Virginia Pundit Watch

Will Vehrs



FREE Chamber of Horrors

 

Two prominent pundits took different directions this week in analyzing the fall-out from a legislative rating report put out by Virginia FREE. The non-partisan pro-business lobbying group rated Democrats in the General Assembly higher than Republicans on business issues. According to Jeff Schapiro in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, Republicans are “squealing like a pig” because of the ratings. They are now “on the defensive, fending off criticism that they may be more interested in re-election than solutions to the state's problems.”

 

Over at the Virginian-Pilot, Margaret Edds blasted the Virginia Chamber of Commerce for backing away from the FREE report. She accused the leading business lobby of “fawning deference to Virginia’s political establishment” and “coddling powerful politicians.” Edds even found a nameless “pro-business voice” to make this explosive charge against his/her colleagues:

 

“Until business is willing to stand up and stay the course on issues it thinks are important, we're not going to get anywhere. Gutless behavior is part of the problem.''

 

Republican pundit and Del. Preston Bryant, R-Lynchburg, writing in the Roanoke Times, defended the negative response of Republicans with a veiled warning:

 

Virginia FREE did indeed mess up this year. The few new friends they may have won with some artificially inflated scores may well be offset by the number of old friends they lost.

 

In the “hope springs eternal” department, R.H. Melton of the Washington Post sketched a scenario — “the rosiest of rosy scenarios” — for Gov. Mark R. Warner and the Republicans to get a “real chance to restructure the tax code.” It involves a Warner appearance with plan in hand at a meeting, a warm welcome from 81-year-old Del. Harry Parrish, R-Manassas, sudden cooperation from Speaker of the House William Howell, R-Stafford, and host of other unlikely planetary alignments.  Not coincidentally, Melton’s dream scenario would be a commentary gold mine.

 

University of Virginia Professor Larry Sabato urged Gov. Warner to take on tax reform during an interview on the public television program “Perspectives,” hosted by Barbara Berlin. Sabato said the Governor should get focused on “big things,” as opposed to his association with smaller issues like seat belts. This controversial recommendation begged for follow-up, but the affable Berlin stuck to her script, mumbling an occasional “Mmm hmm” before moving on to her next question.

 

Attack of the Week

 

Until this week, there had not been much of an outcry against Gov. Warner’s veto of legislation prohibiting in-state tuition rates at Virginia colleges for illegal aliens. Melanie Scarborough, in the Washington Post, has filled that void. Noting that Warner rejected extending in-state tuition rates to military personnel while denouncing the illegal alien measure as a “political ploy,” she wrote:

 

Hmm. Advocates for illegal immigrants generally vote Democratic; members of the military tend to vote Republican. Exactly who is more intent on scoring a political victory?

 

Scarborough charged that there was little chance Warner would press for compliance with immigration laws “because that means protecting taxpayer interests” and it “is not how Democrats score political victories.”

 

The Day Shift

 

Barnie Day is a busy man these days. In addition to his columns in the Daily Press and the Roanoke Times, the former Democratic Delegate is making appearances at Democratic fundraisers, rousing the faithful. Day’s columns last week were skillful partisan efforts. Knowing that Democrats trail with the “family values” crowd, he quoted a long passage from the “fabulous” Book of Matthew in the Bible, saying it was “the Democratic platform.”  Knowing that roughing up Republican Attorney General Jerry Kilgore is essential to Democratic chances in 2005, one could almost hear him chortle as he highlighted the rift on the “morning after” pill between stalwart pro-life Del. Bob Marshall R-Manassas, and Kilgore.

 

Rewriting History

 

It’s been axiomatic that when Virginia Democrats controlled the General Assembly, they engaged in the same partisan gerrymandering and agenda control that Republicans have exhibited. Along comes Daily Press columnist Gordon Morse (subscription required) with a revisionist history of Democratic control: 

 

Actually, the Democrats largely did not [do what Republicans are doing now] and mostly because they didn't see the need. Well into the 1980s, there weren't that many Republicans, and a number of them were former Democrats anyway.

Besides - and this is a little hard to get across to people - you often had a hard time getting Democratic lawmakers to think and act in their own partisan interests. Democrats - a mixed lot of lawyers, businessmen, teachers and farmers, mostly - long figured they were a fixed part of the landscape. The sun came up and the Democrats ruled Virginia
.

 

Not surprising, the Democratic Party of Virginia’s “Demo Memo” describes Morse as a “masterful political commentator.” 

 

Recounting History

 

Retired banker Robert Norfleet was this week’s Richmond Times-Dispatch Commentary Columnist.  The headline was misleading: “Loss of Banks, Brokerages Shows Need for New Vision.” Norfleet’s piece traced the loss of financial institutions state-wide and in Richmond at length, but offered only this short “new vision”:

 

We need to support our existing corporate leadership and encourage a new generation of leaders to join with it so they can better leverage their resources and influence.

 

The recent Philip Morris and Wachovia/Prudential announcements were both timely and encouraging; they demonstrate that the Richmond area remains an attractive venue for a wide variety of businesses. As a community we now need to provide these corporations and their employees with a warm and hospitable welcome, one that will give assurances that they picked the right place and one that will encourage them to become active in the community.

 

Reservoir Dog

 

The City of Newport News’ long battle to withdraw water from the King William Reservoir is over, after a Virginia Marine Resources vote against the costly project. Del. Harvey Morgan, R-Gloucester, in a Daily Press post-mortem, showered praise on all parties who opposed the reservoir. Meanwhile, of course, the water needs of Newport News continue, a fact Morgan failed to mention.

 

The Rah-Rah Sisterhood

 

Virginia Tech Professor Karen Thole, writing in the Roanoke Times, offered a creative, last-ditch appeal to keep the Hokies in a viable athletic conference: Donna Shalala’s feminism. Shalala, President of the University of Miami, crown jewel of the Atlantic Coast Conference’s expansion plan, should resist bolting the ACC because of her status as a role model:

 

If you decide to leave the Big East, your decision will affect numerous institutions and, as such, your reputation will be scarred, which will make it even more difficult for women to achieve academic leadership roles.

 

On the other hand, the legacy you have the opportunity of creating in deciding to remain in the Big East will not only be for you, but it will also serve as a model of integrity and loyalty for women leaders everywhere.

 

Apparently, Shalala’s own legacy as a female pioneer should override the interests of the institution she leads — and advance the interests of the institution that employs Ms. Thole.

-- May 26, 2003

 

 

 

 

Will Vehrs grew up in Prince William County. He has a degree in American history from the College of William and Mary and an MBA from Chapman University. Will's experience includes a stint with a Fortune 500 company and economic development work in state government. His "Punditwatch" column appears on FoxNews.com and Jewish World Review, as well as on his own Punditwatch website. He also writes for the Quasipundit political site.