Guest Column

Michael W. Thompson



Scuttling the Ghost Fleet

 

Seventy aging warships at the mouth of the James River are an environmental disaster waiting to happen. Bay Bridge Enterprises is backing a proposal to convert them to scrap. 


 

An environmental disaster of unknown consequences drifts toward reality at the environmentally sensitive mouth of the James River.

 

Seventy old naval vessels, retired from active service, are quietly moored in the James River off of Fort Eustis. This fleet of slowly deteriorating ships is conveniently called “The Reserve Fleet.” But in reality vast numbers of these once powerful war machines are rusting away; their stored oil and chemicals are waiting to ooze out into the James and then empty into the Chesapeake Bay.

 

The common reference to this rotting fleet is “The Ghost Fleet,” as it is only a wisp of what these ships were in the past. From a distance in the light of the moon or in the morning fog, these aging vessels appear like a fleet of imposing war vessels ready to fight for our freedom. But any fight has long since departed these wraiths of the sea.

 

The Ghost Fleet, managed by the U.S. Marine Administration (MARAD), poses a real danger from catastrophic oil spills and chemical spills. A whole Devil’s brew of contaminants could severely endanger the mouth of the James River, Chesapeake Bay and surrounding waters. Imagine the impact of a huge hurricane whipping these ships around like tooth picks and smashing them against each other. It’s a nightmare waiting reality.

 

Some in our government propose hauling these rotting ships to China for destruction by workers paid $75 a month. Of course, the environmental rules and regulations in China are much weaker than here in the United States and the potential for environmental problems is greater. The Environmental Protection Agency has deep concerns about hauling these ships half way around the world. But U.S. Sen. John Warner, R-VA, and U.S. Rep. Jo Ann Davis, R-1st. These two Virginians led the fight to find $31 million to begin the careful dismantling of these aging ships without harming the environment.

 

Vassilopoulos and Williamson LC has some ideas about how to scrap these ships safely. The Wyoming firm has engaged Bay Bridge Enterprises, a Norfolk ship-dismantling company, as one of two key contractors in a novel proposal. The team's scientists and engineers believe the ships can be dismantled for about $750,000 each -- comparable to the cost, including insurance, of shipping the vessels to China. 

Using innovative HAZMAT (hazardous materials) remediation techniques, the team is applying for a federal contract to tear apart the Ghost Fleet. What's more, Bay Bridge would use Virginia prison inmates to do much of the work, training them, housing them, feeding them and paying them. The combined benefits would be close to minimum wage -- more than they are paid in prison for stamping license plates. The inmates will learn marketable trades, doing real work while performing a valuable service to our state and our nation. While the inmates dismantle the Ghost Fleet, the state budget will be relieved of the cost of incarcerating them.

 

Using prison inmates is not new to Virginia. The Commonwealth  has employed inmates to remanufacture items for resale.

 

Besides the old warships, there are two brand new, partially completed oil tankers in the Ghost Fleet. Bay Bridge and its partners propose converting these two vessels into carriers of liquefied gas -- work that could bring $95 million in business to the Hampton Roads shipyards. Of course, that $95 million will be multiplied throughout the economy as shipyard employees buy goods and serves, save, or invest their money.

 

Letting the private sector dismantle the Ghost Fleet makes sense. It is a “win-win-win” situation for all of us. We dismantle the Ghost Fleet before it breaks apart and spoils our environment. Prison inmates learn marketable skills and earn “good works” credit during their prison time. Virginia’s budget saves the cost of supporting the inmates while they work. And the retrofitting of two vessels by shipyards in Hampton Roads boosts the local economy.

 

The Ghost Fleet awaits a decision. Every day, the rust gets thicker and the steel walls weaker. Every day, the odds increase that oil and chemicals may leak into the James, or that a storm will cause an environmental disaster.

 

Virginia should pursue this project with the federal government, taking whatever actions are needed to speed the process along. It just makes sense.

 

--June 2, 2003

 

Bring Home the Bacon

Help   About search

 

 

 

 

Michael Thompson is the Chairman and President of the Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy, a “solutions tank” presenting alternative ideas to Virginia government programs and policies. The opinions expressed in this column, however, are his own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Thomas Jefferson Institute or its Board of Directors.

Mr. Thompson's email address is: mikethompson@erols.com