Guest Column

Larry J. Sabato



 

It's Even Worse than We Thought

 

The Center for Politics has released some statistics regarding the upcoming General Assembly contest that should prove depressing for anyone who values vigorous, two-party competition in Virginia.


 

1. Nearly two-thirds of all candidates for the General Assembly will run unopposed in the 2003 elections, equaled only by 1987 in recent years.

 

The most discouraging piece of data we have discovered is that 64 percent of party nominees are unopposed by the other major party; 68 percent of House nominees and 52.5 percent of Senate nominees are essentially elected in advance because they are completely unopposed or have opposition only from an independent with little chance of success. This is tied for the highest percentage in the past 20 years. Only in 1987 did the lack of two-party competition equal that of 2003. In the past six legislative election years, the average uncontested proportion of seats has been around 45 percent — bad, for sure, but not nearly as disgraceful as in 2003.

 

2. The rate of party competition in Virginia is far below the national rate.

 

How does the dismal lack of competition in Virginia compare to the country as a whole? According to the Center for Voting and Democracy in Washington, D.C., 37 percent[1] of the 6,222 [2] state legislative seats elected in November 2002 had nominees from only one of the major parties. Virginia's 2003 noncompetitive proportion of 64 percent, then, is massively greater than the national figure. Throughout U.S. history, Virginia has led America in many ways—but this is not a category in which Virginians can be proud to excel.

 

3. The number of women nominated by the two major parties has plummeted.

 

There is more bad news in terms of the number of women nominated by the two major parties for the General Assembly.  In 2003 just 24 women [3] were nominated. The last time both houses of the General Assembly were up for election, in 1999, the two major parties nominated 39 female candidates (23 Democrats, 16 Republicans). Moreover, the parties nominated more women in 5 of the 6 previous election cycles. 

 

4. Virginia is 43rd out of 50 states in female representation.

 

Not only has the number of Virginia women running for the legislature declined, but the state ranks very low nationally in the proportion of women in the General Assembly. Countrywide, there are 1,648 women in the fifty state legislatures, 22.3 percent of the total as of 2003. On the eve of the general election, Virginia had 22 women in the House and Senate combined, or 15.7% of the total. This percentage places Virginia 43rd out of the 50 states.[4].

 

5. African American representation is marginally increasing.

 

African Americans have 17 Democratic candidacies on the November ballot (12 House, 5 Senate), but just 2 Republican House challengers. [5]  Since the GOP House nominees are unlikely to win, it appears that the African American delegation will be entirely Democratic and, as of January 2004, will consist of 11 House Democrats and 5 Senate Democrats. (There are 5 non-incumbents: 4 House members and 1 Senate member will be new). The current number of 15 is relatively stationary, [6], yet the nomination of Onzlee Ware in Roanoke, who will replace white Del. Chip Woodrum, D-Roanoke (there is no Republican opponent), suggests that there will be an increase of one this year.

 

-- July 14, 2003

 


[1] Center for Voting and Democracy.  Fair Elections Update: November 14, 2002.  Unopposed means faced no major party opposition.

 

[2] This number represents 1,263 Senators and 4,959 House members. National Conference of State Legislatures, July 2003.

[3] 17 Democrats (9 House, 8 Senate), 7 Republicans (7 House, 1 Senate)

 

[4] Number and percentage of women in state legislatures as well as Virginia’s rank were drawn from results compiled by the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University.  May, 2003.

 

[5] Dr. Alvin Bryant of Hampton and Raymond Johnson of Newport News.

 

[6] There are currently 10 African Americans in the House and 5 in the Senate.

 

©2003 – Larry J. Sabato, University of Virginia Center for Politics.  All rights reserved.

 

 

Bring Home the Bacon

Help   About search

 

 

 

 

Larry J. Sabato is director, University of Virginia Center for Politics.

 

His e-mail is sabato@virginia.edu.