will do nothing for them. The most at-risk children for school failure will be even further behind, increasing the “inequities in school readiness.” Then what? Will the state take over raising children?

    “With our action today, we move closer to realizing Governor Northam and the General Assembly’s vision of creating a unified system of early childhood education designed to eliminate the wide inequities in school readiness that exist today among children in the commonwealth,” Board of Education President Dan Gecker said. “These new standards will promote consistency and quality for children, educators and care givers in all of the settings where our youngest learners are preparing for kindergarten, including child care centers, family day homes and preschools.”

  6. Eric the half a troll Avatar
    Eric the half a troll

    Do you have a link to the actual new Birth-to-Five Early Learning and Development Standards?

    1. Nancy Naive Avatar
      Nancy Naive

      No. Like Proxmire he’s devolved to assessing the titles and like Republicans everywhere he accepts works of fiction (1984, Atlas Shrugged, etc.) as having evidentiary value.

  7. Stephen Haner Avatar
    Stephen Haner

    The 77-page document is linked. Paragraph 3, “published.” https://www.doe.virginia.gov/early-childhood/curriculum/foundation-blocks.pdf

    I scanned it for anti-racist dogma and must say I came up pretty empty. Perhaps Sherlock could point to something? And how could they have missed this list of dead white European artists?

    “Read books about artists and their art, such as Claude Monet’s “Water Lilies,” van Rijn Rembrandt’s “Mona Lisa,” Edgar Dega’s “Ballerina,” and Vincent Van Gogh’s “Starry Night” or “Sunflower.”

    Might be overplaying your hand on this one. But show me….The push to move the regulation authority to DOE is not a new idea and is all about improving the educational content of those programs. I would recommend people read the thing before reacting. They won’t….

    1. Eric the half a troll Avatar
      Eric the half a troll

      Those are the 2013 standards. That is why I asked for a link to the new ones.

      1. Stephen Haner Avatar
        Stephen Haner

        Oh! Sorry. No wonder they seem benign. 🙂 I guess the dead white European artists will disappear after all….

  8. Here’s a link to an undated preliminary draft copy.

    See page 9 for the groups “Virginia’s standards have been informed by:” First on the list is National Association for the Education of Young Children. From their website:

    Advancing Equity in Early Childhood Education: A Position Statement of the National Association for the Education of Young Children.”

    Picking out a few choice phrases: “Advancing the right to equitable learning opportunities requires recognizing and dismantling the systems of bias that accord privilege to some and are unjust to others.”

    “Early childhood educators can model humility and a willingness to learn by being accountable for any negative impacts of their own biases on their interactions with children and their families”

    “Members of groups that have historically enjoyed advantages must be willing to recognize the often-unintended consequences of ignorance, action, and inaction and how they may contribute to perpetuating existing systems of privilege.”

    “Recognize that everyone holds some types of bias based on their personal background and experiences. Even if you think of yourself as unbiased, reflect on the impacts of racism, sexism, classism, ableism,
    heterosexism, xenophobia, and other systems of oppression affecting you and the people around you. Identify where your varied social identities have provided strengths and understandings based on your experiences of both injustice and privilege.”

    Sounds like CRT to me.

  9. Good find, Carol!

    VDOE is smart enough to NOT state its intentions in a way that the general public understands. It’s more of a wink and a nod by alluding to documents like “Advancing Equity in Early Childhood Education.” I have no doubt that Jim Sherlock was correct in his assessment of what VDOE has in mind. We just have to be careful to document everything or risk being portrayed as conspiracy theorists.

    1. I’m wary of preliminary drafts when it involves any Commonwealth agency. Probably we won’t see the final version for a while to see what gets changed. The draft talks about its writing style and avoiding the use of him and her, opting for them instead.Willing to bet the occasional use of “gender” in the standards is eliminated in the final. After all, they say, “We also follow the Publication Manual of the American Psychological Association (APA), 7th edition (2020), whenever applicable to ensure that the writing is professional as well as reader friendly. In addition to using person-first language, we followed APA 7th edition on the usage of the pronoun “they.” APA advocates for the singular “they” because it is inclusive of all people and it helps readers avoid making assumptions about gender.”

      The other half of these standards is the adult side – to indoctrinate caregivers into the CRT ideology and make it seem normal and acceptable, then get parent to buy into it. How will that get translated into interacting with children? Will children considered “privileged” be pointed out and made to feel guilty for it? Will children considered not to be privileged be taught to dislike those who are? How will these ideas affect social lessons like sharing toys? I’m still trying to wrap my head around “heterosexism” as a concept equivalent to racism and xenophobia.

    2. James C. Sherlock Avatar
      James C. Sherlock

      I augmented the documentation. See my extensive note below and the new update to the post. The Board eschewed subtlety on CRT in the new “Virginia’s Early Learning and Development Standards (ELDS) Birth-five Learning Guidelines”

      1. vicnicholls Avatar
        vicnicholls

        Find not one doggone thing wrong with your postings Capt. Post away.

  10. James C. Sherlock Avatar
    James C. Sherlock

    I have heard rumblings that my columns on health care and education subject were too long, discouraging many from reading them. I had a version of this column that was three times as long, but cut it back by putting what turned out to be too much information in links.

    Sorry for that.

    First, many of the links were to versions of documents and regulations that have yet to be updated under the Board’s new philosophies that are laid out in the March 19 press release. That was meant to be evident, but that is unfair. .

    “Virginia’s Foundation Blocks for Early Learning” is from 2013. Readers were meant to imagine what the new ones will look like. I should have said so.

    The original had some of the telltale quotes from the press release that I linked, but I should have printed them.

    The new “Virginia’s Early Learning and Development Standards (ELDS) Birth-five Learning Guidelines” https://www.doe.virginia.gov/boe/meetings/2021/03-mar/item-g-attachment-a.pdf which I had not seen when I wrote this (published the day before the press release) validated my concerns. I quote (the parenthetical notations are mine):

    “Culturally Responsive Caregivers and Educators:
    – See cultural differences as assets;
    – Validate the inequities impacting children’s lives (which means what exactly to a one year old?);
    – Cultivate relationships beyond the classroom or learning space, anchored in affirmation, mutual respect, and validation (same question);
    – Believe that ALL children can succeed and communicate high expectations for all children (valid one);
    – Engage in reflection of their beliefs, behaviors, and practices (any particular religious baseline?);
    – Utilize children’s cultures as vehicles for learning;
    – Challenge racial and cultural stereotypes, prejudices, racism, and other forms of intolerance, injustice, and oppression (among three year olds?);
    – Mediate power imbalances in classrooms and learning spaces based on race, culture, ethnicity, and class; (power imbalances among 2 year olds?)
    – Communicate in linguistically and culturally responsive ways (anyone have any idea what that means?); and
    – Collaborate with families and the local community”

    “Achieving education equity- that is eliminating the predictability of student outcomes based on race, gender, zip code, ability, socioeconomic status or languages spoken at home – indeed requires that caregivers and educators engage in culturally responsive practice. It also requires that caregivers and educators are culturally competent, exhibit cultural proficiency and are fully cognizant of what culturally relevant pedagogy and culturally relevant/responsive teaching entails (see glossary for specific definitions that have been adopted by the Virginia Department of Education). To learn more about the Virginia Department of Education’s (VDOE) equity commitments (#EdEquityVA) visit the Virginia is For Learners website. There you will find information about Future-Ready Learning, how the VDOE is supporting early learning, and learn about #EdEquityVA initiatives.”

    That quote linking early childhood education to the EdEquityVA dogma eliminates any doubt that critical race theory will be the baseline philosophy of the education of children from birth to five years old. I repeat: From birth to five years old.

    Those guidelines will be converted to Virginia Administrative Code regulations for the purposes of inspections and penalties. I looked yesterday and they were not codified yet.

    I have asked the VDOE to let me know when they determine the qualifications for inspectors. Which I think will be interesting.

  11. Nancy Naive Avatar
    Nancy Naive

    Latest poll numbers:

    The leading candidates for governor are former governor Terry McAuliffe (D) with 26% of Democratic voters followed by Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax (D) with 12% of that party’s vote, and Chesterfield Sen. Amanda Chase (Q) leading with 17% of the Republican party voters followed by Virginia House Speaker Kirk Cox (R) at 10%.

  12. […] It also provides an overwhelming indication as to the source of the Board of Education’s dreadful new Birth-to-Five Early Learning and Development Standards […]

  13. […] It also provides an overwhelming indication as to the source of the Board of Education’s dreadful new Birth-to-Five Early Learning and Development Standards. […]

  14. […] race theory education for newborns?  Can’t start too early – […]

Leave a Reply