Nice & Curious Questions

Edwin S. Clay III and Patricia Bangs


 

Edgar Cayce’s Legacy: Virginia’s Psychic Phenomena

 

In one of Shakespeare’s most famous plays, Denmark’s prince muses on the paranormal. “There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy,” Hamlet tells his friend after encountering his murdered father’s ghost. Four hundred years later, there are still those who passionately adhere to this notion. In Virginia, they can find evidence for their beliefs at two institutions – the headquarters of Edgar Cayce’s Association for Research and Enlightenment in Virginia Beach and the Division of Personality Studies on the grounds of the University of Virginia in Charlottesville.

 

The former houses more than 14,000 “readings” given by Cayce, a seer, mystic or clairvoyant (depending on the term you prefer), on subjects ranging from holistic health to reincarnation and the existence of the mythical submerged city of Atlantis. It is only one of 25 Edgar Cayce Centers throughout the globe and is visited annually by thousands of his followers, as well as the curious.

 

Cayce settled on Virginia Beach as a result of his “readings” or visions, which were always given while he was in a trance. At the height of his popularity in 1925, he and his followers wanted to establish an institution that would survive him. Possible locations included Chicago, Ill. and Dayton, Ohio. In "There Is a River" by Thomas Sugrue, originally published in 1943, the author explains that Cayce’s readings vetoed the other two sites. Instead, they directed him to Virginia Beach because the readings indicated it was better for his health and psychic abilities to live near large bodies of water. Also, it was better that psychic readings be carried on over and near water and that individuals travel over water to receive them.

 

Two years after moving to Virginia Beach, Cayce established the Association of National Investigators in 1927 and a year later, the Cayce Hospital was established with 60 beds. It was designed to explore the effectiveness of the holistic healing cures Cayce experienced in his trance readings. In 1930, Atlantic University was established to train those interested in Cayce’s theories. However, a year later both the ANI and the hospital faltered due in part to the Depression and conflicts among donors. Atlantic University closed soon after. The Association for Research and Enlightenment replaced the ANI and in 1932 held its first congress with 16 attendees. It has survived to this day. (See Wikipedia -- Edgar Cayce.)

 

Cayce’s popularity grew during subsequent years and after his death in 1945. By 1955, the University of Chicago accepted the first dissertation on the psychic, entitled "Charisma of the Seer," by Harmon H. Bro.

 

The bulk of Cayce’s readings – more than 9,000 – were physical readings and this is where his legacy resonates most strongly, among the growing number of those who believe in the mind-body approach to health. Cayce seemed to have a fairly realistic approach to his gift, though, urging those who came to him to take away only what seemed relevant to their situation. He fretted that individuals who consulted him during the last two decades of his life in Virginia Beach were much more interested in “life readings,” which often dealt with reincarnation than the “physical readings” that he felt more confident about.

 

There are, of course, skeptics who point to incorrect prophecies and the fact that any evidence of the success of his healings and predictions is anecdotal and not scientifically rigorous. But whatever their beliefs, critics and believers alike concur that Cayce sincerely believed in his powers and his intentions were altruistic. In fact, his death is attributed to overwork. A 1943 article in Coronet magazine, a national publication, resulted in increased requests for his readings. To satisfy this demand, he began giving eight a day, which finally affected his health. He died of a stroke on January 3, 1945.

 

About 160 miles northwest, on the UVa campus, a small group of researchers in the Division of Personality Studies in the Department of Psychiatry apply scientific rigor to some of the phenomena Cayce only experienced in his trances. The division is best known for the work of its founder – Dr. Ian Stevenson -- on children who claim to experience previous lives. He has traveled around the globe investigating such cases, and has written hundreds of articles and a number of books. His latest book, "European Cases of the Reincarnation Type," was reviewed in the April 2005 issue of the American Journal of Psychiatry (American Journal of Psychiatry).

 

Dr. Stevenson founded the division in 1967 when he resigned as chair of the Department of Psychiatry at UVa and became the new department’s director, as well as the Chester F. Carlson Professor of Psychiatry. He remained in the position for the next 35 years. DOPS is one of only a dozen or so university-based research units that investigate similar paranormal phenomena. Others are located at Princeton University, the University of Arizona, the University of Edinburgh in Scotland and the University of Amsterdam in the Netherlands.

 

In 1997, a Washington Post editor, Tom Shroder, traveled with Dr. Stevenson through India, Lebanon and the U.S. as he investigated children who seemed to remember past lives. Shroder related his experiences in a book, "Old Souls: The Scientific Evidence for Past Lives." In one case in the Blue Ridge Mountains of Virginia, a child named Joseph remembered his dead uncle’s life in more detail than seemed possible. He called his grandmother “Mom,” and spoke of incidents in his uncle’s life as if he had experienced them. As a child he always insisted on buying shoes that were too big for him. “I know I wear a size eight,” he would tell his mother. His uncle wore that shoe size.

 

Schroder began his travels with Dr. Stevenson as a skeptic and was still uncertain how to interpret what he experienced, but believed the many cases he saw with Stevenson were not the result of fraud, coincidence, delusion or any normal explanations.

 

In addition to Dr. Stevenson’s research area, the 11-member staff at the DOPS, which includes psychiatrists and clinical psychologists, studies other apparent paranormal phenomena, such as near-death experiences (NDEs); out-of-body experiences (OBEs); apparitions and after-death communications; and deathbed visions.

 

The department takes its research seriously and in a link on its Web site, Who We Aren't, is sensitive to the ghostbuster stereotypes that haunt such research. The staff does not conduct phone interviews from the media or students, or offer recommendations of psychics or hypnotists who specialize in past-life regression.

 

The department does, however, invite individuals to participate in the University of Virginia Study of Unusual Experiences (DOPS Research). It’s unfortunate Hamlet didn’t have such an opportunity. He might have met a more pleasant end.

 

NEXT: Don’t Cry Fowl: Virginia’s Feathered Friends

November 28, 2005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

About "Nice & Curious"

 

In 1691, a group of English wits, calling themselves the Athenian Society, founded a publication entitled, "The Athenian Gazette or Causical Mercury, Resolving All the Most Nice and Curious Questions proposed by the Ingenious." The editors accepted questions posed by readers on any and all topics, and sought the most ingenious answers.

 

Inspired by their example, Edwin S. Clay III, president of the Virginia Library Association and Director of the Fairfax County Public Library, created an occasional column on Virginia facts that may require "ingenious answers" of the type favored by those 17th-century wags.

 

If you have a query, e-mail him at eclay0@fairfaxcounty.gov.

 

Fairfax County Public Library staff Patricia Bangs, Lois Kirkpatrick and MaryAnn Sheehan assist in the writing, editing and research of the column.